High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1163/1991allowed

(O&M) Swaran Singh Etc. v. The Tehsildar & ORS.

2018-02-16Mr. Justice Arun Monga17 pages

!"#$%!& !'

'('''!!")!**!+ ,-.

(/ (01,1 '''2233 4 1135 #(3

651,1 '''

25 $'

'('''!!"7!**!+ ,-.

(/ (01,1 '''2233 4 1135 #(3

651,1 '''

!"#$%& '( $(')#

- ''('(#58# 12233 11223'

- '(91(#58# 25': 11223'

;;;;; (')#*% 1 5 913352/ 03 (5223

0'!!")5!!"7!**! 015 5 5 83 ( '7*: 55 !$'!$'!*&: 35 <(/ (01 , 1 4 135 #(32 651,1 ='1 95/ 5 5 1 3 85>50955 55$:'!'!*&*'/ 8322 0':?55)')'!*&*35<23(014 135 # (32 651 , 1 = 5 :* 55 ?')'!*&* 35 <135 #(32 651,1 4 (/ (01,1 =/ 35'1122318 33/5'1 @0 5#1

95/ 03 (52231123 18 35'

12351390133/0 3 <( 53 1 1 3 / 2 0 5 2 1 5 5 /1359 0&$@3)9 3 0 @1 ':7BB$$9+7A%.#"!BB$+&A%.#!9+7A!&.#*+!%A7.# :7BB$$9 +7A%.# "!BB9 +7A%.# ::BB!" +&A%.# !? +?A?.# :7BB!*9+7A%.#$%+&A%.#$!+&A%.#:7BBB!*9+7A%.#$:BB$:+"A !?.#5"%BB:B$+%A!?.#3&$@3)9 3#5 8330 C932 # 13 (32 651# C2 132 9 5 1 !*&!A&$51 5

3 5 1 (3 99 # C2 13 55 $&')'!*&:85/11138 -1(01 335 8330 -1/3# 13 (32 651# C2 1355$)'!$'!*"7D1351 33553391358 23(01 55 ': 1 5 5 01 1013 3303#

# /

5 /1 > 5# 0 1 83/51 35 50 1 01531238 135/11 D 3 2 9 > 0 1 55 9 0135 30 1 9 5 1 0155 9 012321231 35 9 '= /511232 15135#535 8# 9 9(01 >0 (015 >0 (01 (19(01# 1 55/5#/1/ 55 3 / 213 8 5 97%#%%%BA 858 0 535555"'"'!*?:&#%%%BA1515 23 5 2 0 5 2 1

83 35 '/8

51 2 10135# 1231595 352 2 D 914330

/ 13185 5 3#5011 85 / 3/ #1 952 2 /2 15'

/8 #5 10

5 55$&')'!*&:5$)'!$'!*"725

11(399 #C2 13#155925 312 2 330198 55':'

19/13305 30183!$'!$'!*&:'/5 11 5 25 11(399 /3303#335 85 5 /1 > 5 0 50 1 01 1 23# /1 D3 3 0 1 55 9 520123'

1 95/5 55'! 7##10 51183 15> 5'1 2 / 53 /1 5 1 > @0 3

2 +23.#!*?"+ 1 <1=.1> 51 /

5 2 ( !" 1 5 5 1 3 95 1 5 ' 9 #/51135/ 033 335 -1 (01 335# 5 4330 C932

555 135 (3#C2 13$)'!$'!*&7 9 :):%BA'3?1 955925

212 1 312 2 33 13 3139@ 19 12 11 35 331E2 !% /118 3 '53#135/ 3 3 95/1 19'

-1 (01 85 1 95 9 5

510 9 33013545 //C19 15859'$%%%55!%')'!*"* 9$%#%%%BA'1 9 /

512 ( # 1 3A9A(39 99 #/185 5 55!?'"'!*?:12 1 (399 # > #A51 9538 -1(013355#1 #/33523(01'

5':23(01352 / 9 515@12 39 >D9 3 #> 5 1 ' 9 #/51/ 5 -1 (01 335 305 > ( 5

3313398 -1(01#135/ 33519"'!!'!*&!52/1558 '/2

23/ 35' 1 3 #1 1235012 # 95133/0 !. F11 183 1> 5G $. F11 12311 95 G ). F11 19 3G

7. F11 231G :. F11 1 5 A>5 2 G

". F11 123 1 52 1 1 35 835/1G

?. F11 1233553 5> 5 G

1 3 # 01 03355E'

! E'

:511135/385 9(012 1 E1 9535551 123#91 3 3D 15 95/011>9 5

"5@1 0 5/ E'

?#/11/ 35191 85 #5 51'/223#5 8#/ 35/11 18 33/5 16/ 2233 '1 @0 5# 12 03 (522318 35'

- ''('(# 3 5 3 22 0 13 1 2233A23 95193 8 /555 1 5 11

./--

/- /0'1&

(

31.4..52 2 1.2

. 31 112.#.

31.*555!7':'$%!7#/1 13135 5/3355123

52 1 /2135'1(2368 0'

$"?!7$%!:1 595' 951183 15 > 5 11 1 32 9# 330 13555':!*&!#5508 22 1 0 122338/1 555335 1 331 1 33 6

.4..42

.* /8#+++'1> 5183 #2 12 8 (*183

5 5#1 135 9 3'

9 #1 9511 / 1 8 920 -1(0131353313

3139 331E2 !% /118 3 'E'!#13 5*'7'!*":/992 59'55 5'1 # 1 90#12335 5 1@/3501

23512/ -1(01' / 1 951135151059

15# # 033 135/335-1(01#/135 45 /#45 / 9(015 9(0112233 "'"'!*?:'FA:3555 5 1 6/ 2233 5#1# 051 0A51 >50955 16/ 2233 19 9 3303 52 8 '

#- '(91(#3 5322 0

13 25': 9511 3311 732 9 5

31.4..'1:2

772..2

* ; 36 3 < ; 7 3*8 9=

31.* +>> , 2;2 > 2 339 95 5 1 235

+92 5 1 3. # !*:7# /1 93

3/2#1351185@123 52 1 '351>509 5 5 18 1 1 % 2 1 4.. '1 ?6 36 1=22332

@ 7@ 337 3

772..2

* 1=22332

?33 %

31.* />8#%,>,* /1 135355 1

> @03

2 3 951 5 2 1 513 !% 51 5 92/2135' 9511 33995!*&!1 133055#1 #1/ 92'123133051 5 33E') 55!?'"'!*?:1 2

083F #/11/ 525 85 5 55 *'!%'!*?* 90 1 9 1 921 '1921 #85 5 55!:':'!*&!# 21351 5 33'12232

5/2585 5 55&'*'!*&$'/8 #1(3999 21351

5 3385 5 55$&'&'!*&?E'?'1501 6/ 2233 5 2 1 22 3 5 59 855533 1 3303 2 8 5#1# 051 5931 223' 1 9511315 22 12 2 5#1 #/35 3213@ @'

181 513 53 12 #22 51 22 @# 51 3/51>5095 /1 1 3518/11 59 1 913 53 12233A23'

6 53 12233#/1 5/11 5 55!7':'$%!7 5 51 03 (5223'!&::5 !&:"!*&? 103 11 52135 1H 3 (2 9 #555219' 901 8 15#1 2 85

51 8 5

01 5#''#>9 5E'

5@1 0 5/ E'

?#551/11 / 5 92521 0333-1(012 1 019 313519 59555 8'

FA!1(01#C0#(3(32 651#/1 22 5#525185 2'7!"# 9 32/08 55':#/1 23 15 1/ 3303 2'FA$-15 (01# / 3DC932 5251 115

011 8 5#''# I91'&&55$$'!%'!*&!

0 2 '7!" 55 $:'"'!*&" E'& 5 E'*' 33 1 59 8351E212 2 180 95#

1 8 1 5 1 > 8AA8 1 3 5 1 19'1 8 59511 032 1 5/9231 35 1E2 !% 3313 313 9/118 3 ' E'!#13 #1/5112 93 /923 #/11/5*'7'!*":' 3 1 @0 51 8 5#3501>9 5 55 313305 '15/ 3 32 9 !% /118 3 '1

01 /11 1 8 5 5 1 3 /1 0 51 @01315 1 '33 5 /@1 5 913'

(12233/ 0822 1 0 193399555':!*&!#183 8/1 555335 1 3311

57!. ..*/9 3' 1@

8 # 50 5 5 ?15>509 51

#$% &'() &'*+

, ! -

// // // // 0 1 / / "

/ 1 / "

2 2 "

/ "

2 "

) , ! %

3 "

#$% &'(( 4'5

56*7 &(

7 % : #"

&'*

# / 1

9 &+ &5

;

2 / 1

/ 1"

- 2 - #

56*7

/ / 1"

56*7 / / 1 /"

1 /"

< 1 /

56*7

$ "

# / 1

3 "

/ 1

2 1"

3 "

2 1

1 /

56*7

&( #.

6#$% &'() &'*+7 67

$ 1

/ 1

#$% &'('

1 ,

> 67 !

! 6

3 > (

$ # +++?

6#$% &'*@ 9 &@)7 1 "

1 / 3 1 /

, 1

1 2

/ 16/ 2233 #9 8/#195 5 201 3912311223/8 95

123 11 12 2 01 2135'21 8 5/11

2 92 1 D 5 1 223 0 12 23<"6"AB 16/ 2233 15 58 513 E'!55*'7'!*":#

5 1 3 #/111/5112 93/923'1 # 1 /9259 -1(013313530 330533'11 15#9 8/# 51 E'!# 3 521 9551

5#/11925533313 13 !% /118 /3 '

% 2 1!. ..* 2 513395

!*?"#/11/3351831 95 59209259!% 3'185 / 305 5 1 0 8 1 92 > 5+ ).'1# 3352 2#1 09 - '(91(11235518 35 /133 9235' 1@

8 # )150 5 5

51 <5

, B1 C ("

% ="

% &&

# "

+)"

6#/ 9&7

# , "

3 1

B1 %

# "

1#10 518 3335 309 92

0/115016/

2233 112233A23/ 52 1 135'815515 228/ 19FA!3 9 32/08'

1 919 551 '539 #''# ( '!&::!*&?15 555!7':'$%!78 1 5 1 1 13505

93 &@ "

# 93"

< 1

$ "

(

* )

&'4@

% &5+

D 2 "

2 "

D 1 955018 2135 1H 3 (2 9 (6 +.'$"?!7$%!: 13505

$ +) @

+@&( ,"

9 "

5 #1 # 3 15 901 3D3//135501223# 8/1 555335 83 5501H 3(2 9 8 C9C.12 31 1#.

31.4. 1

31.

(+> +*/1 12 2 /11 8/1 8(*?+!. #2 8(7!1 > #!*!&/35223 1223'' (/35 355 (!%% 583

5 #1 5 91 3D 3/ '131H 3(2 9 1351

155A 35

31.4.< 2 2 1

=6#.

31.+>>,

++223 3 (*?+!.

3/##12 8(7!1 >

#!*!&15 5 @' 1@

8 #1 38 2 1>50983 5501H 3(2 9

@>@1H+2 . 51 < *& 91 # /

E "

&@@ "

C ! B

!"#$%&!'#($)*!+,-./ .

F +

+'GA <+

: # +)*

*& 91 # &'&4

9 4@# < $ #"

&'&)"

! $"

< $ #"

&'5)"

+'+

$ "

# 5')"

< $ #"

&'5)"

91 #

$ $ # +6&7 $

# +)* $

# + $

$ "

# +6&7

0 '

6&7

9 6#7 #"

( *& 91 #"

A 1 #55 91 3D 3//135501223# 95'

1 5 8#1 3303 52 8 150 5 5 16/ 2233 >5095 5 5 1330'19 1 A5511 3 5'223533/5'

:=6*+> (')# 7.1 %&?<$ )131.C2 D.

E.D

)131 3= E.D