← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5842/2022allowed

Rajpal v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-12-07Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal6 pages



      

    !"#!$%&%'()

* +   ! % %'!    ,     !"-''# .!&  !&/'#!' &  0(  120   32

!&!' ( 0 '4!'%#5$ !46% . 0-'#!!/ '4#5$ !4" .!/! % %'! 0/'378#544-'  9999999  324:

2;

.7<. .!/!&!' /! % %' .!/! % %'!&!!=&>7&.%'<"#! # !# )) .7<.6.%$.7'#! 7+!):?;" .!-'%5%+ !5%$!&:

!'&%'; 7+!&4)@:"&. 4 .! 7+!&;!<7+#!/ 8!' + %'>7%-.&?!!'#!!# ?!.!+#<%'& .%8' .!<7'# . ?! 6!!' .! -!&)A

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

 DE .!?&%&6.!!" .!7/!%' !'#!' " +%$!488'#:;!6+43'+ /&&!#'#!# !# )) .7<.6.%$. .!/! % %'!6&%'"8!# . !<7+#!/ 8!' +%'>7%-.#?!!'#!!#<%'& .%8+'<6% . &7$.#!$.<!&.!! 6&+&&!5!#7/' .!/! % %'!&/!6.%$. .! ++!<!#8%&$'#7$ ?-.%86& . ?! 6!!' .!-!&)A

46.%+!.!6& /& !# 3'+4.!.#7'#!<'!.%&22$7&!"8!.70!8%+26 ++!<!4'78'<.4 *& .''#0!.%&%-''#&6 % '%5!&% -4 *8!4 *& .''#&%'$!.!$7+#' .5!?!!'/!&!'  ? . .!/+$!& .!  &8!  %8!  .!  .#  "7#<!#  .!  !$#    !% .!  /+$!   .!  /! % %'! !/!&!' !#  .!%'>7%-""%$!%'"8%'<.%8?7  .!+!<+?7'#! 7+!

):?;!#6% . 7+!):

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

6.%$.6&6!++?!-'#"7-!& "8  .!  # !  "  .!  /! % %'!1&  ! %!8!' 4  .!  %8/7<'!#  #!/ 8!' + /$!!#%'<&6!!?!#7'#! 7+!):?;!#6% . 7+!):

;:;" .!

7+!& '&7// " .!"!$' !' %'!+%'$!6&/+$!#' .! "++6%'<*7#<8!' &(

 DBE )   





     

  

:) ;)B@@@F 

   

 

 :

; @ F B 

 !"

#  





:B; ) F'#

      $

  %

  :);



!$' 4+!'!#  !$7'&!+&7?8% & . " ! .!/! % %'! .#&7/!''7 !#.!6&<%5!''!-!1&!C !'&%'%'&!5%$!'##7%'< .%& /!%#$8/+%' 6&!$!%5!#<%'&  .!/! % %'! . ?! 6!!' .!-!& )A

46.%+!.!6&/& !# 3'+4.!.#+&7'#!<'! .!22$7&! "8 *& .''#&%'$!.!$7+#' ?!/!&!'   6/+$!&  .!&8! %8! .!.#//!' +-6'<+-&.6'.%8&!+"/!&!'  !% .!/+$! ' .!?&%& " .!&%#$8/+%' #%&$!! %'>7%-6&.!+#6.%$.6!' <%'&  .! /! % %'! $$#%'<+-4!<7+#!/ 8!' +%'>7%-6&%<. +-#!!# <%'&  .!/! % %'! 2!'!#$7'&!+" .!/ %!&.5!?!!'.!#'#6% . .!%?+! &&%& '$! .!!$#.&?!!'/!7&!#

7+!&):?;'#):

;:;" .! 7+!&46.%$.!!+!5' 4!

!/#7$!#&7'#!( G) %<. "//%' %'<7 .% - 6% ..+#6% .#6/!'&%' :);

CCC CCC CCC :;

CCC CCC CCC :?;

CCC CCC CCC :;:;

CCC CCC CCC :;:?; .!#!/ 8!' +/$!!#%'<&4%"' %'& % 7 !#6.%+! .!5!'8!' !8/+-!!6&%'&!5%$!46.! .!?!"!.%&! %!8!' 4#7%'<.%&! !8/+-8!' 4 :%;&.++' ?!%'& % 7 !#&5!6% . .!&'$ %'" .!5!'8!' 4 :%%;&.++' ?!%'!&/!$ "'-!5!' 6.%$. =/+$!8! .'"7-!& ?!"!&7$.%'& % 7 %'4'# :%%%;&.++?!$'#7$ !#?-&7$.7 .% -'# &7$./+$!& .!5!'8!' 8-#%!$ '#%'$$#'$!6% . .!/$!#7!//+%$?+! #!/ 8!' + /$!!#%'<&%'6.%$.'#!"#%&8%&&+"8&!5%$!$7+#?!8#!%' !+ %'  .!5!'8!' !8/+-!!#7%'<.%&&!5%$! :B;

CCC CCC CCC :

;

CCC CCC CCC

 D E :

;" .!/7/&!" .%&7+! :;

#!/ 8!' +/$!!#%'<&&.++?!#!!8!# ?!%'& % 7 !#' .!# ! '6.%$. .!&  !8!' "$.<!&%&%&&7!#  .!5!'8!' !8/+-!! /!'&%'!4%" .!5!'8!' !8/+-!!.&?!!'/+$!#7'#!&7&/!'&%' "8'!+%!# !4'&7$.# !H .8'%7&!#%'<" 7+!&):?;'#):

;:;+!#& '+- '!%!&%& %?+!$'$+7&%' . " !'!8/+-!!.&! %!#"8&!5%$! .!! %&$8/+! !!8?<' .!%'% % %'"#!/ 8!' +/$!!#%'<&<%'& .%8 %'!&/!$ "!5!' :&;6.%$.8-.5! =!'/+$!8! .'"7-!&/%  .!%'% % %'" .!#!/ 8!' +/$!!#%'<&'# .  .!# !"%'% % %'" &7$.#!/ 8!' +/$!!#%'<&%&#!!8!# ?! .!# !6.!'$.<!&.!! %& %&&7!#  .!$'$!'!#<5!'8!' !8/+-!!I/!'&%'!I<5!'8!' !8/+-!! /+$!#7'#!&7&/!'&%'.!//!' ?*!$ ?!.%'# .!&! 7+!&&!!8& ?!

. ! %!#!8/+-!!4" ! .!&  7 -/!%#""7-!&4&.7+#?!+!"   +%5!%'/!$!%' .! 6%+%<. J'!".%&+%"!.!++!<!#8%&$'#7$ '.%&/ &.7+#?!++6!# &! +!6% . .!!""+7C" %8!.! %'+!+&//!& ?!?&!#' .!/.&!1+! ?-<'!&?!?-<'!&1"! %!!&'#?!$7&! 8!8-"#!&6% .<!&+&" .!!&' . % %&' !&-"! %!!  .5!$$!&&  .!!+!5' !$#.%&$++!<7!&46.8-.5!+&! %!# '#&! +!#!+&!6.!!48=%'<% #%""%$7+ ".%8 !""!$ %5!+-#!"!'#.%8&!+" '  





    &$&!:&7/; .!

!&/'#!' ?!"! .!7/!8!7 ! %!#"8&!5%$!'B  '# 6&%&&7!#$.<!&.!! ')  .7<.6.%$..!6&&7<.  ?!

#!/ 8!' ++-/$!!#!#<%'& "!5!' &6.%$..#++!<!#+- =!'/+$! ?! 6!!')   B)%'$! .!&!!5!' &6!!?!-'#"7-!& "8 .!# !"%&&7'$!" .!$.<!&.!!   .!!&/'#!'  .!!%'4.! &&%+!# .!&8! .7<./! % %'"%+!#?!"! .%&7 ?-!+-%'<' .! &!$'#/5%&  7+!:?;" .! 7'*?%5%+!5%$!& 7+!&:,+;:" &. 4 .! 7'*? 7+!&; .!&!$'#/5%&  7+!:?;" .! 7'*?

 D E

7+!&%&&%8%+  7+!):?;" .! 7+!&'#%&!/#7$!#?!+6" !"!!'$!( K7$.#!/ 8!' +/$!!#%'<&4%"' %'& % 7 !#6.%+! .!""%$!6&%' &!5%$!6.! .!?!"!.%&! %!8!' #7%'<.%&!!8/+-8!'  :%;&.++' ?!%'& % 7 !#&5!6% . .!&'$ %'" .!5!'8!' F :%%;    

%     

' 

 

 %  

     (            

)%   :%%%;&.++?!$'#7$ !#?-&7$.7 .% -'#%'&7$./+$!& .!5!'8!' 8-#%!$ '#%'$$#'$!6% . .!/$!#7!//+%$?+! #!/ 8!' + /$!!#%'<&%'6.%$.'#!"#%&8%&&+"8&!5%$!$7+#?!8#!%' !+ %'  .!""%$!#7%'<.%&&!5%$!H &%'<+!*7#<!" .%&7 " !!+-%'<' .!"!>7 !# /5%&>7&.!# .!$.<!&.!! &!5!#7/' .!!&/'#!'  .!!%''%'  7 //!+&7$.#!" .!%'<+!7#<!6&7/.!+#?-%5%&%'!'$. $$&%'%'< .!$.++!'<!?- .!!&/'#!' 1&!8/+-!?!"! .!7/!8! 7 6.%$.$.++!'<!6&!*!$ !#& .!7/!8!7 6&" .!/%'%' .  .!%<.7 .#%<. +-//+%!# .!"!>7 !#/5%& >7&. .! $.<!&.!!   .!&8!!""!$ %& .!*7#<8!' "%5%&%'!'$." .%& 7 %'  &$&!:&7/;6.!!%'% 6&.!+#&"++6&( G@?!/!7&+" .!"!8!' %'!# 7+!8=!&% $+! .  7+!:?;

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

8!' 8%<. .5!  &! +!#  " "+7'</+$!& '#8!8- 8- ' &!5! &7$. 6% '!&&!&  '#  .!  ! %!!  .!  16#  "  8$+!&1  %'  .!  &./!  " #!/ 8!' +%'>7%-$'' ?!=!/ .'<%'<' .!.!#" .!! %!!"++ %8!& $8!'#.!&.7+#?!++6!# +%5!%'/!$!" ! .!&  7 - /!%#""7-!&".%&! %!8!' .&$8! '!'#0!5!4 .! +!'!#    !  $7'&!+  .&  '  ?!!'  &7$$!&&"7++-  ?+!    $' 5!  .! <78!' '#*7#<8!' &:&7/;!+%!#7/'?- .!+!'!#$7'&!+" .! /! % %'!H %8%++-4' .!%5%&%'!'$." .

 &$&!:&7/;46.%+!$'&%#!%'<&%8%+%&&7!4.!+#&"++6&(

 D@E  %' !# !' %'" .%&7 .&?!!'#6' $+7&!:;" .!"!&%# 7+!  :?;    $!"7+  /!7&+  "  .!  &8!  67+#  &.6  .  %'  $&!  #!/ 8!' + /$!!#%'< %&   ?! %'% % !# <%'& '  !8/+-!! " ! .%& ! %!8!' 4% $'' ?!%'!&/!$ "'!5!' 6.%$. =/+$!8! .'"7 -!&"8 .!# !6.!' .!/$!!#%'<%&%'% % !# %&$+! .  .!$.<! &.!! 6&%&&7!#  .!/! % %'!%' .!%'& ' $&!' )))AA 46.!!& .!%'$%#!' %'>7!& %'%'!&/!$  6.%$..!.&?!!'/$!!#!#<%'& !+ !&  .!-!)A

%!'!#!$#!/%  .!%&&7'$!" .!$.<! &.!!  %&?5%7& . %&&7'$!" .!"!&%#$.<!&.!! %&6.++- 7'$$!/ ?+!%'+64& .!&8!%&$+!+-?!#?- .!/5%&%'"$+7&! :;"7+!:?;!C $ !#?5!H ' .!$&!%'.'# .!"$ &!' %'#%&/7 ! .  .!/! % %'! ! %!#'B@)A'#6&%&&7!#$.<!&.!! ' )) .7<.

6.%$..!6&&7<.  ?!#!/ 8!' ++-/$!!#!#<%'& "'++!<!# 8%&$'#7$ ?-.%8?! 6!!' .!-!&)A

.!++!<!#8%&$'#7$ ?- .!

/! % %'!%&/% "7-!&"8 .!# !"%&&7'$!" .!$.<!&.!!  %'$!?- .  %8!.!.#! %!#4&7$.$ %'' .!/ " .!  !%&?!# 7'#!  7+!  ):?;  !#  6% .  7+!  ):

;:;  "  .!  7+!&  '#  .!!"!

7'&7& %'?+! !&7+ ' +-4 .!%8/7<'!##!/ 8!' +/$!!#%'<&<%'&  .! /! % %'!!>7&.!# .!/! % %'%&++6!#%' .!?5! !8& ) D 32E &.8&.!     .! .!&/!=%'<I!&'!# ( !&I .! .!!/ ?+!

(!&I