← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/232/1989allowed

Jugal Kishore Etc v. Hy State Etc.

2018-07-06Mr. Justice Amit Rawal10 pages





      

 !"# $% $&

&'&&&#(#$)%)* +,-  . /01+01 &&&22

 31  0'1+01 &&& 24 #&

&'&&&#((5$)%%* +,- 631 &&&22

 31  0'1+01 &&& 24  !"#$%&' ()%)(*$

1

,1&07318"46"

1022

 '&#(#$)%)& ,& 7,.""1"

10'& 99999 )(*$+& 0  141    8  0

 42    :  .

1  '4 22   ;1.  &#(#    $)%)  4  #((5    $)%%    0  88 <  :416 64&01;.718 ' &#(#$)%)& 22

=2  . /014'0/ 81 4 6 '

&$$)%$)%> 8.4 1;.=40141 44$%&$#&$)% 24;0 11;4 01"184;0





1  64  141  44  #(&(&$)%#"  ($&(&$)%(    881  4 ##&$$&$)%?  1414  ;  0    881  ;.  .  0 8412161 .@4 4."$)5#*1 01  A$)5#  B-  :0  <   1     11  .  0 4418

.0 4442":00:484 ;01  14184;0@:122

 1& '&#(# $)%)01.140; 4& 016 '

&#!?=$)%!8 1.1 4:  4;631 8.:12 48 1.(!?

7 $%81 ;.C01 48 1.5#)7 $581  *011

40 442 -;0

..01410 

1" 11;4 0148 &":00:484;

01  14184;0@:122

 11

.

'&#((5$)%%& 22

=2 611400;40010

442 2106  14144$)&?&$)5#4$)5 18'06"011&"22

&$.$D(010

48 1. $?? 7 $%81  64E 4.84 4144 $)&?&$)5#*F& (-":0122

&#64E 4.8441 $)5 &02244:#(&$#&$)5#& $%&$#&$)% "0 11;4  014 14 48 1.$!7 22

&$4$% 7 $?81 22

&#;

;1.08; 88;108  804"0101";. 4:1& 8 040

.401841414  2

0 01& :61"0 11;4 0144 022

 14E 48121.

1"1" 022





:1:10 44"011"82 .41411 ;

& 041:24;102244"&&"#(&$#&$)5#4" 011"$)5#:

4;22 ;

& 0184 :4;044;

1. 81 21 81;E6==60E 14" ;.

;41=E41 804:121& 81": 1406  141:21 14$)&?&$)5#"00 804;.1472.6:0841216 ;= *?-'$#0&

&$041:00   4&082 .4141:121 6 4414:0

:& '021:161"01  11840 

:.  =       

      

       

     

   

 

     

   

  



 

! 



   "



#

$ 

   %

&'  (  

 )

     &'*          

 $      "("       +  &'*    

$$         

  $   &'* ,         

 $   )    $  

   &'* - 

$$  ( .    

(

  &'* / 0 $ 01  1"0;064 4;021

,

0 "4840 ;1.02244;#?&$&$)5$ 40 4044060E 14&022  4;10 @:122

 1 8:008& ,1&07318" 14  221.;0 0 22

 '&#(#$)%)" 22108814 822

40.1 4"140

:. ;8 = - 082 .4E 4.84411 ;

 0 :408112"1;114 1 182161G ;- 21  06  14144$)&?&$)5#" 16 00;0:1024 146 1 22

&$"8 ;1.&$$? :4 06 1#5&%&$)5(G - 22

&#;80:1 48 1.$??

7 $%81 ;.$D(14 01?(?7 $?81  :4;'0601$)5 & 804"01 022

"1840:118.$D(14 01& ,  210E70:4#%&?&$)5!& , &$((?01.14:4&22

 &$  4  22

  &#  ;8  F

6  :1    0 2121184"011"0 014406 E 14.10:102022

;

1.01 40:102 804G 4- 022

4416. 0214.

8414144$%&$#&$)% "0 "



1:44401;" 1

-

6 4;

41.140841216 0  "  1"  0  :1  14  4  04  1    ; 21E 44G - 022440411  ;1 4  #?&$&$)5$":01:#(&$#&$)5#6:0E 4.8 1414;0 1  .  / 0122 33  !4 2+,  56

. 7122 /+   8$&   

:4  ; 0   1   64 444#$&(&# $51414H &# ???# $(& 6041:0 4;;4":214 ;'%*$-$)5#041: 14;1 02244G - : 8; 20 11;4 01   022

":0 :11144 :1 0 16 114G .- 

214.:164 :42 :

40E 4.8"1114;6"06;7 41;0 1; :& ,& 7,." 142 461 "1 121.0'=1241;

401.

8,1&318;

 ;8.002244#?&$&$)5$041.0 ;7 41&0 114.4 :;114 :0  4  01.1

. & 8 0;44 41 '(*-$)5#":00:

480 ;4":40181 0 411:1810844

"21'(*-":

;81&08114814 .010

;140 4"

6

011"  0  141    0  11;4   01    1.  0  4 8 1.$!7 4$%7 $?81 004022

 

:0

E 44"0 " 1.40 1148 0 22 & 060140 14  1021"22140 221;7406:00114810 ;8 ,1&07318& 2 482 14.0216$)5#" 221  0  0  224  4    0  184  141     #?&$&$)5$;

 #(&$#&$)5#& 1 07;16"1 6   '(14 41 =    *$ % 1    

   .  # 2

% 4

 4

 #     5 ...

....

....

36  

4

#%$ 

 $7  

1/5 ...

...

...

83$4$

4



#$

  

 

#    $  9.

 %

  

" 

  



9.

 %%



  % 3 

 $

$  

   (  #$

("# 5 3

 $#$$  

  (  

("#5 3 

"



 $ 

  #$

("

#   $ ..

..

...:

0< 22 ; $)5#;1.;

5

2244 1$)5$8;2414 20E 4.8 4 21&21.120(. 7"2 22 +0;0  41 = 6;

("  (



         ;"     #

    ) $    $"  #   (

    "   

$$

#  

#

 "    (   $ +   3  $    ;



   

          !  (

 

   

     

  

  



 



 $ "

 



    

 --< $   

#

   $$





  $ #

"(  #  (  



  $  

    /-  =   

  

(  $ 

 $ (  "  ( $   



$    #  

"

   

  (

#

$$ $  >" # " <  



 #     # 

$  ;" #

 

" # " #  "

#  

"

  #  <    ( 2   $   $+  3 $;



 " ?

;

"

 / #

$  ;" 



  <  (   #

 "     >  /-#  "

  





    "

   ("  "(   

  (      ($$#$/

"  $   #

 ( " (

 " (  

  > /<



 ("    $  $

#

2  (  # +  /*  ("  

 /-  "

   

" 

 



     ( 

 "





  <;"  ( 



  

$$ $"(" (   (  $+ 31 (# $

      $;"       

#2



< 

# <# $   $ "

 



 

<#

 #(  

   :

0 1":0 01.0:12" 422 .

0E 4.81414;6"

:408;7.0224 4#(&$#&$)5#&00 1; :06;44;1.0 2244#?&$&$)5$&44 "0E 4.84411 $)5 4$)&?&$)5#*F& (-":01;'06;61 041"

11140 4;0022

"01;101&0 11;4  01

41012121;004 8 04"0101&0:121:102121"011" 4 10 48 1.$!7 4$%7 $?81 0 0422

&$4#;

6414144$%&$#&$)% : ;

& 01    01  2    0  81&  22

=2  F84  H=#  0  '.0"    :  18  0  14  8   && "'1":0"21 114"40:  401144:1"&&" 022

& 4 :0 :0114106;24:0 4010216  1 E 426 ; 0 16184"0E 14 06  121')06  14 14 : ; 674&01  1 0

4   06= 4 022

 1.14.8; 0 4E 1406  1"



0 "082 .44.1 ;

& 4 ;"0 1"1 104;18.0  ; <  ::0 44.022 ;

6:01 444

4 ;6 14 4.0I;

'

218 1 



            

   :0102121:0016:0 216')5*$- "216'?$0

E; 1 "$)$%:

422 1022 && ':

4; 4 41'$ 46  14 14401

4;:0 18.0  ; <  :&0  0I;

'

218  10 4004!"# !     $ "

 %



&'     

(

  22 ; ' )5*$- 11 :""0216'?$ 0

E; 1"$)$%04;114;7& 107;16"

01 6210E 4.86 14 4.0I;

 '

218 1 7E70I* 21-140  = A++   $)  .

 $ # 

"

# (@ + 

# 



   (

< # (     

 

# 

 !

= $;"  

 $$) * +,- ./ , 0 -  

     

   ( 4A  

/%B:

A/9($  ,  $  #

    

  

  +   $ )     $ ( "'( 

 $      

# 

      ?"

  $   +   $      $1 

  $ 1

#



 (

?"

 +   $C (  $  , #

##

 

"

#$  =   1

 

   $     

   $   C (  $1  , +  $1

9

$   $1 

 $ 

 , 

C (  $1  , )   #

  "

#$   $ 

 $ 

  $  $1 ( $ /3 $   $1  < "

 ,  $   $1 # 

 (       

#$   

 

 

#

?"

 $ +  . "

#   ( $ / $   $1 1$



  /3

 # 

   

# #   $ 

  

 

  ?"

      (



  $        +  /3 $       $  (

  3

 /-

      +  $)    # 



  

#$ : 011"44180 ; < 

::0 44.022 "184&



 "  0  82 .4  4.    0   1  ; :  1 01;=4&'

022

=2 1414&1=0; 2121414.

&22 4

:4& &496+9  )(*$

.20 &':;% *0302</ =2

 >2=

*030 3? >2=