← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1179/2019dismissed

Ramesh Chand v. State Of Haryana And Others

2026-02-10Justice (To Be Nominated),Mr. Justice Rohit Kapoor6 pages

   

        +911  !"

18918< =)> ".%%!

(1: 

  ?33'' $ 

 ?3!

 +91  !"

 918< =)> ".%%!

(1: $%&#'

?33'' $ 

 ?3!

     ( ) ) ) 

  

     ) 04 !#', -!.  )%* %'+ , -!. , )%

 , -!.  6%  "! <> )     )% % /0 ',

' , # ;;;

  1 .  ".  % -!'-  2 2!

 33'  % %.', ,

"!, + 9118918 

 +919 18  2% .% %  .!!

&0 . 2% 45 .  "!+9118918  +  % %  6%  3 % %!

 -% &0 7118,2#!2-% 40

(9 "

"This order shall dispose of tw wo writ petitions bearing CWP P N Nos.3125 and 3128 of 2014 as s the common issue is involved d t therein. Unable to show any jud dgment or ruling that 9/10 years s

@A service of Rajasthan Government can be added to service in Haryana, this petition has to be dismissed for the simple reason that service rendered by the petitioner in a Government department in the State of Rajasthan cannot be counted for any purpose in Haryana including pension by clubbing the two services together for reckoning qualifying service for pension and retirement benefits. The petitioner joined Haryana Government on 15.10.2007 and by that time the New Pension Scheme had come into operation. Relief granted by the department by mistake to one person has been corrected. As per the statement of Mr.Rathee when the written statement was filed that order was under reconsideration and presently stands withdrawn.

No merit. Dismissed."

7 "! - % 4 ! 4,%  6!0'

233!%  !" !. %  %'". (9 71  6 % % %''# 33!%     !" & 8 ! 3! !"$ % # ""%. .!

0  !6!*0.



33'% 300  ! .0%  5.%% % %  ,%

 # 8 ' % '#,  . ! 2 33!%   $ % # ""%. !

 1:1, % 7 .036% .2"! 0 !% %

 2"!  ' % 3%!

 !" 6!*% 4%   !"& 2.!0  !6  ' !"-%.% #6'!   !5 

2 "% !" B!'

3 .

C2#  % C !-%.8

@7A 77 4, !6-, &.   .'% 2# !2-% ! 0' ! 40' %!

 5%   "! -%.

  !"&  !2.!0 "! -%. 

   !" # D  %! !0 '3'.'% .03!

0'D

1E!"

0'!"1:,6 5 .  % " (9 FDRegulation of claims to pension or family pension. Any claim to pension or family pension shall be regulated by the provisions of the rules in force at the time when a Government employee is retired, discharged or allowed to resign from service or dies, as the case may be.

(15) "pension equivalent to gratuity (PEG)" means the notional amount worked out by applying the following formula :9 PEG = (Amount of ÷ (factor of death9cum9 commutation retirement table x 12) gratuity) Note.― Factor of commutation table is taken from the commutation table against the relevant age next birthday after the date of retirement."

'% . % '! 3'.  03!

'0 71 !"  0 &2 %-%' -%.0',$!'0,33'%.2' ! ,6 %'! 5 .  % 2'!6(9 "3.17. (a) Government may transfer a Government employee from one post to another; Provided that except-

(1) on account of inefficiency or misbehaviour; or

(2) on his written request; a Government employee shall not be transferred substantively to or, except in a case covered by rule 4.22, appointed to officiate in a post carrying less pay than the pay of the permanent post on which he holds a lien."

@DA  %!.!0 ''!3'.'% .03!

&0

% 4!" % !0 % 

 ! "#$%%&'()! !

 '% &, G9EH119D, .%  !

 1D117, 6  2 ""% 2#%-%%!

 .

% !0  E   .!0 ',!

!

,!33! .'%!"

4!0

!-%.!" %" 11:

, "!, 0'!"1:, 181:, 6!0'

!33'%. %!

 ! ". !" 3 . %'!02% 

'%0'

! .!

% '07<>'% 03!

33'' , 6!0'

- ! 2 % 3   -%6 !"  02I0 

 6'' 181: %'!02% 

% !0 % .!"0  /0%<03> 

!33'%.2%'% # : -% 45% 3. %-.!

%!

,6"%

!0'- !2% .!3' 4 6% -%6! * 4' 0 4 !

'#3!-%%!

6 2 '% 03!

"! .!0 4 !" -%. % ! %"%. %!

 181:, 6 2#

!- ! !" # ,    0' * !6   # %-%' -%. <  0'> 1:  @"!  !  B  0' !" 1:CA, 2# 5.%% &0% %. %!

 .!

"  3!-%! !  %.' 78 !" !

 % 0 %!

 !"

% 0'3.%"# !!

6 !% 6!0'

233'%.2'0'!"

0'!"1:,3!

0. % " (9 F2. Extent of application.

Except as otherwise provided, these rules shall apply to all Government employees appointed to a post on regular basis on or before the 31st December, 2005 in any Department under Haryana Government.

@EA Note 1.─ The Speaker of the Legislative Assembly has agreed under clause (3) article 187 of the Constitution that until a law is made by the Legislature of the State under clause (2) of article 187 of the Constitution or rules are framed by the Governor in consultation with the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly under clause (3) of article 187 of the Constitution of India, these rules and amendments thereof, if any, after prior consent of the Speaker, shall apply to the secretarial staff of the Haryana Legislative Assembly.

Note 2.─ The Chairman, Haryana Public Service Commission, has agreed to the application of these rules as amended from time to time, in the case of officers and employees of the Haryana Public Service Commission.

Note 3.─ If any doubt arises as to whether these rules apply to any person or not, the decision shall lie with the Finance Department."

  !-%.!" " 11:   0'!"1:, !6-, .''# 3.%"#   %   '' 33'# !''4!-  3'!#33!%  !3! !

40'2%!

! 2"! 711E %   # 3   0

 # !-   # -% 0 !"  3!-%%!

 .!

%  0'  !"  0' !" 1:, 33'%.2%'% #!"0' 181:, 

5.'0 !" 3 33'' %.!

.  !-%.%   !" # !" %" 711E 0.

.%.0  .,6

! %  %!

&. % C.!

%!

181:,6!0'

233'%.2'03!

%!0.

!

,0'D

1E !" 0'!"1:, 181:,6!0'

!33'%.2%'% # !

". !" 3 .!" ! 7<>!" '071!" 0 &2

%-%' -%. 0' $!'0 ,  33'%.2' !     !" #  % .!

. , 6  !"  -%6  %  0' 6%'' - ! 2 

@:A .!

&0 . %!

6% 181:,6 3.%"%.''#'%% 

33'%.2%'% #!"3 0' ! !6 ! - !-%.!

! 2"! 711E !

'#   ".  !"  3  ., % .   !" # !" 33'' ! -%.!"     !" #  % 3!  11:, ! 7<>,6%'''! !33'%.2%'% # ! % H % !0 % .!"

 ! "# *  6 %  .!

5 !"  .'% !" 6!*% 4 %     !" # "!18 !18D 3 % %!

J0  /0%633!% !

1D188 0.

.%.0  ., ! -%. 6 3%! ! 711E 

 .!

I0 '#  0'  !

181:,633'%.2'03!

  2% % % 40% " 0

#!" 2% 4" 11:, !3% #. 2

6  6% .%%!

 

 0   /0% <03> 8 0.

.%.0  .,6 ! ! "%

 #!..%!

 !% " 6% 3 7118 33''.*% 

% %% ..! 4'# 1  ''3

4%.33'%. %!

<>,%" #,'! 

%3! !"   +,     +, 1: & 1G 3*% 4K!

L ( K! G 3! 2'L ( K!