High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/79/1989allowed

(O&M) Bimla Devi v. Devinder Singh Etc

2015-02-25Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal14 pages

"# # $

% &!

"# #

!"#

"$ ' ( )#!* ( '&!# * *

# ++++ " %

# ,!"* -

." / 0

. 0" !

# * 1 0 0 ! # 2#

3 "# 4 5 (

! 65

- 4 . "" # . # 2 0 "# )! "#

- 1 .!

" #

- .

.1 # 5! 2# * 3 # - ! 2 0 "# )! "# !

1* # 5! #

-" 7 5( 4765

6 82# 1 . #

"# 3 * -# -

- .

.1 # 5! * # - # ! # # - # 59! 1* # 1 " .1 # 5! . !:

7 ; - * 2 0 "# "

"# -

! !" #

* # *

# .#

. # 5! " 2# 5! #

# 4 2#

" # ,!"

%!"* <!#* -# .1 ,!"

$ .1 !. %!"* &# - ! #

# #

! # " ! # = , &! * !"#

)! "#* - # - # ! " $ # #

2# - ! # = "#

= "# " $ $ = , &! >

." # " # = , &! ?@* # ! -# #

" # % &! #

1 . ! #

9! # ! ! !

% &! # # ! 7 4* 1* 5# , &! %- &!

-## # # "#* 7 4* ! * # 6 $ 2# ! - .1 # ! ! " ! # #

# " ! # # ! - . % &!

" # #

9! - ! # .1 # # # !"# = , &!

0 # # # ! # #

9! 7 4 . A #

" # * 5! #

-" !6 B## # ! = , &!

- " >! .1 C ;

C A'

;

! * -## #

# ! 1 C A''

7 B## # . ! # # 1 ! C A'

4 B## # ! .

C A'

B## # ! . .1 # C A' $ :

2 5! ! ! !

# 1* = , &! - !"# % &! = , &!

9! - ! # .1 %

&! # = , &!

$ $ D> ( " = , &! - E -#

"# ?

@ 7 2# 9! -

! # = "# = , &! - ." !"# )! "# ; - -# # # # - -

"# ?

@ 2# - ! # ! #

# )! "# # - #- # * -# ! # #!.

# A # # #*

"# - #- ; # *

- # !., -## - ! # *36 37 # # ! - 9! -# 7*736 A $ $

)! "# >!

D> 6 D> 6 1 ! = "# . *736 9! -## %" "# - # - )! "#

B64 # . !

.! #

-1 -# # 2# -

# # -

# ! .

D> 6 D> 6 D D> 67 D>

4 # .0

# # ! - !

! = "# $ $ = "# #

* -#

" B6 * # ! ! ." ! # 2 5! ! # # # 9! -* * # = , &! .! # - .1 % &! )! "# #

-1 -# # 2# ! - !

'B6 1 # # # " ! 4*36 = , &! ! # #

" .0 ! - - - > '

# -1 -# % &! D ! "

= , &! *

-# % &! -

! # 5! .1 # 2# ! 9! - 74 4* 1 # = , &! 2 5! # # . # ! ! "

1 " ! # !

5! ! ;! #

" .1 " " 4 ?7@ ?.@ # 2 ?' #.@ *

?F# # @ # # % &! #

- (# ! 1 1 9! # # # . . "

! 1 1 9! # <-

5! # # = , &! * * - * -# # # 1

$ ! # " ! 1 1 " ?# # @ * # *

4 ?7@ ?.@ # - 2# * > !

# . # " !

-## # !* 1 "# 1

1 # #

. 1 "# 1 1 # #

- 1 !* 2# > " "

1 # " 4 ?7@ ? G .@ - ! #

; ! # # # 9! 0

$ $ # ! - 74 4 2 5! .

$ - # 9! # # # 5! 6 8B## $ $ ! = , &! " # " # .- # .

- # - -

# 2 ?' #.@ C:

7 4 # ." ! # . -6 &'

( )* )+ ?

@ #

1 . ?@ #" !.6 ?

@ #

1 # ! #

1 .1 1 # # - ! !"# #

. !* ! # 1 *

# # 1 # . ! # # . # - # ! !"# ?7@ B# 1 . #

. !#.

-# -## 1 > # 1 -# -# .# ?4@ -#" 1#" # 5 5 ' ! * 7*

! # #

. 6"E.

. .

* , -

- . (+ ?

@ !* 1 "# 1 1 # . " # -# # 1 # " 1 #

.1 .#

" . # - !# 1 ?@ . 1 "# 1 1 # .* -## " # -# # 1 # " 1 # * #

- 1 !* .1 .#

" . # - !# 1 ?7@ #" # #

1*66 ?@ -# # -# #

1 # =! !

1 # 1 # # . # # 1 ?.@ -# # -# # 1 # ! # " ! 1 1* # 1 # # .

# -# # ! - -# # !# 1:

7 #

" # ! -

# .1 # 5! * #

7 4 # - ! .1 #

# 5! .)/ ( ,) ( / 0123245 "

4 2# 9! . # # - -## 4 ?

@ # .

!* 1 "# 1 # " -# !# 1 # 1 # ;

" .#

" . #

- # * # " 4 ?

@ # 2# 9! - .1 # # - # # #!"# 7 # #!"# 4 ?

@ # > 1 .1 1

. -!

"* -# "# 1

" # ! .- # # 4 ?

@ # -

1 -# " # " "# . "

# # #1

" #

" # ! # .1 # -

5! * # - # - " #

. 1 4 # . # # -

5! # # # - 9! 1 # .1 # #. # 0" .- ! # "

# ! 1 1 " -

2# -

5! . !"# ! # # . > 4 ?7@ ?.@ # #

.1 # " # # "# # .1 = , &! # . !

. # .

0 .1 # - #. .1 # # #

- # 1 # = , &! ." #!.* # * "#

- # * - !

# # = , &!

$ 2# - > .)/ ( )*)0) - 4 . . =F.

# > 5! -.04 ),)( )7 04 )12280"

45'3 2# > 5! # # . " # 0 # # #- # # #. ! 7 ?

@ " -# # - #

1 -## . ! # -## # #. -#

. *

.)/ ( )*) 0) - 4 - ! # >

#. # 7

# # 2# ! 4 ?

@ # - 0

.1 # > 5!

2# .

#. # "# 1 #

* # -# # 2#!* -

# # >" "# # -

# .1 # !# - " 1

.1 # " !

4 ?

@ # * ! #

# # # # 1 # .1 # 1 ! !# "# " 4 ?

@ # -

2# =F.

5! -.)*)0) - 4 # # # 4 ?

@ -!

. ! ; # ,!"* # 5! # #

! " #$ %$&

& $ &

$' " & $ $ $

& $ $

!(& $

( $$$

$ $ $

$ $ )

%( $ $$ $ $ $ )

& $ !(&

2# - - !

1 # !.9! ,!" # =F.

5! "7 . "7 ) .

) -

,) /)

012284 9"

66 ; - # # # " 4 # #- # # - ! " #

1 " # " # # .1 -1

H # 1

# " # * .- # .

- # - .1 1 -# 2# - - " .1 # =F.

5! :/ ( ,); (-.

) <<2 054 0 ,.4 8= 2# ' - #

" # # 1

; - * # 9!

- # - # # #

" # 2 ?' #.@ *

# .1 # #. # #

! - -.)*)0) - 4 B 8/! 1: # . !. > ; *. ),) )5<15054 0 ,.4 255% # =F.

5! # ! 1F >

!. !

# " .

"* * ,) - ) 5<11 0'4 0 ,.4 21=% -# # 5! >

# F ! 1F F ! 1 # F #

-" 6 & $

& $ $ $

& $ " & +

$ & + * 7 2# ! 1 # >#! .1 # - -

0- # 1 # -## 1 ,1 # F F # 1 -# #

# !"#

> # 0 # 2# #

# ! # -## # ! # # 1

; - "

* # - # .1 #

. 1

4 # # - 0 .1 -

5! . # .

- - -.)*) 0) - 4 =* #

- ; !" ,!"

.1 # -

# # 5!

$ . * " # ! -# # !"#! 0 "$4 !;$

56%5<16