High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1079/1991disposed of

Sarbjit Singh v. Notified Area Committe Etc.

2015-08-12Mr. Justice S.S. Saron11 pages

#$%&#'( ))** +$, -$.. )-

$ /$#(0-10$())** /$#2#'*0-10$$)-

-$..0/((3$4($ ))** +$, 2.*&#'(4($ )-

$ /$#2#'*0-10$())** /$#(0-10$($)- ($-$(**-)$.-($$',*$- ))* # 56 $)#()7"8 #!95

$)#()"6- # 55 66 $)#() 750,-#.$* -0/((3$#**())*$, (.*$0(.$:,)$($''($31$0$ *;$$0($%':$. # 56

( )*<$)- *- , $ ) ( #() =, - * $ .) $ , - ,) ( ())*-'($. (;0/((3$3(3$) ( *- .,$' 2* > /$* .)$' 2(3 69 0 2(, >>90 5??

?>0$$--(.%-$( ;$ 657<55 ( - *- 3 *- , .$$ /* @ -- 3 " 9 $ )$- ;$ 1- *, 5-- ! 9 - 3,($A-$,() (-.-)$.0%,(B)$;(*)$-0(3$=,$- -*1$ ( 1 ) ( *- ( $. (; $ $.1'(,)$<$,,$0; ,$,,(*0-- $,- () - * , ( . -$ , *$0 ! 9 65!0$--*1$%:()

()($. (;0/((3$1%$(B)$;(* )$- ( - ( ( *$ 3,*- ); (. ( $=, .)-**3(.$3()$$$)$- ;$ -$' ( $=,0 *, "0 7 4 5 3$ )- $*1' ( -- (** $ () - ( '-3 .* .(*; $ "?< ( -),- () *'3( ($ () 3$1-%;-- -1)3$$-( *$)*- 03(3,);'(()0 $- ( $. (; $ ( ) 3 ,$$-$- %; -- - * $- );' $ ( $.

(;($ ?<)$.( #,%=,*;0 9

65!0 - $ .. 3 ,- $ -*1' ( $. (;0 (,0 ( )* %.

3$(,)$)$;()*0($$0*-()$,$ ) - * $ -.' $ , - ,) ( () =,(,3,-$($()$-',-$(

,%* $.C-D14 1$;E0 65>-%;( )*0 -- -- ( $*() *-<3$ - -0(,0()**.-(-- $-(;$'( - %. $<)$ - ( ( )* %. *- $ ) - 3$ . $- ,.%$ )*-'*,-'(((**'-*3$-($,'( $'$----(($$..1%*)$)$;%-*; ($,'($'$-$,.

($,(()-),%; -- 3 -- 3 $- ( ( *- ( () =,1-( ,&%F:$-%')$('$1<;$-- 3 *;' 1 3 $- ( ( () 3 $,- %; %, >;$%:-((,,*;) 3$ *.- 3$() ( % -1$ ) - * -- ( ( () -), )$ 2** 5??

?>- *--(((3($ -- $($. (; - ()$3$.1$$-(( )*(-)-;.)$(,)$<$,,$(() -),-(,0.)*(,--(((-- 1$)($($. (;$()*-- ($'(()*-.-($$.--

$. ( )*-' ( )$0 ( $* ,$ $.- ( **3', E F(($(*--$%-)$ ()*3*-, -- %;($. (;G

E F(($ $ :' ( *- * ( () -), 3 $,-,)(.%;-- G

D>E F(($ ( () -), 3 *- , -- %; G

D9E F(($ -- $- -*1$%:() (()-),($. (;-($3-,*; )-G03(G

D"E F(($ -- $- ( ; ( $.

(;G

D7E F(($()*..(*,-*()$ ,G

D5E F(($ ( () -), 3 $,- %; -- (.* %, > ;$ %: - ( ) (G

D!E F(($-- (%.3$(()-), %;-1$)G D6E F(($(,.%***'-)$ ( )$*.$; %& ( 3$ . -- G

E F(($(,3(*.G

E F(($(,%$$-%;()$)*$&,-G

E F(($()*$))-$.*'()$,%; ($3--,G >E F(($ ( ,)$)$; ( % $$*; -$%-%; ( )*03(G 9E F(($(,)$)$*;1*,-$(),$),$- &,$-G

"E F(($ -- ))- $. -;' ( * ( )*%;(--,G

7E F(($ ; $ -, $. -- G 0 (3 .,(G

5E F(($(()-),,-2** 5??

?>G0 3(G

* )$1 0 )$ $. B.' F< 1-$ ( C,($0 B<#$)(0 $. (;0 /((3$8 F< #($ +2$0 B,1 $00/((3$8 F<>*)#'(02,'- F< 9 $:((0()*-$-1-.;9"-,.0 3(( *,- *, 5 4 !" -- ! 9 DB

E 4 5 7 6!> DB

E $)1*;8 ) $ ( $ $'$ .-%;($. (;0/((3$DB

5E8))* -- ! 9 65! DB

!E8 ); $ $'$ DB > E8 ) $ $)DB >>4 >9E8).$'$(-, (; DB >" 4 >7E0 ); .%- $ ( ;$ 6!

DB >5E - )($$'$.-%;($. (;0/((3$ DB 9"4 97E (($(-0-- ))$-(33 F< - * B.- F< $% C*0 3($ -- B.- (.* F<> )$ $. B.' F<9 $($ #'(0 F<"#,$&#'(-F<7/(-$#'(0$$-2,'- * )$-,- $$- ); ( $-$ -- >

6!" DB E )-%;( $**$0#.$*-();(&,-'.--

6!9DB E)-%;())**,($;0C,-('( $-$DB E)$$.-$'($-,.

$-$'($*3**-,.$;1-0( *$-$*,$(*-((*-=,3*-,%;($.

(;-- $,(-'0($*,$$*-,) ))*-- ! 9 65!DB

!E3$%;-- $=,' ($. (;:)(()$,-%;(. $), 0($*,$'$,$--'((() 3 $,- %; -- ( ,$ $$$- ( $ $) DB >>4 >9E,-%;($. (;1,$#$%&#'( $*'(;$ 65!03(($3-),%3()$ $),>0($*,$$,$--'((-),-() 3*-,%;-- -- $,$,(-'0 ($*,$$$$-(&,-'.DB 9 E,*-%;-- '()*-$-$-->

6!>DB E$-$-%;(

$**$0#.$*))**-%;-- ' $(1,-$( ,&% $% $ 0 696$),90'-'$$--((*- =, 1$ 3(( () $ $,- 3- %; ( )* $$$'B >53**(&,-'.DB >6E)-,*-%; '()*$)$.0(*$-$* ,$$$--(**3'-'

H,"

9 ( -' , > $ * (*),* --' ( ,(*$-;%(*-(-- (-$-( ; 1,$ ( $. (; ( - $ ..0/((3$03,-$,)$-'($.

(; ( )*0 (,0 ))- ( <) ( $. (;($-),(($)$)$;( $. (; 3 .,- 1,$ ( - $

..($'(;.$-,% ( $* .; F< 0 F<9 - F< *$ - ' (;%-$--;,3(1$$3** ( ( -,.$; 1- $*; )$1 $.,"*---1,$()*I =,*;0 3(* --' ($ , 1,$ ( )*0($*,$-$-(,))*'(-&,-'. - -$ $.- ,,,* #** ''$1-0 -- -))* -.-*;0 ( -- ( $.- ; ,%* =,*331$0$',-(($-*,*-%;( )*<$)-'($,)(**'-()$,- %;-- --.-1-&,-'.-- !

6!!$-$- %; ( ,$ # 9!

6!! *- J- $ ..0 /((3$0 C,-( 4 ($ + *-1 #'( 4 ($K ( - $-$ %' )$ ( $$- ( ,$ -.- 1- - .$:-/$:@(.$-,-$ H(-$..0()*<))***- ,$)(()0-),$-'(*$- ,*$())**0B,3$-$-%;($*,$0 3($($,'1'$ ',*$#-))* 9!

9!> - 9!9 6!!0 3$ -.- ))* ' ( - -$ $ )-' ( ,$ ( $ ,-'0 C,-( (,0$',-(*$-,*0())*$*%*%-$- %,($*,$('1-$-'-$, (($(-0(*$-,*$--<$)- ()-,((($,(1%-.-%, ( % ,$$*; ,- %; %( ( ,$ %*30 3(* -,', 5(-- (%)$1-% ,-$-- $()*;.($$0 ()*$*-$1$;.,$.--

(,0$',-(*$-,*013(,$$ -' ( ,$ %*30 ( ($ , (1 % $'(*; -.-%;(,$%*3

$($'(*$-,*$()$0-$ ( $- %(* ( $)- 1 ( ))**,$0(%(*-(()*<))***- )$1((()0-),03$,-%;-- (*-.)$-2** ->0$'* 5-3 *- , %; (. $)- 13 ( ,$$ -'((($,0--;$.;$ **'*; ( ))* % $$- 3( - ))* =,*;0())**--.-I ($',.*$-,*$())**( ( )*<$)- ( *- , , 3(( ($ , 3$ -.- - ( -.* ,( , - *; 3( # 9!

6!!0 # 9!> 6!!- 9!9 6!!3$-.-0 ($$0(-'$$--())*%;(,$$)$- $ &,- - ( )$ ))* (,*- % **3- ( % ( $-&,-'.(,$-(-,$-*0( )$, ( ($ (-0 /$ #'*0 *$- ,* ))$' %(* ( )*<$)-0 ,%. ( )* $ &,- .1-0 ( $ - ( )* $ &,- ( ( )$%((,$.()$0-- 3 )$;;(($))*-.-1-$-$-- !

6!! 1'($-*$-,*$()$0--; .$()$-))*)$,*($-$('(,$ (3((,3-.-$($(()*(*- *-;1-(3$()1$2** ->0 '* 5

-*-- 0(<**--,-%;.$$ /* ( , % --- (% 1-*- %; ( )$/;%()***(.-$--* )*-'0%,(1-*-.$**;-$()$0( )* ( *- 1- 3$() 1$ ( *- 3(* )$-,' &.%- $ ( ;$ 6!

DB >5E - ( *, 5 -- ! 9 DB

E ( )* ( * )$1- * () %; -- -*$=,$,$$-$) %; -- 1- ))* -- ! 9 65! DB

!E ( &,-'. DB E )- %; ( $**$ $$-0 3($%; &. ) *- %; -- ' -- - -.- ('$,-(($ B $*()*-<3$ - 0-- -$..($* (&,-'.(.;%%-'0%,($.( ,( &,-'. (3 ( $ ) *- %; -- ' --.- 2)' 13 ( ($ 1$3(*.' 1- *- %; ( )$*,-'(-- $'$-',$$-$) 1,$($. (;-*)$);.$1-$ $) DB >

5E - ( $ $'$0 - ( ( )*< $)-()$1-(--<))**03($- 1,$()* -'$,$-((--<))** ($-1,$()*0())--;(*( *-<*$-$.#

7(1-

13 ( - 0 - - ( ; ,%* =, *3 $ $ -$ # 56 ( -'$$--$-),-%;:'$<))$1- 1 $ B.' ( 1-0 - - ; $$$ ( -' $$--=,*;0(.-.-

#!95 - # 55 66 $-$- '(&,-'.--$)-%;($))**,$)' ())**-%;--<$)-($))**,$-- -;1,$3(()*-1$)0-- ( B.-;.$*%,$$03(.'((13$:$$, (()($$0$))**,$,-(-- ( 03($,-(()3*,-((%; *--0$$;($-,.$;1-0-- )$1-%-,-%;-- (**3',%*=,*3$$-$ ( 3 ))*0 ' ( .

--0 %, $) 3 -$() E F(($ ( )* 3$ ( , *- ( % -,.$;1-*-%;-)-%;($*,$G E F(($ ( )$-$ ( )* *- , ( *- 03(,$*-()$$,'(. -- G D>E F(($ -- $*=,(- * - -- $-*1,$()*G ( )$ ))*0 ( )*<))** B.

-$(*-$0#.$*- F<9*)#'(02,'()*< ))** -$- .*$ -,.$; 1- ( % -$-

# 56 *,5-- ! 9 B

# !95 0 3($ B " # 55 66 - ) $*,"0745-- 9 5 65!B 9%(())* ( *$- $* ,$ -$' *. .*$ 1- -$-(,'#$%&#'(<-- >

6!70,%& .$ # 56 03($&,-'.--$()$ ,3$)- !

6!7-

6!7#()*-'-( 1-.*$0()*<))**(*-%3$(,*- ($))**,$03((-(&,-'.--$)- %;($*,$3(**;$$,'$,-#()*<))** )$1- % 3$0 ( -' $$--%; ( *$-$ ))** ,$$%**31(-,%*=,*30 )$1-(()*<))***-(*--- 03( ,$$*-(()-- - ($*=,(- *1,$)*--- (*$-1,$ )* =,*;03(*3$'(,%*=,*3 1,$()*0%(())*$**3-(&,-'.- -$)-%;($))**,$$--(($* ,$$$$-

" D/

E +.*