High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1465/1992disposed of

Sampuran Singh v. Rajinder Singh

2019-04-29Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma16 pages

!"# $%& '&()*)+, - -

, ."/ !

! " #

! $ % " &'()*&'++, " -&&').()&'++) //// 0/ 1! " " 1 2

# $ " " " 1%!%"

" 1% & "" "" 1 %&'& (

) !"

* $ "3 2'()*"'++, 4(5"

- "- "

6'6""

6',6 " " "" "1& 3 7 %" " "',%,% 8 % 9 ! 1 " " 1 """ 1" :

2!1 8 ! " '*+#+ ');3, ')5 3 )

" " <= <:= > <-= % ! " "

'+5*'+(4 "":

! 1% ?" " <= "<:= '*'3' "');3, <-= ! 5'5*'+(( ,'5*'+(( 545*'+(( % " " 3!1

$ ')+3' 3 !2((@(, ',43'. # !2(*@(( ;3 # !2((@(4

.,3', 3 !2*5@*+

! 1%

2,(

@ "" ! 1% 2'

2;'5

1 ., 3 ', < = ""

2@ 2,&:1

1% ""2@ 24&3 1 #

1% 0 " "

@ 2* . 0

& @ 2'''4 1%!%"

0 A7 , A7 ( A7 C.@'& C.@4 A7 C''@$& C''@B A7$C;@&$C;@- 0 ! '5 555@& !', ! %

1 ++34"')5 3) " 2'*,4 18 " %

" "

@ 2*.

" "

1% 3 " (" 1 " '+'4 6 '+'46 %"

45 555@& !

!! ,'5;'+)+0 " ! 1% "

@ 2,( 1% !% " ', " '+'4 ! 1! 2*.

2,( !

2*. " ,'5;'+)+ !

! ? 1 " " '*5('+.( !

" !

! 5(','+.) A7 '4A7 '. :

2,( '*5('+;5 "

%1 ! " 3 1%66$AB 661%""7"

! " %

!', !% , ! %A7 A7 D ! 0 ,(54'+;, A7 '; ! " % " '(5*'+;*

3 1# ""2'4 " " " A7 , A7 ( %"44 555@& & 2'( !

3 1 # 7 %!"% "" " " 0 ! 1 1 1 ! 45 % % " ';5*'+(4 !

" 7 ';5*'+.40

! 1%

1 &

'45;'+); " "%

1 " "44 555@& " ! 18 " !

0 "" "

" % ! % 0

3 1# " " .,3', 1% ! 0 ! " ", !% "', !%0 !1 " 1$

'*'3 '"');3,

@ "" 1

" !%" ');3, 0

')53)9! E # :

@ 2'''(! " ""! % " ! -" "! &

" !

# $% &

( ( ) *

+ + , ( - $ * # &

//0 *

! *

+ 1 : 7 " -1% 1 31%

31" ! -! - 1% 1 "" 1 " -1! 1 %"! !- 1 -"" !!8 " " "? ('44" - "- 1

% " !

" 0

" & "" ! % 1 ! ';5*'+(4 !" ", !% !

! " '(5*'+;* 0 !- " A7 " " (*" 9 A !

1 " " A7 !3 0 -1! % ! " " A7 C.@'&

C.@4 !

! % "1 ! "

0 !4'5.'+); ? % A7$C;@' $C;@: $C;@- !

! %'+),0 1 ! 1 !

!! 66F 66 0 " 1 1% %'+),% " , !% ', !%0 ! 1%3 1#

& 7 1 0 " 2)% " 2'''(

1 "

C 0 %! " ! 1 "" " !" " 10%28 G8 !# # 9 .,3',! " !"

++3 !

! ""2, 4

! " 1 245" ! "$C;&

+*34"')53) ! 1% " 1 " 9 &7 ! " %'+(( 1!1%!%" !

H ! 1"% !" -1! % " "',

!! ! "" "1& 1% "

6'6"6',6 0

! 1%!%"""7"

1 "

! 1 3 0 & ""

3 % ! 1 !

3 1 # % !" " 1 -"

- 1% $ % 1 " " 1 1 8 " % 1 %"! " H ! !"

1% - +,# !"

$ - ' . / 0#, 1 ( 20 " 1 1%% "G61 - 3

$ - %% 0 " ""1 " % %2 " 1 " "

! & $C&; " !', !% , !%A7$C;@

! " , !% 1 "A7 , A7 ( !"', !% " 11 1%!" $ !#

!%! A7 !3 1%!%" 1 "

! 17 7 A7 C.@'A7 C.@4 " !"'+);"

" ', !%A7 C''@A7 C''@- ! 1 1% "1 " " 1 ! 1 " " ! 1 1 %

! "

)5 )," !! " 1%&! 1%3 " "

G61 - !445 /55 !44 5 56 !"

!445 /55 !44 3& $

(7% -

- !44%5044!"

)044 $ ( 7 % .( -" " 1%"" " -! ! 5''5'++) !

1%!

13% % - " 1% & % " % "

! 1 " - "

1 ! 9 " 13! " -1! " ! "! 61 I "!6 " &

! 2 " "

1 " "

/.# !- 2,+4' "

1 & / 4 "

(5 1 &&

666666 $

666666

4 " 0 89

.)2 ).

//7 "

/./ 1 8

" % !-& % % "% 1% 0 " 24, 44 & 33

$ 9 *

& &

! *

( / !( : 4 2 4 2

) 4 4 & & 4

" &&

9! 1 "? ('44 " - "- !

& 338 4.. %0%

"2 42"

0 ; & 9 "

9 & ! #< & 5

2 &

== !-1 -"" !

!@ 1 " % !- " A7 !

1 " (*"

9 A !

& 99 7:)

9 > "

#< =&

0 & & '< ;

= #< = ( 9 33 " !%17 !

! % 0 "" 3% "

3 1 # 7

% " ! !

% % 1 "" %

"! " " " "

3 %'+), !" "!% !%0 1" %'+;*0 1 1 %"% " 0 !"

" "

1%G61 - 9 ! " !%1& 1 1 1%!" B 3"

1 % " & 660 9

! 1 ! $

3 ( '

4 2 &

9 7

# && ( '

4 2 &

? & 2 '

( :

2 2

9 7 ;

& 0 !

@ @ " 0 @ @ " , 1 B4 :

1 : (01AB 5

1" %'+;*0

"';5*'+(40 " %%7 '+.4 2! " 18 8 "

" 8 3 ! " 9" 13 !% 9 1 1%!" 1 " ! ', !% 1 1%1 8 " 7 !8 1 31% ! -1% "A7 1 1 " % " 1" 1 1% -1! 1 %" 1%"

"! 1%

! 11% !- 9 !" 9" ! " !

8 1 " ! -0 1 I "! " 1 3 % " ! - !- " " % "? ('

44" - "- ! !

1" !-,,5*,5'+

" -1!113 " 1 ""

! ! - % 8 1 % " 0/ !

- - J 3 @ #&*4 1 #&*4