Ram Kishan v. Ut Of Chandigarh

 


!"

#$!

%&' &"(& && 
& ) &"

  )*+,+ -.*/%012  



    

 
"& -

 3'4 "

%!5

"&%5 &"&

"

          

 !



  

"&%5 &"&

"

2% 


 



     

"

#  $"

%&     '(     )*+ , 

"

 
-./0  1 12( && )*+

,  "

& 
-./0  1 & 12







 

     

34-

     &"&  56)
78 7-

78
9      

  77         & 

  3-   

6     7-

78
9 

(     
7 &  

&    
8& 
7 '  &    7& "

 7   ( :

   &    &   & '

( 

 &"

 , &  (       ,   "

  (   

  

    

  )
8//0;2 
-
8 788
 ",  <

  )
=-"




 
 



 
  



 





  


  


!

  

 "

78 &&(   & # ,  "     3    

  "
#$#
% 
&
 
!##''%     #     (  

& / & =  "& &   

 (

& 7 &&&,  '  ,&  ,

  , "

  &

       &   & &      (

 '

  "

 "&  >       (           &  (     
7  &  7&   73& &  73     &&  (    &  # ,      ,   "

   

  &,(       "&   &   & &  &(

?



 &  

 "   

 & "&     "& 7 & ==  &    #  , &   ",   &

  &&"

     & 

  6              &    &

   

 4 >  $ 1"&   0 +8/9 /: /

5**+  6+     "
" 
  ;<        ! "

 #  788.0
2 7=@( && >    $%    & 

 & ) A=
4 78
.   
7 78
.@# 

'

    &      &   ) A7/8    78
.      

7 8
78
.@ (  #   &     &  ) A7/9.9 78
9   7/ 8
78
.@   "  &  & ) A
8
8 78
.  

8
78
.@     )          &      &  ) A3==- 78
.   878
.@( 

'  

&   & ) A34/3
 78
9   
- 8
78
.

!

")!

  &   78
=0
20 &2=.9@ * 

 '+  788=?!=93@* 

 

&  78
=04332;?40 +$2@,

' 

  &   & ) =
77 78
3  &  &)

A33-4A B 78
4   
9
7 78
3@ 

  &  78
/0/2 ?(  $ &  4-4-@  

        &      &  ) 78--9 78
9   48 8.

78
9

    & 

   & "     

&&( :


88 & "

    & ==0"2(   &&(   &# ,  (&&& &, & "

>   &  

 &(  "

&   

   "&    &  

  

   &     &

 3   #         (                  &  # ,  , "

0"

78 "

2 &  "&    & ==  & D        ( "& 7   & ==   &(    

      "& 7 0"2 

 "

    &&(  A

C">    "

B& :

"     

49    "&

   "

",  &

  ">    

    &&(  ", & (  ">   *=, +=0*=*/+8+* +*=*  * )0= $ /*8

50> * +

6        &( 

"



6   ">       "

  &&,  , &   "

'

 6    "

  &    " (     

&    & &&  :        "     &       &  &

&   ,    ' &(   ?

&

 / (    &           &:           @ 

'

         &  "

"   

,  & (   

 "

:

(  ,  "

 

  

  "&   &<



(  "

   

     



& &   , "

 (  
  & &  ' &( & 

        '    &  

      "   "&,

& &&,  : 

       
-.7 ?

&

"

 

, 6  "

  "&       &&         &&

           "&  "         "

    ("  & 

 &&,, "

  & ==(&& "

  '

    1, "

1  &

  & =/A &

" 

 EE666   

 7       

F, "

G A ( 
") *
 

")
 " 
  



 " 
  


 

   +
"

") 

  
 "

 

+  
") 
 +

 
 ",

  &             (    

 


, "

 "



(   (

 =  ) -7  &

& =/  )*

:

& "  &       , "

 &  A ?.& 5+280 / +2  08*0 +8 /*8

0> * + )  && &&     , ,  "

'

   

 (   *  & 
-3/H

   &       , "

  

& 6 &&"

&,   

  66 5   &  ==  &            ,  ,  "

 "

   *+ & 
-3/

   &&"

    ,, "

  , 

 & 3/    &  & &( &&,     "

  ,  

& 7  :

 & ,(       &

   A ?--&  ' '  
- 
 


 
") 
+

+  
"

"
% .
"
"


 /+"

" 0


"

") 
+

+
 
  "
"
 
"1
2 
 

+

 
")  +

 "
3
 
)

+
 
" 



4335#

-/  
 
 

")"



 9  
"


 

 
  
 "
)
6 

 
)

)




" 
") 
/ 


" 


  
") 
"
 
% .
7"


2 / 



" 
"
 
% .
7"
 
2

  )
8"


+
"

") 

 
)
   +
 
"
 +
8"

"
 8"

)
+
"





   )
 
 
 
"


 

 
)
  
 

 

,G 5 & 7 "

# ( ( @       
88  

    A        (    ,   "

   

     &   & & # ,   &&  '



       $(

    &   &      "

 "

",   & 

7    A

       &,  # ,

'

   

                I" 

'

    

               H      &&   &    &&, "

",    & 

042     &  ,

 

 . "A& 072 &&      

&      ,  "

 

?



   &       

             # ,    & , "

 
88    

  , & 

$ (  '  ,   &&"

     (   & & 

    "

" "   (   6          & 

   &       

    "

  :

  

,  &(&&

&"

,:

(  
88&  && 


,  "

     (       &     (      , J   A &:

 "

A 

   (  ,    , ;

              

 &&        

 &

      $       "

   ( &&        

8 & "

&"

&&,     & 

6

      "

  " ,&,  , "

  " "

& 7 & ==  &

  & (           , &   , 
88   &  , "

  " 

 -

'   ( ">   ">   & &," " 

   &     ,  "

   6    

, ,  "

 &&(  "  &# ,     

 &"&

    

'

 ,     &   "& :

"    , "

49 )*

  A FC

    "

  K"&     A"&"&  L  0
2 )(    ,   

   &

  
-9407 
-932A 02 

,  

   "&           &&  "

 K"& @ 0"2     

  "&  I

  
- 73 79 & 



&  &# ,H &&"

&  

"&  ( "  & A 02   "&       "

 

 

 , &   &   02  (   "&         &        "&   "

&

    &,  

   &:

&,  ,

( &  "& 072 &     "&   & 0"2  "A 0
2   &      &   
-9407 
-932 , &(   "

       "& 6  (  &,"

   (     "&        &&     

    

  

 
8  &# ,  " ">    "

",& 0"2  "A 0
2 

5 &&

 ,     "&         "

 

      &   &     (   02       "&   "

&

    &,  

&&  

"

 @02

 &:

&, ,

( &  "&        "  

#  "&  

  "&  


-

73

79A &

&  &# ,

" & 

      



        &   
-94(    "&

$ 1"&     ! ,@

5/@5/:+6+ 2;;5

;A &  (        &              &&  "

 "& &  (      , @       "&   "

&

    &,     &:

&,       ,  

 ( &    "&  B      

   "

    6         (      "   

"

&   "&

'      

 490
20"202    M  "&  M  '               6  

   " &  ""&      "

&

    &,  

         "&  "

&   &          

'

    

   

 &

> ,       

 

 &,  

 

(M  "& M  &(      "&   

 (    &&    "&,:

( :

( 6  &

'  (M  "&

M F6 1!&* ,3 ;

 A77/.   (&"

  "&  '  '  (1  "&      &      , ,        &           

 (     :

  (  "& & &&  (&:

> &    &1, M

 0 8 
8    )+/  @  %=  */  & /:

600  /8392  0B*C*+50881, 5+D+=+',@ !E0++ *  0B*$4*,

EEEEE

( &    &  "& ( 



 &&        &, 6  &   &&,

 #   &     "&  &&  

    "&   "

&

    &,   

" '

    B  

        >  #&         &,

7

 &&,                   ( &  "&   &:

&, ,

 && '  &    &

M    

  >   $ 1"&          5*85=/

5**+$0B>
78
. 60 %278

 

& ) 3(  "&  &# , 

 
7 " (    A  

)*

(      

  "&  


-73 & 



&  &# ,  && "

&   "& &  "&    "



 , &   &             "&         &         "

            "&   "

&

   &,   && 

   &:

&, ,

( &  "&  &  "



   "

'

     

   &              "

  

 , &(      "& 6 (   

  

 &( :

 

&,      &"&  ( &   &

 &     "& *   

 49      

   '

    ,          '

  ,     &   &  &&,&&     &   &              

 "

 & &&    (  &(  

490"2  :

&  ((    "&"   



( & ==  & ;

        "& 7 & ==0"2

   &&    

 
4  &,   

   "&   "

&

  5  &    (   :

  &  # ,      ,   "

 &&       &        &       "

   

 49       

  

& ==  & 5B&>/

5**+6+< 0788323 33
 $ 1"&  ( & &,  (

 

0 +8/9 /: / 

5**+6+   

 

5**+ 6+   08    "

       

,   

8  &    "

 &&  (   &&  # ,     "              ,   788-  A  (            " J,   "

  &&  "

           &# ,

 &&&A ( "

   (&&  &, &&(   &# ,

     "

# 



(  &&# , 

 "  &     

  
.

788-

$ 1"&    5B&>/3   02 ( & &  &

   0 +8/9 /: /

5**+ 6+0 &  &)
7/= 788
   = *

"

 788
2 (

 

,  

8&    ,   "

 

"

   (  (  ,     (   & &

  0 +8/9 /: /3 02



 ((  

790"2  ",

 
3 &  

8&  B

(   0 2 &&(  &&# ,        788-& $(

   &(, (

   & ( B

$ 1"&   
8 
7   &&( "  A ('#
3
 
+ 
 
/
 

 + 
+

"

 
 

/
 
 
8"


+
  ") 
 
/
 
/

 
+ 
)
 
 #
9 
 
+ 
 


/ 
 "
)" 
9  
+

 
"



+
 
"#
9 
)"

 

"
  
 


)


 

 

 
 


 
 "


 
 

)

  ) ")#
3

"

 

 +
 
:"  

)

 
+
) )# #
$

"
+
 
+ 
+


"


/

  
) 
 
 
 
8"


+
)" 
9   / 

 

+
 
 
+



"

 +
 
++ 

)
 /"
+ 
"
 

+
 


# #
;
 +

 
  
+
 
 
  

+
 
5 #
;
 


 


"  
"
 
)
+
 
-<2
5
/ 
 
+

 #
=

 

:


+
  
 
)
/#
3


  
+
"

 
 

)

:


+ 
)
 
 

)
"#
;

 +
 
 
:


" 

 

+
:

 + /
"
8"


 
#
9 
 
 
+

 
) 
#*   0 +8/9 /: /3  +02  (

  

790"2  )*

", &  

,

   &&(  &&# ,  "

 
/  ( 0 +8/9 /: /3  +02 ( #      "

  

8 &    &   (

  

790"2   B    "

 ",$ 1"&   5B  &>/3   02                     788-   

  & :

"

 &( 5B&>/3  02(   # , 

"

 "

:

 & # ,  ' &

 & B     %=,+5=/

5**+ !

2 
/,=/< A7.994A78
9        7= - 78
9    &  &( 5B&>/3  02(  "

"

A F6          (   

,          

       &  ) &  "

  ( 

 "

 "

   ,    ( (  &&

 

   (   

   >      #      &  

  >  "

",& 

 &   

 &"&  

6 (,    "

& 94 >  B

   &   &   & 

 &  

  

 :


88   "

(   (      ,   "

 

       

  &    6    :

J 
88 

   , "

(   && )*

(  , &  (  ( 

 
=     

"

:

  &     &

G



 &  ",  &   

  

49 

"

          

  "

       

    " 

 

"&          "

 

   " (   &     ' ,  >"

6       , && ,  

*  ,  &&,  >" 

   "  "

 ,  , "   ,  , (  ":"

 ,  &&     6   

&,  &

  

 & &,  6   (     



"

&&( :


88  "



8, "

 (  &   &&,(

  &      (    & &

&    0"2  &, & (     "&   

6 &&(  ' &&  >  & "   >" $,  6( &&A &  &   ?

& "

  ",    ( &

;

,&    &"

 ( 

 '  ( & 

6 & ,      & &

 
9     

 &&  

     & "

 "" &"

 :

   ( &      , ' 

'( && 6      0
7     78-2 "

 A
(5

+
 
)
:" 
+

 
"



"


>" 


 

/
"
+

"


)"

 

 

 
 
+
   
 
 
 
+
/
  )
 # ;  
 
 "


+
 
  "

+
/

"



+
"


/ 
/"
 
 ) "
:"
 
"


"
  /
 
"

"
"



)

"
 

 )

)"

)
 +

 
/#* 5  7
8 "

"

 A (9 
 
 
"

/ 
 
"
+

+
/  
/"
)

 


)"#*    & ==    &,



&   ", & &  (   (   (  ">   

   "A& 7 & ==  & 

" 6 , ">    &  

C

&, &     (    

 ">  "

 

", & &   

   (  

 "> 0  ?

 

&  78
4 ?!


70 2



  ( "

    

 
.     &    (  

  

, 

       

  &&  (    & # ,  "      

  &,

&   

 :

 &     "& 70"2 N   :

  &  &&, &  &      "

                  " 6     (:

  "      &   &

        

,

  

  , "

 &&(  "  &# , 

"



&  & &&  &(  

 # &,   &  "

 "&        

"&%5 &"&

"

 .*/%012  %!)  %  : J 

N J) %  "& N J)