← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1621/1991dismissed

(O&M) Jasmal v. Kamalbi & ORS.

2020-05-12Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal16 pages

 

 !"#$

# 

 #  % &' & & ( )  **))   +, (- ( )./  *

0% 1"20!

 2- 2  

     

     

     

 



  

   

   

 !

  

 2- 23! "#!

 

$ % &'(& &'(( &'()

&'(*

&++&

# 

!

) 

  ,  -



 



!! "#! 

 1











# "#! 1 



#



 !

  / 



 #

!  !

 

 2

  3    0.  /

 !

. ,

5- 

. 

   

 #

   6  78  9 :# ;

5  #

  

< 

# . # 0    .



# . =< 9'> ?

   

 



#

@

00000000000000000000000000000000000000

@

@

@ 

 

8 .

@

@

@

 

% 

@

@

@

00000000000000000000000000000000000

000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

@

@

@

@

@

@

@  #

.

!

$

!

B!



 

@

@

9

!

!

.

@ ,

-

5

,



,C-

@ ) -

, #

 - ,  >-

!

0

 

 ) 

#  !

.

 

  % )+)

&? D* &+?(

!



 #

 !



   #

.  #

 # 

!

,-0

.   # 

 !

.

E 

,5

.- 

 ! # '+G  &+  

! ! # G)'

 &+F



!

 !   

.



, - 

9 :#

 

!

. . ! ! 

 



# /

 .

#

/



!.

   #



 #

 #

 . ##  







4  /

! 

#  

 

 / 

!

 



 



!

.  

!  

 #

!

 



  % )+)

/



!

 "  #   

!

# !# ## #



/   

  !   



 

  % )+G

GD D? &+?(

/





!

.  /

!

! 



<

   &+ DH &+?(  8#





    &

 ! #    .# 

/ # /



#  /    (& DH &+?(

# %< 



!

  % *D&

&( D* &+?+

!

 !#   

.

#

# 

  < (& DH &+?(



    & &H



  !

!

. ! # 

/

  % )+(

&? DH &+?G

#

 /

!

!

.



 

  &? D( &+?G

 

5 

 !

.

  !/

8  (? D& &+?G

! .#  #

!/

. 



#

  &? D( &+?G  .  / # 

 



. 

!

.



 !



.

!

. 

   !

.



./   

. 

 





./

       # !

.

, #

 -

 

    

!



 .



 2

  % )+G *D&

)+(  

   )+)

&+?(

E () D& &++D 

 

 !



#/    

 

    )+)

&+?(

1 



  





# /

 .

#

 



/ 

!

 

4 



   

.  









 



.



!

.

 





.2/  

 



.

E #



#  

' 



  #     



 

"#! =< 9H

   #

8   





 .



!!.  

   .



.

 

8

 







/   

!/

 

 #

  2 # 

 

  #



"#! =< 9H  D) D' &+H'

6

   





1





0  # 



#



(G  

 

0



     

  

 

  

 !          "             #  $

     ! 

   "

     " 

 

 

     

 %   #$

      "            %   &               !  #'#  ()  *     +$, !

) !       

      

    " 

"

     &

"-.

     . 

  

 

!

 

  

   

                   !

   -.

               

  "

        



   # $

      ! 

      "        "  

 

  

  

    

 %   # $

      

  !

      % &   /

"

  &

0 1









   0 # !



 



 





 !



  



#



.

  # #

"#!





 .

 1 

 

.!

  0

.

 !  #    )+(

&? DH &+?G







 



.

4

 .!



 /

#

4







  E )& $ (H





 .



 

6 !# # 

"

.



  

 

4

 .!



# /

 . 

 :#

4 



 . 

C !

 / &??G  /#  

!

:#  

"

.

4 



 (

 0



 .

!



  #



!

 !    

4

 .!

 8 



I  

  

 

4

  



!

 2



!

 





  J % * J % '

# *G



J % G

# *)



< 

0

1    2#  

"    "  

"       

!   

 !  

    2



)     

         4

  )   !   

!   

 !  "

    4       #

  "

   

    4       5)

   ! $"!6!

,  ! ,

"    

7    4      

    !    

   4   7 8  9  "     4         

  "   

!  



     4  

                   

  "     

 !"    



   

  2

         !       

    ! 



 

4          



!

4

!   5

   !  " 

  7  8 

4  

            

!     



: 

4       " "   &    

                

 : !  "  2 "

 &         2    !               

" 

       5 7   !57   2

  8

     "                   4  )      4 

4  

    !         "



4

  :

!                       8  

  

 

  

 5

  



7

8

     !     5          

     4

7    

         4      5(!  % "!

9!$"!8!,  !6!) 7 8  !                 4         

      !       4"

  8     "  

        5) !  , % !*!6!*7  /    !  

       

      !           

         8  

 



  4     "       4 4

0 E #

   

 



!

.   E 

  

#

0  

#/  



 

4 .!

  

 

   !

/ 



!

!# 

##     

8  (? D& &+?G

#  .2 # !! !

&? D( &+?G

!

. !



  / &++D

  



!

.

   

9C)

 /

!



!  .  !

!

 

9C&D

& 

4





#   < !

.



 (& DH &+?( 

!

.

 / 





5   < !

#!



  / 



/

. !

. 

  C 4 $ # .8

BE$K 1C   $==%  =$%=9

&'

= .  / (DDH .8 0  9  9

 / (D&(

 .8

0  

!





. 

!! # /

 .

# . 

  #

!#

#

  

#

 8 !



!





 

"

.

 # !! 

  .

! .





  



!



 



    . 4

!







G+

. 2  .

 









. </

  

 

.  

I 8

 G+ < 

0 )  



       

-.

57     "  ; "    -

 7 

 

   43 

)& 

. 

 

 #  2  / !





 )) 

 / <

/ ! %  # 

< !



  6

  ! 

#   

  2!

# 

. /

  % )+(  &' DH &+?G

 ) *

'



0 L< 8   3

    

 

   =       



> ?>      =   

  ""  

% !  #$

   = ) " 

   @ 8        =             = = 

" 

> ?> 

3 8  = 

3

"



  " !

   

  ;

 

        

     

    

8

 

 



!  

      "      %          #  $

  = 8

 > ?> 

 !  





   A 8

 > ?> 





            

        

"

           =

8  = #

 $

    =    %  !           

                    

   

> ?>   

 !      

 

  

    0   

2 



6!

) *

' 





 # "

. 

!

  . !!/ !!/

 

#







 /

!/

   !!/

 

!

#  # .



 !

 

 .



  . 

! .# # >

  



 /

4  

   .  

 !.#   .#



 <

!

 

!

#





 #

.

  

# 

!

  !/

#/  !  .   /

!





! / .

 /





E  

!

# 



  I < !



 /   / 



4I. !

        



!

"

#



!

0! /  

#

4 



!

!



#



4I. !





##   

  / /

 

/ 

 

 "#!

 4I. !



.

  9 5

"#!

$

  %    &'

 

  ( ')

*#

 '    (+  

, -*.

(/

* ,   #  

 

  0

 

   "#!

  # 

 !!/

!

6 "#! #  =< 9(

 

!

 % . 

  % GD)

&+*)  &+ D? &+**

< !# ( . .





0

L8   &  ( . .    9       ,              8  =     3   :

     

 

 " "!

   

      "   "           8      





,           "

   

    . 8 " ( . .  9   , 

  

     

 

   ,   "        

    

  "    !  

    ,    %     

     9



"

,=  9 



")!

5 9<     6 $  

  9@  "     6 $   9A  " 6   #       " ,6  !  9B  

",(;

  9> 

/

# .

# # .

 

$ 

=< 9&D =< 9&(

"   #

!# 

=< 9&(





/  0 ! 

 /

  .

 / $ "00





!

!# 8 

/

 /

!

  



!

8

 !



  "

 

!



!/

/ 2

!

  



!

8

# .

 

 =< 9& 

% . 



! #

B!  $ I



!

 

 



 

$ "

.

 

$ "

.# 

 

 .

.



  B! 

$  &&

# !!

 .# 

 

% .

8

B! /    ! ;



    



     "#! =< 9H =< 9+ =< 9&& =< 9&G =< 9&* =< 9&H

 

  "#! 

.





#

'

 



 



 / 



 "#! 



  C

 $ #



. 

< 

% I < !

#!



 6

#!



!

.

 

# 

 .   



 



#

#

  % )+(

  !

.







 

. %<

#!

  .

 



 E )& $ (H



!

 

4 





  8   

 



    

8#

# !

 

 !



 !



 





!  !/ .  



  !# #  "

.

  

   !# 

%<

#!



  # 



 .  

C !



 / 





 # 

   !

 ! /  



#  !

 #

 !

     





# "  

#

  

 . 

 !

#



< /

.

 4I. !





 #

# 

 / .

 /

4I. !

 6   



  

.

  

 

C

 ! 



!

 



  



/ # #  

#







 4





 !  0 83 & & 

92- 2:

  !

#   8#>  

K>%   . 

K>%