← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/905/1989dismissed

Smt. Shanti Devi And ORS. v. Iqbal Singh And ORS.

2024-07-31Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl37 pages

           



!"#$%"&'('#)*+,-,..  

        



        

  

   !"#$ 

 " % & '$

 ( %) *  $

 

   +  $

  ( %, -  #$ 

 " -!$

 $ +- #$

   $

(  %) )

   %, ."    &   /0/1,/,2     

) 3     

)

 )4, , ' (( (   

,4))

 ,45 .

-  ((  

),4).

 54)) -  ((  %)  



)2

 ))4), 6 ( 3

)1422

 ),4.0 / 00")1"')!/"23"(")! )  (   %,     &  (  %,

.

'"    &  ( '" $        $  (         # -  

,)/5)570 

&   3 "    (

&  ((    %)8  &  (    %) 

  (

 "      ( (  -  #       (     &

       # -  

   3   %1.7 ( )57)  (  (  

 %, "  $  

 "       (  ((   ((    %) " 

   ( (     9  ( )81  (     3      # -  

/7/.)575 "     (

&         -

&     3 :            (    2) (  # 3   )5)7       )// ( 3   ,0 (  # -  (  3 '   6

;   '   (  <=   - 3    (



!"#   $"%&'(" )( ) %*%!$ $#+!

 &$"%! + "

%#

 &$"%!

 &$"% ,&,$ - $$%!    ./01 1  023$  "  

   50 ) (  3 ( 3  

 -  -   $ )50>$        2) (  # 3  $ "   "  &  "( 

3'"$$ &!(#$!/"& ("

, ' ( (  (           %)4

 8((   (   (    ? ((@  (  (

+

   ((    " 9  "     (    -  ).. + , - -  ! " % )10$ + %).1, 04))$ ).71 04),$ ,/)1 )40$ ,/)> )/4,$ ,/)7 04.$ ,/)58, 042$ ,/,>8, 04))$ ,/,0 74/$ ,/,7 14.$ ,/,5 54)>$ ,/./ 74/ + %,/.)8, 04))$ ,/2) 74/$ ,/2,8, 24)>$ ! )2$  55 + )> - - %).,>  ! " %)10 -$ ! %,/.7 74/$ ,/.5 24/$ ,/2/ 24/$ ,/2> 74/$ ,/20 74/$ ,/)58) /47$ ,/,>8) /45 ,/.)8) /45$ + 7$ -  .. + > -

- %).,1$   ).. !4 ,    '+ %5.$ :  :  #-  )507405  ( 

 "   

).)))57)   3   %1.7 ( )57) &  3 (  ;   3$ !+   (  (  %,

     %)   (   (     %, "       (    -  .. + > - "  $  

  3     ( (  -  #    

 (-      &  -     

 "  &      " &     3 -        ((      (    $    ((     (     :  (  ((    "      " "

 

&   $ (  (  ((  "   (  (

 %,  1   (  %)     "   ;  &     (    " 

  &  )57,  " (   

   " ;  & 

   $ $  -    

    

  ( " (  .. + > - (   





).)))57)  (  (  %,  " (      (-  (    

 "  

& ( -   $  - "     ( " 

"  

 $   $  ((        (  (( .  # "   -  " (

&  %,  1 

   "   - $  "  

   &   "  ( 

  & (       - "     &  " (     "      -  ..

+ > -$       (   -   %,   (-&   -  "  "    

).)))57)  "       "   -   &  (  

   %, " "     (  

-  .. + > -  "       -  $       (    "  "   (($ (   

 -  "          "

        "   -  (

&  %,  1$   -    &   "    (-&   -   +   $   -           "     (-&   - "" 2  "   -  "  (  ( (  %) " "  " " (        "   - $  "

  

  ,  

    &  %, " -  &  "     - "  $  

 

     (  "    , (  

"  -   

   "4    

              

 

          

 

    

      

      " !

# ,% #! -%)4 !$ * *% &$6##(&$" !5%#(7 $

1 :"      "  (

&  (($    # "   -  (

&  %,  1      "   -  (

&  %)      (   "   -  (  %,  1$  "  ( &    ) -   "(-&  -  +   > :  3  /./,)572  (-   $"    

   "4 

 

   



  

 

!

!     "# 

 

  $%&    ! '$&  %&  



 

    

 "# ()

    

    

 *

"# $

   

"#+ ,

    "#+ '

   

 *   

 

 

- "#+ .

  

 "#+

/

    

  

 

   "#+ &

      #   

 00"#+ %



0 A      %)$  "  

&       & 

   ( 

  &   (( 

(     (       & 



 &$    "

  ((   (  (   B   %,$  "   

&   3  

).)))57) "     (  -   "   -         (   & (-&   -  "          

 %,     "         "  <    & (- ; <  6-&  $  "   

  

         (  $        )0 (     $ )5/7 6   (   " -    -  (   $ "     A4) "      4 9-    -  (        "  

 

 "  $ "  (

&   (     "  (-&   -  "      -  

 &$  %, "

 (  (  ((     B   %,4$  "   

  (( "     (      9  ( )81  (      %) < !$ " "  -  (  (( 

 %,  1$ 

-

   & "  "    "

&    "  ( 

  &$   - " 

&

-  (

    $   ((  (  

 %,  1 B    %.  2$   "    -    "     ((       (    

 &$     " 

 (  (  ((     A       %1  >$  "   

     "       - ( -   

 &$ " 

 (  (  ((       %0  7 "  

 (  (  ((       "  

   "      "   (( "  (- (      "   C   (    (      $   (  (( " &

 -"         7  (   %, (    (     3

    # -  

  '" $ " "  (      $ "  #    %,   

  :    3   

  5 (  # -    -  

  "       %)$ .$ 2$ 1$ >$ 0 7  $ (       "  ((-      

(  3       8 (            "   

(     3 :    3 (   -     "    "  

&  (    

 $    " (    

  (  (  %, A

    $  "  

     -

& A4)$  (-&   -  

+                - (   ( 

     "        ((      "  <     & (-  ; <  6-&  $ -  

        

  (     (    

  $    (  (   3      

-    (

&    :$ &

 (  # -  (   3      3$ (

    (             & "  &  5 

"  # -  (   3      3$   (         )/ C /0/1,/,2$   -  " -  ( (          -     %,  . 

       %,  . :     (  

/0/1,/,2 

&  3  '   (  3    

   "4 )



 2  

        $ *

   *    *  

  

       



    

      





  *        $2 ! $" *%!$ **)) $! "

+ & ,) #-8'

$"-

 +#5 &7 $" 6&+ %!*&$! &.

 9 % (#+ '* 3 4,4/4,2   54/24,

))    %,  .         ! 

! !$ "   %.  (   3      (     

 $ "  "    

&   %,$ 

     

  

-   

-  .. + > - "   

&

-       (   $ $   $         "

$   (    %, .

 %.  2 "

  $   

- -    &   "  3156")!(#)7"/ 0$#$!/" 22"00 )!( ),       (    %)8   (   %, 

   # -  

 (   3  "      3 &        )0 (     $ )5/7 "  -    -    "    

-&    $   (  9  "       ,    -  



 (   )0 , 9   &

    (  3 (-   

     "  

     9   -   --   --  "     --    &     "     #  -  (    

  

      (  # -  

).)))57)



 9  42 

41$ D97 "   -  (

&      3 %1.7()57)$D95  - ( 3  %1.7 ( )57) " "    

     

 "         "     &  "       $       $ 

 "       (   - $    

 8   (         # -  (  <=   - 3    ( ?:'%,"

%  #("

 &$"%! ! (%;  '%  &$"%$ %*&%$ ! ././0/  .2/E ?&"

--  <'!'7 !  '- %= %*&%$ ! ././0/ .1>E ?"'!"#  -  &$"%! ! ) #("

 &$"%!=$ %*&%$ ! ./.001  .3?  "    # -  (  34  '   (  3  $ ../0./0? * !! # @.2 &7 0???   ?:'%- #) #("

 &$"%!

! A+ #("=$  " $    -



4,,. ).   (   -    (  (( "    &      &    "  

&  3    &      &    ( 

  & (        (  ((   (   

$  $       (  ((  

 -         " (   4 (  

 -    " 

" &  <=   - 3    4 # - $    (

&        -    -

"

 # -  (   3  "    )  

 3   

 %,     "  ( ..

+  > - (   

         -  (  3156")!(#)7"/ 0$#$3"(2#)%")!#, '!# 8' )2       (    %)   &  (   %)  - &  -   ((       -        $   

&

     "  (-&   -          ( D9 42 

41  "    -  D947 F 45$ "        $ " "    "   (    & (-&   -    & (  "  "

  - & "    " &  4 9      &  (  (  %, $ &  (   

 $   "   (  ( -  (  (  %,        "$  - "  "     - "        (   -  "     (-&   -     &   & &    -     (  %, "   ((     & (      ( 

 $  $  %,    4 9  "   

   





&  (   

         ( 

D9 41 " "   -   $ -  $      (

--  

  -   -  &    "   -       -  (     -  - ( 

 %,       (    %)  ( 

.

-   (  (     4 9- ( A4,  "   

  ( &  -

&      "  (-&   -  

$       ) (  "   -  (

&  %, "   &      (  - $    

  (    %)     # -  (  <=   - 3  ?

"&&* #(" !  - #("  &%=$    0??2 2  3/?   ?

"&&)

$$#  &$"% !  - #("   $"%&'("

( ) *%!$ $#+!

 &$"%=$    ./02 9 '*%- &'%$  !! 01> 6      

  # - ( 34  '  (3 0B/0./.9 

  ?#%# "

(5  ! '%$# A+#   $"%&'("

!

 &$"%!

 &$"%!=$    ./..9  #+#) 91/$  

#+#) A# %4 &!.239/C./.9  "    -

&  <=   - 3 +# &%%  $ /00../.9     

        - +  (  $ "

 

-&       -   ( (     ((  -     

 $ $  - "  -G      (     ((   

  

        - & 8  

  ')%')1#$!/"#53!

)1 : 3         8   (           (    %)    

   +   (             

+  -   

   

- (    "  



   (  )> :     ( " "    (        4 ?

 

  $%& 678('9       "

)0 6       ( $  3  (     

          (  (   3   )   3        



""        )7     (  %,   %)      &      & "  "   ( 

).)))57) "  (4

  & (    :  3  "    )   3 

-        &    "     &    (     

&   3   ), (  # -      & 

   ( 

  & (    :  (   

  

& & (    (  3 :     ).. + , -$ "        - # -  &

-  (     (     $ ((  

 %,  1 (   :        &  - "      -  .. + > -$ "    (   4  "  "   #  -  ( 

).)))57) )5 : # -  

).)))57) 

 9 

  D9 42  D9 41  

  (   &        (   # -  ).)))57) " "       (    & (-&   -    -      (    & (  "  " "    " &  4 9  (  %,$ "   "   G

&  (  

# -  

  :     (  # -  

    

   "4 :;70#<1#=!;1:>:5)3?<5)1@)?!;:2 ;0!2!<@A<+B72:::03)!!2?<1<?!;71) 0* ! '$&%& + : C.((& + + C$& !  !

  + *   @  !  

  !

!    !    >

 @ !

 

  2+ ?

    >  !

! ! D>

 @!

 

  2+ ?

 +   ! +      C !

0!) -20



  !

A ! 20



   A  C 

      

  !  !

  + *   @  ! 

   !

 !

   !    @ !

 2    

     

 

   

  

  

   $$ ?  . 5   



  

     

     A  

 %/&(/% 

  " 7 $ "% #(" !& &7 % # #(" "

!

-&+  **)#, $#& # $" *%!$ , ! 7&% $ #( $" , ! !

$" 7 $ #! % 4 $& -  $" !$ $-$ "#!

**)#, $#& #!-&+$"%&'(""#!,&'!)" 

)#("+&, $ $ 

   !

 !    ! 

 5%#$$ !$ $-$  $&2 

 

 2 # 5"#," " -#$$ $" ,) #- &7 $" *) #$#77  $" 7 $ "

! *% 4 # "#! %*)4 7&% $" ,% &7 $" *) #$#77 ! !'#$  ,*$ ,&!$! 



    

   !

!     :     

        





 

   -#$$ $" ,) #- &7 $" *) #$#77 # $&$&  7'%$"% "

! !$ $ $"

$ " "

! & &6 ,$#& #7 $" !'#$ &7 $" *) #$#77 6 ,%  ,*$ ,&!$! 

          !

 A  !

)*  



     !

 0! ) -        

 

 



    

    , : *  

      

         



   5"%# " -#$! $" ,) #- &7 $" *) #$#77 $" !'#$ &7 $" *) #$#77 7&% $" ,% &7 ,) % $#& $& $" 77,$ $"

$ $" *) #$#77 #! 7')) &5% # *&!!!!#& &7 $" !'#$ )  - !'%#( 99   )! 1  %) ! 7'))4  

     

  A  

  %/&(/% 

  

 ; * 2

   

 



     + 

    =

  

  

  

 

 ) 

0  $((& D( ! A 2:::0 

4 ?

  C)

     !D( !A:::02?1?$((&

,/    (   4 " "   (-  (       (    & (-&   -   &  4 9   (  (  %,$        # -        (  "   -  (         -  - (  ((  (       "  -

&   D     ( 

   D9  "   D97$ "    "   -  (          D945$ "     -  (        $ "  "    "   -     & (-&   -      & (  " &  4 9   (  (

 %,  - &$          

    D9 40    "          ( #  (

&  %,   !      (($ " 

 -

 %)        "        "   # -  

).)))57) "   ,)  A4)

 %,     9-   ( &     "  (-&   -  8 -- "       $ "  "   #  -  ( 

).)))57)$ "  "     (  :  (     (   (A4)  

   "4 

+ 

       2  

- )

  D 0       

 

,, : )   3   )7      ((-

(    (-&   -   +    :     %)7 ,) (  # -  (  )   3    

  

"4 888 & &-#( $& $" 8'!$#& &7 7 -#)4 !$$)-$  7# $"

$ -$ "

$# A+# ** %#( ! AD0    

   

 

     



 *



      

 

 

 !



 

  

 

    

   







 

 

 & -#)4 !$$)-$ "

 +% $  *) , # %!*,$ &7 $" )  $% !7%% # "%  - $"%&'(" $" !

# ,% " 6&+!

# -#!!#& & $" * %$ &7 -$ "

$# A+# "

! !$ 6)#!" & %,&% $"

$ $"% 5 ! & 7 -#)4 !$$)-$  $" #-*'( ,% 5 ! &$ 6 ! '*& #$ "% #! &$ +  #&$ &7 +#, & %,&% &% #$ #! !& *)  $"

$ $" * %$#! 5% #'!E $"

$ $"4 7&%- &#$ #' F -#)4E  $" $ $"% "

 6

-#)4* %$#$#& : &--#!!#&%&7:#7$

+! -#("0?B/ '%%$

5 &'% ) >>3 A   

   



  

  

?      =

        

*      

   !  !

  + *     

   



  ,&') &$ 6 $% !7%% & $" 6 !#! &7 $" !

#

 '%(#!$% ,% $" *) #$#77 5 ! ,%$ #)4 $#$) $& *&!!!!#& $& $" +$ &7 "#! !"

% # 0C2$" = 

   0      )     

,. -&$   3    %)0  )7 (  # -  

-       (-&   -  "  

 "           $  $  

  +    "   -        "      (-&   -         - & 

              "   - $     -  ( &

 -    &  (   (-&   - $        "     (-&   -  "    "  $  (  (   3   )   3         &

 ""  ( (    ,2 6-   4

 $            (  %,$     & (      ( 

   "  (-&   -      -     ( 

   - ).)))57)  $   "     - & "   %,  &  4 9     &       ( $  # -  

).)))57) +    (

 $      (  (

 %,      $ "          "$" "       (  ,1 : <=   - 3    ( "&&* #("

!'*%  (    3

 (  4  , (   )0 ( 

    $ )5/7$ "        ( (   $   

  9  "  

 (      " -    

    (  $    

    9   -   -- $ "  -  &

 *%@ #!$#( %#("$  # &$ 64 #$!)7 ,% $ 5 %#("$ $#$) &% #$%!$ # *% !$#=   --    & (   ( )//84  "    (     

 &    " " (  -  ( (   (  $ "     &-  ( - &       & (    9-     $   "       &  4 9    --    & 

       "      

 (   " 9    & $            --    & (   ( )//84  "   (  (    & (  ( - $   & --        -   $ 9  & $         $  $  -    "  

-&     A

&G  "   $  "  ( &   

 ( 

--

 "    $ (  ( - & $        --    & (   ( )//84  "   (  ( & &   $ 

    "     %)>,/(  # -    

   "4 . D "

+ $& +#5 $" % ," &7 ,) '! +# 5"#," #!

  ,*$#& $& !'6@!,$#& 0 6 %#( )) $" 7&%!

# # -# D 5&') $"# $"

$ $"  ,*$#& (% 7$ #! - $ $& ,&+% $"

$ ,% &% &%% &7 ,&'%$ #,)'#( ,% &% &%%

.  *%!! $& 6 -  & ,&-*%&-#! 5"#," ,) %! $" *%@ #!$#( %#("$  &! &$ 64 #$!)7 ,% $ 5 %#("$ $#$) &% #$%!$ # *% !$# # #--&+ 6) *%&*%$4 &7 $" + )' &7 !0//C@ &% '*5 %! 4 &$"% +#5 5&') 7# $" -#!,"#7 &7

+&# , &7 %(#!$% $#& 5"#," %8'#%! * 4-$ &7 !$ -* '$4-6#$",%&%&%% / $ 5&') $"%7&% 6 $" '$4 &7 $" ,&'%$ $& 

-# #  ," , ! 5"$"% $" * %$#! "

+ *%@ #!$#( %#("$ $& $" #--&+ 6) *%&*%$4 &% 5"$"% '% $" &%% &% ,% &7 $" ,&'%$ & * %$4 "

+#( %#("$ $#$) &% #$%!$ $"%# (% &% !'77% $&  $#('#!" $" !

-  ,% $ %#("$ $#$) &% #$%!$ # *% !$# # #--&+ 6) *%&*%$4 &7 $" + )' &7 !0//C@ &% '*5 %! # 7 +&'% &7 &$"% * %$4 7&% $" 7#%!$ $#- #$"% 64 ,&-*%&-#! &% *%!$ ,&!$ 7 ) $$% 6 $" *&!#$#&$"&,'-$#!,&-*')!&%#)4%(#!$% 6) 0B " )( ) *&!#$#& 8'

,) '! +# ,  & $" 6 !#! &7 $"

7&%!

##!,'!!#&6!'-- %#! !6)&5 69 0   

 6& 7#2 



,&-*%&-#! #! &$ +#, $& &6+# $ * 4-$ &7 !$ -* '$4

 7%'!$% $ $" ) 5 %) $#( $& %(#!$% $#&2     

   : * 

  2   

   69 7 $" ,&-*%&-#! ,% 5% $& ,% $ 7&% $" 7#%!$ $#- %#("$ $#$) &% #$%!$ # #--&+ 6) *%&*%$4 &7 $" + )' &7 !0//C@ &% '*5 %! # 7 +&'% &7 4 * %$4 $& $" !'#$ $",%&%&%%5&')%8'#%%(#!$% $#& 6$9 :

 

     

    (   69  !

  /2  

  

  * 0   0 E  2   

 

 

       6,9 7 $" ,% 5% &$ $& -6&4 $" $%-! &7 ,&-*%&-#! ! 5 ! $" *&!#$#& #

"&% , ! 67#$ 7%&- $" $%-! &7 ,&-*%&-#! , &$ 6 %#+ + #7 !'#$ 5%

. $&6#!*&!&76, '!&7$",&-*%&-#!#8'!$#& 6'9 :



   



 



F -    

  

F2   6*9   (   69    



 

      

 )   %%2  

    

    

* 0 2    

     *

   2 *       



     % 2

 

 

   

 

   ! '  %/$2

                    

  2 

 

 *

    )  2     C 69 " ,% "

+#( *'%*&%$ $& ,% $ %#("$ &% $#$) # $" *) #$#77 7&% $" 7#%!$ $#- $"

$ #! &$ 6#( ,) % $#& &7 *%@  #!$#( %#("$ # %8'#% %(#!$% $#& $ - )!& 6 *&#$ &'$ $"

$ $" 7#%!$ !'#$ , &$ % ))4 6 !

# $& "

+ 6 ,% & $" 6 !#! &7 ,&-*%&-#! ! $" !'#$ 5 ! ,% H# +#5 &7 $" 5%#$$ !$ $-$ 7#) 64 $" 7 $

-#$$#( $" ,) #- &7 $" *) #$#77 $& 6 ,&%%,$H A,%#( &7 !'#$ # !',"

!#$'

$#& #! ,&+% 64 %% 0. ') 1  &$ 64 %% .9 ') 9 5"#,"  )! 5#$" ,&-*%&-#! &7 !'#$ 5"% ! $" 7&%-% #! & $" !'6 ,$ &7 '(-$ &

-#!!#&! 69 )

 

   -   

 





 

     F

* F    *   

 

   

  *



   B   3   A 

;

0   

 *  4 

 

   -        

   

  2

   

..

   (   # -  " "   " (   

      $ 

 "    - &   - (  -- $  $  ( (   - ( -- " 



$  (   "  

 (

 (  -- 

        -         $      (    "& (  -- " "

   " -  (-   ( 

  : (     (

"&&* #(" !'*%  "  -   (  (      $ -  $     ( "&&* #(" !'*% $   "

 

 (  "   -  (

&      -  - (  (( 

     

 "    

& C  ),  >$   & C  ,.  .$ "   " -- (    

 $  -   ( (         ((   

 "          " ( " 

 

 

 (  4  , (   )0 (     $ )5/7 "     "   

  (  "     

     (      (



    -   "    -  9    (    +  (  $           (  (   $    --    & (   ( )//84 

" $  (  $  -      -- - - 

-&     A     (-&   - $ 

  " " "    (-&   -      -  "  "  

 "   " (    

   

.+ (-&   -  "  

 " 

       (  (  & &  (  - $  $  - " 

      : # -     4

     (          # -  

).)))57)     (  ( -  (  (  %, "      --    & (   ( -  )//84$  - - &    ,> &  

   ( "&&)

$$#  &$"% !'*%   .)/.,//5$  '   ( " ;   (  <=   - 3 

&        "    &   # -  

"&&* #(" !'*%    ("'   I %! ! )# '!!

#  6#%

 &$"%!    .//B 09  0/.$  (   -      '    "  

   &$  ;   (  <=   - 3  ,2/0,/)2   

   "     & "  (  "

 ,0    (  # -     ( "&&)

$$# 

&$"% !'*%  " "  "      ( 

  &$ &  &  "&&* #(" !'*% $  "   

  (  (  -    $   -    (  ( -    &   

 $  <=   - 3    (   -  -

& '"    (  

 -  (   

-       (-&   -  "  "      ( 

  &  $    (   & "   (      

-  : " 

"

.

&  <=   - 3    ( "&&* #(" !'*%  " 

       # -  ( "&&)

$$#  &$"% !'*%  ,7  

    $  "

      &

 (  - # -     & (    -  ).. +  , - 

 &

-         ((  

 %,  1 (     9  ( )81        %,  ( 

 $ "     (    &                  (  

  D   -  (  %,     "   -   

 

   "   :$  - # -    

   ""  & ,5   $  /0/1,/,2$   -  " -  ( (          -     %,  .

       %,  . :     (  

/0/1,/,2 

&  3  '   (  3    

   "4 )



 2  

        $ *

   *    *  

  

       



    

      





  *        $2 ! $" *%!$ **)) $! "

+ & ,) #-8'

$"-  +#5 &7 $" 6&+ %!*&$! &.

 9 % (#+

. '* 3 4,4/4,2   54/24,

./    %,  .         ! 

! !$ "   %.  (   3      (     

 $ "  "    

&   %,$ 

     

  

-   

-  .. + > - "   

&

-       (   $ $   $         "

$   (    %, .

 %.  2 "

  $   

-   -    &       "   

  (       .) : 3  '   (  3    ( " #%#

"

(5      4 G$ =

            

 C( D"$"% ,&!$ ,% #! )# 6) $& 6 !$ !# & $" (%&' $"

$ $"% 5 ! & 7 -#)4 !$$)-$  $"

$ $" ,&!$ ,% # 7 ,$ -&'$ $& &% ) (#7$ 5"#," 5 !

#-*%-#!!#6)'%) 5#$" 6!,&7%(#!$% $#&J= 4 

   

  



 

 

 

       2

= )

0         

     ) 

     *

   





  

  H !  5  + *     

 

  





  ! @ 2  



.4     0* ! .$&  %&4 ;

     

  

  

    

    

   , #$ #! 7&' 64 $" &'%$ $"

$ & 7 -#)4 !$$)-$ # 7 ,$ $&& *) , &% ,&') "

+ $  *) ,  ,&!$ ,% 5 ! !'77% 64 '%$# A+# +&)'$ %#)4 $" &'%$ #! 6&' $& ! $" )( ) 77,$ &7 !',"

,%  #$ , &$ 6 !$ $ $"

$ #7 $" ,% -&'$ $& &% ) (#7$ $" &'%$#!- #(&'$ 7%!", !5#$"&'$*) #( $  $" *%!$ , ! ! #$ "

! 6 7&' $"

$ & 7 -#)4 !$$)-$ "

 $  *) ,  % $"% (#+#( &7 $" *%&*%$4 64 -$ '%$# A+# $& $" 7 $ #%# "

(5  -&'$ $&  &% ) (#7$ 5"#," ,&') &$ 6 77,$ 5#$"&'$ %(#!$% $#& $"%7&% $" ,%  $ 00000?B/ "

! 6 %#("$)4 ") 64 $" F#%!$ **)) $ &'%$ $& 6 '))  +&#

 &$ 6##( & $" %#("$! &7 $" *) #$#77 @ -$ '%$# A+# , 0   

  2

              

 

  

    

-    

  

= )

0  

 :

     

    

 



   

.,  %,10./ ( ,/,.    # -    

-

 /)),,/,. : " 

"    

# -  "  (    (  ((      $

  +              $    - "  -G      ( ((   

       - & 8            "     " "       &     $ "  

.- (    

   $   (   (

  "     "   -  "

(    " "       &$ "   &  4 9    - $ "

 ( & (   

 -   "     &   - "

-  "   (       &     8 - &  - "

    9    .. : -    ( (      ((     "         &    

  (($ $    "        

       -     (  ((    

-  $   - 

    -  (  

"  -  &

    

  &   (    

&  &    (  

$  - " 

  "       #              $   "        &      (    

).)))57)$  "      $  %)  ,   3 " 

 &

        (    "    "     "

    -    ((     

).)))57)          

   

       

  %) "   -  (  (( 

 %,  1 

 ( &      &   

 "  "   

.

        $  

     $   

& (  3     -   " 

&        "    

     & (     "   &    

&  (  

 (  (-  .2 : (        8   (   $  3 " "

 "  # -   (   &  -: ( # -  "        ( (      # -     ( :'%,"

%  #("

 &$"%!

 : (  (  

 "  -  & ((   (-  (  (      -        "       

 $ "  "      

 $   "   (   +  "         (-&   -   )1/>)552   "    (      "      (-&   - $ "  ( - "   -   "   - $   "  

   "   4 9   (  (  ((     -     &   ((     "   4 9  " $  #  : <H   - 3   

       & (  # -     (

"&&* #("

       (  

  (   "   

   ( :'%,"

%  #("

 &$"%! !'*%    - "          (   # -     

   "4 . 888 888 '#$ & 221 5 ! 7#) 5#$" $" *) #( $"

$ D#))  $ /./?0?B1 ! 5)) ! F -#)4 $$)-$  $

. 02/10??> 5"#,"

% !*,#7#, ))4 *)  # ./ * % (% *"!

. 9&7$"*) #$ %$&$"7&))&5#(77,$@  

       *  



  44%%&.  * 

  

 



   

      2          

! (   $ "

$ $" 7 $ ,&!#%#( #$ *%&*% "

! 77,$

-#)4 !$$)-$ & 02/10??> +# 5"#," $" *%&*%$4 # !'#$ 5 !

))&$$ $& $" *) #$#77! # 8'

) !"

%!

 $" 7 $ "

! %)#8'#!" )) "#! %#("$ $#$)  #$%!$ 5"

$!&+% # $" !

# *%&*%$4 # +&'%&7$"*) #$#77#$"!

#7 -#)4!$$)-$= / :

 2 @ - !       2   

         4$%%,2 ))( $#&! # * % (% *"! .

 9 &7 $" *) #$ 5% -#$$ 64 $" 7 $ # "#!

     

   $2    





  C( 

   

   $

%  &9&7$"*) #$#! -#$$$&6,&%%,$= & :

      2

   @ - !

    

 

 

    " *) #( # $" !'#$  # $" 5%#$$ !$ $-$ ,) %)4 ) !

$& $" ,&,)'!#& $"

$ !'#$ 5 ! 7#) & $" 6 !#! &7 *%@  #!$#( %#("$ # 7 +&'% &7 *) #$#77! 5"#," 5 ! 6 !#! &7 $" !'#$ %@ #!$#( %#("$ &7 $" *) #$#77! 5 !

-#$$ 64 $" 7 $ ,%5 !* !!$"%# % "'! $" !'6-#!!#& &7 $" *) #$#77!@%!*&$! $"

$ !'#$ 5 ! &$ 6 ! & *%@ #!$#( %#("$ &7 $" *) #$#77!

, &$ 6 ,,*$ 5"#," #! 6)# 64 $" , $(&%#, ) *) #( # $" *) #$  +#5 &7 $" 6&+ *) #(! 5 % &7 $" +#5 $"

$ +%4 6 !#! &7 $" **)#, 6#)#$4 &7 $" '(-$ &7 "&&* #(" !'*%  #! &, &'$  #! &$ $$% ,$ #

+ $"*%!$, !888888

.1       $      $  "

    -      "   & (-&   -  

  - "   (  (   

).)))57)   $   4 9- (  %, A4)$  

  &   -

&      "  (-&   -   $  # -       " (    (   .> :   # -  "        ( (        ( &"

--  <'!'7  &$"%!

   

 $  " 

" &  <H   - 3  

 ( "&&* #("

 "   "   

 



    "  

    - "   - $ $  " 

"   # -     ( "&&* #("

 "  &   $  (  (  

 " 

-  & ((   (-  (  (         

 $    "  "  - 

    ( $ 

    "   --

 "      ( 

   : < 3   

      # -  ( :'%5 %

"#6!:% -

,"

$#)) (#%$"

)   &$"%   ./0> 0  11?  -        &    4 9      &    (

 (  " -      ( 

    "   

&  <H   - 3   # -     ( :'%'5 % "#6

$ 

  

&   ;  '   ; -  ( 

+ <H   - 3    (  +#% '%:%5 ) &$"%!

!  #$ '% &$"%!   ./0?B3.? 

   (

 (      ( 

   (    ( ), & - "-     &" 

  $      "  "  

&    8"    " (    

  &  (  < 3 (     --

/2)/)571     " + +

  (  # -   

   "4 888888 &  $" 7 ,$! &7 $"

$ , ! $"#! &'%$ ") $"

$ $" 7#%!$ !'#$ , &$ % ))4 6 !

# $& "

+ 6 ,% & $" 6 !#! &7 ,&-*%&-#! !

$" !'#$ 5 ! ,% G# +#5 &7 $" 5%#$$ !$ $-$ 7#) 64 $" 7 $ -#$$#( $" ,) #- &7 $" *) #$#77 $& 6 ,&%%,$= =

2

   



 



*     

 

   



*        *

      * % (% *" 0? &7 $" '(-$2   



   C( % 2

 

 

   

 

   !  '  %/$2

                   

  2 

 

 *

  ,,&%#($&'!#$, &$7&%$5&% !&! 0 " ,% "

+#( *'%*&%$ $& ,% $ %#("$ &% $#$) # $" *) #$#77 7&% $" 7#%!$ $#- $"

$ #! &$ 6#( ,) % $#& &7 *%@ #!$#( %#("$ # %8'#% %(#!$% $#& $ - )!& 6 *&#$ &'$ $"

$ $" 7#%!$ !'#$ , &$ % ))4 6 !

# $& "

+ 6 ,% & $" 6 !#! &7 ,&-*%&-#! ! $" !'#$ 5 ! ,% G# +#5 &7 $" 5%#$$ !$ $-$ 7#) 64 $" 7 $ -#$$#( $" ,) #- &7 $"

+.

*) #$#77 $& 6 ,&%%,$= A,%#( &7 !'#$ # !',"

!#$'

$#& #! ,&+% 64 %% 0. ') 1  &$ %% .9 ') 9 5"#,"

 )!

5#$"

,&-*%&-#! &7 !'#$ 5"% ! $" 7&%-% #! & $" !'6 ,$&7 '(-$& -#!!#&! 69 )

 

   -   

 





 

     I

* J      *    

  

        *



   B   3   A 

; 0   

 * 

% F&))&5#( $" 6&+ '(-$ &7 "&&* #(" $" #(" &'%$ ") $"

$ !#, $" ,&-*%&-#! ,%  $ />0/0?B2 # &$ ,) % 4 *%@ #!$#( %#("$ &7 $" *) #$#77 ", #$ %8'#%!

%(#!$% $#&" #(" &'%$ %)# & $" '(-$ &7:'%5 %

"#6 ! :% -

,"

$ #)) ( #%$"

)

 -  7&))&5#( &6!%+ $#&!#* % (% *"!0/00 0.@ 4 :

  2 

   0! '4( )D%&,

           



  * 

  

 

 

   

  " +%4 7 ,$ $"

$ $" !'#$ ! 6 ! '*& $" *) &7 +%! *&!!!!#& %7),$!

$"

$ $" *$#$#&% "

 & *%@  #!$#( $#$) # $" !'#$ *%&*%$4 

   

2

     



2 

  

     " '*%- &'%$ # $" - $$% &7:'%'5 %

"#6 ! :% -

,"

$ #)) ( #%$"

)  "

! !$$) $"

$ ,) % $&%4 ,% 6 ! & *) &7 +%! *&!!!!#& , &$ 6 ,) #-  +%! *&!!!!#& ,  6 '! &)4 ! !"#) # 7, 64 $" 7 $ :





  C( / :

!

 )

   

++

 * 

             

 & 



 

  

-   

 

       

  7*  

    

 * 

 2   

      

 



* 

           #  



 

 

 

           

* 

 

D   

 

 

      !

  / 

3   )   

 *       

 

8   

 

     

3   ) 2   *  

-  

   

 B !

      

 

    

 

 



  

4 " '(-$ &7:'%5 % "#6 ! :% -

,"

$ #)) ( #%$"

) "

! &5 6  *%!!)4 &+%%') 64 "% '( ,"

'(-$ # +#%  '% :%5 )  $"%! !   #$  '% "#! &'%$ ") # $" 6&+ , ! # * % (% *" 1. $"

$ &, 0.

4 %!

*%#& &7 +%! *&!!!!#& #! &+% + &5% ! %#("$ $&  ,$ "#- #! )&!$  $" *&!!!!&%4 &5% ,8'#%! %#("$ $#$)  #$%!$*&!!!!64$"&'$(&#(*%!&C&5% 888888 $  +#5 &7 $" *%&&',-$ &7 $"#! &'%$ 64 "% '(

," '(-$ # +#%  '% :%5 )  $"%! !   #$  '%  $"%! $" +%4 6 !#! &7 $" #(" &'%$ 7&% "&)#( $"

$ ,&-*%&-#!   $ />0/0?B2 %8'#%! %(#!$% $#& #! &, &'$ 

    

  

 

 

  4,4%&'   

*  

 

 

 

+ 4,4%&'   * 

   /  2 *  4$       *  4$2  

  

      ,  "&&* #(" $"#! &'%$ ") $"

$ $"  %)#% ,% %8'#% %(#!$% $#& 7&% $" % !&!

! -$#& # * % (% *" 0? " % !&! (#+ # * % (% *" 0? &7$" 6&+ , !"

! & **)#, $#& #$"7 ,$!&7$"*%!$, != .0       $        $    

 "  

 +          - & "    " &  4 9   (  (  %,   $       $       (       " &

 (

--   -- "   ( 

 

$  (  (       -  & ((   (-  (  (  # -     ( &"

--  <'!'7  &$"%!

    # - " (    (   .7 :  # -  "        ( (     "'!"#  -  &$"%!

 : (  (  

 "   -  & ((   (-  (  (          ( "'!"#  -  &$"%!

$        ( "  

 

 "  $ "    

  )7 (  # -  

 "   

  

  ( &              # <  (-&    (-&   -  

+     " &  ( ( (         ((    "  "     (      " (  +           (    ( - ( (-&   -  

  -   "   -   

+ <H   - 3 -        "   4 9   (  (  ((    : " 

"    (

"&&* #("

 "    " (   - "     " (   (      (  

# -   

   "4 &  #+#) '#$ &903 &7 0??0 7&))&5#( 5 ! *)  # * % (% *"!. 9@ G. "

$ $" * %$#!

% ,)&!)4 %) $ $&  ," &$"% $" *) #$#77!

% *"5! &7 $" 7$  ,&!$#$'$

&#$ #' F -#)4 " 7$ -$  (& A+# #! $"  '("$% &7 " "#6

) $" (%  7 $"% &7 $" *) #$#77! $ 

    * 

   >

   

  

 

 

    

       " 7 $#!+%4"

**45#$"$"!%+#,!&7$"*) #$#77 %% $& "%  &'$ &7 )&+  77,$#& $" 7$ "

 ))&$$ $" 6&+ -$#& )  $& $" *) #$#77!

# 8'

) !"

% # -#)4 !$$)-$ C %% (-$ 5"#," $&& *) , 6&'$ . 4 %! 6 ,  !#, $" $" *) #$#77!

% &5%! # *&!!!!#& &7 $" !

# )   $"7$"

%)#8'#!" ))%#("$!$"%#= 888888  

   

 

%)#% #+#) '#$ &903 &7 0??0       

    %4&%%2

 -      

 

     >

 B 2 @-  F'%$"% $" !'#$ 5 ! ,% & $" 5%#$$ !$ $-$ 7#) 64 -$  (& ,,*$#( $" ,) #- &7 *) #$#77! $"

$ $"% 5 ! 7 -#)4 !$$)-$ 6$5 $" * %$#!

# 5"#," $" "

)7 !"

% # $" )  5 ! (#+ $& $" *) #$#77!

&7 #+#) '#$ &903 &7 0??0 " 8'!$#& #! ! $& 5"$"%

+4 $" ,% * !! & 0?/B0??0 %8'#% %(#!$% $#& '%,$#&03&7$"# (#!$% $#&,$0?/B 888888 , 

 

   @  ! J 



      

-  2   

  *        

  

  

    :

* 

   

 

   



 

 



     

  

          888888

.5 :$   # -  "   (    (    2/   # -  (     ;  (  3  :'%- #) #("

 &$"%!

     ( (       -  & ((   (  -     

 $

 

   +"   (-&   -  "         $    & (-&   -    

   "     8 

).)))57) "  (  &   (-&   -   +    :$   # -   

  (  " (    ( %, 2) 6-  (  # - $        ( "&&* #("

          (  

 -  (      $   &   $       (  4

 %, "  (4

  &    "         "    " & (-&   -     %,  &  4 9  $ &  (  # -  

+-

).)))57)$  "  "         (  (

 %,   $   3  & -  

     # -  

).)))57)  

  :     ( "$ "    (-   )> (     # -    "   (  (     %) ((        $        $   (  - # -     

    (   &     $     "

  &$    &   (  (     - # -  

 (     3"  3 2,  (    %,    $             +  "- "    %)   $      (  -   $    (

&         -  2. !    "    (  

 - $ (  -     $ - 

 & -  22       $ ( &$  

 ( 

 "(   # -    9: ;   50<+=..  D* A   +8 

I 8% A     I 8%