← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1511/1991dismissed

(O&M) Gurmail Kaur v. Gurbax Singh And Others

2025-02-20Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal15 pages



               

     

!"#$%%%     

"&"'

!"#%%%%  &( )*+&         ,-- ))+". /  &0+12"34+"!.4

                 ,

-"!

".

   5#  675  /* 5 87   



        

 



      

  

! "#     

$  %   &&&& /* 5 879 7 

' 

"

 "%   () )* (++(   !  ,   

 - " . %" 

 !

 "

 "%

    /( )+ (++)   !  ,    ! ".  !



  % / 0  

 

!

"

     " .

2 -  "  

"     -   - .  .  

3

-2- !   

4   

"    5  -  -. 3  

4 *  

6$%

    "  .

" "   "

 "

   6  .

"

  

    "

.

   7      "   8 +1( /9/(   

"



  "

  !

!

 * ( 7  .

" :() )9 (+;<

 "

 6 .

"

6$%

   "

!"  " 7 

  "

 .

 "

  7   "

%  8 (1  %         "   8 +1( 

"   % 8 /9/9

"   !

%"

=

>!

 %  "=

  " 

     ?

     !     7    %    %  !

  "

      

 %   !        > %   %  .

" 6   :  "

 6 % 7  

-3- .

" "6% "

 !(/6(1  "

:  % $!

: "$ " 

- 

"

   "!"

%      .

"  7     .

"   %% "

  "  " 

 !

! % " !

! % "  

   .

" %!  %   ! %

.

" !

 7   .

" 





   %.

" ?

( 7  .

" : =

 "/+ )< (+;/ =

 :  $!

: $

 -  "  %  :   =

     %!

 7      %  " !  -%

   < 7   %%  %  % 

  0%   "     

"    %6  



             

  

! "#$  



 

 %  &       

   

     



   %  & ! "#$ ' (  )    *+       *          

 



   ! "##

-4- ,   *      -      

 *

 * .  ! "## /   *              *  ! "#$    *     0

    *   1.  

  ! "#$ 2     



1   *   ! "#$   3

;

   

,%  !

  



% "  "#"

 

+ 7     

 () @     "  

  "      ! !  ,     !

= "=

A:

-(   !%  =

!%     =

   % "  .

"  "

 !   " $%

  @     !%        =

 !""$%

 .     %       =

       % " @   !%  =

    !"   . " !  $!

:

$ "16*  %: =

    .

" 

-5- () (   @        %  "

6-=* !%  " %"

%  !      "

 .

   %

    @      !%     B !  !

  .

""%      =

       !" "    !   !!!:

 

"

   () /   @           

 6!: =6/ @    !%   !!  %  .

"!" 

%

 "+)  ! "

!

 ()   @     !%        =

     !        !       %        !

   "

   !% %" "%

   !

  !

!      !  

   !   7       

  "% .'!

  % ,  7   45   6 * 7  

8      93

 +  ,, 3:3: '/+  . 

  7  ;

 +    9:  '

 :

-6- <**  )  0 2   / => *  9  # :  ) 



  ,?

((

    "  !%  "%

"

 

6  %!

 

(( (   @   !% :=

    !  ,    %     ! 

"!    

"

"% .!% "

% ".

" "

 !:             %   %  

%%A:

-6(-6<!

   %   !  

  @    !% =

 % !.

" !" "   . !%    =

   :  /( )< (+;/          %!  %  -  "  !  // (( (+;/  %  %  



  "!(9 )+ (+;* )?

)1 (+;< .!% .

" :  () )9 (+;<   ! 

       "    =

 .

" "   :=

!       ! " "% (( /   @   !%    %  

    %   " =

 

  %    % "%"

  % 

    !  (/ )/ (+;(   

-7- %   =

 . !%          .

"% % "=

@    !% %  ! % =

 ((    "

 "   !      %=

   !%     "   =

 !     %

   

" "=

 .!%       

      @    !%         %.    !  % !   

  (( *   @   !% %   

!% 7

 

  "%.'!

 % ,7 $



  7





+  / <(3:  '

+ 3   $  93

  7 @ 

& + 

 :: 

 ;     :  )    &  7

<

; & +    / <(:

 $

* 7 % *  & 

 +   3 :

: 2'

(/ 7     !% %  !    "    (1 %     ! 

, 0

, % 6 34 =.

"  %C% ""

   " 

-834 = .

"   : =

   /( )< (+;/ !!B " % $

$!

:  %!    %

34 7:=

 =

 !%  (* "   " 

 8 ( 1    "% "

 :=

7

!   

(?

5,    "

 .

"  %C% ""

 

!, !

    %:

%! !

6 :

%    

6$%

   "  =6/   ,

   %         %  % " "

 :   ! " !"  "    !

        , " 

.  !% ,         "

 .

"  %C % " "

  "   "% % " =   " =6 /  

6$%

 %   6:

%   "

 "

"   " 

 .

"    !"



"  !:   "

  "

-9-





7  %  66

 "

"   " !



 %!% !! !

   

   -=6( "  =

  % ".

""

   

     -=6* "



    6!:  ! %  -=6?-  

" .

  !% " .

""

  : !%      !       

          !  "

  .

"  %  "

   !%% "  

! ,   C 7, !     7



 %

!    %%% " %C"%  %

 ! " 



 %  

     "

%% " % " %!   

             !   "     %  % "  %C  (< @    6:

%  "

  %            

"      6  %

 % 5   " 

  .

"

-10-  "%% "

 !    %  (9 ,%"=

:   ! -=6(  -=6/ 5 "   ! " 

-=61

 " 67 

  =



% =

  

 " 2%!% ! :          %   "   !  % 0%-=6(-=61"  <17  (+/? <;7 A (;9/%   "  !! , =

  :!.

" (;

,%" 

 =

!% 

:

%=

       A:

-(  "  =

   

!

" "  

  %

 

=

  6 A(+



  

 

$

  

 

   +  2 . +

      %

+ B $ .

+ $  * (

   

+ 

 B +  +      %

+ @ # 

 B

 +  B $ .

+ 1



 

C (   1  



-    

4.  

  

 B+ ( 

           +     

 * 

  81   

 8   .        %

+ B $ .

      

  1.  .  B.

       

-11-

 (

 **.  

B+ (     *    



-       .

 + 81   + 8   .    1     .   **.+  1

 

 1+  .*+



  C+   .+     4+ @

-+  +

  *   @

-

 # "+  

  1  1

 

 1+  .

      %

 @ 

 1.   

. 

4.      1 *  1. 

0 

4.   *

 

.

   1 +   1    C      10  81   

 8   (+ 8 !

 =

 .

"%   "       : =

 . %   $!

:  $        "% !" . 

  $!

: $ " !% % !

 %% !

  !% !    " .

  

"

!%!   %   =

%   "   %

 !

.

" $!

: $ " /) 8   % " %  %%.

"  0 % 

 %    % "   % "    !

!

!    =



"

!%   %  %

-12-  "6$%

 "  !  %% %  % "%% ""



 %  %:=

 

 !(/ )/ (+;(

!% !

 %  " % "  " " "%  % !% 8 "" "    "  ""      %% % ! % " %  ! %  #"

  ! %    "%   ,      $

* 7

% *  & 

  * 

 )    &  7 <

; &  *  7 $

* 7 % *  & 

  *  , 5  6 A,

(    C         .       ** +   *    -.  1 .  1.    +  C  1

        4       1  *    1                B          **

0*         *  

  

 1 *           



 C     1 *   *    *  

     1 *; B+     1.  : 1   * 

 1    /(



 )    &  7 <

; &  *  , 5  6

-13A'

    

  

4.

1       

   1 0                 

C   *       

  

   *    B 3  < )

  

 

     . *          3

       

   -   

   

  

 E

    .  

 +  

    

            *

1.      4+      

   .



  

  

**  .           +  *  * 

    

  

<     1  * .      1  **     

      *  *         % 

 & +         

 +     

       

            * 3

  

+    

 

  *  *  

     

      



 3

  < *             

+  

   -         2,

                 



     3

      



 B            1 *

1.  : 1

          1

   1.           **

        

+    

         * 1. 



  * +          .

 

-14- // " %  %   % "    %   $%

  "   % %

%  %6:

%     66

 " "



 .

  

      

6$%

  

"

%  % ! /1 " %=

 .

%  % !  %!

 

        %

      !  B

        

  

""   " 6%" %$%

 =

 %  /*  "%    !

 .

"!"   

                !    !"    "  "%%   "   "% $!

: $ " %

     =

  :   .

  ! !   !

 " 

% 8!%    . !!%  

" 

" =

 !! 6      

" " 

 %  7  !

!

  

    7  %   =

 !% 

-15- /?

7 "" "% !! 7    "%!   "



      %     

"% 

!  %   

         %   7   

      !  %   !: 

    %     7 !%  %     /< %

     

"

 "% !

,

!0 

 ,        !  

6$%

  " % 7 %"% 

 %%

"   34 

   /* 5 87   

"&"'

!"#%%%% #  = "2    D28  = !

  D28