High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/142/2025disposed of

Chanda Thr His Lrs And Others v. State Of Haryana And Another

2026-05-20Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

- %#!-/ %#!-/ %#!-/ %#!-/ :6 :6 :6 :6-/ -/ -/ -/6@6A 6@6A 6@6A 6@6A B B B B !.2 !.2 !.2 !.2 6@ 6@ 6@ 6@@A6@6 6@6 6@6 6@6C D55!44%"# 55!44%"# 55!44%"# 55!44%"#

5-"+!"# !

5-"+!"#

!"# /- /- $ $ $ $

$ $ $ $ $%&#%'*+,-.%#!%"+ %"(%)%&#%'*+,-.%#! #0!%55!44%"# 102"% 0%2"**% 3%"

"% % !"+! $&'% % 0#*

%"!4-&"

!4* !

5-"+!"#-6 ???? * * * * %4 %4 %4 %4 - - - - 76 76 76 768 -/ -/ -/ -/6@6A 6@6A 6@6A 6@6A 3 9%3-/5 !

!"#%5542.%#2-"*5 % %3! 0% 1!!"'%+!/- .-"+-"

"2"= #0!+!4%3-/7:7 7;+%3 2"/242"=#0!5 !

!"#%55!

!%4 " 5& &%".! -/ "-#2.! 2" #0! %5542.%#2-"* !543 -" 1!0%4/ -/ !

5-"+!"# -6 6 0% 1!!" /24!+ -9!,! * "- !543 0% 1!!" /24!+ -" 1!0%4/ / -/ !

5-"+!"#- <#%#! 0 0%,! 0!% + 4!% "!+ .-&"

!4 /- #0! 5% #2!

%"+ =-"! #0 -&=0 .-"#!"# -/#0!% %5542.%#2-"

".!+!+43*#0!-#0! 2'24% 43 #&%#!+4%"+-9"!

5! #%2"2"=#-

%'! %.>&2 2#2- " 5 -.!!+2"= 0%,! %4 !%+3 1!

!!" 0!4+ !"#2#4!+ /- #0! !"0%"

.!+ %'-&"#-/.-'5 5!"

%#2-"5! #%2"2"=#-#0!4%"+

2#&%#!+2" !,!"&!!

#%#!-/,244 %=! $0% %( %')2* !0 24 %"+ 2 # 2.# 2"+ %4-"= 9 92#0 -4%#2&' %"+ -#0! #%#&# #- 3

1!"!/2# *2",2!9 9-/)&+='!"#+%#!+6A@6@6:

!+13#0!-"J14!5!G- -& # 2"2,2455!%4 2,2455!%4 2,2455!%4 2,2455!%4 -A-/6@6: -A-/6@6: -A-/6@6: -A-/6@6:#2#4!+I%")%3B I%")%3B I%")%3B I%")%3B B #%#!-/% 3%"%J B #%#!-/% 3%"%J B #%#!-/% 3%"%J B #%#!-/% 3%"%J %

!+#0! !&5-"%"+%55432"=#0!5 5 2".254!-/5% 2#3*1!

2+!

= %"# #-/ )& #%"+/%2 .-'

'5!"

%#2-"*#0!4%"+-9"! <%5 5542.%"# 1!2"= 2'24% 43 2#&% %#!+ % ! !"#2#4!+ /- = %"# -/ 2'24% %'-&"# -/ .-'

'5!"

%#2-"* 0-9!,! * 92#0-&# % %"3 5%3'!"# -/ 2"#!

! !

# /- #0! 5! 2-+ -/ +!4%3 2"

" /242"= #0! 5 !

!"# %55!%4 " # #02 !=% + !42%".!.

.%"1!54%.!+&5-"#0!+!.2 "-/-"J14!&5 !'!-& #2".

.% ! -/E2"=%55%0 E2"=%55%0 E2"=%55%0 E2"=%55%0 0-#%55% 0-#%55% 0-#%55% 0-#%55%"=%+2!%+#0 -&=0 "=%+2!%+#0 -&=0 "=%+2!%+#0 -&=0 "=%+2!%+#0 -&=0 0

5!.2%4%"+.>&2 5!.2%4%"+.>&2 5!.2%4%"+.>&2 5!.2%4%"+.>&2 2#2-" 2#2-" 2#2-" 2#2-" //2.! %"+"- //2.! %"+"- //2.! %"+"- //2.! %"+"- -#0! F -#0! F -#0! F -#0! F !5- #!+% E6@6@ 6@6@ 6@6@ 6@6@ A A A AF%"+#0!4%#!

#!G52#2-"

"-/ 4%9 4%2+ +-9" 2" -0% 2"=0 !%+ 0 -&=

-0% 2"=0 !%+ 0 -&=

-0% 2"=0 !%+ 0 -&= &=0 B &=0 B &=0 B &=0 B #%#! -/

#%#! -/

##%

%+!

0 -44!.# -44!.# -44!.# -44!.# #- B

#- B

#- B !5- #!+ % E6@67 6@67 6@67 6@67 @F @F @F @F 90! !13* +!4%3 -/ / 6 3!% %"+ 7A7 +%3 9% .-"+-"!+ #- %..- + + 5% 2#3 1!#9!!" 2'24% 43 54% .!+ 4%"+-9"!

%41!

!2#"-2"#! !

#9% %9% +!+/- + +!4%3!+5! 2-+0! !4!,%"#5- # #2-" #0! !-/2 !G# %.

.#!+0! !&"+!

8 E6 6 %,2"=0!% +4!% "!+!"2- -&"

!4/- #0!5% #2!

%"+-"5! & & %4 -/ # #0! '%#! 2%4 54%.!+ -" !.- +* 9!

! % ! %#2 /2!+ #0%# #0! %55!44%"# % ! !"#2 #2#4!+#- !!(5% 2#392#0#0!2 .-8, ,244%=!

2"#0!= %"#-/.-'5!"

%# %#2-" /- #0!2 %.>&2 !+ 4%"+ 02 -& # 0% .-"

#!"#43 0!4+ 2" % .%#!"% % -/ +!.

.2 #0%##0!2"- +2"%#!+!4%32"/ /242"=%55!%42".-'5!"

%#- 3'%## #!

* 5!

!*'%3"-#1!/%#%4% #0! 2=0# % %"+!>&2#2!

1!#9!!"#0!5% #2!

.%"

"1! 9!4 44 1%4%".!+ 13 +!"32"= #0! #%#&#- #- 3 1!"!/2# * &.0 % 2"#! !

# /- +!4% 4%3!+ 5! 2-+ H! % ! #0& -/ #0! .-"

2+! !+ -52"2-" #0%# #0! +!4%3 3 2" /242"

2"=#0!/2 #%55!%4 .-&4+1!.-"+ +-"!+ &1)!.##-#0!.-"+2#2-"#0%# # #0! %55 5!44%"# 9-&4+ "-# 1! !"#2#4!+ #- !"& ! &"+&! 1!"!/2# /- #0! +!4%3 %3!+ 5! 2 2-+ H! = %"# &.0 2"+&4=!".! 2"

2" #0! %55!44%"# /%,-& %4 - /- !%

% -"#0%#%1%#.0-//2 #%55!%4 %# #0!2"

#%".!-/-#0! 4%"+-9"!

9 9%

#244 445!"+2"=.-"

2+! %#2-"1!/- !#0!

!2=0-& #44#0%##0!2=0- -& # -&= =0# #- 0%,! !'50%#2.%443 +!"2!+ # #- #0! 4%#!8.-'!

9% #0! 1!"!/2# 2# -/ 2"#!

! !

# 2".4&+2"= -" #0! -4%#2&'* & &"+! !.#2-" 7: -/ #0! .# /- 5! 2 2-+/ -'#0!+%#!-/5%

2"=-/#0!

!%9% +13#0! !/! !".!-& ##244 4 #0! /242"

2"=-/#0!/2 #%55!%4 F ", ,2!9-/#0!+2 .&

2-"'%+!0!

!2"%1-,!% 9!44% .-"#!"# -/ %5542.%#2-"*#0!

%'!2 %44-9!+%"++!4%3-/7:

:7;+%3 2"/242"=#0!5 !

!"#%55 5!%4 0! !13.-"+-"

"!+

-:6 :6 :6 :6-/ -/ -/ -/ 6@6A 6@6A 6@6A 6@6A B B B B KL 3 9%3-/5 !

!"#%55!%4*.0%44!"= =!0% 1!!"4%2+#-#0!9% ++% %#!+ @6@;6@75%

!+13#0!4!% "!+++42 # 2.

#&+=!*2"+8.&'8 !/! !".!- -& # 90! !13 !/! !

!".! !#2#2-"&"+! !.#2-"- -/#0!%"+.>&2 2#2-".#* : 5 !/! !+ %# #0!

! 2"

#%".! -/ %55!44%"# <4%"+- 9"! 9% 5% #43 %44-9!+ 90 024! %9% +2"=#0!'.

.-'5!"

%#2-"M

@*@*@@@<8 85! %. !/- %0% 2%"+0%02% %"+ "!% 2"+-0%"

"% -%+&5#-6%. !

%"+

6 @4%(0 5! %. !/- %2 &'

'(2" 1%+2!0%4-"= =92#0-#0! #%#&#- 31!"!/2# <2"

"#! !

#2"#0!2 /%,-& K6L !% % "!+ .-&"

!4 /- #0! 5% #2!

% ! %+ 2+!' #0%# &"+! 2'

'24% .2 .&'

#%".!

% %"+ 5! #%2"2"= #- #0! 4%"+ /- '

'2"= 5% # -/ #0! %'! %.>&2 #2-" 92#02" #0! !,!

!"&! !

#%#! -/ ,244%=! $0% %( % %')2* !0 24 %"+ 2 # 2.# 2"+ '% (!# ,%4&! # #%"+ 2". !% !+ #-

*A@*@@ @@<8 5! %. ! ,2+! )&+='!"# +% %#!+ 6A@6@6:5%

!+13#0!-"J14!5!G-& # #2"2,2455!%4-A-/6@ 2,2455!%4-A-/6@ 2,2455!%4-A-/6@ 2,2455!%4-A-/6@ 6@6: 6@6: 6@6: 6@6: #2#4!+I%")%3B I%")%3B I%")%3B I%")%3B B #%#!-/% 3%"%J #%#!-/% 3%"%J B #%#!-/% 3%"%J #%#!-/% 3%"%J K7L ..

.- +2"=43*#0!5 !

!"#%55!%42 + +2 5- !+-/2"#! '

-/#0!+!.2

2-" !"+! !+2"%") %") %") %") ")%3B

")%3B

")%3B J.% ! &5 %%"+#0! %55!44%"# % !0!4+!"#2#4!+/-

%'!%'-&"#-/ /'% (!#,%4&!%

!+%"+0% % 1!!"%9% +!+#--#0! 2'24% % 43

2#&%#!+4%"+-9 9"!

*%4-"=92#0%44 #%#&#- 31!

!"!/2# %"+2"#! !

#%,%24%14!&"

"+! #0!%'!"+!+5 - -,2 -/%"+.>&2 2#2-".

.#*:% %5542.%14!#-#0!5 !

!"# %.>&2 2#2-"2".4& &+2"=#0!2"#! !

#-" -4%#2&' -9!,! *#0!%55!44%"# 0%44"-# #1! !"#2#4!+#-2"#! !

#-"#0!!"0%".!+.-'5!"

%#2 2-"/- #0!5! 2-+-/+!4%32"/24 42"= #0!5 !

!"#%55!

!%4 K:L

"+2"=%5542.%#2-" *2/%"3 0%44 %4 - #%"++2 5- !+-/

%36@ 6@ 6@ 6@*6@6 *6@6 *6@6 *6@6C #2( $ $ $ $ H0 H0 0!#0! 5!%(2"=< !% -"!+ !

0!#0! !5- #%14! !