High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/355/2024disposed of

M/S Shriram Transport Finance Company Ltd. v. Harjit Singh

2025-07-22Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul4 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()*+, ($- .'/01&121('3"1 &((%!"23(,4&2& !$ 5555533+&%( .33!++( 6!1'*' 17& /&(80 55555!'3"($!( ' ) ) ) ) 94/5/:4 94/5/:4 94/5/:4 94/5/:4 1!'!( ) 155/5/($0*-$;"% ! #"1 0!33+&%( 5 :4-5 :4-5 :4-5 :4-5 5 0!33+&%( 0'#&+!$ 0!31!'!( 33+&% &"('!!<&(881( "#+!;! "33!+8&(' 0!7*$82!( "#%=*& +3''!$&(%"23+&( %'!&(' & * !$*($!1/!% &"(>"# 0!!8" &?+!(' 1*2!( '% ->>

0!1!&(# !11!#!11!$ "'-@% A-B0!1!?, 0!%"23+&( #&+!$?, 0! 33+&%( B'$&'2&''!$($ 0!%%*'!$B'%=*& !$5 5 0!+&2& !$=*!' &"(1&'&(8#"1%"('&$!1 &"(&( 0!31!'!( 31"%!!$&(8'&'B0! 0!1(33!+8&(' ("1$!1"#%=*& +3''!$&( %"23+&( %'!*($!1/!% &"(>"# 0!% %(?!!( !1 &(!$*($!1 0! 31";&'" " /!% &"( C "# 0! 1555 0! &(' (%! "# 0! %"23+&(( D 5 0! &''*! &' (" +"(8!1 1!' &( !815 ( @.' !+!' &*2 @.' !+!' &*2 @.' !+!' &*2 @.' !+!' &*2 &((%&+ 6'5 5 (('!<1( %5 / >

) &((%&+ 6'5 5 (('!<1( %5 / >

)

1&2&(+ >A

1&2&(+ >A- 0!"(9?+!/*31!2!"*1 * 0"1& &;!+,0!+$ 0 %"23+&(( &(31"'!%* &"(*($!1/!% &"(>"# 0!% -=*+&#&!'

'@;&% &2A*($!1/!% &"( B"# 0!1555-?!&(8 0!3!1'"(B0" '*##!1'#&((%&++"''$*! " 0!$&'0"("*1"#%0!=*!5"('!=*!( +,- '*%0%"23+&(( &'!( & +!$ "3*1'*!(33!+8&(' %=*& +*($!1 0! 31";&'" " /!% &"( C "# 0! 1555- B& 0"* 0! 1!=*&1!2!( "# '!!<&(8'3!%&++!;!*($!1/!% &"(C>

"# 0!1555

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

( 0!%"( 11,-'8&(' ("1$!1"#%=*& +- 0!/ !- 01"*80 0!*?+&%1"'!%* "1%(31!#!1(33!+!;!(&# 0!%"23+&(( $"!'(" 31!#!1'*%0(33!+- 0"*80"# %"*1'! '*%0 ( 33!+ &' B& 0 0! +!;! "# 0! %"*1 5 "B!;!1- & &' (" +B,' (!%!''1, #"1 0! / ! "1 %"23+&(( " 31!#!1 ( 33!+5 * B0!( & %"2!' " ;&% &29'1&80 "31!#!1(33!+- 0!&('&' !(%!"('!!<&(8 '3!%&++!;! "33!+#1"2 0!&80"*1 *($!1/!% &"( C>

"# 0! 1 B"*+$ ?! %"( 11, " B0 0' ?!!( &( !($!$ ?, 0! 1+&2!( ?, &('!1 &"( "# 0! 31";&'" " /!% &"(C "# 0!1555 "*1 0+,- 0! 1+&2!( 0' (" 2!($!$ /!% &"( C> " %&1%*2'%1&?! 0!;&% &29'1&80 "31!#!1(33!+7*' '& 0'B& 01!81$ "%"23+&(( "1 0!/ !#&+&(8(33!+5

( 0!" 0!10($- 0!1+&2!( 0'&('!1 !$ 0!31";&'" " /!% &"(C '"' "!(;&'8!'*3!1&"11&80 #"1 0!;&% &2 "#("##!(%! "31!#!1(33!+"( 0!81"*($'2!( &"(!$

0!1!&('%"231!$ "%"23+&(( 5 &# 0+,- 0!&(;"+;!2!( "# 0!/ !&(1!'3!% "#("##!(%! *($!1/!% &"(>"# 0!% &'%"('3&%*"*'?,& '?'!(%!5 0&'&'?!%*'! 0!%"23+&( #&+!$*($!1 0 31";&'&"(&'&( 0!( *1!"#31&; !%"23+&( '3!1/!% &"(

"# 0! 1555($/!% &"( "# 0!% ?,(!E31!''&( !( &"( &(%"13"1 !' 0!31";&'&"('"# 0!1555&( 0!2 !1"# 1&+"#'*%0$!!2!$"##!(%! 1&!$'%1&2&(+"##!(%!5 0!1!#"1!- 0!%"23+&(( -B0"&' 0!;&% &2"#$&'0"("*1 "#%0!=*!2*' ?!%"(' 1*!$ "?!;&% &2&( !12'"# 0! 31";&'" " /!% &"( C 1!$ B& 0 0! $!#&(& &"( "# ;&% &2 *($!1/!% &"( B"# 0!1555 EEEEEEEEE 5 ' +1!$, (" !$- 0! 31";&'" " /!% &"( C "# 0! 1555B'&('!1 !$&( 0!' * !?""<"(+,B& 0!##!% #1"2 5 5

50!"?7!% ($1!'"(#"1'*%0&('!1 &"(2*' ?!1!+&'!$($2*' ?!8&;!(& '#*++!##!% "?,%"*1 5( ;&!B"# 0!#"1!'&$$&'%*''&"(-B!0"+$ 0 0!;&% &2"# ("##!(%!0' 0!1&80 "31!#!1(33!+*($!1 0!31";&'" "/!% &"(C "# 0!1555-&11!'3!% &;!"#B0! 0!10!&' %"23+&(( "1(" 5;!(&# 0!;&% &2"#("##!(%!&' %"23+&(( - 0! %( ' &++ 31"%!!$ *($!1 0! 31";&'" " /!% &"(C ($(!!$(" $;!1 "'*?'!% &"(

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

"# 0! 1555 H5 $"3 &(8 3182 &% ($ 7*' &%!"1&!( !$ 331"%0 ($ 8*&$!$?, 0!31&(%&3+! 0 31"%!$*1+1*+!2*' '!1;!($(" "?' 1*% 0!%"*1'!"#7*' &%!- 0&'"*1 $!!2'& 331"31& ! "$&1!% 0 0!

31!'!( 33!+ ?! 1! !$ ' "(! * 0"1& &;!+, &(' & * !$ *($!1 0! 31";&'" "/!% &"(C "# 0!1555 C5 ( ;&!B "# 0! * 0"1& &;! 31"("*(%!2!( &( .'!+!' &*2&((%&+9'%'! '*31 .'!+!' &*2&((%&+9'%'! '*31 .'!+!' &*2&((%&+9'%'! '*31 .'!+!' &*2&((%&+9'%'! '*31($ 0!;&!B <!(?, 0&'"*1 +'"&(/ 3+/&(80;5/ !"#*(7?(15 H

H $&'3"'!$"##"( 5 C5 - 0!31!'!( 33+&% &"(&'$&'3"'!$"#B& 0 $&1!% &"( 0 0!+!1(!$/!''&"('*$8!%"(%!1(!$'0++ 1! 0!31!'!( 33!+'(33!+#&+!$*($!1 0!31";&'" "/!% &"(C "# 0!1555 ($''&8( 0!'2! "(331"31& !"*1 #"1$&'3"'+"(2!1& '-&( %%"1$(%!B& 0+B5 >5 0!%"(%!1(!$33!++ !"*1 '0++31"%!!$ "$!%&$! 0! 33!+!E3!$& &"*'+,-B& 0"* ?!&(8&23!$!$?,(,$!+,&(#&+&(8 0! 33!+- &( ;&!B "# 0! +!8+ 3"'& &"( ("B %+1&#&!$ ?, 0! "(9?+! 3!E"*1 5

5 0!!8&' 1,&'$&1!% !$ " 1('2& 0&'"1$!1+"(8B& 0 %"3, "# 0! %"23+! ! 33!1 ?""< ($ 1! *1( 0! 1&+ "*1 1!%"1$- &#1!%!&;!$- " 0!+!1(!$/!''&"('*$8!5 5

&'3"'!$"#%%"1$&(8+,5 *+, *+, *+, *+, ($ ($ ($ ($- - - -

:4 :4 :4 :4 *(!! I0! 0!1'3!<&(8.1!'"(!$ )

!'." I0! 0!11!3"1 ?+! )

!'."