Sarabjeet Singh v. State Of Punjab
5
!
!"# 4444 (&( $%&!
4444 (*$!, $% $% $% $% $%*+$ $%*+$ $%*+$ $%*+$ ) ) ) ) ! ) ( $!) ( $!) ( $!) ( $!)'#< '#< '#< '#</5 /5 /5 /5 $, !") $, !") $, !") $, !")'#< '#< '#< '#</5 /5 /5 /5
2-4
2-4
2-4
2-4
- - - - 4 (#"":+/,;$'
%$ # 4 4+ !"#/,, $ $!+&!
4 ===== - - - -/40+3 /40+3 /40+3 /40+3 ! * $!#(
!% + &!, ' $!>6$%# 8
" .& .(#!# / 0# !% $
,(1 # 23 3 %$"! $%* * ( ?! ' * $8
/ !'(
!"
$45 , , >445/ " ( , %$ $%% ( *&! (# &!, ' $!( 6 6/ 603/ 503 !, 0<3 $% ' / / $+ '
$!#, ,($!/ ( ' +4 4
";7 ! $% # ++ " $!
!( " !( # ( # '$7*+ !! / / !7 +8/ @!; !"#/ (
, # $! 44< $&
9) / #
:( *$'
, !" $:,( # ( ;
; ++"
$! %$$ 4
++ "
, # :# !# '
'# ,!
# *$!,$%; ++"
A A //// !"#+$!": # #
# (($! #& ;
$! ' $!,( $** ' $ !%$! $% # '$7*+ !! 4$ #$% # 7+ "# ,%$7 # ' $4
! # 7 ! 7 /
!"#0* # !3/+$!": # # ( ($! :! !"#/ '# , # (*$ ! # '4 / :! !"# !%+ '
,( '. +$:$! # '.$% # '$7*+ !! /:# + !"# ";
!"+ +$: $! # ( # "#(4 & B& ! +8/
!"# 0* # !3 , $ '. # '$7*+ !! : #(:$,/ 7 !" # ( (#$&+, $:
/ # '$7*+ !! ( , # ( "# #!, ! ( +% /,& $:# '# # (:$,( &'. # ! +$% # + + % !"
$%# ( "# #!,/ (&+ !" ! ! !
&8 %$7 :# '# +$$, ( , $$C !" $& 4 % '&( !" # (/++ # ($!(%+ ,:8%$7 # (*$ 4 - !
, '$&!( + %$ # #( , # &(+$% # ( +%(#$:( # ++ " $!(+ ," !( # '$!'$'
,/ 7*$ !, , ;$ , $% !8 7 4 - !
, '$&!( + #( %& # , # # #(
!%+( +8 7*+ ' , ! $ # ! B& ( $!,& $($7 * 8%' $!/!,/ !(* (* ' ($!($% ; ++"
/!$(&'#% "# $ !' , ! #, .
!*+'
:
! # * - !
, '$&!( + #( "& , # # '$7*+ !! "$ # ! B& ( $! " ( ," !( # $! # ( ($%%+( !,'$!'$'
,( $8 !, # # !
( (&( !
!
,/ @!; !"#/ :
( +% !%+ '
,4 44 - !
, '$&!( + (( ( # # *$+ '
#;
!$ '$!,&'
, % !, 7* + !;
( " $!!, # !B& 8'$!,&'
,($% (!$ $!+8 !'$7*+
/ & +($ !
, : # (4 - !
, '$&!( + #( (( , # !$ # !" ( $
'$;
, %$7 # 4 $ $;
/ # '&( $, + $" $!(#$&+,!$
&( ,(*&! ;
7 (& !, ( &( % ,$!+8
:# ! ($+& +8 !
((8 %$ # '$;
8 $% 7 + ; , & # 7$ / # ( ,8 $ $ ! # ( " $!!,/# /!$ &( %&+ *&*$( :$&+,
( ;
8 ( !, !" # 7
# !, # (4 ! # %$ ( ,(& 7 (( $!(/ # "! $%! ' * $8 + ( ! ,%$4 >4 '$! /+ !
, '$&!( +#(% + , *+8 8:8$%! %% ,; , , >4 45/ ! # $& $,8/ :# '# ( .
! $! '$,4 ( !"(& 7 (( $!( ! !, 7: # # ( , *+8/+ !
, '$&!( +#( $**$( "! $%! ' * $8 8"& !" # # $%% '$77 ( ( $&( ! ! & 4 - !
, '$&!( +#( , # # (* ' % '!,, ' ++ " $!(" !( # '$7*+ !! #((* ' % '++8!7 +$!": # # ( '$''&( , $% " ; !" ( $&( !
( $ # '$7*+ !! 4 ;
! # 8$% # $%% / # D ( ((& ( ! ++ .
+ #$$, # # 78 ('$!,$ 7* : # # ; , / %# ( !+"
,$! +4- !
'$&!( +#( , # # '&( $, + !
$" $!$% # ( ;
%$ # *&*$( $% !,% !;
( " $!!, $&!
# '( $% # *$( '& $!4! # (& 7 (( $!(/, (7 ((+$% # * ! $! ( ! ,%$4 <4
#;
# , # + !
,'$&!( +%$ # ;+* (!,#;
"$!
#$&"# # ; + '$,$% # '( 54 ( * # *& %$ # ! # ! B& ( $!/ # $&(!,(* ' % '++ " $!(+ ++ ," !( # 4''$, !"+8 $ # '$7*+ !! / # ''&( , * ($!(/ ' !" ! %& # !'
$% # '$77$! !
! $!/ !
! $!++8 ( !
, # 7 $! # :8 !, # +&!'# ,; $+ ! ((&+ &*$!# 74& !" # ( ,$''& / !"#+$!": ## (($!E #& ;
,$! ' $!,( $** , !%$!
> $% # '$7*+ !! / #
8 +$'. !"# (:84$$! # / # +$!" : # # ( ($! E :! !"# '# , # (*$ ! # '4 ''&( ($!( # ( , '. !" # '$7*+ !! 4 :! !"# !%+ '
,( '. +$:$! # '.$% # '$7*+ !! :# + !"# ";
!"+ +$: $! # ( # "#(/ #
8 '&( !" !
, $ '. # '$7*+ !! : #(:$,: # # ! $! $'&( $&( !
&84 '$7*+ !! / ! $, $ (;
# 7( +%/ ( , # ( "# #!, !( +%, !, # (:$, +$:( &'. # ! +$% # + + % !"
$% # ( "# #!,/ '&( !"
, !" !
&84 ' $% '. !" # '$7*+ !! : #, ,+8:
*$!+ .
(:$, %+ ' (; $+ ! '$!,&' !, ' 7 !+ !
! $!$% # # # 7!!
!:# '# # ($!( $ ! +8 !
'
'$7*+ !! $! # :8 !, ((&+ ,# 7 : # :
*$!(/ * 7 %'
/ (#$:( # # $''& :( !$ (&,, ! B& + & ,
!,* , ,' 4 ($!(%+ ,%$7 (*$ $!+8% '&( !" !
( $ # '$7*+ !! 4 544
#(
!(* ' % '++8!7 , ! # /!, # ! & $% # ( & , $# 7 (( $&( %+ ' !" # ( 8$% # ++ "
,' 4 $'&( !8*+&( '&( #(
!(#$:!/ # (( "
/%$7 :# '# '!
, ' *# , # # #(
! %+( +8 7*+ ' ! $ # * ! 4 94
(
% !" $7 ! $!# # :# + '$!( , !"*+ %$ "! $%! ' * $8 +/ # $& #( $ B& +
:
!(% "&, !" !, ; ,&+ "# ( !, *$ ' !" ($'
+ !
( 0(34 $& $&"# $ '.$!: # # 7"! &, !,! & $% # $%% F # $+ & , $ ,F # !
,%$% !,%
( " $!(+($ # ,
!, : , 7*' $%(&'#++ "
, ! B& ($! # ($'
84 ( 7* ;
#
<
8* ($! ! # $'
8'! D* ' ! 7$(*# %
%$7%$
$, !" G% $%!8 !(" (( $!4 # (( "
/ # (!$7 +$! '$, $ #$+, # * 7 %'
( !$ 7, $& " !( # 7 +:# '##('$7 $! '$,!,* + 7 !8 !;
( " $!/** $
( + (# , ($! ( ( %$ # ''&( $!(4 #&(/ ( !$ **$* $"! ! ' * $8 /( :$&+,!
(( +8 '&( 7* , 7 ! ! !;
( " $!4 ! ;4 ! + #7 ;4 ! + #7 ;4 ! + #7 ;4 ! + #7 H
H
H
H ;4 ! + #7/ 0II93 9 69 ) II9 0 3 IJ ;4 ! + #7/ 0II93 9 69 ) II9 0 3 IJ ;4 ! + #7/ 0II93 9 69 ) II9 0 3 IJ ;4 ! + #7/ 0II93 9 69 ) II9 0 3 IJ/ # &* $& # +,(&!, )0*46I/*53 K54 A % !, %$'
! # (& 7 (( $! $% # '&( $, + !
$" $! ( B&+ ;
+87$ + ' $!$ , #!B& ( $! !"(&(* ' :#$ (:
++
!('$!'
,: #%;$& $, &!, ' $!> 6$% # $, !'( + .
# (/ !
$" $! $% (&(* , * ($! ( $% !,$&( ,;! "
!, ( !
!"7!8&( %&+ !%$7 $!(!,+($7 +(:# '# :$&+,#;
!'$!'
+ ,4&''
(( !(&'# !
$" $!:$&+, +&, % # (&(* ($!.!$:( # # (:
++*$ ,!, !(&+ 8* (
+$, ,& !" # 7 # ( !
$" ,4L 8$% ! !
$" $! !(&'# '$!, $!:$&+, ,&'
$7 &+4 "&7 ! # # '&( $, + $" $! (%&"# : # # ,!"
$% # ($!
!"(&
, $ # , "
7 #$,( !
, !$
'$&!
!!'
,/ %$/ (&'# ! "&7 ! '!
,;!'
8++''&( , !++' 7 !+'( $& #( $* (&7 # (*$!( *$+ '
$%% '
(:$&+,'$!,&' # 7( +;
( ! (*$!( 7!!
!, # #$( ! &( , : # # (. $% , ( !
!" $%% ( :$&+, !$ '$!,&' # 7( +;
(($%% (4M 944
!;
:$% # ( $&(!
(($% # ++ " $!(/ # $+ & $ # !,# ('$''&( ,:# + 7 ,: #:
*$!(/'8 !" ; $+ ! '.&*$! # '$7*+ !! / # ($& % !,(!$'$7* ++ !""$&!, $ !, #
% $%, (' $!8 % $ # 4! !" +/ # (( "
/:$&+,!$ $!+8&!, 7 !
# ,7 ! ( $!$% &( '
& 78 +($ $+, ! # ,!,*$( # $ # (% 8!,:
++
!"$% ; ' 7!,$ # : !
(( (4
! ;
: $% # "; 8 $% # ++ " $!(/ # (* ' % ' $+ & , $ # / # ! & $% !
( (&( !
'$7*+ !! / !, # (( 8 $% '&( $, + !
$" $! %$ % !,
5 #$$&"# !;
( " $!/ # ( $& ( $% # '$!( , , $* ! $! # # ,$ (!$ , ;
# '$!'
(( $!$%! ' * $8 + ! # %' &+ 7 D $% # ! #!,4 $ $;
/ '&( $, + !
$" $! $% # (!
((8%$! ( " $!G $&!;
+ # & #4
$! (/ #&(/, ;$ ,$%7 (!, (#
8, (7 (( , (7 (( , (7 (( , (7 (( ,4 64
$ # !"( ,# ! $;
(#++
,
, $
! D* (( $! $%$* ! $!&*$!7 ($% # '( ? !;
( " $!4 I4 !, !"**+ ' $!0(3/ %!8/(#+++($( !,, (*$( ,$%%4 0 -3 0 -3 0 -3 0 -3 '#< '#< '#< '#</5 /5 /5 /5 7#; A# (* . !"? ($!
,) (?
$ A# *$ ) (?
$