Max Hospital & ORS. v. Monisha




  
      !

" #$#%"&'($)  * +,"&, "-./01'(2

3"

4+ 1.5"6"+7,  ,++",

8, .

" 7  4"6,+ '    !

" %2%0"&'($)  * +,"&, "-./01'(2

"  ,++", 8, .

 +, 7559 6"+7,

 4"6,+




    

, ,+-  : ; 6 1<,"68"+,9+7    ; <5 168"+,1&"+7,4,++",



" 7!, 4"6,+!!4, " ! !

      )  * :6,+7 "6,1+9"4,++" =,5"



!

!#$#%"& '($6

!

!%2%0"&'($.6,<,+">$'  ,=,5 6 4"

,6  "&      ="+71  7

,5,  7  =,,  6  +"  ?.65,+  6+,6 $ ' '(@"&+7, ,8 " ".+197,,=/"6,6+,6'2 (' '(#"&+7,  ".+9 4+ / ,+! 6,16 

5+7,"4 +"&, 4"6,+ .6,<,+"0#)%*   "=,8+/1+7,&+ ,=,5,3++,6&" 

!

" #$#%"&'($

 ,& /1    +7,  ,8,5  "&  ' ' '((21  +7,  &+7,  "&  +7, , 4"6,+!"4 +9 5"+6++,6 3"

4+ 1.5"1" &,, 5=,+7

,

,9 A,4+&""8,%(7". 1"65+"+7, , 4"6,+1,5 5,+ /9+7".+4"865/4"4,+,+,+ 7,,&+, "+" +7,,,&,,67+"+7,"9=7+<A,+),9, 7* <,1 +9 ,,5,+ +.+"1 "6+""&+7,, 4"6,+B &+7,9

6,+,"+5  8,/  & +  6  "  =.

,  9  6,  8 = ,  +"  +7, , 4"6,+!"4 +1+7,,&",1 7,+""A7,&+7,+",=/+

"

4+ 197,,7,=,+7,67  +  7,, 4"6,+!"4 ++7,,&+,4

+"4"

+ 5 7,5".

,=".+,5 5,,"&+7,4,++", +7,+,+,+"&7,&+7,1 =.+".

6"+5,+/,6,

 +"7,5,8, " ,C.,+ /1 7,"8,6 "4 +.6,<,+"0#)%*  =,&",.6 5 ++,1 + 

.5"15 ++7,4,++", 6+7,,",6"+" 197"6 

,67, "4 +86,"6,6+,6'2 (' '(#) !%*  ,555,8,61+7,, 4"6,+!"4 +44"7,6+7,

,8 " ".+197"1&+,"+,67,5="+7+7,4+, 1 ,+! 6, +7,"6,"&
6+,6'2 (' '(#) !%*4+ /1,4+,6+7,,8 " 4,++"86,4.5,6"6,6+,6$ ' '(@) !>*1+7,,=/6,+5+7, + ".++"4",,6&.+7,5 ++7,4,++", D,,6". &"+7,4,++", 1,&,5+7, "&"=

+7,98, .

<++,"& .?=6"+7,1 '((0<) *1%#26

+ B<".E8, .

"76 
7&C1'((2)*<) *120$1.5, +7+ +7,"6,"& ,,6
 4,&,+ / ,5 1=,.

,+7,"4" ".57+=/ +7,, 4"6,+!"4 +7,&8".&"+7,

,5,6,5 5,,"&+7, 4,++",  "+&"/"8,,+"+"""++,,"&"+"

  6.

/" ++.+,6=/+7,"8,,+14. .++"+7,6,+" "&+7,4,3 ".+="8,,&,,6 8,1+ "+ , +"97,+7,+7,6"+"1 97"  7  58,  "4"    &8".  "&  +7,  , 4"6,+!"4 +1  9

4, E,6+7,&, 6&"9777,&+7,9 +,+,6=/+7,4,++",

  +7,  "+7,  761  +7,  , 4"6,+!"4 +    4, " ,&.+,6+7,="8, .=

" 8558,+7".57+&.

" 6,+"+"+7,8 .=

"

+A5+"".++7,6,+" "&+7,"B= ,<.4,,".++7, ="8,,&,,6.+7"+, 1+7,+ ".++.5" 6,+,6+",&,+7,  ,"&, 4"6,+!"4 ++" ++D,8, "6" ++.+,6=/+7, <++,"&/86,"+&+"" '0F(F'(@!#
6+,6% (0 '(@1 +" ,,A"4" +"97,+7,+7,

,5+" "&+7,, 4"6,+!"4 + 5 ++7,4,++", +7,4.5,6"4 +9+7, 4,++"+7, ,6 ,5 5,,, .= +++,6 
+.1+7,7,& ,6  &&,1.5"1

+A,,6 , .,+7+4+ 6.= ,6"4" 58,=/+7, ++D,8,

"61&+,?"5+7,, 4"6,+!"4 + 7,, 4"6,+!"4 + 5+,6 =,+/+"4"6.,7, ,+,,86,,C.

,5,6,5 5,,"&+7,4,++", 8 = ,9+77,1 ,664"8,7, ,=,&", ++D,8, "6  7,  ++,  7   ,6/ =,, 6, /,6 .7  7,,&",1  +7,  ++D,8, "6 6,+,6+" .=++ ,4"++"+7,+ ".+9+7 +9""+7 &"+7,6+,"&,,4+"&,&,,,4"

+8, /  

+7,1+7,"6, "&="+7+7,".+ =, "9

, =,/, &+,,,4+"&+7,,4"+&"+7, ++D,8, "61+7,+

".+

4",,6&.+7,+7,++,1"65 / 

 "+7+7,4+, ,6,+,6+"44,=,&",+7,+ ".+" ''  '(2197"

+"65 /6"=?,+8, /"4 ,+"+7, 6,+" 

.,686,+7 "6,  "+7+7,4,++" +66 4"

,6"&"65 / 



  !  "




























#