High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1262/1991dismissed

(O&M) Jangir Singh v. Ujjagar Singh

2019-10-01Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal10 pages

! !

"! #

!"#$%&'() %%*!)(($

!"#

$%&'

) (*+ ($ %&'

# * * &*%*

($%&'

$%%(!", - +++++ %*!)(($,& . *%+*((%*#

% %'** * /

* ( - *0 1"

%,"%*'

* 2

'*(* 3 '$

((0 * # ( - %*'

* ''" *%*0 '%% -3 " + -3 "* #/

*,"'

* **0 % % / * *0 * #* #% "# ( % / "*0 ($ %

*(% * % #( * "

&*(( 00( #, / - %* 3 5 56$ + %'% -3 * ( " &*% ,"%0/ % %' %

% 5 (# %-3""'' "( 4% % %*/*%-3 %%* ()* *'

7"%0$ 0" .

(& %*# ( # (

((0

* *% -3 #%

$ " 7 */ ( /8 "+*%+ !

,, *0 ++ %/ "*066

(5/ ( *1"

( "(% (/ ( (%& *0

*0 &*% 0* % ( %% %

5. #% **:'("*&#* %*' 5 "% " % /8 "7 0**0 ;

((0% */( &#"'

%( / /8 "-"

/ *#* % . 4% % +*

/ **0 #(*/* 3-,'

"* * /

-( #% / *% / %'%* *"%+ *' **#*

"* % /8 "+ " % ( /

"''%% /8 " %/"

*65 %

% 5+ '

*%* *0 %. +*0% % **#* "* "0 * %"

< / , *0 . #%

*(% #(*'

% % *

* #(

. * ( " /% *"$ *'% * # ,"%0/ *%" . #%

/*%

*8"/ =$> '

*0 =6$> *0 =$> /*0 =?

% */( %* +* -: %$ :

/*% ,*0 $ *"

< /)=$ "*0 )= $ !"%&*0 )=6 % *0 )= . * (" + *(%'*%*0*",'

%#(

* * #* "* ( % *

* / 0/ ((-"

* (% -*#* "* %" "

*@%(3 ''%*0(3 *"1"

#* ( %+ % /*%A&*+ *%*0*"

& # *" "

*@%#* %'

- ((+% -%*#%-3 " ' % '

-%*#%(3 ''%*0 %"#' ( +$ "* *,"'

* + %'% **0 % %

/* *0*# ' "(#* #% & "* % %*#*0 */ '*-(3 %+* "

%"#' + - *'% *- $ ,"%0/ % %' # % -3 * ( "

*/% * ( -3 %%* ( )* *'

7"%0$ 0" "

*/% *%*0 * (" +* #* ( %-3 -"

% *#( '3 "( & / (3 0"%

** (

0 #'%*0$

*% '

0*' #(

* * #* "* ( % *' 5 "% " % /8 "B

$ ##(*'

/%/

#( +* % + * #( '3 % * #* "% 0/ (#"# -:'"

%-3 "* 3

5-"

##(*'

/%/ + ,'

%-3 * ("

*% (* 3A * " 0"%

* , / - %*

3 5 56$ * '

C,, *0 '

/ * #* % - * 0/ (( ' 3$ * + - * #* -"

* 3 * '("/ +* # 3/ 'A * " 0"%

* &*+ ' %*'

-3

'"#(%+*

-' - * * 0 % + C,, + '%% - * #* %$ " &'//*

#&* 3 -3 ''# *0 '( */ #%

0 %*' 3 %1"*

-((* *,"'

* "-/**/ %-3'"(*

"+ (

+* 3 + *# *0 *( % / "*066 ( 5 / ( ,* (3 +% -3 " % / 8 " -3 */ #"#

0/ 5 + ((0%(3 :'"

% -3 */ *

&" $ +*'

* #(

/* #/**& #* "* ( % A * 0"%

+* 0 * *

/8 "+ + % ( -"

63 - '

* /"

*$/"

*65%

% 5 '

*% *

&" A * " 0"%

##(*'

**0#/** %%"' %%* ( &*%' #( ' '% %'"/ +* 0 ''

0*% * % ** &"'%1"

#* ( %*

&" 7 0**0 . ( "-/**/ %-3'"(*

3 3*

, / - %*

3 5 56 ('

*0 #*

- / % - * 0 *0 (* #/ *,"'

* A "## * ' *$ (*% "# )*&** 9' ,"%0/ * "

! " ##

! $" % !

( $ # '(

# ) &

'*+,-./0 . ( "0 1/* "( # *0 #%

%$ "## % '* *%*0 '%% -3 " +* "-/**

*%*0 - % "# /

* ( '% '

- % +* "( #&% - &*

% -3 #&* 3 A * "

0"%

# * & #"

"# * + *0 '( */ * #'

#* %#% - (% -"'' "(* #&*0 *#* "* ## 3 % ( # '

/ :'# * %" '" ( + A * " 0"%

4% % +* "* %-*0*#* *

% "

< / , *0 % *% '-

/ 3 %'"/

3 &*%' #* * "

* "* , *0 :

/*%

3 % % + & "/- ( %*1" *$"

*'*

(* 3 %-(*'( */

* +* -: +* "

0*-( :#(

*$ $ %&* '*(* -( -% + * */A * " 0"%

+* :

/*%-3 #& *#*-3+ 3 (&*%' &/ %' %*'

/ +* #*%*'+ **#* ( (

%*'( "/- *%( %

0*% * * * 0 "* ( % . ( "-/**

/ %-3'"(*

%*& 3 %&

0 * ' / %'"/ "0 -#%"'%-3+ 3 %%* ( &*%' 3 * 0*% * + ''

%%"*0#%'3

(- * ##((

" $ $ &*% 3& (" * 3 ( + A %%* *$ * * "-/*

& * #( +* '3* "% -*''

4% % *#'

*#* - "%

($ " *0 (3 ((+%/"(%%(* * ''% '+*

"( */

(3 "%2 *#"#$(* ' -#( '%"# ,"%0/ *" 23 "

',145.,0 -*+ A & %'"( # *$#"% # #-

%'% A%*#"

-(3$ #( #%

+* 0 * '31"

"* - ''# %-3 " /

$ - '//'/ * ($ #%

"0 +* % + * #( '3 -3 *(*0 ##(*'

/%/ #( ((0*0/*

*'"( - * 3 0 * / "* * &" %'"/ % *% '( */ 1"

#*"% 0/ (-"

" "

(3 /%/ ((+% -3 * ( " %

*% (* 3 . "$&*%' %%"'%-3 */ #& * 0/ %

% ? 5 <:%(*&3 #*"% *% 0/ '

'*%

+ #/*

*#( %*0 +* 0/ *#*"% 0/ A , / - %* 3 5 56 : *-* % '%$ " % /

" '%% - '+ * '("/ % #% * '%% -*#*-*0A '("/#

**0

$ * 3 "' $ " & *0 (3 (%

" #% $ * &*+ , / - %* <:6$ *

" "

*@%''"# ' #*'%% -*#* */ "*$ *1" * '%*0 3- * *#* %A 0*% *<: / 3 56 5?$

*'%% -*#* %"(

(*'* 3

* ' :

- *+ * */3-'/%"-

"( *'%*-*(* 3**/# ' %. #%"'%, / - %* #* 5 56

-(*

+ '%% - * #* %$ $ 3*, / - %* 3 5 56 '

-- %% 3 3$-3(3*0"#,"%0/ *" *

7! "# "( %*#"

0*% * + / % -3 &"

% /*

* 1" * #*-3 * (" %%"*0#%'3 ( A 0*&'*'"/

'$ '

%*& 3 %&

0 ''

* 0*% *"-1" * ' %

* * %'"/ <:6 % 3 *$ "$(* -( -*0% . * # $''

* 0*% *%#* /

-*0#%*0 - * ##((

" %%'** 1" * #* *

&" -3 * (" 0 (0 3 +

+ %#

% ((- 3 #** *

&"%#*

*'+ '/# /

**, / - %*+ *' (*+* * %/ * *&*(" A

*&*+ /

$ '

"( * *%*0 " $ - * "-1" & "0 -#%* &*' -3 *(*0 ##(*'

%%* (&*%' . %*% * +* -: '" '

-(* *#( #* % ##( * +*

/ $ "* %**#* , *0 "

< / % ,*0 %*

+* -: "## *'

"1"

#* "* %A :

**' * $ %#%' 3 #( *+*

% % **#* %>%*%

-*0 "

< / % % * * #* "* ( % A ' :

*$ *

* *#* 66? 3 0 0*% *

%* * / * '

#%*0 >+&$

(( "/- ( %.

/ ,*0 0 (0+ 3

(* 3 %-(*#(

* #'

* #* "* ( % *0 (3 -

0"%-3'"( $*

/ +* :

/*%

#&#* $ ' %*'

*+* #'

#*%*'+ 7 0**0 **#* 3

(

%*'( "/- "* % "( ( / %

/# /"

*5%

% 5*#'

"''* / / " (* *0

*+*

(( %/ "*066 (5 / ( + "-,'

5%'*%%-3 *"

&*%,"%0/ %

%? 5A *%'

$ *" (%

((+*0

D##(

$ /8 " - % # -"

6 3 - *0 (3 0"%-3'"(

*((%

$ *%'(

*-3 '/# " ++* %

/ 8 " <& * "* *(% -3

$ "0 3 "' %'(

+* %

/8 ""/*0

3 "' %'(

* * "0 '

- 0 % * # "* $ /+"(%-

*& / %

*(*0 "* *"0" E A&*+ -&$ '

%*& %&

0 *' //"

*65%

% 5 #( *#'

*#*& "* -'* (3 (%* *

&"-3 " %A%

*% 3 * * /$#% '

-"* 0"% *

*(" #& * #( '3 * 0*& '*'"/

( *% 1"

((3

(#( #*

% & *% & ' #'%*0 #%*0 - *&*( " -30

*0''

** 0*% * /&"

0 / -3 *(*0 ##(*'

%%* (&*%' A&*+ +

-%*'"% *- $ *%*0 /* $ (

*( %* ''%*0(3%*/*%+* '

"(# *0 # ** +"(%

* &*+ *%*0 *

$ *0 "&*& '*%

* * " ''%*0(3$ (

%%*#% ,'*+,1 .

2860 F)!"(

*G = # *04 %

34 = #