High Court of Punjab and HaryanaARB-ICA/1/2025disposed of

Talwandi Sabo Power Limited v. M/S Sepco Electric Power Construction Corporation

2025-03-05Ms. Justice Lapita Banerji13 pages

!"

# $#

%& ' & %( ### )''

' % & '

###'

("

*% ('# '

%

!

"#

$

% &

$&#

" #

% ' (

)))) %

+ # ,%- * + &&#

#

" -#

/

0

&

& "

&12-3

(

4

& + - & +#

" - &&# 5 67,

8689

5

5(" *: 866, ; 18

(

5(" *= 86*8 ; 19

>

+ + > - + #

#

? ( -# = 8

5

866, ## &#

&

" ( -

+ #

;# ? ( -# .

866,

(

& -# :

( #

" # &

(

## 5

? (

# ( 5

+ # &

&&(

" # &

" -#

@

A

&# + > # &&

#

"( **.

**,

# &&

" +# -((#

" ( %C"# &( - (

"

# ;&

( & % "( & **

"

# &( - (

" #

" 5

"

# 1

4&# & ** % -# = :

5(" *: 866, # # &

1

$

/

!!!" #"$ !! %&' ! $ ( ! #"$ &

#"$ )

! *

+! ( !!! ! ! $ & #" $ , " * '-. -) *

/0 !

! $ .1

!! !" "

2

!" "3( 4513&

73507 05#

.

0"!

/5" "!

889!"5

! $ ! 0 "

2 0 ! !

:0 ! 0"

$

$ $ "" ! 5

! $ ! ! * $ 906"" ,!

15 ;; # <

0

" 5 " $ $ 5

,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,= % # -# = .

5

# -# &

D

!"# 0 "

5

$ % &' () 5" ! 5 " , "$

*

0!" 6 #"< ! > 6- - - - " " ! !! ! 889!"5 = =

% "( #

&& + -

#

& %

" '#

& +#

" - + -

'# : 2 E * 868=

& + -

" " + - '# # ## (

" "

& ( + - '# .

5 - ?" 86 868= & - > # &&

#

"( +& "),

& "#

/

& & + #

& ## &&#

F

& + - + - # < +#

"

*,,9

&

& + -

&&(

" %

*,,9

% # 0'

''

'1 ) ) #

%1 8686

-- 0-."( ,

"# & & 0& "), # & :

% "( ("##4"# "& " &1-(&

&

5

& -#

5

&

- +

;# &&#"#

&&(

#

" # # &

#

& % ; "( C #

#

&&#

" ;&# &&# **

%C"# &( - ( -

&&# H (

+& "),

" -

&&# #

( &

+ - % & &

( 0(

!3!1!

435 !

!63 ) # &#'## 3 5 # % #2 8667

-- 79* "( &

+

7

(

-

# #

& (#

& #

& " *6 5

" &1-& E *7 ; 1**

#

" ( (

-# : 8

5(" *: 866, ## & (

" ( # # ;&

"# !"# #

(# # 5(" 88 8689 (

"

&1-& &&

&

"

&&#"# & & ** I(" 8: 8689 ( &&# ; 1*=

+ -

&&(

" (

" # &#

( (

"C "# # &&

" ( F

&&(

"

&&# **

# &( -

+

E : 868= ((# & &

- 5 &&# ?" 7 868= &&#

# ?" *9 868= -

(# +& "), &# " F

8

+-."(

" "

& # +& "),

" *8 <& &#

(

/0"1&%- "23 && # +-."(

" # (## +& "), *7 & G8

( &

1 ?8

! $

" !

+

% , ! ,! @ ! = & +

% , +& "), ! ,! $ "! ! & ! 0

@ ",!!= &! +

% , " +& "), ! "!

* ! @ =! " ! ! ! ! ! ! 0 !

% +

% ,+& "), ! " +& "), ! 55 , ! " +)4

% , ! 5 ,

9

! 889!! +&)") '

% , +& "), !! = *9 <& &#

5

( && 5

"

-#

&

1

0

" 5 " $ $ 5

/ ! ! ,

2

! !

#" $ " * ' * ) & , ! "

!"

( ! " " ! & !8 ! ,!!!

!

: !! ! 5 0, !! #" $ # ,, , , ! , !" !! 5 , , !

!" !! " ! ,!! #"$ ,

" !!( " &

A" 0.

" !! &,

!.0, " 0 5 , "

,

44444 95"

#" $ !"

6! " #" $ ! = *=

(#

-# , * ##

##

#

+ # # "

-

+ -# .

5

& &

-# :

*.

+ #

( &#

" ( 5

" (# #

+

# (

"

" "

"

#

+ + # "

;

(

" # &&

" **

+

(

- !

# +-."(

" +& "),

"

*:

5; # # &(

/1 0 "

( & + (

!3!1!

435 , :;3-+ &1 # # ; &

1 /:

* " ! ! B '

)5, +$ ! B+ ') $ !$ C ') $ $ $ !!C '

)! ! +!

! + C

444444444= *G #

(

"

# ( ("#

+ - 3 - !

+ - &&

" &( - # ## ** &&# # # (# (" - 3 F

(

- # -

&

"

#

" ( & &&#

( # F &

- (((

&#

*, -

& !

" (

(

+ - &&# 5 67,

## ( %C"# &( -

" #

+ - &1F

3 (

" (

(

" #

+ -

##

& &"

3 (

# -

# # &

&&

- # #

(

(

( &

( & & *6

"

$

8* +

-

;

'1+- 1*1868=

&

( &

&&# 5 67,

+ - ## ( &&# **

&

%C"# &( -

+ 5# ( # ! "

" ( - ( ##

# (

## #(# "# !"#

# $#

,% - #D"

& 4 J45 &"# J45