Manohar Lal v. State Of Punjab









 

 



 





!

"#$#%&

'('
%) *
+ ,



# #% *



-


.%/ 0


$1%!

% &

 2+
 '
 -
- 
 +




 
 

 



 

 


!!!!!
- 
 +3
'
4 +5

"

 


#
 
 
$%&

'(
)*)&



#
#
 


 
+,-
(&&
 
"&*.)*))
 


 
 #
 
  
$)*

,/
0  
")*1'

)*"

,/

#  2

#
 
/34
  
- 
)

5





+,-

6 
0



 


  2


##7 1
8
  

 


  

 



 







P a g e | 2 !



 

 "

#

  $%

&

 ' &



 &  #
$%

#

  $%

 %( )


*




 +

,%



 +  

 

 -

    

 

 

 !



 

 "

 #

   $%



 +  .

%(  ,%

 ( %     

 



  -+*/
0$/ /0/ +1#+0 -# &

 





%(2345-
647

'



 

800- 029 52+-#+1: *+$ *-99$ #/ + ;0-0 $90# 1/0$ 52 01# !9!02$0 <7 21805 =+1#+0>   ) 6<?<<667   * 1 @6 &&&  

( A &

  &

 

  


B .

%

(5  



'

!

1  !

?"

%

'

 (   4@<<@7<

   :%  .

% 

  "

 ? "

  (   @@73?

76@6<(

  (%







  

   

(     

 

 +

 %  

(



% 

9 67



%  <  0







5   

%  



 &

:%

!

%%    



    & %   . $ ?C 

  C

%9  

    



&    .

9 1&

 

 '

  

 +  .

%(  ,%

%

 %

$ 4? 



( '   $   1



  

 

  & ) 1$ 

1476@

671$   4@< 

 6< 1 6 $   1 4@< 

 6< 1 77 

 @ 1 <    77<3

41  774

@7 1 3    1 <77< 1 @ $   1 <77 

 6<14$  1<747

61  $   6 

 3 1     6 

 3 1     6 

 316  66

317   67

31<  @@

 631  64

@@13    3<6 

 3 1 @    3<<6

P a g e | 3

  1 4    <<7 

  1  <@

31  <4

31  

31 6     

 3 1 7    7 30 

)?



-

 

'

!





"

#

  $%

D
&

9 
 #
 

 

3

 


 
 
":"))*))

;

 
 

 
7
  
 


3 

6 
 

7

 #
  
7 
  
4 
#


-
' 


;
<


3 
7

+4 

9 
 #
 

 

 

#
"$
 
7 


 


 #
%
7
=3  7  

# 
 
 
&">
//
7
##7

)$*$)*).
6
 
?
   
7#

 '
#

; 
#
#




$

9 
 
 #




 

 

##  

   




  





 


#
#
9 
 
 #
4

#


 
  
 *"*>)*).

/

7

4


.

,


 #


#
 
 

 



##




@

5
  
7
 

":"))*))
 


  
 
5 
   
7


 
##
7
 

"&*))*)&
7
#
"$
 
7 


 


7
%


=3 
##
 

A 



P a g e | 4 # 
 
 
&">
//



 
7#

' #

,



 
#

6 

3 #
 

5
#
  


'



 #

##

  

 



#
5
/


3
  

#

 
#
  
 
 
#
 3
 
#
(  
 #



7
  

#4#

 
  
3





  
7 
 
 
@"



 
  
 
*"*>)*).
#

# 
 
 #  

7
 

  

 #



+,-

6  

;7




 
 


 
 
":"))*))


+,- 



 


#
#  
/
3
  

 
 


 
 
3 )*))


+,-

6  

+ 




 
  
 

 

 #

3# #
+,-

;7 
 3
 


 


 # 
# 

 

#
#
 


+,-

6 
7



3




#
#
,% 
+,-

6 

    

 3  



+,-
-# 





#


3


; B#
3
/



















 !C



' 
3


; B#
/#


;
/



 
"


##






$%%
D
3 


/

&
' ( &
#

) 
 *




P a g e | 5 +,


)>"")*)"

 
-.



+,
##
( 




#




 
 
 

 

 


6


 
 
3  





:
,
7


 

##7

  




#

#
#


  
# 
 


  


# 
  
/


 
;7 
 

   

3

3


  
/



  
##
3
 


##7 
    1
(i2

5
  
##

31

# 
 

02

5
  
##
 3
7 
 
  #

3 
 
#

02

5
  
##


3#

 
 

#

02

5
  
##

33
 
 
7#

#

02

5
  
##





 

7

#
/ 

02

5
  
##


##
 
3


,    
<;<

  
#
 
 
##

 

##1 
3
7 

3

#
/ ,##6

 
02

5
  
##


 
3 


#

#






















02
5
  
##
3




74 



3 





  

#
/







 #

33

 
 
 
 
#

#
,

 

 


 #

 
 
 

 
 #


P a g e | 6 #


+,-





 
 7 
 

3  
3  7 

 ## 


#
7
#
 

##

   

3 

%
,




 



   
 

7
3

3

  
/


 

  


7 
 
 

  3# 
##


# 

3
 ## 

#

 

>

<
 #

"*
(  

 
##

  


=

 


3 




""

 

3




  
3## 
# 

 
##
#
  


(SUMEET GOEL) JUDGE September 01, 2025 ' Whether speaking/reasoned:

Yes/No Whether reportable:

Yes/No