M/S J.S.W.Iron And Steels Ind. v. Punjab State Etlc.T Bd.










 

 



 




 !"

"

# M/S J.S.W.IRON AND STEELS INDUSTRIES 

 PUNJAB STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD AND ANOTHER  $

 %&
$
 '
( 
'
 )





*****
    

 

    ! "

    ##### ( 
'
 )+

, -./ $"" %              &  '()  ))

**+

,- './ 01  2'

('3/  %   ) $ -    !  -  (

*3* - ) (2 )435  ""%    6"1 % 7-  01   ,-

% 

 8

             (

*3*9  % " 1

6"1 %7- - 

-2-  " "0 , / " 0      "1 %7-"   "/  -  0

:/  %;:"/ "  -  0 <0 ""%    " 0 % 

  0  /

  "1 %7-" / ;:" "    0    /    -  "       0            %1 :   /      " 1 -"1          / 



/  7-     " 1 -"1 /         - $ " =    &   )4' 
*3* 0   $ -  :  /    /     
)5
*3*/     !        >-" $  - 01   /" - 0  " 1 !     

  /

    """ /  "?01>- "  $      -    01  !   / " 

 0 

""  5 :   "" %    0   >- " $  % -  /  "        " 1   %         "  

!  0  % /""       1 :10 %-" "1 %  "  %" "- % "  %    % ! 6- 

  ,"  - 

-3-   /  /

  7- 0 </ "  "  "" "         "   0  -"1    ""0""/ %-" "101 <  

   /  ""01 >- " $  ,"  0  6"1 %7-/ "  ""- 01>-" $  ,"      & '()))

**  /       2'

('3:   " -0   "?@ ">-" $   - 0 " 1!    
3
)
*3*:"  %/ 0 %" 0       :    " 1     0      2      1 
*33   & 0


*33 :  /    -" /   -  01  A     (

/   / "01 /   0  

   6"1 % 7-  01   ,-

%      (

*3* / -  / </"   " 1 / /  " "0 ,  % "" ,  -0  6- 

/ ;:"

"   / "  -  /:  -"-0  01 % / ;:"     01

 %  % - " /

-4-   %1 - 01  %  %%:      & ) /    ,  - 
   

          





 !!"

#!$ "%& '$  (

  )  * ) "

 +

     

 

,

   

  -

  !!$ '      

    "  !  "$  !  !' ./0  1 2  3 " ! !

   ' #  /4 !

! 

  *!

 * !'  '$ "  /5 !

   '$  *  " 

      "

    !  "     "$ 



 '$ *

"   " "

 6 "   

 



 

"

'$ 

3% 7$+   6

     6 "   "   !  !  !  



 

      !  "$ 0! 3

(' "0  

% !$ -



' "   !  !'     !       !

!  -



' "   (

 )  *) "

.#!$ "%& 2 

  !! '

!!    



!! '     !$8

-5- ' </

 $"-55  %$   -"1  % " -    %1   0 %"1</" 

 /%  -""  - 1     "    - 0 >-" $  / "1

         /01  $  :    "  0 -   "   ) (2 )435     2'

('3  : $    

 -     1 
*33 & 0


*33  0  % - - %

 %   "1 %

   0  -" : "

3
*3*</" -0   "   >    %   %  "1   0"" % -       %  "

      "1  %   "        01  -0 >  "9 

 

0- "10- -  / "

/  %  -  %   -" 0  0  B98C<"    -   7- /-"101;:D0 /"  -  0% - 

   /     % / "/ ""-"      "

10 -"   4 : / (5
***

-""1  /   -    4*))(  $ -

-6-

     &  '()  ))

**  "         01  @ " D " >- "  $      %" 
3
)
*3* 0  -

 : -  !  /    -    -

  % 2 - % 0 

01$ -   /0 % -%   "15'1  "   0"             $ - "      -     %    %   >- "  $  
3
)
*3*  0  -

  0   0

  -  <" -0   -    % %0 -   "1  

07-   --0     " 3 <     "

 $ - "   0"   

    %  -% -  "0"  * :   0     "  $"- 55  

%$   -"1:"-, - 
 

9 :*  $ 



  !"

"    "$   6 !

   !

     !! /5

!



 ' 6 ;

"; *  * '      

 !    -   ! 

   ! 

3 

   !    

-7- !



 '  !"

"  

 "$  '!!

 " *   #!  



"  "$  !$     '!!  

  ! '

! "

  !$   !

 <    

  *! 1 $

 7       "  

,

!$ '

    $   

 -  .

# =$ 

 

 .

.

2#      

 .

2 #           '

&  

>
 

 -%     0   01  $ -       "/  - 0     "   -

016"1 %7-  - / -"

 0       %1   /

   %     

  //  1 -  -  -"% %    %1 /  " E " FFFFFFG    -   0        %1  

   "       0- "  / "

   0 , -"0       -"0 /:%   -7-   

0%   01A%$ - -

"))4 $ -  <  :   % 

 0  "1   "  01   

 < /    %- 01  $ -   

  " 0 , /  "        01 

-8- ;:D0  10 %   -

0-  / 1    0"

% 
) $ -  / "" -          

  "/ "0"

 /   0 , / 7-  0"A/"      % -  0 -  "   1"$ -" 7-  " 1   0 "0 ,  0       -

 0 $ - 0 >-" $  // -"

 "1 0   %-  - -" / -" , A  -       1"0" %-"  " -" --  " 1+-"1. 
*(3   1 -   0 - 
5 <       %-        /

0 - %   ;:"0

   %-  -  0 " / 

,- 
0   01   "

%/  "1    /  1 8- $ -    /  /   /-  01 
(       0    - 7- 

%  % -    %1    0 $ - <  

0-01/ $ - :  /     %"1%/"0 1      -    "

 1   1 "0"   /"/

-9-
'

""    % ""  - " +.

       "    






,( 
'
 )/
  
+
"

#









  ?

!% =  %H  

IH&  =  0"  IH&