← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6420/2021dismissed

Ruldu Ram v. Uttari Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam And ORS

2023-07-19Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil10 pages

  

    

 

 

    

 !

   " #$$

  %&& 

  

%



"

$  & #$$& 

& "  '  "$ &  &  " $ 

        

&  " !

!    "!! #$$%" !  & ' ( !)  !        #     !   '  # )#  

!   * *+ $*,,* *% $*-   .  '  !

 #'!

# ) )  /0 1!

$ ' !

 

  #            )   2 34 # 5 

 6 7+,)( '      !'8!# )  !# 9  *0 *0 70*       6

   -    ##   

      !!   ,* *% $*-  :          



, &  !'# #   $*,6-'#    $   #  )  '  !## !  .      

 * *+ $*-   '   !#     # '    '

  #!

)   * *+ $*- -    ) !7 *, $*$!'8! )  '###) #!

;.!  ;

!'2'

 2345<# =             #  # ' 

 % 

 3">?@?!#$**03">"@?!#$**0   ,* $ $**0)   !  !#

  !# :!# ' ?!#* 3">?@?!#$**0) !# ) ?!#$*3">"@ ?!#$**06

  

  



!"

"

# $  

"  



#

#

  % "

&$

"  

# '

&$



   % 



 &$    &'(

&

 

   



!"

"

# $  

)*+ "  



#

#

  %

"   &$

)*+ "  

#  '

&$ 

 

%  

 &$   &'

(

% :!  "!?!#, $%>@!'"

#  ?!#>5#!

66@)  !# ,!% "   "     

-



 

     #  .

#



/   #  .

#



/   #

" 

% "

% "



 "

  "   

  # 0"  # " 

  01



* .34 -



%

5

+   -

  

  

 

  " #  # # 

#  %

  

(

+ A#     '#    #   #

 '  (      )      !##   ,* *% $*-  "! + $*$) # #  !    #  ) '  !  "!   



  

 & '!# # !#       !   # # =

$*$*>.!6@)!  !##' #

#

8!!#   ) ## !

!

  #

'   8!# #   ,* *% $*-

!   $*,6-  )   !



 !  "# $%    &  $#  '

    $ ( ( ) *+,  *-*. )    ' #6 $ 7      ""



  %   



  





 "   

     



 #    1  ""

# 

8 

)

#

 # 



 #  

 #

3 

#



  #  

 

 

 " 

9

 



  #

# 

:"

 "





 #

   "



"

 #   







    

 

 # "

 "

 #



  







   #

"

 "

 0

5 # 



 #

 

%  

    

  



:



 # # 



" #

3 #!#  

* B   ' ! ?!#*C $*  3">?@ ?!# $**0   )   D  #E ) '!   F

;  -

:"

   





 



#

"

# .

 < $ &=

#  

    



 

  -

:"

  



 

 



"

# %    



 

# #

"



6>:$

 # 

""    

 ;

?

"

  '

 &$

"!  !D  ;

#E > ' !'6->@' # ! )  #

 !#  @) ) ##! .   

 !#  D    ,*G !  &     !#  '     $ C , !

 ;

#E  #.!#    # $   !#               #  !  !

  = *7 $*+  '  3

 "!  $/# ) ,.*  *-,0# 11 ''

(&   !-*-,) )!# '3G'#! "!&  2%#)***3.*-3   &42#11 ''

(!*.-,*-3 $ ;!)3

"! '!0"HG $$ *- $*7 #$/#)*+ *-3  (

 526

"

 &422 7 1  '  D !6 4  

 0 &> < &@5 8  

 * 

-

"  



 #

    



-

/  9 

""" 

"

#  #

3 

 

 /  

+ 5

 &> "  



* 

-



 #

2

A    

 

 * 

-

 """ 



9 2 /  



3

 

 

" 



 

"

 "  

2 /  9  """ 

# 

"

  #

8  #  * 

-

,  # )(!) D &  )8!

   ' *0 * $*$*    !

!'D &  .)  >.!?6@( !# 3G'#"!) DB#



!6 &

3      

-





#   

& 3   + ) "



     

     1# /B

/#

*  + ) "



 "



; 

 2

A 2   /B

/#

*  1# + ) "







 

  -

 +

) "





 * 

-

& < 3

     C

/B

/# * ) +   /  

&6 *

2    .  

 .  3 "" 

  ?   

"



 A 1

 02"5  

?      #  

#  

 " -



#

    



 



   

#

# 

      

3 #

)

=< *2

# 5 "





-

#  

2

"

 "" +# 

)""  





;  "

=

+ 

 "





" 





 



"  

*   3  -

) "

 

 9#  



 

#  %  " 

% 

)

6 *)

# 5 

    

 "



A 1

 0"5    "  

 

 A 1

 0"5 



 ?) * 

-

"

 

  

 "

 9 ?  

#



1#  9   0"5

& = 3   8 1# /B

/#

*  +

) "



 /B

*) 



  F   @ < &@ )

7

<:<@:&@ )

7

<:<&:&@  

&'

< &@ )

7

<:&$:&@   

 8 

 

"





&  /B

2" *

 1#  &@ < &@



# 2G+ 0*5 ?

7 $=$>:&@ 

?:F



 # 1#  < 6 &'

/B

/# * G9  D+ 7

=>=:&

 HF3 F

4

29

 "E F   .

 



# 

6$$   

#

"



"





  

 2"



+   

"#

8 

 "

-  3

"! &

1 & 2! 1   '  8/#) *-,.*4*-* *,*-*9   &2  8/#*3+..4-93G'#<(3

"! 

 . :) 8/#33 4*--.9#6 A "  ;

6$  " 

-

 

 

       # 6>



"    @ < @<'

 

> < @@6

 "  



    -

  #   

"

 # ;

6$  

@'<.'= # 



 

D # "   05 ;

6$ 

"  

    



 

 

" #  # # 6>



 

  #

 = @<'

 

 < = @@6  < < @@6

3 "

 

= @<'



< < @@6  

#



"

  @ < @<'



   = @@6

 

    



*)   "

 -



#  < < @@6

< < @@6

 = @@6

  ;



05 *) #

 #

 <    #

  

  )"  # 

 )" #



= A#

8! ##)  # #'' 

'"!) #.    )! #$$%" !  & 3

 "! ! ( . )  ! #

  

       #      

  (  ! ) #

 !

!!   3

"! .       #  #8!

#

&   #   # )   !#   #.# 3

"! # 

 #  .  ) !     % &)!#'#."! )   (

 

;

<  26  *--*28.92$.+! ) "!! 3

"!

# #  ) ! !' .#  '     )    ! #   !'# #   ! +    "!  # ' !       ( '   )        # #    =

$*$* >.! 6@   =   )           '!#  #'   !## # #

  !     ') ' ) &#

'   ')##!)  ! # !

#

 ' #  '!# !  #  "!  #) '   

##

 I ) ( #          "! ) !#! '     !#'     ## # #     #   ' $*$* )  )   !    

  #)'# .# !#+ 

! $*- 3)   #  )####  

) 

 !



(&  " )





D "

9#:  

I :7

D

"



I :7