High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/11863/2023allowed

M/S Whirlpac Aids Pvt. Ltd. And ANR. v. M/S Kamal Kishore Goyal And Brothers

2023-09-21Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary7 pages

" #$%&'()&*+,+'- .

0,12+345$*6+), 7%.8%).$-)$-'%2&3 ..

&%+%+'-&3, 9&3,:, 0,;$<$4;+,2'3&='>$4?@3'%2&3, ..&,5'-)&-% AB CDAE F !

3&,&-% 3.63:-;:<$3;$:-)$4G6)7'*$%&('3%2&5&%+%+'-&3, H'-&('3%2&3&,5'-)&-% III

!J E . K2& 53&,&-% 5&%+%+'- 2$, L&&- (+4&) :-)&3 M&*%+'- 3.

.. ('3 N:$,2+-O '( +<5:O-&) '3)&3 )$%&)

. .

5$,,&) L> %2& P:)+*+$4 $O+,%3$%& ,% 4$,,G 8:)2+$-$G Q2&3&L> %2& $554+*$%+'- (+4&) L> %2& 5&%+%+'-&3 :-)&3 M&*%+'- 3 Q$,)+,<+,,&). . 8&$3-&) *':-,&4 *'-%&-), %2$% %2& $554+*$%+'- Q$, (+4&) :-)&3 M&*%+'- 3.

.. %' 3&*$44 %2& M5&*+$4

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

! "# $%## &'()**+'# # ,'-## +.%## &/'/*## -0## 1%$%2# 4 5 6 7# 8'(9:'(## ,':## +.%## &/'/*## -0## ,')'./;'(2#

4 6 # ,')'<':## $<'.'=## >'='+## +.%## &/'/*## -0## ?@;'<2# 4 6

"7A BCDEFA

" G H G "I

" 6 G J! 7 G" " " "

KG7 "

" 7

" " G

I ""K

" " " "

G 6"

"" " M # NOO%## $-P*<## /-## .9::-(## :'/*<@'Q## P@/(*..2## -<## *R':@(*# # S*<.-(## S<*.*(/%#

T " !T7 " T "I T

U T7 " "

I " 7 !! T

K "

7 V!

"" 7 "I

" !! K "

7 V!

T V!

W " " !! V!

" "" "

""X" "Y ZG "T7 " "K "

!TW "" "

K V T T " " T "I "

I UT

" !

" I K [\

"7 "" !H

! " " " !! V!

K G

" "

" " X" " ]

K 6"

T " "

" "

" G T "

" " " " G " G " " "

I " X" " L"

!"T K " " " " "

" ""

! T K "

K K " U "T

! # $ % & " '" ( % ) * &%* + ,-.-/-0+ + 1/-2-3++ 4-3-5+ ! 7

8) # 9!* %

! *)9 )

:'" ;*

)

9 "

% 9 < (

% !!

) ) * )$

'" = % >% )$ ? =

% )

9 )$

? '" # @ $ ! 9 "

&%*

)

)$ & ) " '" A

!! )

@ *

@ * $ ! " '" # @ ! 9 "

) $ )& % ) % !! !

" '" # @

! ) ))

* >

@ ! )$ %

% * % & " '" # $ !

) @ &

$ ) $" '"' # *

$ !

@ *

* @ *

" '" # )& 9 "

$ *!

$ *

& "

!! !

"# $ % ! $ &'

$ ' (!)& % # $ $ % ! $ * * ( %

! $)

!! +,) *

# * ' " ! )!

! $

* )!# % , ) !

! $ &! '"

$ * ! *&

) ! * '' ! % !! ! & % $) ! ! " !

! $ &)& '&)

& - $ *!

! $

* ' * $ " * ' !

! **! ''" & * & '

$ . '" * )# % ! $

* * *

! )) ''" ' ) ' ) '

$ '(!

! $ &! &''

' , *

" '%#&" !! $ !! ! & $ ! ! )

) *

) " * '" '% & $ , ! -') &! ! - " $ !!# % ! $ )&

! ! ''"*$ ) '" '% ! / & *# $ -! $" " ! & !

* ( *

) !

! !

& & $ , ! %

& '

! $ &! * *

& !

" !# *# ) * * ! '' '' '

!# & $ ! $)

) # % &)0 .

!# $

! $" !

* ' '' * "

* " ! % !

) '(!

''" )! *

! '' #

& $)

* ( ! *

! '

! $ ' ! * * ' *

# % $ ! $"

!"##$

% & '()*+ ,- )--,. )-/) 0 / + ( )(0 0( )((0 12 )- )( ,-- )(

. + ) -2 1/)( ) ()3 ,)( /0+ (-0 (- )//(0 (44. ) )-2 )--2 0() .)52 4 /0 12 ( -),2+ )0 -0 )+ 67 ) /(/( 4 4)/ ) /)-- 4 ,((( ( 1. 0/0 )-2 4 2)( )4 2 , 8)0 /4 )1 ) /0 ) ( )-2 (5 2)( -09 :-)2 )3( ) )52 -- ) 2 )) 4 10. /2/( )1 44/)/2 4 ;0/)- (2( 0/0 /)(( , ) )()1-2 4()1- 09 ) 8 )( 8((0 12 9 ),)-+ ) (/ )2 (44 ;0/ )// 4 ) 1-)0 /)--+ )2 1 ,--2 , )2 1)((9

)5. ()0 )+ , ) 4 ) ) )2 4 )(. )0 -3. /(</( 4 0)- 4 2 /((8) ,(((+ , ,-0 4 4)5 4 )--) .. ) 2 ) ) /. (/ ).)( ) ((1- ;0/ ) ( /(9 =)(( 4 )- ( ) 5 ) ( ()/()/ ;0/)- (2( )0 / ( )52 / ) 59 > ((1- ;0/ (/ ( 5 ) /+ -)5 )- ) ,-0 ;(42 0)- 4 ) 4) 2 )//(0040(-49 ? @9

A1-

B !CD !

% D '()*+ )0 .-.0 1;/ 4 / 1. ) )2 1 4)- 4 ;(/ )// 4 -)5. )1.2 ()( 4 ,((( 8)0 4 (09 0)5 4)/ ( , ( (()- ;( 0/( 4 /)( 9 >( ( )) ( /)(+ ,)( )// 4 ) ) ) <( ,)( /((8)) /)-

, 4 >2 4 /-))+ 7+ E)-1 . )0 )

" # $$ !% $ #& !

# #

# ( #

)

$ !

# # #! $ # % # # !

& !$ $

# '

#& !

*$ +!

(

# % # , -./01,, 2345,, 467,, 89.93,, :;,, <.0.69=./>, ?

@A( B B C !

, 8D.E./,, F1G.H,, I=.993H033,, 467,, IJK>, ?

@A ( " #&

*$ +!

(

# % #" ! $$ $ ! !

# ##

# ( # ! $ & !

# $ %

# # &$ # # # !

# %

! ! ! #

) !

# !& # # !

% # !

% !

#L# !$ # !

% $# !

% #

& !

$$ !

# !

& !

# ! % # !

% !

% $" $ !&

) #

# ( # ! !

#& # !$ %

# !

$$ !

% $ # # # ! % ##& '

B B

*$ +!

(

# % # , N.H6=.,, O.HP,, 467,, 89.93,, :;,, -7Q7>,

( RS ( @" !$ # $$ !

# ( # #& !" TU+!

% !V ! !

# ! $ # !

#$% '

B W !

##" !

# ! &$ #$ !#

# ! !

& ## !!

# $V'

% BX

"! !# $ ! !% !& '% $ # ! % ! $% ' ! % (! % %

%& %

% % )

%$ % *%& %

# +,' ) # !'( %

&" %

%!! % !#

- %

% $ *

%&#

%!%$ .%

' ! / !!% % "! %

! % !

% "# % & %'!% "

! ("# $

$! %& %

%! % ( ! % 102324056278629:0;0 < =78>?0 !

%@ + !

@-!% A!-.% + %' A!-.%