High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/1525/2015disposed of

Simran Arora v. Central Bureau Of Investigation, Special Crime-Ii, New Delhi

2016-02-25Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan8 pages

!"#"$%&%'( ) *%+, ',, "!%!%'", -",&.&

"'!, /.," .'0"&!%1 !%'2*3"$% / ,%+"2"4"/5% "&3'#"'!

( 67 * 8 7* ,"&"'!( ,-%9, + 5 .#5,%2*"'%,#0$ !"24%!52 , ,&5%!*"!5%2#0$ !"2,!5"3"!%!%'", ,*.95#""3** '#5.2*"'%,*! '#%'1 .'&"/2 ,,"&3'#"'! 2"4"/5% :5"!5",!5" "3,!",&/$ /'"4&3 3",+ ;<" //4"#! &""!5"=.#1+"'!>"& <","",,"#!!5" "3,!",,'!"& :5"!5",!5"=.#1+"'!&5./#<","3,!"#%'!5"#%1"&!>"& 7*

7 *%+, ',, 3"!%!%'",5 &$5 //"'1"#!5"%+3.1'"# ,#", # !"# ?@ ''"A.,"2 3 &&"# <; !5" /" ,'"# *3"$% / .#1"2 2 .'= <2 !% / 2 4,'1/; +"'!%'"# & ##%!%' / *"&&%'& .#1" '# .,!5", ,#", # !"# ?B

''"A.,")23 &&"#<;!5"/" ,'"#*3"$% /.#%$% / 1%&!, !"2

2.'= <2 !% / 2!," !%'1!5",#",!5"/" ,'"#*3"$% /.#1"2

2.'= <2 !% / 2 & $+3/ %'!.'#",*"$!%'C /& $5 //"'1"# ,"!5"&.<&"D."'!,#",&# !"# ''"A.," B23 &&"#<;!5"/" ,'"#*3"$% /.#%$% / 1%&!, !"2 2.'= <2 !% / 2 &4"// &,#",# !"#? ''"A.,"?23 &&"# <; !5" /" ,'"# *3"$% / .#%$% / 1%&!, !"2 2 .'= <2 !% / 2 $++%!!%'1 !5" $ &" ! !5" .,! *"&&%'& '# ,#", # !"# ? C ''"A.," 23 &&"#<;!5"/" ,'"#*3"$% /.#1"2

2.'= <2 !% / 25/#%'1!5 !!5"$5 ,1"&.'#",*"$!%'?

'/; ," + #" .! '# $'&"D."'!/;2 !", , +%'1 !5" & %# $5 ,1"2!5"$ &"4 &&"'!< $9!!5"*3"$% /.#%$% / 1%&!, !"2

2 !% / 5 0"5" ,#!5"/" ,'"#&"'%,$.'&"/,!5"3"!%!%'",2 /" ,'"#&"'%,&! '#%'1$.'&"/,,"&3'#"'! 2"4"/5%2 '# 5 0" /&$ ,".//;1'"!5,.15!5"%/" 5"<,%" $!&!5"$ &" ,"!5 !!5" "'!, /.," . '0"&!%1 !%'%/"#!5"$5 // ' 1 %'&!'"* , <=%!*%'15 /% & =.

'#!5",&.'#",*"$!%'&@) '# ?," #4%!5*"$!%'@) 5"!,% /4 &$'#.$!"#%'!5" .,!!5"/" ,'"#*3"$% / 2.'= <2 !% / 5"$ &"4 &#"$%#"#20%#"=.#1+"'! # !"# ?@ ''"A.,"C ! $+"& .! !5 ! !5" 3,"&"'! 3"!%!%'",2454 &'"!5"3,&"$.!,%A2!.,'"#5&!%/"#.,%'1!,% / 5",","2%'!5"=.#1+"'!2/%<",!;4 &1%0"'!!5"3,&"$.!%'! %/" ' 33/%$ !%'.'#",*"$!%'C 1 %'&!!5","+ %'%'1

!4 3,&"$.!,%A ! 33,3,% !"!%+"!.,!5",$+"&.!!5 ! ' 33/%$ !%'# !"#)

@4 & /," #;%/"#<;!5" ,%'%!% !%'1 3,$""#%'1&.'#",*"$!%'C 1 %'&!&*%+, ',,

3"!%!%'", 5" /" ,'"# *3"$% / .#1"2 2 .'= <2 !% / 2 3 &&"#!5"%+3.1'"#,#",# !"#?@ ''"A.,"245%$5 &54& !5 ! !5" /" ,'"# $.'&"/ , !5" 5 # !"'#","# %'! "0%#"'$"&+"#$.+"'!& '#!5" &! !"+"'!&!5"4%!'"&&"& 33 ,"'!/;2,5/#%'1 '%'D.%,;.'#",*"$!%'C 2!5"

$'$/.#%'1 3 ,! !5" ,#", # !"# ?@ ''"A.,"2 3 &&"# <; !5" /" ,'"# *3"$% / .#1"2 2 .'= <2 !% / 2 %& ,"3,#.$"# &.'#",( E'0%"4+;%'#%'1&%'!5"+ %'$ &" '#! 9%'1 %'!$'&%#", !%'!5"&! !"+"'!&,"$,#"#.'#",*"$!%' ) & 4"// & .'#", *"$!%' )C *%+, ',, 2!5%& .,!%&!5"$'&%#","#0%"4!5 !

3,%+ $%"2"'$" '!!;3"#%'!5"!,."$3;!5"

3"!%!%'",.'#",*"$!%'C %&+ #".! 1 %'&!

*%+, ',, 4"0",2 &3",!5"3,0%&%'&*"$!%' C 2 &#%&$.&&"# <0"2!5"+ !",%&,"",,"#! *3"$% / .#%$% / 1%&!, !"2 2 .'= <2 !% / 2 , .,!5",%'D.%,;%'!5%&+ !!", !", ,#%'1," &' </" 33,!.'%!;!!5"3,&"$.!%' &4"// & $$.&"#4%!5.! <"%'13,"=.#%$"#<;!5"3,"/%+%' ,;%'D.%,;+ #"<;!5%&

.,! ,!%"& ,"#%,"$!"# ! 33" ,<",".#%$% / 1%&!, !"2 2.'= <2 !% / 2,B 5/+ # !5" .,!%&#%,"$!"#!&"'#!5"%/"!!5"$'$",'"#

C $.,!4"//4%!5%'!%+"F '0%"4!5"& %#,#",2!5"+ !!",4 &3.!.3<"," !5"/" ,'"#*3"$% /.#%$% / 1%&!, !"2 2.'= <2 !% / 245 0%#"%+3.1'"#,#",# !"# ''"A.,"B2!," !"#!5"

& %#,#", & $,%+%' /$+3/ %'! 5"," !",20%#"&.<&"D."'! ,#",2%!4 &5"/#!5 !"'$".'#",*"$!%'? %&+ #".! 5",","20%#",#",# !"#? ''"A.,"?23 &&"#<;

!5"/" ,'"#*3"$% /.#%$% / 1%&!, !"2 2.'= <2 !% / 2!5"

$ &"4 &$++%!!"#!!5" .,!*"&&%'&5"/" ,'"#*3"$% / 2.'= <2 !% / 245#" /!4%!5!5"+ !!",20%#",#", # !"#? C ''"A.," 25"/#!5 !"'$".'#",*"$!%'

? %&+ #".! '#2!5",","2$++%!!"#!5"$ &"< $9!!5" /" ,'"#*3"$% /.#%$% / 1%&!, !"2 2.'= <2 !% / ',#",!3,3",/; 33,"$% !"!5"+ !!",2%!%&'"$"&& ,; !3,#.$"*"$!%'C 245%$5%&.'#",( E

,$"#.,"%'$ &"&+"'!%'"#%'&"$!%'

? :5"'2.3' ' 33/%$ !%'+ #"!%!%'!5%& <"5 /, !5",4%&"2 '; .,! %& 3%'%'!5 !%! %& "A3"#%"'!%'!5"%'!","&!&=.&!%$"!5 ! '%'D.%,;&5./# <"+ #"%'! ';"'$","",,"#!%'$/ .&" <&.< &"$!%' &"$!%'?245%$5 33" ,&!5 0"<""' $++%!!"#%',%',"/ !%'! 3,$""#%'1%'!5 ! .,!

,2 & !5" $ &" + ; <"2 %' ,"&3"$! #$.+"'! 3,#.$"#,1%0"'%'"0%#"'$"%' 3,$""#%'1%'!5 !

.,!2&.$5 .,!+ ;2 !",&.$53,"/%+%' ,;%'D.%,;2%

';2 &%!!5%'9&'"$"&& ,;2

,"$,# %'#%'1!!5 !""$!G

<+ 9" $+3/ %'!!5","%'4,%!%'1G

$&"'#%!! 1%&!, !"!5"%,&!$/ &&5 0%'1 =.,%&#%$!%'G

#! 9"&.%$%"'!&"$.,%!;,!5" 33" , '$"!5" $$.&"#<","&.$5 1%&!, !"2,%!5" //"1"# "'$" %& '' < %/ </" '# !5" .,! !5%'9& %!

'"$"&& ,;&!#2&"'#!5" $$.&"#%'$.&!#;! &.$5 1%&!, !"G '#

" <%'# 0", '; 3",&' ! 33" , '# 1%0" "0%#"'$"<","&.$5 1%&!, !"

5"34",$'",,"#' .,!<;&.<&"$!%' %'

,"&3"$! '"'$"+ ;2%' ';$ &"45","!5 ! .,!

5 &'"%!5",+ #" $+3/ %'!.'#",&.<&"$!%' %'

,"&3"$!!5 !"'$"',,"="$!"# ' 33/%$ !%',!5" + 9%'1&.$5$+3/ %'!2<""A",$%&"#<;!5" .,!! 45%$5 &.$5 ,+", .,! %& &.<,#%' !" 4%!5%' !5"

+" '%'1&.<&"$!%' C&"$!%'?

$+3/ %'!+ #".'#",!5%&&"$!%'&5 //<"&%1'"#2

45","!5" .,!+ 9%'1!5"$+3/ %'!%& %15

.,!2<;&.$5%$",!5" .,! &!5" .,!+ ;

33%'!G

<%' ';!5",$ &"2<;!5"3,"&%#%'1%$",!5"

.,!,<;&.$5%$",!5" .,! &!5" .,!

+ ; .!5,%&"%'4,%!%'1%'!5%&<"5 /H

C'!5%&&"$!%'2I .,!I5 &!5"& +"+" '%'1 &%'

&"$!%'?F !1"&!&54!5 !!5"3,$""#%'1&$./#<"%'%!% !"#' !5" 33/%$ !%'%'!5%&<"5 /,<; .,!&'!5"1,.'#!5 !!5"

)

.,!%&!5"3%'%'!5 !%!%&"A3"#%"'!%'!5"%'!","&!&=.&!%$" !5 ! '%'D.%,;&5./#<"+ #"%'! ';"'$","",,"#!%'$/ .&"

<&.<&"$!%' *"$!%'? 245%$5 33" ,&!5 0"

<""'$++%!!"#%',%',"/ !%'! 3,$""#%'1%'!5"& %# .,!!

%& 33 ,"'!!5 !!5" .,!5 # $!"#.3'!5" 33/%$ !%'245%$54 & 3"'#%'1 <"," %! '# $'#.$!"# !5" %'D.%,; <; ! 9%'1 &+" #$.+"'!&'%/" 42 .,!5", D."&!%' 4./# ,%&" & ! 45"!5", !5" /" ,'"#*3"$% /.#1"2 2.'= <2 !% / 24 &=.&!%%"#%',#",%'1 .,!5",3,"/%+%' ,;%'D.%,;<;!5"/" ,'"#*3"$% /.#%$% / 1%&!, !"2

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

@ ? %&!,% </"<;!5" .,!*"&&%'&2$++%!!"#!5"$ &"! !5"$.,!!5"/" ,'"#%&!,%$! '#*"&&%'&.#1"245,"+%!!"# < $9!5"& +"20%#",#",# !"#? C ''"A.," 25/#%'1 !5 !"'$"2!,% </"<;!5"/" ,'"#*3"$% /.#%$% / 1%&!, !"2 2 %&+ #".! ' !5"&" $%,$.+&! '$"&2 + !5" 0%"4 !5 ! !5" 3,$"#.," / %# #4' .'#", *"$!%' C 5 & '! <""'

3,3",/;//4"#%'!5"3,"&"'!$ &" #+%!!"#/;2%'!5%&$ &"2!5"3,&"$.!,%A4 &'"!5" &! ,4%!'"&&"&!5"3,&"$.!%' '#%!!.,'"#5&!%/"5",","2 33 ,"'!/;2%!4 &"A3"#%"'! '#%'!5"%'!","&!&=.&!%$"!5 ! ' %'D.%,;&5./#<"5"/#.'#",*"$!%'C ,!5""'$"

$++%!!"#.'#",*"$!%'? < ' 0%"4 !5" & %# $!&2 !5" ,#", # !"# ?@

''"A.,"23 &&"#<;!5"/" ,'"#*3"$% /.#1"2 2.'= <2 !% / 2 ,#",%'1 .,!5", %'D.%,; <; !5" /" ,'"# *3"$% / .#%$% / 1%&!, !"2 2.'= <2 !% / 2 '#!5"&.<&"D."'!,#",&# !"# ?B ''"A.,")2 ''"A.,"B2 ?

''"A.,"? '# ? C ''"A.," 2 3 &&"# <; !5"

/" ,'"#*3"$% /.#%$% / 1%&!, !"2 2.'= <2 !% / 2 ,"5","<;

&"! &%#"5"$ &"%&,"+ '#"#!!5" .,!!5"/" ,'"#*3"$% / 2.'= <2 !% / 24%!5 #%,"$!%'!5 !%!5" .,!%&!5"

0%"4!5 !!5"%'D.%,;.'#",*"$!%'C %&'!$+3/"!"2!5"

.,!&5 //%!&"/5/#.,!5",%'D.%,; '#%2 !",!5"%'D.%,;2%!%& .'#!5 !!5"$+3/ %'!%&,"D.%,"#!<"+ #"2!5"/" ,'"#*3"$% / 2.'= <2 !% / 2&5 //5%+&"/+ 9"!5"$+3/ %'!%' $$,# '$"4%!5!5"3,0%&%'& #" ,%+%' /,$"#.,"2?@ !!5" .,! +3"!"'!.,%&#%$!%' /'14%!5/%&!4%!'"&&"& '# /%&!#$.+"'!&5"%/"<"'43.!.3<","!5"/" ,'"#*3"$% / 2.'= <2 !% / 2') )2,.,!5",3,$""#%'1& %&3&"#

7* ) &=9&