← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2750/1989dismissed

Ajit Kumar v. Atma Ram

2019-04-12Mr. Justice Amit Rawal16 pages

 ! " #$%#&'( )  ( "  (*++,--.     /

/     

        

 





!"

 # !

 

!  

/ /

$ 



!"

 # !

 

!  

/ /( 0'&/ //

    

        





!"

 # !

 

!    /

/ !%  



%

    

        

 

!  

.

1'2!&# ! 32 %  & '

 ' ( 

  '

) (

 * "

#! +

,-./(,-012,-03*43132 *    +

0(4/45!+ .-5*4335

'

 (

 *  !+ .-5*4335 *     ! +

,-./(,-012,-03*4313

6666  32 &   / 

/

/ -/

/      (    7 ** ( *4080  **    *     

' 

 *

/  /

/ -/

/       (    7 ** (      7       7  97   *

' 

 *

 !    *   *     

7    

             

  !  "   #$ %  & '  (    )  *+)  $  $ ,&)-%().  *+ -8-*4314*

  * 

" *  :*  :#( /     0$*+)$$,&)-%().

  *+ 804*431,* 

" *  :

 :#   /          !  "   #$ %  & '  (  *+)  $  $ ,&)-%()).  *+ 3/4* 431,* 

" *  : :#  !+ .-5* 4335     $  1     )  *+)      

  !" #$ %& '().2 *      ,4 /4 4335(  7*  *

    4.

/8 4311; * + 0( 7



*      

)*  (** !   



    *   539 4/    

  5/9 4    %  

  39 3     < * 

 *  5.9 .   19 48   ,8 9 3   *    (  

  

*  4./9 .  

    '        =*   + 4       

*  1.9 48   449 4 

   (519 41    %      5.  9  41              *        >  7     **  

* + 4 43-/ 

 ** 7  

*  1.9 48  



* + 4?*  4./9 .    +

,//4(.111(,8-. .8,**    

     ** * + 4?    7 %  +$ (9  *   > @*  1.9 48  (***  > 

  4/9 4/        * +

3/A41"1?/#(,4A4",?4/#  *  *  !( + 53/,  48 /3 43-/  (7 >( 7      *   (('  (%  ( *   7*    (  +$ ( %  *A * + 4(79 *   ** >  (*  (    5/ /3 43-,   >*B   

7(  * (  ;   *    9   *>    -.9 8  

** 7

*   539 4/   *

*  5.

9 .    3* =* + 4?    519 4-     % (39 3     (4/9 0            * 

 =*  + 4?  7*  

 (7    *     4./9 .   1.9 48 

)  

>*  C ( **7  

  7  *  449 4 

    489 .     (

        519 4-    %        *   ***  



 

*+$ (%  *A *  + 4( > **    * (

*  *   A * + >*  4/9 4/     7 **     7(**  7   * * + ) *  > 

 $ A * + 5*  *   **   *   7  7 **     40*% 7  )

   7 

   4      **   7   ( *     *

@    7  *      (          *    * 

 &?

 

  

   

 



 

 

      

   



   

   

          

  

  

   

   

!   

 

"#$$ % &

 )  (*      (* 

*  4/9 40  

  (=  (  *9 7 ( *  7       9

 * ( * !    * 7

$ A * + 5*  *

*  ,-9 4/  (*

  5/9 4 (  7* *   *,4(.//A?(     ,- /3 43-3

@    7  *      (          *    * 

 &?

)

  

 

'(    

   )

 



  

  





   



 *+        





 ,    !   



 %    



   "

 -   

 

 (  # $$ . &

 )

  

 

   

 

   

 



 ,   

 

   

    





 *   



        ! 

 



*  

   %   

 

"#$$ 



 /   (0



1 - &



    >     * 

  7 * 7  

    *  ***(7  **3 9 3  (7     

*  5/ 9 4 (   1"7#* * 

*

  5.9 /.  (   

     7   

*   4/9 40     ( + .111 "D> %0# 7  >  97*        * B  

   * 7*      *

  7*  *        *    !          

,4 /4 4335(  7*  * 

   4.

/8 4311; * + 0( 7 

 '

    ' (          

  7 '

) (    7**"

# ! +

,-./(,-012,-03*4313 *    +

0(4/45 !+ .-5*4335(  *  7

 &?

#  >(7 *   (     * 4-203*!    +*  ,8 /5 433.>    * .0*  * *%   (% 7(

*

/4 /0 43..(  

7

#  > 7 7   7   (      

#      >          *    ;  * !   *

    4./  9  .    (        1.

9 48 

# +       *5/* B   (4310"  :4310

:#   

  C    %  (  *    >

#  (     *-3* 4310 (   



# **?

! '7 *  7'*

*    4384    =7  43-1(   * (  

 

7*  (7  

# )*> 9(

  (7  

#   7 * * 7

$   40*% 7 

># ' *    7

>#  >  

)  *  (  *  

  &?

# 33$   %  *+)  4     )33  5  1("   7**  ,8 /5 43.. #33 6   %  *+)   $   %.    1("  /  

337 0)*+)8)$0).

54,1 9-/ ( > ; 

  

# % 6 %)*+)  %  %.4 5 1 9/ (*   5* (  79

#33 !$*+)$ $6:! .

,- , ! 6-/ (   >(* ( ;       

%  ('

 (      7**    ! +

,-03(,-01 ,-./*4313 *

 !+ .-5*4335(       

*  7  *   

  

 

)    * 

  7  7     *..* 4310 (  !    7 * * 7         ( * (  * (     >  

7 *B       * (  ;      +**43..  % 7  B  @7 *>( !  7  *    * (  

> 7(* *      * +

,44(   7   *          7         * 

7*  *   * *

 

  ('

( 7   7 7    * 

   * (   * 7  * 

   *  7?

  (7 ***( 7      ( * 4.,24.5*  *%   

) 7('

' ( 7  *  *  (7 *(  7



 )  7

)    *   (  

 79   

*  7 (

(  

  * * ::7 E  * ::

  *   &?

 

)

  





2            3%%   

4   0  1 

( 5 

 )  

 *   ;  (  7 *

*           >   7 *   *'

' (    (  %    C  >(  (  (       7 ;  

       *  

  C  *    * (      *440"#*) D  (41-,(  

  &?

66& 

/,%- 4 ;! &&2   017 *     

         *

     66 +$ (=F,( (    79     **  *  

  !         

*** 7     

D> %5(  (  *>  (  ( 7* * (  ,- /3 43-3(   5/9 4    % (

$ ( D> =8(  

  19 48  =

( D> =0( 4/9 0      )   =

( D> =?5 39 3 ! ( D> =.(

***   (7 ( ! 7

*     % ( 

$ (     "D> =8#( * *   *

$ (    ( 7  

* 19 48  =

( D> =0(4/ 9 0  )   ( D> =5 39 3   ! ( D> =.(7979

*    489 .    *    (* ( **(     

( 



         7

  !$3)&)"

 #(   >    (   ;       >

C       ( (   ( (   7 ; (7   

 *   *   >* (*  (   *   (    ( 7  7 7      *4310      7

 7   *   *

  *     7B:7      '16*+) 71).

5,/-  , ! 6- /   *  =F,?+

$ (   C   > >

*   *7 

)     9* ( 

*  * ( (   *'

' ( * D     *  (      

(  @  1!.* *%    =F,(  

?>(   > 7 ! **   ?

* + ,(  (



*(7>(



  *   *           !  +  $      **?

  !(     7*    

   (   /0 /1 43-/(9   >*    "D> %.# 

  ( + .1,"D> %,#    (  

   *     * *    *    *   * (  7 > 9(7  * 

(     (   A  * 

)$ %3)&)"

 #(     * >   *   (   > (  * (    

) 6 %3) "

 #(*  7

*  "D> !?4#(  * 7 *   (7>     ) ( 

    (                     > 

  9*7 (  + 0*  

  &?

66!  +            )

  8 

     9)

 

9)

&'



    )

/4 (

   



  

    

! 

  



 *& (

7

                *     9)

&'    

     

8    

     

9)

 7    

  * /     



*

    

&

9 ( :7/  ; 

$

  /+&33 * $ 

!7                         )  





   7



 

  9)

&'    

 

   )

   

   <'

+ * *

)



*

 7

  /4   (

  ;

 (

  $

  (

 

=

(



 

*

 7 

 

      

* /4 (

 /4 (

  *

)



 

   

 



*     66 )7 03)&)"

 #;      >(7        ;        9*7 ( + 4*  

  &?

6601

  



2 

 

    (  %!7

  /

 *



  

 2   





  

66 )    (  *'

'   > ;     (  7

$ *  *     ()

*         *   7     7

:7 E 

* : *  7( 

  *  &?



 )* *   ?**?

!    ?

* 

  )* *   ?

* ?

!   ?**

  ()* 

  

     (* (   *4., *%(*  *  (79 (7 *  

?7   ( *   *   

*  39 3     (    

*  *  

 

 

?7  7 G@ ?45?*4335(  7* 7**      

7  7   7 * > *  *

 (  ;  7

* ***   *  39 3 

   ( (=   7 

7 * ** A       * 

  (*  (7  *   7   *  5/9 4    

7 *  * ** 7*

7  *   ( 7 *  *

)*  *  7

   7  *  **

*  39 3     

 ;5.9 .  (  

(  

*

*39 3  (

      

(> * *!

! (              (   

?

7        

  32  &#("!

    H    F  9A  

)+4   F ! 7 )+4