High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2501/1989allowed

(O&M) Dharam Pal Dhiman Etc. v. Haridwar Giri Etc.

2024-04-05Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal18 pages

"#"$%"&'( ) *+" $&"$( ) ) ,*$*- *. ,/-*' "0"*#"&+,$12,3#*'&*'+,"$ 44"..*'+# 5"$#1# *$/&6*$/$/ "0"*#"&+,$12,3#*'&+,"$#"#4'&"'+# 77)

,*$*- *. ,/-*' "0"*#"&+,$12,3#*'&*'+,"$ 44"..*'+# 5"$#1# *$/&6*$/$/ "0"*#"&+,$12,3#*'&+,"$#"#4'&"'+# (83 39 3

$"#"'+( $9*'6*.".:&%0*+"

$9*$+/;"<*:&%0*+"

$%/'&*'6*$:&%0*+"

*'&#,""'* *,/<*:&%0*+"

$+,"*44"..*'+# $"-*'+*$/':&%0*+"

$$"#4'&"'+'

! "##

$$ %

& &

( )

$ '

* #+ +

, %

# # # & . &

* #+ +

# * , 1 % 22 # & .

3&45

6 22

6 ,

& &

6$76% 2$* ,

# * 8 )

* -

2 '

& # &9 "

' :

( .

7 &

!" ##$ % "& '

& !

)" '

&!"

' *% #(%& *+(+ %

"'%( (%+* $"",

%+$ +!%

!" ## %!(%- + + %& %$ (,

%+ !(%%# %&*#(%&

(

%('. ) !

(%$ %""

* !( +"( + %&%(+*

$%+"') ( /+( ' %!(%- + + %&%(+* , /+

%%##

( *('&0) &'

% 1+'*& %# %2)"

+!( & %+( ( !%(

3 *$3 * -(1'3 * , 456 78, &((9 '%

(-(9 ''

( 454,78:,'3( &'+(- 9 +(

'( !(

')0 (+('

(, 4;::<; 45:=+!( & %+( 44

>&)'( " '+!%)%"+

"0+?( ")"

)

+ (0 (0'"% '

() ($ +( ) *

"%#% @(! ,$ , ($+($ ""!" ## ' "& '($+(

"%#A+9 (+(. '&"("0,

*%) (- %&'

%('

! ' )0

( + + %( 0 '% % ((0 0 $ * * "* %##'*(

%('

')0

'-"

%+(

" ##?&($ %#%

(A (

""* '"%,A (

% (!+(=*8!(:%# $(

& '&

')0!" ##( !" % %

!(*(! # '&

')0? &9 B

"'&9 %"0

) ($+(""

* '"0!!%

', C

"C&(, $ &!(%))"

( ? * &(?8'& $

"%#

& (%#A ('"%.

& &0!

(% +(+)+ % ($+(0&

($+( 4::?:; #%(

#( & . '& %# '"%""* A (. 3

%# -'

%!(%- + %& % )

!(%'+

'?0

( (

%('

( *

& ')0+1)'",)+ % !(%'+

'. ?: 1 '

( (' ( =!' !+1( %# &'("%+!!%(

%#'

# '

'"0,

%#!" ##?&( 3 &'

&& %)%#""

')0($ +(,$ ('+'% 9%$ %0%#

. )%'

!!" %%#&'%#3 9 $ "

!!% *&(

(%)"

%!(%-

+ %&%#!!% * %#

&!"

. '%!

(%9 $

"%#($+(.

*$ ?5

($+($

!+1(%#

&!"

-" -%#"

')0**%&&

) #%(

%2)"

%+( '*%

%""%$ '*

?#'*

-"+ %) (* ) !" ## "& $!% %+!

5<747E %$ (, ""

* ** %&&

%%9!% %;&% ) 9#(%&#"*%# + =A?56478)+ -" -%%:< %:8 %# 475 =AA?5<7475, %&

')0 %&&

0 (455

(!"

(+ #"

')0""

,#'*)0

-" %+(

')0 %&&

4;E '+& (%+%('

& %#

= DA % A !"

'%(

%('$ )0

'& '

&** %&&

!(%( %#"*%#

-"+ .

% ""+( *

''% +& %!"!!

A"*+* . ) =( - * () %# "" ?E

$ $ %0 '% 2 9%$-(+(' '

*% $ % A(@%&" %

&!"

=$ % +( '

*% %&

%& ! A% 2 9%$)%

* $

(+* #

%(0 %

($ 3+ 9%$ /+

* $ ?5 @+&(=$ %#( '%#' "3 ""?

=A (&* ?;? () %#3 9 09 $ (-+((-+(+ ' %* ''$(

( % & '$ ""

$!!

(('+ )+ '% 2 9%$$

( $""%(% #%( ,# (-+(9 $('+"*+* ,

&+ 9%$

'% +& ""

%'"0,#($+(%

9%$*('+"*+* ,

$ 0 ' %$(

$""

("*+* "9 ('+$ % 9%$

% &!(%!

("0 '( -* $ % () %#"" & #( &

A ("%*$ % %# #( '' %$ -( +( (+ &

- (0#( & '9 ' & %$(

$""('+ 0-(+(9 '+9%$!

%$(

$""'% %

(%%#

A (' %

% $ % ( $ ""?9%$ % &F #

* $ ? @+&("%'& $% 9%$

%($+(

?5?

? @+&(?@%$% *)%+ -( +(?'

#( '%#' "3 "" @+' "3 ""

&!"

!(%!

0 0'% % 9%$('+'% +( $

(($ +(9 $('+?47 %# % $

- )

& '*!(%1

* % !

(%#

(

'"" & ,

0 - #"

'( .(1'$""

* ' %)

"%#($+(?#"

(!"

(+ ?#"

'= A.

%' -+($!(%1

'?#"

'? &'

& + #"

' )

.($+(

"& '(* ?#"

&!%((01+

%+ ,

+ A& 'A #+"

. ('&(!(%1

' " ' , "

%+* '& (%'

'* %#A ( ""* '"% ' ($+($ ( +(+. )

%#!" ## % %)0#"* '&

'$(

& %# &'()"

*+ *,- .- !/ ''

(("0 *0 %(*+& %#'

# ' %

' "

( , $ )0

%+ " ( !(

* '

# ' !!

& "0 **($" ' *- ##'-

= D+( 2 2) #%( ' %$ ( !!

%+(

( #"

$ * %+( %+ "

% !( # ( !!

" *

%('

( &!"

('$((!( 0. )%( ("%##'*)00* %$ (" %+( (( ' #

% -'

' + ' +!%$ ("%+(

" '+!%.

#'*%# ("%+( ( ( /' %) %'

> '

$ %$ (% '% ' "

'+!% ''/+=A)0 - &"*&,6<=868<=!(%-%&' %(0 +(

G(* +9 (* 44E=6 5< %# 1

#( !!

" ')

+ &(' '% 6<477 '+(* !

0 %# !!

" ' %

('$((= %#'"% "& ' & "# %)

)%#3 9 ?)+ 3 9 !!% & & )0 0*

%# A ( '"% ) !!" % #%( &!"

'& ""%$ ' % 64474?

"" $

' %#"

-" -%*

%('

' ##'- '

' 5<74 "% *- )0

**($" '- ( #"

$ $0 ( ""

A >+'* ""%$ '

" $ %+ (* !!

"" 2 %+ "

$ % $ & D+( 2 2

'##'- $ !!

%#"$0 ( ' $ 0%(*+& %#!!

"" %

A>>+'* &

(* ( %

'($ %$% "%# &(&!"

'3+ !!

%+( ''% *-

%!!%( + 0 % ""

* $ "" +, ) * !+ % ""

* ) #%( %2)"

%+( '

(('

8E+"

%#J

$ ,

# ;7 67<6478 &(#"

'!(

+ #%('

"( %

$!% %%#&* & '

% (%" %# '( -" A&%'( A,

*$('

' % =E:@? ' %! ' #%( !

(& 1+

(* '

# ' % ' 6 #(%&

(# (*

!" ##2 !% % '

&* & %

# ' $

%! # ' % ' 6 %

"&*

&* & ' % (%"%#

'( ' 2 !(%!

$ $

**%&&

4;E?;8'

!" ## $ %"0 &!"%0

+!!%(

!" ## 664475 (" %+( '& '

+ " ###"

' !!

" 6<477 A+(*

0%#

!" ## = &(' '

!!" %#"

'#%(&!"

'* ('$( ( %# &(

# ' % ' 6 %

!!" % 644474

%$ ( !!

%+( ""%$ '

!!" % ;<474 A # ' %'6#"

'?EE68?474*

%('

'64<4474 5<474 %$ ( !!

%+(

"%#

!" ## ' '

+ %+ " #%( '

# ' % ' 6 ( #+ ' % ''( (*+& 6474 (

' 4474 3% ?EE68?474'!(

( 0 6474 %!(, '-%

!!%

- (

$'(

' %+)& /+(

("0

& % %+( 44:

- (#"

'?6<<?44:#%(!!% * %& %

- ( :444:

$ %('

' %# '

!!" %

&!!

"#) (' :<6<8 ('$((' ' 6<:

- (#"

'?:7;8?6<:#%( '+ '#%( !!% * %

( !

- ( !!" %!

'* :6<7 '

%('

( ! ' ?:67;?6<: ' (&!"

' %# ('$( (J .#2 $ #

. &

& 1

< 22 * "

4 #

3=1+*=1+ =1+/ =1+, =1+>5 - #

/ 2 22* ,

* #+ +

* *

& #

* "

6 2!- * ,

* "

/ $ 2!#,3=1+05

* "

2!3=1+0 =1+85

#, =1+@ 1 ;7 A +)&

')%- #"

%+( &KKKK+

""*)"

??? $ (

' !"

%#($+(

&!"

)(%+* & !"

- % %

( $

&!"

( (- '($ +(%(

(- '!

(#%(& ' $

&!"

- % %

( ' (* $

&!"

($ +( $

&!"%0

'( %&&

,$ - !(%!

("0

%& %9%$)%+ )0 %&* '%% $ % !+(+ ,????+

""*)"

????,-%"+ ("0', $ '($ &0 "# #(%&

"" )

'& '

($ %9

( %#

&!"

- )

#%( )"0 9 % !"

!(%!

0%#

&!"

( *(

'0'

( "&

!(%!

0%#

!" ##

(!% %, $(%*$ '($&0 "##(%&

' - () '

$( *%#$ '($"#(%&

+ &"#"

) #"

%##

6:<:57 -' 3 ( -+( )%- '& +) 0 % "& %/+( ', *$('? ''? ' '? 'J $$ / 6! 2!#

& * )

0 #+ +

* "

' &"

!'#

;7 **%&&

(

%('(

')05%(7!" ###-%+(%#

(%+* **%&&

#() 94;E?;8

** %&&

"% !(%'+

' %

%('

# ' %! %#

& %#

!" ## &'

& !!" %$ "

(( (%#( 455$ %+ 0%)1

% "" $%+"' %$

!" ## ')

' %

!( & '!+

** %&&

# ' %"6'

0 ')

!0*

'**%&&

'%)-%+"0

( %$

%!!

' % '!+

+ %( 0 %#

**%&&

%'+

' %( "

( #(%&

& '

""0,

+ %%#

(

#-%+( %# -" (%+*

** %&&

4;E?;8'

(

(%#

(

!" ## %+( %

**%&&

455,#+(

( %$

%!'!+

$ "

%+ %

)00 %($

(

" ')00 '

** %&&

"% $ % ''+

' )

( "*

( #(%&

&%( ( %"%

!" ## $%+"' )

%!!

' #(%& #"*

(!"

(+ # (1'#

(% "

' % &*

##( '

!(%!

0%#

-" &0,# %'

( ,#"

-"+ & "#*

**%&&

$ &

( )

')+

$ % '

-%"+ ("0

%( ' %

**%&&

"%*

& ) 9 % %$) ""%$ ' %#"

(!"

+ )-%+"0

#%(

% &'

%+ #%(

0%#

& !!" %#"

')0

%&&

%) "#%#

-"*

!" ##

!!" % %#

!" ##

%('*"0 '& 'J $% ' !$7!%* "

* "

'* "

$ 2 * / ! !%/ 0 $

)

&9 "

;7 359

,7* :, ,, 7* 0,$7,# ,%7/ 0 , 7) , * ,67 +# ,27 @

% % #

5 '

3$5 '

# #&

% % 3%5

& & &

* # + +

#& *

7 365

6$76% #

2$ $6 '

$2 -&

& + -

)

* *

* # . 1

C $!

' 1.

. &

A * , B

* CD $ "3"0 3"45" 3"4"0 6 # ##3 4"0 "+ 03 *

7-89:;-,<="

# & & # $ '

# )& 2!72 3=1,$5 # # #

#+ +

& @

E #

8 " +' #

# &

+ &* #

) $

#* , &.

/0'

! !% * ,

, "#

2 223=1+95 * "

/$ F ","

, $

# ,

$! 2! &* "

, & . &#

# "#

6 2! &

) +

2 $$ '

:4 #& * #

# & #

* & &. &

* $% &

&9 "

* # # # &

&,7* :, 04

0 ,

, -

,8 # # ,% *

+ #

8 #

+ 4 , 0

8 ) , ,) & & # ) , ,

$6 /0

& #

# ,7:, ,7%/0

# #& &, )&* #

, )&* #& $2 '

) 9 "

# #

& 9 "

& $!

& - #

, 7) *

* "

* &

* & # & * "

& /0

=1+@ #

* & * # # # #

# #

$ 2!"#

2 26 "

22 "

% 22 #

& #& * #

4,$7,# &,7* : , ,27 @

+ , ,2 & =1,

1 ++ +% & ,

* "

: $ 8 # !

& :+ ,

* #

%6 2 8

, &

%B7

< 2 < 2 & 2 B7

E7+

* #=1+ B

2 2 726- #

# # 9 "

# &

$ '

E # ' 9 "

* $ '

% % #

& 1'#

' & , & #

& . # ,

' * "

# ' #

'#&

$ $

' 1

' #1 +78 ,

+ , +

$ $ '

4 & &

& *

'9 "

$ % '6

6$76% - & . 2$-

8 9 "

% % @ # # #

9 "

& 1 &

# # #& % '

%$ "##

$$ %

! #

& 9 "

* /0 %%

* 0

& & %

+,4$/.: ) 39 3 '+

?,"+,"$#4"*;/'2@$"*#'"& (!@ ?,"+,"$$"4$+*A."

(!@