← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1332/2019dismissed

Jitender v. Rajbir Singh

2022-12-22Mr. Justice Deepak Gupta17 pages

TARUN SAHNI 2022.12.23 16:19 

      

!"##$%&%'( %"#')#* ++#,,!'"

-&

!./%*%'01  #&+')#'"

 (2  34   5

 



    

 

 

!!!!

 5

6    "  "

 #    $    %  % &   '

()   * %  "( ) 

% "

"

 + &,-../0,'/12 3* %  "4 5 3

"  %6 6 "

"

17 1/ '//7

"

6  (%) $ % "  8 1//9,:20'   "279 ' (  + 1 )  4 "  ;%+ 102  *  "  "1/ 9 

 '/9,:20'

  ₹0 "

"  1/ '//7    ₹:99-//,  

   " 6""   %  % *"

   8 

%

  ""  $ " " 

    6    

"   

 

%6"

8 "

   ()   "8  ( <)  "    "  "  " 8   = "    "  

 + 9(0 /)1',1(' 9)* + 11% %    %         " "

" /.

/9 '/1'

    %6

%  8   >/- 1/ '/1'    > *"

 "8 "

   "

%  6  8%       %

 6%6

 "   %    () ?

  6

 " 17 1/ '//7 

 6

      8 6"

 ;"" 17 1/ '//7 %6 %" %     6 6  "

    6

() ₹     '1 17 1/ '//7" "

'

 " 8 %6   %  "



",    6%6  %66 "

 $  %

 "  8     #      

"    %     % *"

      1/ '//7   8 

%

   ""  ;  ""          % "   81//9,:20'    "279 '     



% 



%  

* " /.

/9 '/1' 

%  %



 6   () 6   ₹'1 

@"  "%    ?

  "   6



.

$      

-

A

"    %6 & 

?8 " 17 1/ '//7       

  6             

  * 0/////B> '

?  6%6

 "   B>

?     

 2

6%6 6 " B> .

?

     %   B> -

?      

B>

?   

%6  B> :

* 



"  %6    %6 &  $ + 12   "   

$ 8 " 17 1/ '//7D8 ?1,  6 

₹0 ;  %    6  " 6  "

  8  6   ""

 6%  A % "       6%

#

%"   & 6    "   8 

6 =  "$ + .7 "  &#    "

6 %6   6₹:99-//,  "



 E9F

     17 1/ '//7              "

       '- /9 '/1-

:

$(&+*+;**D/1 //-'.- '/1-) %6 A  "   .

   (8₹-//, )%      "     6   A  "  &     

  

  %6 6  "       

8  

6   

    6 %  

"

/1 '/10

" %   "



   $ 

66    

    %6    6 6   ""

  

" 6%  6 =  

 "

  

"

$  ""  8  17 1/ '//7 ?  "6     "" " 6/.

/9 '/1'    6

 "   $  "  

 &  "6   %6

"          #

%"     G                !*!)!7!'% 5!')!++!'-&*& !.!,!8&17%!')"1#*&6 9 : -

  

#

% 

 %"%6A &   $   ""  %    " " % %8 



& % 8    "8   "  8 %6 " "      6  6 A 

  % % 6<      

6 "6₹-//,  %  ?

 %

  6 "

 %

 " "

%6& %

H6 "    "%6        A &  "6" 

"     "

 

 1/

$  %

 %     " & 

D8?1, "  #  8 "

 1/ '//7 $  %%6 I

""  ?  "%65 * %  "

%6

 6  "+  G* "* +

% $ "  6 

?7%  8



 "" ?'

 "

+  ?2 H  6  7

 ?7* % " " 8 " %6 * %   5  $  

6?2+    "

 6"* +

%  "  8   1'

 5   

6?.   "  "  "

 "* %       

"

 % % *"



;

+    "

  "

  

%  8  66

" 8  %6

  

  %   8   "

  6  %  % % *"

 

+6%?1J"

 & % " " ""

 " D8 ?1,  % "

     "  "  8

56  " " 8 ?.    

%

 5   "" 

 



%

    

/2 /'

'/1.D8 ?.,H %6 " "  

%

 "      



%



  5    6 %     "8

1.

$        8 "  :

#      H& "

    " "  #  8 %6   =   %   "

1-

= %6     ₹   '1 

"  "/7 1'

'//7 "



  6%6  

%66 " ;    6"   %6   ;       6



  "

   6%6

=   "6  

 %6  6

$ 6

  6'9 /9 '/1'

D8 ?2,H" /.

/9 '/1'D8 ?-,H  " "

 "%  6%6 6

  %



;  "    6 6" "/7 1'

'//7 6  "  "  8

  $ ₹ 

 %6   '1  

"  "    6%6

 % 6 % ?

8

%6   %

= 6% %6 

""    %  6 " D8 ?1,

1:

  %6    &  "6% 

      "

         " 

0



=     6   %

"  % 6       "    "        

  

        ""

 =

6?7  * % 



""  %   6  ( ) 6;#   

   %  ( )" /.

/9 '/1'

    



 " %#  %6  8 "  

     "  "%  '/

$;*%')#*5!;*-&!1!);*%'016%<%,++#!,:992:9= )#$%)#)/>'?/,#;+*#7#;*"'  6 % D8 (') '/ *    % 

   % " %6   

'1

$%*7!,!'!')-&)<#'"*+*!"%'

4")   @6

"    "6 

     +" "  %6;<%  &   K$  "      9

     66"  

6 " $  

     

6% 

 "6   %66  " " "     ?  % 6      

 >  6  %   6      "6 "  = 6%  "

 %  6%    "  "  %  6 %   %    6 "6 "  ? % "#

  %        "6 $  %% 

 6 6 "   "    6% %6  "   = 6% 

   6 6 = 6 

 #

%

L

        ''

$ ?;A!-&1')*%,!%); 999:  %%6;<%  &  %  "   %           6 "

 $   %;<%   & &  8    6         %%6 +" "   %      H 

  "   6     ;<%  & D8 1  '/ *  6   1/

6 # 6     

        "

   " %  (') '/   ;<%

 & %   %*7!,!'!')?&$!&#    

%6 "      8  % ""  A  "    "  "

   "   "   "

 6%   

  "

"  "



   6    

%   

  ; 6   6  " & %6 %"   

 %6  " 

 6 

'2

$  !'!8*%&1'! #))>-&51!0>!,!8&17% :

=@ %  %  "  

%6  

'.

$%B!'1!')-&5;,)%+5;7!*#1"! C2  =C6

      + " " %6 ;

"&   K="

   

       %6 " % = 8 " 

11

=  "      $   

       '/(') * 1972

= "      "      6&  % "    6%   %     % 6  %      =  #   =    *  & ('//): & & -.0@  # 6       

    *3I

+ *    G 1999(-) & & ::

 33"



()%6G*   &  % ('//-)1 & & 17'

3%      "    "  L

        '-

$!">!!%'-&'%&17#) ;&1)%# 996  " 8

   "6 "  " $   K':

= 

#   %      %%     " ''

1'

19:/ =" 8

 (  ./  6)    " "   



  % "  " =  %% 

   6 % 6       "      "   

'0 =    "  " 

  %6%8   % %   =  8   %6 '/ * 1972 %

 6  8 "

"  

 6 

  = 

"

" %    1'

% 6% %6  6"



 8   

 

 6   6 $

 %  J 8

   6%6 % " 6       % 6%6 &  H6 6       * *6 

I H"6 

 6 +   " + D G 6%  6  '9 =

  % "  % %% "    J "

   @6 

  "     "% "      A   6   #    

"6

   "

  "

 =   % 6  6     %6"  "  %   "    "



6%    & 

L

        '7



6 5 *!8!&1-& !7+!"15;7!* =

6;<%  &   K %#    

%   "    "  *      " 

"   % ;   6  %   6   "  

 & 

" " 

  

 6 8    6 =    %65 "H &  %*7!,!'!')<&)<#'"*+*!"%'

4")!') "1#*&6

 C9@(   @D E @ F L

        ':

!">!!%'?&$!&#    G!*%'!%))%H;%-& 12

!7!,%'0!7 ==C6  ;<%  &  #

%  ""       =6 " % % %6   %8   6

    

  

     

&     %8 %6 "   %66 "   $ %;<%  &  " + '"

 6%+ 1 6%  66 

   6  J 6  "6% 

   6 &  

"

&    A %6"

" "



   " % 6 8 "    "

$         & 8 "    %6 ""   ;<%  &   6      6 6%   



& &   8    6   % 

$  ;<%  &       % %6  "   "   "

"  &   "

₹ 6 1-   6

1.

'0

G"   %   % 

  

)  # 6    

        "  %   I5!*#')*!-& %<%#*!+!*"7#'"&

4") AIR 1999 SC 2309

)=      

      "        

  % L!'.!++!'-& !7!&!7> MANU/SC/0203/2015J

)$        

6 %  "6   %6 6 " " "

 ? % 6      

 I%*7!,!'!')?&$!&# &;+*! J

)>  6  %  

6     " 6 "  I%*7!,!'!')?&$!&# &;+*! J )*     " 

 "  % "   " " 

    6 8    1-

6 L5 *!8!&1-& !7+!"15;7!* &;+*! J  )? % "#

 %                  " 6 I%*7!,!  '!')?&  $!&#

&;+*! J 

)D8 1 '/ *  6    # 6     

    

   "

   " %  (') '/



); 6   6  " & %6 %"       %6  " 

 6  

L ?;A!-&1')*%,!%); &;+*! J '9

=  "  " %        % %    8   A   6

 8 "     %6&   '/ *     % 

2/

6 "%   "         

%  

   "   

 6%  M

    6"     "%6

@ 17

₹ ₹  6  

  :99-//,   0G@       

 8 " @  ""   %  6   "   " 

% %%6% %

$      % A  &  "6  %    " 17 1/ '//7 ; " % 6    %6





#$#7/#*6   5

 *#';

   ?

", ,+ ?*% ,+ 1: