Union Of India v. Pseb Etc.

  
  


 

!"# $#%&'&() *+

,
 



   

 

       

    
) -./
/.

-./
// 0#'#(") (# 0"1#2#"&"&(#0 '/3$##2"&/1!04!5#23"6$7%!"##(#0!853(9!:  !9#'1&($!8 ;;0&#7#$ !;!&('" "1# !%"&(  "1# #0'"<1&8# 3(9!: /"!"# 8#%"0&%&"6!0$

0'10"5-"1#!0$- $#4!($&(;%"0&(#8#%"0&%&"6 %('34#$:6"1#2#"&"&(#05(!4#865(&( ($&!5"1#'!4#1!':##( %1!88#(;#$:6 &8&(;"1#20#'#("2#"&"&( 1#%!'#<!''1<(32&("1#"!=#(328&'"(34:#0 "&4#' (#!22#!0#$ 0"1#2#"&"&(#00#7#("1#!0$5<1'#!%"&(&'3($#0 %1!88#(;#1#2!2#0:=<!'2#03'#$!($"1#%!'#&':#&(;$#%&$#$5!' (868#;!8&''3#&'&(787#$ 1#  2#"&"&(#0  0!&'&(;  "1#  &''3#  '#("  !  %443(&%!"&(  ( >  >>?""1#
1!&04!( "1#!0$5<1&%1<!' 88<#$:6!("1#0 8#""#0$!"#$ @+ >>?(0#'2('#"1#0#"5"1#!0$0#'2($#$:6'"!"&(; "1!"%"0&&':#&(;%88#%"#$(:#1!8  "1#3(&%&2!8
44&""##!($&(

 %!'#"1#2#"&"&(#01!'!(6;0&#7!(%#5"1#4!""#04!6:#"!=#(32<&"1"1# 3(&%&2!8
44&""##1#0#!

"#05"1#4!""#0<!'"!=#(32:6"1#2#"&"&(#0 <&"1  3(&%&2!8 
020!"&(5  !8!($1!0  '"!"&(;  "1!" &(  7&#<    "1#  :!0 %("!&(#$&(0"&%8#?+ "1#
('"&"3"&( ($&!5("!A%!(:#8#7&#$( "1#7#0(4#(" ($&!:6!(6/"!"#0&"'!3"10&"60#B3#'"<!'4!$# "&''3#!%#0"& &%!"#"1!"!8!($1!0
!(""!0#!$#'(" !88<&"1&("1# 930&'$&%"&( 3(&%&2!8
020!"&(1#'!4#<!'0#28&#$":6"1# 3(&%&2!8
020!"&(7&$#%443(&%!"&($!"#$,? >>> ((#A30#C @ &( 04&(;"1#2#"&"&(#0"1!"!0#! !8!($1!0
!(""
!("(4#("!0$ &'3"'&$#"1#8&4&" 3(&%&2!8
020!"&(44#$&!"#86"1#0#!

"#057&$# 8#""#0  $!"#$  +> >>>5  "1#  2#"&"&(#0  0#B3#'"#$  "1#  A#%3"&7#  (;&(##0

2#0!"&(    "1#  !0$  "  '"2  %1!0;&(;  %"0&  (  "1#  "!0&

 :&88' /3:'#B3#("865  0#4&($#0'  <#0#  !8'  '#("  D&$#  %443(&%!"&(  $!"#$  ,

5"1#2#"&"&(#0<!'&( 04#$:6"1#''&'"!("A#%3"&7#(;&(##0  "1#!0$"1!""1#0#&'(0#8!A!"&("!(6"62# %('34#0'51<#7#05 "1#4!""#01!':##(0# #00#$"1&;1#0!3"10&"&#' 0%8!0& &%!"&(1# 2#"&"&(#01!'!8'28!%#$(0#%0$%443(&%!"&($!"#$ ,

 04 !00&'((;&(##0 !'"  "1#!0$'"!"&(;"1!"&(#0E#230!0#!5"1# !0$<!'("%1!0;&(;%"0&("1#:&88' #286""1#2#"&"&(1!'(":##( &8#$:6"1#!0$51<#7#05 0#'2($#("@C3(&%&2!8
020!"&(5!8!($1!01!' &8#$"1#0#286"&'

'2#%& &%!886'"!"#$"1#0#&("1!""1#3(&%&2!8
020!"&(&'("%1!0;&(; !(6%"0& 04"1#2#"&"&(#0 0!(6;$':03;1"&(8%!8!0#!30"1#05&" <!''"!"#$"1!""1#0#&'("1&(;(0#%0$"'3;;#'""1!"%"0&&':#&(; "!=#(:6"1#3(&%&2!8
020!"&( 04"1#!0$ 0'!8# #8#%"0&%&"6" "1#  7#0(4#("    ($&!  <&"1&(  &"'  8%!8  !0#!  !($  30"1#0  "1!"  "1#

*
!("(4#("!0$!0#!&'3"'&$#"1#43(&%&2!88&4&"' "1#3(&%&2!8
020!"&(  #!(&(;  "1#0#:65  "1#  %!'#  '#"  32  :6  "1#  2#"&"&(#0  <!' %(%#$#$:6"1#3(&%&2!8
020!"&('"!"&(;"1!"(%"0& &':#&(; %1!0;#$ 04"1#2#"&"&(#0!($ 30"1#0"1!"#7#("1#!0#! "1#2#"&"&(#0 $#'(" !88<&"1&("1#43(&%&2!88&4&"'0"&%8#?+ "1#
('"&"3"&(

($&!207&$#'"1!"(/"!"#'1!88&42'#"!A("1#%('342"&(0'!8#

#8#%"0&%&"6"(&( ($&! #'&$#'"1#!

0#'!&$:!0:#&(;"1#0#&("1#
('"&"3"&(

($&!  0#;!0$&(;  8#76    %"0&  (  %('342"&(    #8#%"0&%&"6  :6  "1# 7#0(4#(" ($&!5(%#"1#$# &(&"#%!'# "1#3(&%&2!8
020!"&(&'

"1!"#7#("1#!0#! "1#2#"&"&(#05<1#0#"1##8#%"0&%&"6&':#&(;%('34#$5 $#'(" !88<&"1&("1#43(&%&2!88&4&"'51#(%#5 "1#0#%38$(":#!(6 $#4!($ %"0& 04"1#2#"&"&(#0#(%#5"1#!%"&( "1#0#'2($#("'&( 0!&'&(;$#4!($ %"0& 04"1#2#"&"&(#0(!%%3(" %('342"&(

#8#%"0&%&"6&'$#%8!0#$&88#;!8 1#<0&"2#"&"&('"!($'$&'2'#$ !%%0$&(;86

!9#'1&($!8 3$;#  !0&($#0/&(;1/&$13 3$;#

*+

, 4=

# #0"#20"#0