← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5547/2020dismissed

Dharampal v. State Of Haryana And Others

2020-07-16Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal16 pages



!"

# !

$%&% ' %"(% %%

% '

%"



') * +,-$./0 '-))12)   

  4.4 5)  )/) )) * - 4 "

*

4 "%+ 6&7"$!5

%

785

%" %7  

    

  

    

 

 

%

785

%" %70$ !!"    #$ %& $%#'



   )!



"

   

 !!

" *+ 

,    -#

  .

+  #''& /  

0 #''& 01 2 #' %$ $%$%

 (   

 

!

 

!  ! !   $%#5

!    



!

 !

  !"(! !    

  )!

     

 "



 !



 "6 7( 

  



     !



 "6 7(  9



 #''&   $%#-

  .

+ /1  $%#-

.! 

    #:- #''& 

3     !!

  





(

   ;!

 !  !

  < ! 

 "6 7( 

=

  

!!

 (!""

!

  < ! ! /> !

1

=

   (!""

!



 < ! - !

  

 !  

.!   #:- , 

?

   

            

  

         

  

    

          "# $  % !      

   ""   & ' 

 

  % !                      ""        &   "

   '  

 

9 

(  )* @! !"



!

 !  !



 A *  *

  #''-

@ 

, !

   $%%'

!

A  ! 2 !

     

  )!

  

  )!



<  !



<

   !! "

 "

  !

?

# +   )  , 

    "      

 

  &    -   . '  -

 

"      "      ")+ '    /

"

   )

0)  +   )  , 

 1  

  ) ,    ,!                          0232)  ,"      ) , 

  ## 

 " "       456  )0(7     33)33)0230    & - ) 8)+ 39)2:)0237'  ;/ / <             ##    

/    ' ),   ,!      !     )+ = />- 

!  

      ' !'   

  !

 )*

A< 2  

  " C $



)"



 " (    A< 2  ! <   " C #

!

 ! )"



#:- /#1/&1 #''&  "6   

 !

  !

  $%%'

!

A  !



"6 



! !



!

A  !

! !  !"





 "

" + (

!!

0(! 

"

 < 

" + (  A *   !

!!

 A *  *



* *     

!

A  ! "6

 " 

< !

+ (  A * 

!   

 !

A

A< 2

!  

!"

  !

  !



 A *   #''-   ! 7 (! 

 < 

! 

 "! ""

! 

! !"

  2 (    #- %D $%#:

  )!

 



 

!"



  ( < 

   !

(

  " 

 

! !



!!  "

(

 )"

 

  )!



! "  

 !

 



 

 !

     A *     .

! E 3  "  < ! !

 

!

A  !

 !

 (

  !

 

! 

   ,  !



"

!  $5 %' $%#> !

@  C $&:-- $%#> 

   



 

2 #' %$ $%$%

  ! ! 

< ! !    

 !   (

!   !!

 < !

    !   .

+  2 #' %$ $%$%

 !



  !  !

 "  "



  "

 

(!

  " "

!

!"

      "   

   " ! !

)"



 "    <  +

  #''&  B   !

 "

(



 $%#5 ! 

,   (+



 

 "  (+  

  ( ! 

!

(!

 !  !

! #:5 #''& 

 "   -#



 +   

 A *   + "6 ?

"6

  

  (  

+"             

 / !

@  C #D--'

$%#:   #> %D $%$%1 3 ( ! !   !

   !"

 !

!

A  !

 "





!

+ ?

 2   



 

 !

  

! ("

   

 " "

  ( !   < !      

  

 !   $%#5

2 !

 -#/D1/(1 #''& 

 

   



    

< ! !

(



 ! B   !

! 

    ( "

!"

 !



   

!  !    



 ! 

  !

 )  !

 

  ! 

!!

"  A!



!!!    )  G333 ?333 A     !

3 



 !

   !!  

  (!

"7 

    7     

 "

(  !

     !!

!!  )

  

  (  ?

    

! (!"

 



  

 "   

  ?    )

 

  

    !

"#$%&'('"&)*  ##- A 

 !! "

"    !!! ( ! !

 ) "  D- +" , 

?

+&&,-

 )?  '  

'  '  

              

!  "     '     !



' "

      !'     ")

  @

 

  = !  

 "@'   =   ) + 

    @' @/   

 " '   

' 

:

 )< 

!   )* 5 '     

 )5

'  '     )  @

'        /     )  @  

     

! !!



 !/"   )

 4 '    /  

     )



 '         

  

 )



+  '  !"              

 '    

 )

!

4 '  

"'    '

     !

/  "

)+ '       '

     '  

 '  '      

)*  

! 

 



 "  !!!  ##- A 

! (!  ( !   !

!

!  (!

 ! "

    #:- #''&    ?< !  



  

  



 3     !!





  ?< !

< ! ! ! 

! ! ( !

#:5 #''& 



   " !) ! ("

!!"



     +   

;  

! ! 

 

< ! !  !

C (   !

"

"

!

(! !"

!

!!

 " -#/D1 #''&    -#  (!



    

    

B   !

! 

   ( ("

 "

-# 



 

"



!  !    

2   ! )

 



  





6



     (

!

  !  (!"

  " -#  !

#:5 #''& 

C,

" !  !

   

!

A *  "6 ?"6

  * 

3   

 

! !"

<

 

 A 2

 "

 "

!

A  !

  <

 A * 

   ! 

 A * 

 A 2 )!

 + (  A *  (

! E

    .

! E 3

! !"

! ( A< 2

 !



!

A  !

 "6

 

 

   

  

  !

!

A  !

"6 3 * 

  "

#:- #''& 

##

! 

?

833)+     

     . '  -

  & "

   "#  022:  ! 

 A 023:)+ '  022:      . -

  "#  '      

  )@

    "#    "   

    )   +          "#  "     "

"

 "

      

  ) &           -

   "   

 $!       @ 38)*

, , ?#D

  

= 

 "

 !

!   

!!"! !

!

A  !

  

 ! 8."   .

+  *   * 7E

  4! $%%'H

 !    ( 

!

A  ! "  (  "

8."6 *  

7E





  .

!H

 , ?#D

     !

  

 !  3

! ! 

 

   .

!

 E

 "6 !

A  !

 ! "

 "

!!" 

  

  

!  ! 

"  !    !!  !  /1

3

 ! 

!

   !  ! !

 !!

 

  

 

! !

"





 



(    ( 

 

"



C,

" !  !

(   +"  C

 /

 !!  +"  

 "

    ( ) !

  *

   !



C ( (   !

   "6

  

   < 

 7*  "6 9

 G33 ?333 A  #>:$  ( 

  8 (  H

#%#  



  " +"

 !"

"

 ! (!   , 



     ,

  #%5 

 

  !!

 ) !"

  ( "

  

3!! ?( #%5  !!     "

  !!"



!



 ) ( "

("

)  



  !!"

!!

 !! 0"0 ##& <  (  ( 7 

3   

 ! (



!    (! 

 ! 7 

3   

 !  ( 

 !   

!

    

!   (! 



!

   !

0(!   ."#$%%/(0$%'





!

! !

  !    (!"

!   (!" 0 

@   !

 (!"

0 0 

 !! " ! 

0(!   +" "

 "

 #%5

##& A 

3

 



   (!" 0 0 

 !! !  " !

!   .  "#$%%/(0"

*1/ 

"

!



"

!

9

<

 ! 

(

" $-  

! <

! #:D/(1  3



"  !      

! "

(   

.!   !! "

?

0B) 5      

     

          ) 0:) 5   

          

                          "

  

  ) 82) 5        328      5   .!  @'

!'     

      & !'  !  

    

  

) 83) 4 '

  '   "

  

/ " '   !       329   5 .!@)<!'      

 !  

   

       ) 80) +  " '      

  





 

     /"           

" )+ 

! 

"

   

 "    

!"      

/ "  '     329  .!@)5

      !

!'      D5 > !) "

 "

?/ ;)'

3:E9 8 &&80'

37 -$& F" @" ;) !)+ ?/ > '@563:EE &3999' 89 G) 4 '        

"   !       / 

 )*

  

  (   

 "6  !

    !     )

 



!!"   !



"6     



    )  <

 

  "6     

    <

!

"

 

 

"6           C

 / 

 ! )  <  "

!

A  ! 

" !  !

   !( ( 

(

   !"

 !

,     

 

   

  

     !



!

 ) "

!

!



 !     )"

( 

!"     " "

   

 

 !   !



 , ?5   )  3 2 !"



 

"

  !

 ! 2( $%#5

  

!

"  3   !    

 !   $%#5

< 

!"(!



 ! ) !



 ! 2( $%#5

 !

!

 (< 

  ) , ?5 #& #$ $%#5

  

)  3 2 !"

    =  !  

   +

)

!!

+ E ! $$5  3  + " 

! ,"

  + 

.! 0(!  $%#'/#%1  5'-

 "

 

$> (

?

0B)>    

'     

H +   I              !      

)  +   & "    & 

   @

&)5

   !)+ ?&  I

)@       + 



   ") >    

 &   I'              I

      

 )+ I

      !  I)5        

!

  "I)5   !

  

I)+                /      



        

 

, I

   I)  

"  "    ?& )2   3



    !

 

 "   

4

5 6

 

 7

    5 

 !



  



 !



 



  3 

 5

  

   



"3   

"



 

    2 

    5

   5  

 !     5           

 

     

2    5           9   # ("



   



         

"      

 

 5  5 

   

   )@ "                   !       !            



"  )5

    !  "  "        !      "'  



 I)+  

           "        

    !     & 

C -$) &);



)* 

     

  , + ! $$5  3



 ,-$./

%

785

%" %7

  $!'

@  )"7  

F7C @  (! 

F7C