High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1057/1989allowed

(O&M) Ram Kaur v. Mohinder Singh

2022-11-23Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja9 pages

!"#$%&#'()($*&!"#&+

!,-!./ 00000000011#22!*" 3)0 $4(*&#/(*54 "4#/) 0000000000 #)1$*&#*") 6 78 0 -

/#)#*"6 /0!)9(/ !""!*:&3$'!"#:!*& /0!*. !""!*:&3$'!"#:%$/"4#!11#22!*"0 /00-0$5/!:&3$'!"#:%$//#)1$*&#*"$0+0 ;;;;;;; - : /!2 <=!<$%1/#)#*"!11#!2'4!22#*5#4!)9##*,!&#"$ "4#>.&5,#*"!*&&#'/##&!"#&00

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

9#*#%("$%"4#%!'""4!"*$,."!"($*=!)5$"#*"#/#&9<4#/$*"4#9!)()$% )!2#&##&&!"#&0+0:$4(*&#/(*54)$2&"4#)!,#(*%!3$./$% /#)1$*&#*"$0@&#%#*&!*"$03(&#)!2#&##&&!"#& 00A=4$(* "./* %./"4#/ )$2& (" "$ /#)1$*&#*" $0+@&#%#*&!*" $0+ (0#0 8!94 (*54 3(&#/#5()"#/#&)!2#&##&&!"#&0 004#!11#22!*"@12!(*"(%%%./"4#/ '2!(,#& "4!" 9!)#& $* "4#(/ )!2# &##&): "4# /#)1$*&#*") =#/# !))#/"(*5 "4#(/"("2#$3#/"4#).("2!*&=4('4'$,1#22#&4#/"$%(2#"4#1/#)#*").("0

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

!/(&?$": 3(&# (") >.&5,#*" !*& &#'/## &!"#& 00

9< /#'$/&(*5 /#!)$*)"4!""4#).("%(2#&!""4#(*)"!*'#$%!11#22!*"@12!(*"(%%=!)9!//#& 9< 2(,("!"($* !*& %./"4#/ "4!" "4# )!2# &##& B0 &!"#& 0+0

#B#'."#&(*%!3$./$%!11#22!*"12!(*"(%%=!)(*%!'"!1!1#/"/!*)!'"($* 9#(*5.*&#/3!2.#&0 4!22#*5(*5"4#>.&5,#*"!*&&#'/##&!"#&00

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

/'4!)#& "4# ).(" 1/$1#/"< 3(&# /#5()"#/#&)!2#&##&&!"#&0+0:*$,.""($*=!)#3#/5$"#*"#/#& (*4#/*!,#9<"4#!11#22!*"@12!(*"(%%!*&!''$/&(*52<"4#).("2!*&=!) 1./'4!)#& 9< /#)1$*&#*" $0+@&#%#*&!*" $0+ !%"#/ 4!3(*5 &$*# &.# 3#/(%('!"($*!9$.""4#"("2#$%"4#).("2!*&9#(*53#)"#&(*4()1/#&#'#))$/ (0#0 .2>!/ (*54 !*& $4(*&#/ (*54 !) /#'$/&#& (* "4# /#3#*.# &$'.,#*"): !*& !''$/&(*52<: /#)1$*&#*" $0+@&#%#*&!*" $0+ )4$.2& 4!3#9##*&#'2!/#&"$9#! 1./'4!)

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

! " #$ !*& >.&5,#*"1!))#&9<"4()$./"(*'!)#$% %%

% # ! &'(! /#2#3!*" 1!/!) +

/#)1#'"(3#2< %/$, "4# !%$/#,#*"($*#& "=$ >.&5,#*") !/# /#1/$&.'#& 4#/#.*&#/%$//#%#/#*'#0

!"#$

# !

$%$$ &' %

(

! ) !

% % %

!# &'!( %

" *+ ) *

%+* & +

% , + - ) % .% ", - ! . !

- % !

! !

- /0 12

/% 0 . . 1!((( ! " "

#( * 3 !

! !

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

$%1!/"(#)"$"4#:).("$*#'!*%(*&$.""4!"!22"4#1!/"(#)9#2$*5"$"4# )!,# 3(22!5# (0#0 H(22!5# $&#: #4)(2 $5! "4#/#9< /!()(*5 ! )"/$*5 1/#).,1"($* !5!(*)" /#)1$*&#*" $0+ !) /#5!/&) ?*$=2#&5# !9$." 1./'4!)#$%).("1/$1#/"<:9<!11#22!*"!*&!)).'4:"4#12#!$% 1./'4!)#/'!**$"9#/#'$/&#&(*4()%!3$./%$/=!*"$%2!'?$%#B#/'()#$% /#!)$*!92# '!/#0 * "4() /#5!/&: #3#* %(*& ).11$/" %/$, ! >.&5,#*" 1!))#&9<(3()($*#*'4$%"4()$./"(*'!)#"("2#&!) %% ) * + %

% % , - " "* #$ !/!) $0 "$ $% "4# )!(& >.&5,#*" !/# /#1/$&.'#& 4#/#.*&#/%$/"4#/#%#/#*'#6 3%

! 45 6 + 768 / 6 9 6 76 5 : 7 ;

! .< 6&='$ 96>6

6 $%'$-

?14 %" 1 .< 6!

5 6

"=#= = #&

&='$ ?1@ 1 .< 6

"= # =

! 5 6

6> A6

B +

! 1 !

! C

! 6 $ ''%

* 3- * . 1

! < # * 4>(D @?@ #

# $

! #

" #6A6

C ! ! C ! ! # ! 6

320 % %%

% !(3 &

$/# "4!* "4!": (" () "4# 9!)(' 1/(*'(12# $% 2!= /#2!"(*5 "$ "/!*)%#/$%1/$1#/"<"4!"F*$$*#'!*'$*%#/!9#""#/"("2#&=4!"4#4(,)#2% 4!)I04#/#%$/#:/#)1$*&#*"$0+'$.2&*$"4!3#&#/(3#&3!2(&"("2#"$"4# ).(" 1/$1#/"< !) 4() 3#*&$/ 4(,)#2% &(& *$" 4!3# !*< "$ '$*3#<0 ''$/&(*52<:"4#2!=1$(*")!/()(*5%/$,"4#%!'")!*&'(/'.,)"!*'#)$%

"4#1/#)#*"!11#!2!)%/!,#&(*"4#1/#'#&(*51!/"$%"4()>.&5,#*"!/# !*)=#/#& (* "4# !%$/#)!(& ,!**#/: /#).2"!*"2<: "4# !11#!2 (* 4!*& () !22$=#&: "4# >.&5,#*" !*& &#'/## &!"#& 00

1!))#& 9< "4# &&("($*!2()"/('".&5#: !/(&?$":()4#/#9<)#"!)(&#"4#/#9</#)"$/(*5 "4# .&5,#*" !*& &#'/## &!"#& 00 1!))#& (* %!3$./ $% !11#22!*"@12!(*"(%%9<"4#$./"$%"4#"4#*2#!/*#&.9.&5#)"2!)): $5!0

#*&(*5!112('!"($*):(%!*<:!/#&()1$)#&$%!''$/&(*52<0 .

/. 01 - 12/

% . #8 * E 87 .

E 87