← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2317/1989dismissed

(O&M) Amarjit Singh v. Parkash Kaur

2025-03-17Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger9 pages



   



    !    "#"$%"&  ))*

+,"

&"./#/'(  ))

0+$1/, ,3$'423 3/# 5"2+5 3"/$# +(',3"$ )))))) 66"55+(,# 7"$#4# +$8+#3 9+4$ ,3$'423 3"$ : ',3"$# )))))) "#6'(&"(,#

,3$'423 3/# :# )))))) 66"55+(, 7"$#4# 0+$1/, ',3"$# )))))) "#6'(&"(,#     <: )

 

 $"#"(,  $) ))

+#;+5= #) 7+/#3+5/ 3+84$=

$) (8/, 3+$&;+1= &%'.+,"#

+66"55+(,#

$) ):) +22+$= "(/'$ &%'.+,"

;/,3

#) $0++( +22+$= &%'.+,"

+66"55+(, $) (#340+( +$45+= &%'.+,"

$"#6'(&"(,

$"#6'(&"(, ) ) 

=

) 3/# '$&"$ #3+55 &/#6'#"

+>'%"0"(,/'("& ,;'

$"245+$ #".'(& +66"+5#= /&"(,/.+5 /##4"# 5+;

-+.,# /(%'5%"& ,3"$"/()

'$ >$"%/,?= -+.,# >""( ,+8"( -$'0

'$ .'(%"(/"(."= 6+$,/"# 3"$"/( >"/(2 +&&$"##"& 6"$ ,3"/$ #,+,4# '$/2/(+5 #4/,)



) 3/# 65+/(,/--#<

$"245+$ #".'(& +66"+5 +2+/(#, 14&20"(, &".$""

) = 6+##"& 5"+$("& &&/,/'(+5 /#,$/.,

4&2"= 0$/,#+$= ;3"$">?

3"

3+# #", +#/&"

14&20"(, &".$""

) @= 6+##"& 5"+$("& &&/,/'(+5 "(/'$ 4>

4&2"= +$( +$+(= ;3"$">?

&".$""&) '(#"A4"(,5?= 65+/(,/-- '$&"$"& &/#0/##"&)

) $/"-5?=

0+$1/, +51/, >',3 #'(# 9/$6+5 /(23 &".5+$+,/'( "--"., = (+0"5?=

#'( 1+/> 3"/$# "A4+5 #'( 4(&"$ "C".4,"&

&"."+#"& ,3"/$ -+%'4$)

 -4$,3"$ 6$+?"$ 6"$0+("(, /(14(.,/'( +5#'

0+&"

$"#,$+/(/(2 -$'0 #""8/(2 6+$,/,/'( 5+(& 3"/$#

&"."+#"& &/#6'##"##/(2 -$'0 5+(&)

) ( '$&"$ 4(&"$#,+(& $"5+,/'(#3/6 >",;""( 6+$,/"#= /, ("."##+$?

5''8 +, -+0/5?

,$""

&"."+#"&= $"6$'&4."& 65+/(,=  4(&"$ 1+/> &/"& /##4"5"## ?"+$  

+2+,

9/$6+5

3+(

+$+(1+(

9+4$

B/&'; 0+$1/,

+51/,

+5$+1

+$8+#3 9+4$

+5/+# 483+

;/&';



) 65"+&"& .+#"

&"."+#"& "C".4,"&  )) @@ -+%'4$ 65+/(,/--#=

/(23 D34#>+(& +$8+#3 9+4$&"-"(&+(, -+,3"$ +5$+1

0/('$&"-"(&+(, E)

#,+,"& 6"$ 1'/(, >"("-/./+$?

#+/& B/55= 3';"%"$= 3"

&/"& &4$/(2 5/-",/0"

,"#,+,'$)

-4$,3"$ #,+,"& = .5+/0/(2 ,3"0#"5%"# 3"/$# 2', 04,+,/'(

6"$,+/(/(2

&"."+#"& #+(.,/'("& ,3"/$ -+%'4$ ;/,3 .'((/%+(."

5'.+5 $"%"(4"

'--/./+5# >+#/#= ,3"?

+( +665/.+,/'( 6+$,/,/'( 1'/(, 83+,+= 6"(&/(2 >"-'$"

$"%"(4"

+4,3'$/,/"#)

.+#"

#/(."

6$"&"."+#"& ,"#,+,'$ ,3"$"-'$"=  )) @@ ;/55 &""0"& 5+6#"& -+$ .'(."$("&)

'(#"A4"(,5?= ,3"?

('

$/23, #""8 6+$,/,/'( 1'/(, 83+,+ 04,+,/'(

..'$&/(25?= ;/,3 6$+?"$= (',/."& 3"$"/(+>'%")

) "-"(&+(,# .'(,"#,"& -/5/(2 ,3"/$ ;$/,,"( #,+,"0"(, ;3"$"/( ."$,+/( 6$"5/0/(+$?

'>1".,/'(# ;"$"

,+8"( ,/0"

>+$$"& ('

5'.4# #,+(&/ -/5"

#4/,)

3"

+%"$0"(,# 0+&"

65+/(, ;"$"

+5#'

&"(/"&)

#,+,"& &/& (', 5+6#"

6$"#"(."

+5$+1)

)* 3"

,3"/$ $"65/.+,/'( ;$/,,"( #,+,"0"(, >"3+5- )

*

)

$'0 65"+&/(2 6+$,/"#= ,$/+5 -$+0"& -'55';/(2 /##4"#   

           



 

  

   !

 "  

 #$$ %    

       

   #$ $      &   &    #$'

     & (  #$'

)    

    (   

    &     #$'

*       &   (   

& #$'

+      ,             !

 "  

 #$

  '

-    

    & - "   "  

 #$'

. / 0 )@ 3"

6+$,/"# 5"& ,3"/$ $"#6".,/%"

"%/&"(."

#466'$, ,3"/$ .5+/0)

3"

,$/+5 '4$,= %/&"

14&20"(, &".$""

) @= &".$""& 3"5& "C,"(, 

 "C,"(, #3+$"= ';("$# 6'##"##/'( 5"-,  )) @@)

 -4$,3"$ &".$""

2$+(,"& "--"., $"#,$+/("& -$'0 #""8/(2 6+$,/,/'( 5+(& &"."+#"& /(23) )

""5/(2 +22$/"%"& +2+/(#, +-'$"#+/& 14&20"(, &".$""

) @= 6$"-"$$"& +( +66"+5 >"-'$"

5"+$("& &&/,/'(+5 /#,$/.,

4&2"= 0$/,#+$= ;3'

%/&"

14&20"(,



&".$""

) = +55';"& +66"+5 #", +#/&"

14&20"(, &".$""

,$/+5 ,3"$">?

&/#0/##"& 65+/(,/--#)

*) ( +-'$"0"(,/'("& ./$.40#,+(."#= $"245+$ #".'(& +66"+5

 >"-'$"

,3/# '4$,)

( ',3"$ 3+(&=

/(23 3+# 3/# /(&"6"(&"(, $"245+$ #".'(& +66"+5

 >"-'$"

,3/# '4$,)

3/# 3';

>',3 $"245+$ #".'(& +66"+5# .'0"

-/(+5 3"+$/(2 >"-'$"

,3/# '4$,) ) :"+$("& .'4(#"5 +66"+$/(2

+66"55+(,#  ;'45& #4>0/, .'(."&"&5?

"C".4,"& ;3"$">?

 3/# >"A4"+,3"& -+%'4$ 1'/(,5?

>"A4"+,3"& -+%'4$

6$"&"."##'$/(/(,"$"#, 

)

#4>0/,,"& +&0/,,"&5?

6$"&"."+#"&

,"#,+,'$ &"0/#"

04,+,/'(

%/55+2"

+(1;+$= "3#/5 +$( +$+(= /#,$/., 0$/,#+$= #+(.,/'("&  )) @@ ,$+(#-"$$"& -+%'4$

#'(# 1+/> "C,"(,  ,$+(#-"$$"& -+%'4$ 0+$1/, +51/, #'(# 9/$6+5 /(23)

3"

#+/& 04,+,/'( .+0"

#+(.,/'("& @)) )

.'(,"(&"& #/(."

6$"&"."+#"&

,"#,+,'$= ,3"$"-'$"= ,"$0# ".,/'( @ (&/+( 4.."##/'( .,=  

#3'$, <  .,<= "(,/$"

#3+$"= 1'/(,5?

>"A4"+,3"& -+%'4$

@

;'45& -+55

+5'(") ..'$&/(25?= ('

$/23,= ,/,5"

'$ /(,"$"#,  )) @@)

#4>0/,,"& ,$/+5 $/23,5?

&".$""& #4/,= 3';"%"$= #+0"

3+# >""( ;$'(25?= /55"2+55?

+$>/,$+$/5?

#", +#/&"

5';"$ +66"55+,"

'4$,= %/&"

14&20"(, &".$""

)

..'$&/(25?= /, 6$+?"& 14&20"(, &".$""

)

#", +#/&"

,$/+5 0+/(,+/("&)

) +0"

+$240"(,# >""( $+/#"& >"3+5- 

+66"55+(, )

)

( ',3"$ 3+(&= 5"+$("& .'4(#"5 $"6$"#"(,/(2 3+# '66'#"& #4>0/##/'(# 0+&"

>"3+5- +66"55+(,# >',3 +66"+5# #4>0/,,/(2

+66"55+(,#  ;"$"

"(,/,5"& '(5?

 %/&"

04,+,/'(

= ,3"?

+.A4/$"&  '(5?= ,3"$"-'$"= ,3"?

('

.+4#"

+.,/'( -/5"

#4/,)

#4>0/,,"& #/(."

>"A4"+,3"& 3/# -+%'4$

6$"&"."##'$/(/(,"$"#,  +5'(2;/,3

,3"$"-'$"= .+4#"

+.,/'(

/- +(? +$'#"

-+%'4$

3';"%"$= 3"

("%"$ +2/,+,"& 3/# .5+/0 -/5/(2 +(?

+, 5"+#, 46,'

&+,"

-/5/(2 '%"0>"$= /)") 0'$"

,3+(  ?"+$#)

..'$&/(25?= 6$+?"$ &/#0/##+5 +66"+5# 3+# >""( 0+&")

@)  3"+$& 5"+$("& .'4(#"5 $"#6".,/%"

6+$,/"# +5#'

6"$4#"& $".'$&# .+#")



) '(."&"&5?=

,"#,+,'$ "C".4,"&  )) @@ ;3"$"4(&"$ 3"

>"A4"+,3"&  -+%'4$

+66"55+(,#  1'/(,5?

>"A4"+,3"& -+%'4$

6$"&"."##'$/(/(,"$"#, 

)

(', &/#64,"& 6$"&"."+#"&

,"#,+,'$ #+/& ./$.40#,+(."#= ".,/'( @   ., 2",# +,,$+.,"&= $"+&#  1  2

       



 -  

  (

   !



       - "

 

&  (

   "   

 3   0 ) ?

%/$,4"

+>'%"

"C,$+.,"& ".,/'( @   .,=

+5'("

"(,/,5"& /(23)

+66"+$# 46'( &"+,3 04,+,/'(

.+0"

#+(.,/'("& $"%"(4"

+4,3'$/,/"#  )) @@ >+#/#= >"/(2 3"/$# +.A4/$"& >"A4"+,3"& -+%'4$ /(23)

/(,"$"#,/(2 (',"

%/&"

4,+,/'(

= +.A4/$"&  3';"%"$=

;3'

,+8"

"(,/$"

%/$,4"

".,/'( @   ., &/& (', /(#,/,4,"

+(?

.5+/0/(2 "(,/$"

/(23) 3"$"-'$"= .+4#"

+.,/'(

/- +(? +$'#"

'(5?

-+%'4$

3';"%"$= #/(."

('

.5+/0

 

+..'$&/(25?= /, 3+# ,+8"(

;+/%"& '-- 3/# .5+/0)

"$"

/, ;'45& 2+/(-45 $"-"$ +( '>#"$%+,/'( 0+&"

'(F>5"

46$"0"



     

 



 = $"6$'&4."& 4(&"$ G)      (   & 4"

      &    5  /  

    6 " +  7 6/ ."

(



  8 9)    (  &

    &  (    ( 

  %        &  

  !      &                ! &  (   & 4  &  ( &9 , ,3/# #,+2"= 5"+$("& .'4(#"5 +66"+$/(2

+66"+55+(,  #4>0/,# >"-'$"

5';"$ +66"55+,"

'4$,=

+( +665/.+,/'( #""8/(2 ,$+(#6'#/,/'( 65+/(,/--= 3';"%"$= #+0"

;$'(25?

&".5/("& /, .+((', #+/&

3+# (', +2/,+,"& 3/# .5+/0)

 .'(#/&"$"& +-'$"#+/& #4>0/##/'( $+/#"& >"3+5-

3';"%"$=  &'

(', -/(& +(?

0"$/, #+0"

>".+4#"

#4/,= .5+/0"& ,3"?

"(,/,5"&  5"-, 3$/ +..'$&+(."

;/,3  )) @@)

'(."&"&5?=

&/& (', -/5"

+(?

;$/,,"( #,+,"0"(, >"-'$"

,$/+5 $+,3"$ 6$'.""&"& +2+/(#, "C6+$,")

# +2+/(#, .5+/0 65+/,(,/--#=

-/5/(2 +( +665/.+,/'( ,$+(#6'#/,/'( 65+/(,/--= #'423, /(23)

,34# +66+$"(, $"5/"- #'423, .5+/0

+665/.+,/'( ,$+(#6'#/,/'( ;"$"

 

.'(-5/.,/(2 .'(,$+&/.,'$?

"+.3 ',3"$= ,3"$"-'$"= 5';"$ +66"55+,"

$/23,5?

&".5/("& +665/.+,/'(

>"/(2 ,$+(#6'#"& 65+/(,/--)

) ( 0?

.'(#/&"$"& %/";= -/(&/(2# 5';"$ +66"55+,"

'4$,= >+#"& 46'( +66$"./+,/'( -+.,#65"+&/(2# ;"55 "%/&"(."

$".'$&  #""

('

/55"2+5/,?

'$ 6"$%"$#/,?

-/(&/(2# $",4$("& 5';"$ +66"55+,"

'4$,)

4$,3"$0'$"= ('

A4"#,/'( 5+;= 04.3 5"## #4>#,+(,/+5 A4"#,/'( 5+;= /(%'5%"& 3"$"/(= #'

"C"$./#"

+66"55+,"

14$/#&/.,/'( ".,/'(  /%/5 $'."&4$"

'&"=   )

"#45,+(,5?= 6$"#"(, +66"+5# &/#0/##"&= >"/(2 >"$"-, +(?

0"$/,) ) "(&/(2 +665/.+,/'(

#= /- +(?= #3+55 +5#'

#,+(& .5'#"&) ) 3','.'6?

,3/# '$&"$ 65+."& .'((".,"& .+#"

-/5")







))

#18# B3",3"$ #6"+8/(2$"+#'("&

 !"#



'

B3",3"$ $"6'$,+>5"

 !"# 

'