← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/844/1989dismissed

(0 & M) Dharam Singh v. Bhai Ka Bagh Co-Op Society

2015-03-23Mr. Justice J.C. Verma7 pages

 



!"!#$% & '()&*(+ , '

-!#.'

 / 

   

    %$

        

 &.0 12$ '&!'033 &*/

" '&!!&!*/

& '&!50# */

"4#   

 '

!5  .'4

!/

2*'

&-

  !

2*  '

 "0!

 "

7!#. 

&  4""

""!#  

"0&!#. )7 "- &3

" &!4

"   #   3  !#.'*   - -1 &     !

2  &&!#.

'&!8

!#12& "30 % .!#.--!

2'

1&0.'

2 ( ""

""!#  

"  9 "  4& 3   1  !33

.!#.

& !132

!# ""!#

#!#!"40

#)+ 

:  #!# /

!33 3 04

"4!

"7 "12

2 ) 

"   * )   , '

  #

    #2!#.

2 # 3 !-!#.

0# &&!#. 0&

  3  !#.'  9 "  # &   - -1 &     !

2  #&  '

#2 -4

& '&!

2 1&!#. #1

2*!

(

4&4 ""312 31!&!#.' !*#   9# &"

 #"!

"*+++<

,, #/

"9 9# &"!#4""

""!# "!# #  7!#./ &!0"4& 3!-!# &216

!#"* 3 !-"

0412

 !

#0# #& 43!

!#*

2'

" 3 !-"

04!# , 339!#.  !""0 "  9   12   39 &  0&  #

= +

,$

>'

2!" 12 &4&

? ( >'

& 3!#.''

#032 '&!8 !#"

"0!

? ) >'

2!" 9# & !"40

4&4 2?  >'

2!" .

""!# !"40

4&4 2? , >'

2!"

0# ? "*!

?

 = >'

!"#032

% --!

2? "*!

? : >'

 "# !" 3"

#2 0"

!#?

  >'

- 9# & !"40

4&4 2129 2 ""!# ""

9&!

#"

?

 >'

!"

## !3!#.  -43

 #!

5'

 =+<=?

+>'

!"# '!#3!-!

!#? "*!

?





=  ' 4&0 & 3 "9 33 " 0-

&2

 #"!

&!#.9'! '*9'!3

&!#.0#"

3

) 39 & 0& !!#.!""0 ")* ** +

2*## "0!

*!"-!""!#.!

""0!

# + 

:'

339 : '

3

+ 

: 39 & 0& *9'

!#!

"!#

04

""!#

"9 "#

#&"044&

12 #0 && 04#12

"@0 !#!#. !#!#."

#!""0 ")* ** +

*& 3

""0.'

!#!#.

 !# 

3     !

2*& &"!#.  !#!#."  #   !""0 "*

!#.

3*& &"!#.

 !

 >'

04# "

!"

2 '!" 0& 10

#2 "01"

3A0 9#

!#.

&-!#

!#12 '!" 0& !#

&-"



++ * 0#"

3 " '

" - 049!

'"0 '

A0 !#" 99'! ' "01"

3!##

0& 33

&-!#

12 '!"0& '

"0# &$  >'

!-40.# 39

0&  !"  !33 3  1 !#.  # &2     43

!#." 

# &?

 >'

!-40.# !"!33 3'

'0

!""0 "?

 >'

!-40.# !"1 !#3 9'

/!#.

#4 '0  #"!

&!#. !#!#. 0& #"

2!#.'9 '"

#0#"0"

#& &"!#. ?



&!#.'

#4&/!

+ # '!"& .03 &"

#

3*A0 !#!#./ &!

*!

" 3

##

4&/ &-& &9 "/ &37

!#!#."

!""0 " *, #=9 3"A0

""

!#. ""!#

!#*!

!" 3 0&

#0 &9 "-!"!#

&4&

39 !&9# &"'!49 "9&#.32 #0#   !"

0&.

&& 123!-!

2* "4# !#*9 "& A0!& 4&/ '

'!#



7!#.& 3 !-40.#

.03 &"

#

3!""0.'

( 0&!#. # 2

3* #"

A0 04#

'

'

-!#.'*'!"B"9 339 1&0.'

#& & !-!3 &32* #"

A0 04#

'  &1 #"!#.'* (*'!"B"

3" 339 1&0.'

#& &

) 42 .!"

C;(D&

3"

"& .!"

#( :

,,'

#

4!# 0

#2-

3& !&

/0& "'9

2'

#  3!A0!

  &  !

"  & .!"

!#  9 "    "01"

A0 32   %

&- "

2'

#

#'3!#.

.03

!#"9!

'0 #24& *!4"

*!"# .&0#

#0#

&

2& "- .!#. --!

2

9"C; D

2 ## A0 !&/ 3!!

2 212 " '"

#!#. ;

-!#

 &7 "'!#.'

>(*""!"

 .!"

& 4

!/

2*

'!# *#4!#

!#.

& 03"0 03321 !"

A0

2&!

/!#..#

0#

&

3 !-

 3!#.'9 "# &- -1 &

2#&'

'&!8 12!

3" "# '3

&1

0"

"30 !#C;)D :(

,9 "# #324&/ #& &

#!

"/ 3!!

2'

13!"'

10 # 3!#.''!-"

"" 1;  " > #'

" &0 !#!8!#. &"" ;

-!#

'0 #2!" & '!-

&*-&  &"" ;

-!#

!## '!"

""1

 3"

4 &-

"*-&

&32

#"4 32'

&.

29'!3 ##!'!3

!#.

#

2

,  !"&

&9& '#

!#!#." !""0 " *(, #=

, 9'! ''

#&

0&#

/0&

212 39 & 0& 39*

#&"

!#*9'

.#

3

+ 

:

39 & 0& '!" '

#.

!#"

#12

"!# !#.

'0.'

*!"4&/ /! #2- !#!#."#!""0  *(*  #= 39 & 0& 9'! ''

44&/

"  0&!#.  4&

!#."  

 0&  1 39*

!#. !-

0# '

# &&

&

=  !"9& '#

!#!#." 39 & 0& #!""0 #)* * +'

3

/

0&#

E &!

# '!" 0# !"0# #.

: >'

#9 ;

-!#

"*!

!"

!#!

!#*&!.'

&- / &21 .!##!#.

 31!&!#.' #   9# &"'

"3

"!# 2

,,  #"!

"*+++< 0 #

*#&

-# ' "0 '"

!"

!#."

"'

!"

#2 .&

"

33#&"

"044& !#. !& 3 !- /!#.

#

"01"

!& 3 !-# '!" 0# *# '"

#!#.

 31!&!#.''

#1&0.'

""1; ">

 &9 #!#.'

&!#. ""1; ">)#'

341

"

 '

#.!#. !& 0&"

*'

/2& "43

#60.-

=

)C; D

C;(D/!

9'! '# -!""!#

!7   31!&  !#.'   !*  3 !- 

"  '

!#*  9# &" #*9

'

43

# & 42 0&#!"'

- 3#.9!

' 42 9&!

4&0 12 31!&!#.' !'

0#

3 0A0!& "044& #"0"

!#60.- C; D

"'

;(#

32*/ 4&4 2!#!"40

9'! '9 "-&

= " ++<

"'

C;(D9 "&!.'

32'

3 #4&1

!/

&9 .!"

!#!#/!

9 

:  .!"

!# *

+



#

&1!

&'

44!#

!"40

#'

&!#

/0&

"*9'! '3

&9 "-

&03 *!" 3"#

13!"'

'

!"# 9'!"4 &!# "044& '!" 3

"  E!

&- #2  #.3 *  3 !- 

"  '

!#  # &    40& '

  #  &-   31!&  !#.'  !"

13!"'

#& ##

&'

#-

&03 *

#4&/ -/

C;(D!# 1"

.!"

!#* "#  - " 0

" (+ &2'

/2&  '

# 43

" # 7'

"& .!& 9&! "C; D&

3!#.4""

""!#

""!#

:) :  #9'

!# !&4""

""!#0&!#.

::

:!"

"'9#  "  "'

& 0&!#.  0&"

&.0- "*!

"#

!"40

7'

"& .!& 9&! # & &!.'

/!#.#4& "0-4 &0 '

"!" "!# #!

"   / #   &9!"

*  !#  !&  43

!#."*  4""

""!#  

"!"# - &-!""!/ *10

&!"

&!.!# 39# &"'

"!#.!& 9&!

'0" 3".

0412

" ( 

#

2# &'

#!" 3

.&!

3 !" -

""!#9 & !132

#12

"#)+ 

:  !-#2  3!#.'> !# #"#

' &- "!# * 03#

" >'

#"

#

2*& "4# !#*!"43 !# #"4 10

"  !"4""

""!#  12 

"  9!

' 

&-  )+ 

: * 

32

13!"' !&4""

""!#

&0 9# &"*! *

2 0-

&2 / &2'

/!32&

12

"&

!3" -1!

&32 #"'9" !&4""

""!#

:

&-!""!/     #!  &   2

& 

(  C;,D*  9'! '  '

"  .

4& "0-4 &0 '*!#"

"044& !#. !-

"!

"'9!#. !&4""

""!# &-!""!/  0- 9& #'

/!#.4& "0-4 &0 '

&3!

(!"#& & 

#2"0 '& &"'9!#. ""!#1 !#.

'

# 3 .1 '!#!#4&0 !#. 3

" ""!# '0"!" #- (( '

"&!.'

!#& &"!#. !#!#."

39 & 0& #!""0 # + "9 33!# !#& &"!#. !#!#."#!""0 )*  # () #"

A0 32*!-40.# 39

!"# &9!

'0

!""0 39 & 0& #&

!"3 7 !" 0""!#!#& &"!#. !#!#."#!""0 ) # !""0 "'

!!-40.#

"  3"  #  1

#  0#    1  # &2     #  & & 01"

3A0 !#" 9 #"9 "'3!#.

!" 0""!# !#!#."

 &&

#

3"!#3 9 (  !#!#.#- '!"& .03 &"

#

3!"!"-!""

"

"