High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/375/1989dismissed

(O&M) Bhag Singh v. M.C. And Anrs.

2023-05-03Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan8 pages

!"" #$ % "%$ "! ! & ' $(%$ $" )% ' " '')) *( )+' ",-" $ ' . "$%% & ),!

$ '')) # ,!

&"$ $"# ,!

'/ #" )1 , ! $!

$ ') "" #$ %"%$ 2(%$ (" " "("!"'

)+' "-"

&)) / 3 "%$ .

'"%$," 2 "+$ /"$ % , ")& 1+"%/,.()"%$ ,-" ,4"% '" ) - ("%5( !-'""6$

/78 ' 3 - " $ 1 "( " +$ /"$ % ,.()"%$ ,-" '$" $') "" ,$& & $("

2"-$) 9$("!"'

)+--",-" ,&$"!$

'!"" ("!"'

) +--", -" $ - & ') "% !$- ( !" $ .(3 )!, (2(") !"2 :#:$&"$ !$-9 - &$"'$ 2 &"&$"!$$') ""

$& & 4 ) - ) 5( &$"!$& 5( ) 5( !-'""6$ /78, 8, , 8, , 7, 8,8, 89"& $&"$&$"'

-$ 5( $ 2 & ''

! &$")75( & ,&$"!$& $( ;" - !" ("!"'

)!, <$') "" ($') $ "$!$-') $& ''

! & "!)(21-" 4 $ "%2 ( / 3 "%$ "$ &"%')# 2$& 2)%"%$') "" ,&$"!$" !( ))1&% 2!

(') ))"4$ 78&$ '$') -,"& $&$ ))"4$ 782)%"% !!"%$') "" " $"-" 4"!!$ $" !5("21$("!"'

)+--"=!; $

$$""$")$!-' " $" % $"'"2 !49$$ ") (" )""$1 ,&$"!$& &"$ &&"$'-"" ") $ $ "-,$') ""

"!( !" 7 $.(3 +' "!, 72 ")"% $("9"!$"%$ $ "" & !"21$ ,$$ ")$! ("

2"%'("!,2$$ '' !$(" ")"%'

&" - > $ &" - ") 21 /, " & !$ $"-" 4"$!$- " ); $ (2(") & 421("!"'

)+--""- !" $.(3 )! $ "&$"!$$"'() " "( & !) 2(2(") " !--":)(" $ "-4$ (-2 "'() 79 $ 23!" & !

)) - $ % ) '(2)"! " )(" 7 2( 23!" & ") 21 $ "" 9 "!(!" 7($.(3 )!, & !"21 / -') ""

#$ %"%$"&$"!$$$ (2-"$ $& & 4$

78 )%&"$-$4$ (-2 $!--"$ "))% ))1 4; $) '(2)"!'('( $" )

" ;9$&$")("!"'

)+--""")(" 77 $!$-2 !4 !" "")"%$ $ "! 21 #$ % "%$9 $ !$- & &

'' " )(" 79 $ ("!"'

+--"$!"'(2)"$$!$- " '(2)"!23!" ")("8?7 77,$&23!"& !","& " )"@")(" 779"& $ & $ A- " '' ) $ A- '' " 79 $ !$- & $ "-')- '

4&- !

!!"%$

!$-') 9$'

4"=""% $ )1 $') "" $ 23!"(!$ ($ $ $(""2 21 "- " '')1 )( $ '(' +( 3(""!"9 ($$') "" "''21$" ! !(! - ")"% $ ("9 $ '"()1 !" !$- 7 &

-21$ A-"" "!

" , $ $("$ 2!-" (!(( >$&" - ")21 /,$$ "$ ))% " )))"$') " "%$ $"&" '" 4$ 78 '" $ $ )2)21 $"- "(' -)1-) 4$ -,."

-"%$,3"6 (

$,&$ ! 1'

" #$$ ' 1 "-" ) $(" <$ ') "" $ ") ')"!

" !"% $

))% ""$&" -&$ " "%$ -" $') " $') "% $'

", ))&"%"(& - B$$$') "" "& 4$ 78&!-'"" ')#C .. > "(/"'&$$$ !5(" ( $

2)%"%$') "" !--$ ;> " !C

.. B$$$') "" "''21$"& ! !(! ")"%$("C .

B$$$(""&"$")"-"

"C .. B$$$(""'')1 )( $'(' +(

3(""!"C .

7 B$$$"!$-') - &$"' !" "!

" ))%"'

$') "C .. B$$$(""- " " 2)"$' -C .

B$$$(""2 !!( 3" ! 1 '

"C .

)" <$'

")"!"('' $"'!"!) "- 7 $ "%) !() $'

",$"

)+( (2D(%>+) ,-" !""(/ " ( /$)"%$ /$ !5("$) &"$" $'!"2)"-" ! ""!" $.(3 ! &"$!" $.(3 )+' "!, 7

$& "))% )"1"$ 9$!) "- $') "" $ $" & 4$ 78&!-'""')# $ !5("

( $ 2)%"%$') "" !-(2-$ ;& (2 2)"$>(/ &!" $)"%$ $"%" )!$-& !""/-2, 7 ")) ")"% $(" $') "" " ") 123!" E $ !"!(- !, $ ') "" " '' !$ ))% $ !$-,&$"!$& !" " ))1 ''"/-2, 79 $) "! / $ )"%$)1 -" " $ !$- ("%$'!1 $("$ % $!

( !"$ "" !$ ))%$ -,$ ,$& ''21$" !

!(! - ")"%$(" ("!()2 42"-

7 >(/& !" "$ " ( $ "" $)"%$ ("& '')1 )( $'(' +( 3(""!">(/7& 4$ 2!-( 9 >(/& !"" ( $') "" $)"%$("& - " " 2)>(/ & !"" ( $') "" $)"% $("& 2 !!( 3" ! 1'

" () ""% ))$"(,(" $') "" & "-" &"$!"3(%- ! F)"% %%" 21 $ " 3(%- !, $ "" $ ") '' )"$+( ""!D(%,-" , &$"!$& "%"" ) ""!D(%,-" ,&$" 3(%- !

"-"$ -('$)"%$ 3(%- !'

21$"

)+(

")) )"%" " ",$') "" $ 4!4 $ $"+(21& 1 ")"% %() ! '' )' 1"%$ $ -2 !!',$"-'(%3(%- !'

21$ +(2)&2 " $"("2! /"! $ '' ) & %" $ ' '/$ '(" '' !$(%$!() >$ $ ) !() $'

"2"%"% $(%$$! G$"

)+(21'' '' " ) ''!"

" "! !! "' " ) & $ ) &"$ )) $ !"'( & 2$ ) $') "" "$"') "% 3!$21%""%( "% ""% 1-""$!

$') "" <$F"'')) +( "" ) ""!D(%, -" (") " %-&"$$"

)+(&"$% $ !!)(" !$$ $(" $') "" ) !4-" "-" ) <$F"'')) +($ "!$ "" )"( 2 -21$"

)+( ,&$"!$& ))&

<$$F"'')) +(2$ !""' /$ !5("$) &"$"$'!"2)"-" ! ""!" $.(3 )+' "!, 7 &"$!" $!,$""))% )"1"$ -, $ ,"&()2"-- "

)""%$!

)+( %""% ""%"$ % % $ ""%$"(,$F"'')) +($ '( ) '' )$"!$"(%"21$ "

) +( &"% !!)(" $ !!"% $ &$"'

- 5( $ 22" (!

5( ''

! 75( ,"$ & 1$ )+--"$ 4)1 7; $ )(2(")

&$"!$& &"$"$'!"2)"-" '"(!" $ !9 " $ !$- & - &$"!$ & ) " 2 $ +' ""H= B8 "& ''9$23!"& "" 9$("!"'

) +' " " ))1 ''$ !$-9$ '' )& ) !!21$ A-"

H= B8 F($-,$ 5( " 5( & 2" (!

5( ''

! 7 5( <$ ($'

4 (21$ /"$ -&$"' - H= B8 - 5( ,"& " 5( , $ ,"!

2 "$ $ $ 4=! - ; $ )(2(") $ ') "" <$ , &$") ('$)"%$3(%- !'

21$"

)+(,$ '' ) $') "" & "-" > "$ $"!%"21$+(2)& 2 (' '' ''!"

" !! "' " ) & #$ $ +($ 3!$!) "- $') "" > 1 " %&"$$+(2)& 4 " "& ($ " &"$$"-'(%3(%- !<$3(%- ! ('$) /(2 "

)5(" ) & ! ""$" '' ) 7 <$ '' ) "-" !!"%)1 "!$- " '' ) "-",$-"!)) (

'')"!

" ," 1, "' !!"%)1 #"3

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#