High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1580/1991dismissed

Jai Gopal And ANR. v. Jagdish Chander

2025-10-27Mr. Justice Virinder Aggarwal12 pages

!

#$%%&& #$#'$( #$ &)%%&&

* +, %

- .,

!" #

%

$ %&

!" $

'& (

!" #

- .,

/

)

* ## ! &

" +,-.+//+

0" 12 ! (')+/++/3/ $ $

&

" +/-++/3/# + 12 4 (+53#+.-6+/3. $

! & "#

!4 " #

" .+# 7 " +/+3 $ # "

8 # 9

:;)

4 # "

)

#

"##

*&* ++ < "#

& & &

"& #

! #

#

& #

$

# $ " #! " &"#"< ""& "

&

# ! # & &

"

$#

$

" #

) 5 ) "

" ! " " #

" $

## ##

" $# ) ) #" # " $ 9) ##!0!0 ##

0!0 8 "

" ;= & 0!0 $!! $ $ & 7

%

>& 74 <

# 0! 0 & #&74 <

$

# " 0 & )

$ ## (5

# 0! 0 "

)

& 5/+-+/3?

## !#& "4 $ ) @

$ A"

!

B$! $ $ & #

*0* "

< #

$

! "

" # :

? = "

"

$

& ! & +/C+

@

" +/,+ " # A"

!$ &D ##E"

&#

)

&

## ! 5/+-+/3?

$ " #

#" )

#!

"

#& $"

# "

"" ##

" $

" #

& & " F "&

4 D(+*56. & 12 4D&

$ $ 4 $ " "& #"

" "& !

""

# & # . ) ## # "

A

##&

&

" $ "#"

!

#

" ! "

= "# " # "&

& #& #

$ # &

""& "

&

$"

$ + G ## # "

"

"H>77

*1* 5 G #& & H>70 ? G ## ## "

#H>77 . G

# # & " #H>77 C G

" "

" ?C #7H-70 , # C ' $ ## @

! " # "!"

&= " #

# " # + 12 4 " #!#

* ## ! 9

: ! "

*

#

#

0" 12 $" $

$ ! #$

&

" # ) )

&

9

! !

"# ! : ,

! &

" # 1

$"$

& ("$

$ "

" # $"$@ #

"

"

** 6 < ! "

"#

A& & " " $ ! "

#

" " $)" &"

!$

& I$ !

!

! $! # E 3

" # "

$

# $ 7

D "

#

" .+#7 " +/+3

" +--7# " " & & # & "#2$3242356

2" 75 #'85 , 2$"

#75

-9 52$" 632 2$"

#75 /

&::

) #

$

& "#;6 #"6

6$(

( " 75 #'85 , -9 2< 2 325 2$"

#75 /

& 0) 2$"

27 $"

2$"

#75

-9 2 #4 2$"

#75 / &&& & (2=

&

$ $

# & @ # $@ #& / ) " #

& 2 &

"#

0" 12 $" $

$# & # " & #

$

" #"

! " "

# $)

4 "

#$ #

$" @ #

#& & $ $ ) "#

! E " !

" "<

"

*:* & 8FA7+; $ A" $ $

$

)

E# "

"&

& /5 <# " #

#

E ! " 8FA7G+*6J?/ FA7.- FA7G,*+J5+; " ! "E#

<+? & " " $ " # "&

! "

" )" & #&74

$

# " )

&&# D

1&

&

&#%&"

##"

E $# /? ) ""

#

"" # # #"$

<$

!

$ & " " #& $ !

#

1

12 4

& " #& ( $ !" !

$ &

" #& $&

$ )

E & # #

" "

"

$ ! #! " /. < !$## " #

"#

& &

*)*

"#

0" 12

$

$# & # $

$

+- K " #

# # # (+ I

I <

)40 $

##

$

& "<# ##E"

" @ $

# "

# 74

$

! " # " A"

!$

)40

) #

&

## !

5/+-+/3?8FA7+

FA7GC*+;

$

8FA7G+*+; "

& " #

#!#

(

7 ##(5 & " $ "

"

! $ $ !& #" #

" #"!

#! "" +-+ <#"

" $# $ # )

$

+/C.8FA0G?*+;

@

" +/,+ ! " ! " 8FA0GC*+;) ##E! " $ " "

" "

7 ##(+"

"

& # 74

" #"

& & ) 1

""

!

**

! " ##E

)" ! "

""&

! " 8' L&( $;

" !

A"

!

$# $ # "+/C.) ## ! ! ! "

"&

! " )

& ## !

$ &

#" ! " A& $"A " " # A"

$ # ) $ #

$ $ 4 $

D

#

" # # "& +-5 <# & 2 " #

" #$#

&

# $

### "

! " @

" ..

.C#7 K

! "

! #& & # # & ##E$

)#

#

#!#

"" $#

!

& ++ ) " # " #

* ## 1

! 4

"& ! " & #&74

$

# " D

1&

# $

"

)

""

# !

$

* *

&#)40#

$ #& E& # 7 "

& $ # $ #& +++

!

"#

$!% "#

&

'(

) " # "

$"

* "

&

)"# ##

& #

)40 # " & FA7+ $"# &

## !$

)4 0 # & &4 FA7GC*+ )

** @ #$ & ! #

##

&

FA7+

FA7GC*+ " "& "

" #

##A #

+? < " #

"& @ "A

&&! #! A" +--* &# " +6 # " +/-3) ##& ##> 6$85 !% ' 76 6 2"52 ; 652$ 6/ &

0

6!6= 0 $$

#

$ 9. ) $$$ #" $ "&

& "

&

! $ $#

) $" $!# &&! #$! $& +--* ## A"

& " +6 8+; 8; # " # 9 & ###&&! :@

" ./# " "& $" @

" +6# " "

"! ! "##"

&&! "! ! "

" ##" "

$ # $ "4 $ $ ! # $ ## &&! "

!& & & ) & "

** <?632 22"

523'

!% 2< 3>2= 26 :

:

& "

" " # &&! <

# "

&

# &

@& # ! # & " ! ") & # # $ $ ! #"

##" :

+. < " "& A #

< " # " "& & &

" & FA7+ ## !FA7GC*+ ##"

!$ #

+.+ 1& 1

!

A" # FA7+

FA7GC*+ "

"

" ! " ! "< " & $

$ $ &

&

!

$ " ##"#" % $" "

# "& +C < # # !

# "#

A& #" ! 1

$#

# " FA7+

FA7GC*+ ! #

"& " A"

!

" ! "

" ! " "4 #

"& ##"$ #

" # "&

#

# 1

$

*&* #

& " @

! #&

# & +, @ # " #& "

&"

" #

# "

" $ # "

# !$#

"

( # " &

" "#" "

""

# #" " & "

- .,

&)%%&& 2' 2!

# #7 Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No