← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1671/1991dismissed

(O&M) Kartara v. Kesar Singh And Others

2018-02-19Mr. Justice Arun Monga10 pages





     



 !!"#$#%& !'()(*   +,-./   0( ($#%"!1!"!$!1  +()2+3 $ 44!55% $ 6!($)$ 0!$(#%2+$#%"!1!"!$!1  +()2+3 $  +!($  !$4%1!% $

 !"#$%& '( $(')#

(!$!% &

(((,17" !, ( +!44!55% $

( )%#,!%#(17" !8# +

$(9%22(,17" !, ( +!(!$4%1!% $ ::::: (')#*% 44!55% ;45#% ##$#% !2)5(!"%144!52#%$  +!

<)129!% %11!"(!! +!38!(44!55 !)( ,8+!(!'* +!<)129!% %11!"(!! +! (#5)( 1 !1-/2(% #%21!"5( #% +  +! <)129!%  %1  1!"(!!  1 !1  -/=  4$$!1  #%  #7#5  )#     ->/=  "4 #%!1  $  ?0!$(  #%2+  )(9)@+  #%2+  6!($)$  0( (A '!#%2%)55 7#1,#%!!" #7!+51#%2 +!44!55% ;45#% # '!8%!(  +!!B !% C$+(!#% +!5%19!$)(#%2=.'#2+$.'#$8$$4!( +! 1!$"(#4 #%2#7!%#% +!45#% %12#%$ 1!!%1% $%1-5%28# + +!1!"(!!<#% 4$$!$$#%  +!!B !% C$+(! +!$#15%1,+$ '!!%$! ;$#1! !(!17!( #%2  +!(2)9!% $ +!(!$4!" #7!")%$!5 (!4(!$!% #%2 +!4( #!$  +!5#$,# 8)51'!4  2#7!'(#!4(!"! +! "% (7!($*#%757!1

+

%!0( ($%# $#%"!1!"!$!1 '!#%2(!4(!$!% !1 +()2+5!25+!#($,#%$ # ) !1 +!(!9!% #%!1$)# 2#%$ 0!$(#%2+, )(9)@+#%2+' +$%$)(1!7#%2+,)(1!7#%2+$%+'), 0@)$%# ,5'#(#%2+%19#%2+' +$%$(8%#%2+ "5#9!1 +!(!9!% #%!1(!5#!,% +!4(!9#$! + , +!5%28# + 1!!%1% $D%1=8!(!<#% 8%!($5%1'!(#%20+!8 > 9!$)(#%2..'#2+$>'#$8$)55*1!$"(#'!1#% +!+!1#%2 +!45#% 

5#% #%11!!%1% ='!#%2(!5'( +!($+1E.=$+(!, 8+#5!)(1!7#%2+1!!%1% D+1--=DE.=$+(!$ % +!*!(/,45#% #%11!!%1% $D%1=!% !(!1 #% 9#5*$! 5!9!% 8+!(!)%1!(5%19!% #%!1#% ( +!

45#% 8$4( # #%!1%15%1"94(#$#%20+!8 E/,0+$( -9#%; ,9#%;.

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

,

%19#%2+1!!%1% $>%1  !$)5 % 5*, +!*+1'!"9!";

$+(!($8# + +!45#% #%11!!%1% D+!$#19#5*$! 5!9!% 8$" !1)4%%1 +!45#% #%11!!%1% $D%1="9!#%  !B"5)$#7!4$$!$$#% +!5%1,1!$"(#'!1'7!

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

5%1"94(#$#%2C$+(!#%E.=$+(!#% +!5%1 9!% #%!1 5! (HI +!+!1#%2 +!45#% %$!F)!% 5*,1!"(!! 1 !1-/=#%#7#5)# ->/=,$% #"!1'7!,8$ 4$$!1+!1!"(!!,""(1#%2  +!7!(9!% $#% +!45#% ,8$(!$)5  ()1'!#%245*!1)4% +!45#% #'*1!!%1% $ D$+!%!7!( (!9#%!1 +!9!9'!( +!9#5*1!!%1% $ D!!%1% D 8$+#$)%"5!%11!!%1% -8$+#$%!4+!8+!45#% #+1(!5 '( +!(%1%!4+!8$5$%1, +!(!(!,# 8$% !B4!" 1 + +!8)51 2#7!!% #(!4(4!( * 1!!%1% $%1-!+15$$#$ !(,8++1 5!2# #9 !"5#97!(+#$!$  !!8$+(15*>>*!($2!%1+7#%2 214+*$#F)!, +!(!(!,%""$#%($!( (%$!((#%2 +!4(4!

-

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

1 + 0@)%10( (45#% # !!" 1 !B"+%2!5%1'*8(# #%2 +!!B"+%2!1!!11 !1-./.

.

#%2+%15'#(#%2+0( ($)!(!11!"(!!%->/=% +!'$#$ 9#5*((%2!9!% %10!$(%1)(9)@+#%2+1!!%1% $2  +! $#1!B"+%2!"%"!55!1%1( +!"%"!55 #% +!$9!,%2(!!9!% !B"+%2!,8$!B"+%2!1'* +!45#% #,0@),9#%2+,5'#( #%2+,  0!$(  #%2+  %1  )(9)@+  #%2+  %  >/>  %1  +!  $#1 1")9!% 8$ +)9'9(@!1'* +!$#14!($%$9#%2+$#2%!1 +! $9! !(19# #%2 +!$9! '!"((!" +!1!!%1% $+15$4#1 $)9,>..E;$192!$%1"94!%$ #% 9#%2+%15'#( #%2+(2! #%2 +!!B"+%2!"%"!55!1+!55!2 #%$/4( # #% '!#%2% #%"(4( !1#% +!(!2)5((!"(1,8!(!5$1!%#!18!7!(,# 8$$  !1 + # +!(!8$%*$)"+4( # #%#%/, +!1!"(!!")51% '!$#1 '!%)55# *$55!2!1'* +!45#% # !2(1#%2 +!!B"+%2!

1 !1-/.,# 8$$  !1 + 9#%2+%1 F#(#%2+#5!1$)# #% +!)( 2#%$ )(1!7#%2+, +!(1!!%1% =0@)%1 0( (45#% #,8+#"+8$"94(9#$!1%1!B"+%2!8$"%"!55!17#1! "%"!55 #%1!!11 !1>/>+!9#5*$! 5!9!% 8$2#7!%!!" '*8*1!"(!!#%'! 8!!% +!45#% #%11!!%1% $%1- !!%1% =#5!1$!4( !8(# !%$  !9!% 19# #%2 +! "5#9 +!45#% # !45#" #%8$#5!11!%*#%255 +!55!2 #%$#% +! 8(# !%$  !9!% '*(!# !( #%2 +!7!(9!% $91!#% +!45#% #%"! +! 4( #!$8!(! 7(#%"!, +! (#5)( (9!1 +!558#%2#$$)!$&; ? 



    





      

 





   

     

 



   

       

! 

      



 

 



       "

# 

  



 

 $  +! (#5)( % +!4(!4%1!(%"!!7#1!%"!,1!"(!!1 +! $)# 8!7!(,#%44!5, +!38!(44!55 !)( 1#$9#$$!1 +!$)#  #$ #% +#$'"@1(4 +!9 !(, +!4(!$!%  !2)5(!"%144!5+$'!!% #5!1

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

55% 2 %%*!18# ++#$'( +!(,1!"#1!1  5#7!$!4( !5*%1"9!#% "% " 8# + +!(!$4%1!% $,8+!(!1  ")5 #7 ! +!5%1 +!44!55% 2#%$ (!% %1( +!4)(4$!8(# #%2 8$(!F)#(!1 '!!!" 1,'()2+  +!44!55%  95+)( $,8+#"+ (!$)5 !1#% 4$$#%2 +!()1)5!% 1!"(!! %1!9#$! %<', +!4(4!( *1!757!1)4%# #%2+ %1+')#%2+#%!F)5$+(!$0!$(#%2+%1)(9)@+#%2+8!(! +!$%$)(1!



5! '!+#%10( (%10@),8+#%+!(# !1 +!4(4!( *,8+!(!$(9 +! 5#%!     +')  )(1!7  #%2+,  8+  +1  8  $%$,  0!$(  #%2+  %1 )(9)@+#%2+, +!(!(!,# 8$$+9 (%$" #%,#!, +!(!8$% (%$" #%#% +!!*!$58%1 +!$)# 8$(#2+ 5*1!"(!!1

!("% (, ( )%#,5!(%!1!%#()%$!5$$#$ !1'*

$(9%22(,5!(%!1")%$!5(!4(!$!% #%2 +!(!$4%1!% ;1!!%1% $ $)'9# !1 +  +! (#5)( '1#" !1#%% $$#2%#%2%*(!$%$  +! 1")9!% $B,B-,B%1B+!#%2(!1#!% $ (1!(

)5!= +7!% '!!%4(7!1 #$$! 5!158 +  +!()1#$%   '!45!1!1') +$ '!4(7!1!7#1!%"!+$'!!%5!1 4(7! +! $9!B8$1 !1>/>,8+!(!$ +!$)# ($! #%2;$#1! +! 1!"(!!1 !1-/=8$#5!1%--/,#!, !(%!*!(%1$!7!% 9% +$ +!(!9!% #%!11!"(!!%19)"+8 !(+158%1)(#%2 +! $#14!(#1#%$9)"+$ + B,$! 5!9!% 1 !1>/>8$ !% !(!1#% ,8+#"+8$$#2%!1'*0@),0!$(#%2+,9#%2+%1 )(1!7#%2+,8+!(!#% +!(!8$(!!(!%"! +!1!"(!!4$$#%2 +! "%$#1!( #%,>..E; ! 5!9!% E@((%9B-+7#%2(!!(!%"! 1!"(!!)%1!( "+55!%2!

8$5$!% !(!1%-.>/>,8+#"+8$$#2%!1'*0( ( 9#%2+%15'#(#%2+$%$(8%#%2+#%$ # ) !1 +!$)# 2#%$ )(1!7#%2+,0( (#%2+,0@)#%2+,0!$(#%2+%1)(9)@+#%2+ "5#9!11!"5( #% +  +!45#% #$'!8%!($#%4$$!$$#% +!$)# 5%1%11)(#%2 +!4!%1!%"* + $)# 8+#"+8$#5!1%=/>, B8$!B!") !1%17#1!(1!(B1 !1-./>, +!#7#5)# D=/>8$8# +1(8%, +!(!(!, +!(!8$%'1#" #%%1 +!38!(44!55 !)( ,'!#%2 +!5$ )( " %158, !(

/

44(!"# #%2 +!!7#1!%"!(#2+ 5*(!7!($!1 +!#%1#%2$ +! (#5)( '* 1#$9#$$#%2 +!$)#  $(!2(1$ +!(!2#$ ( #% +!1!"(!!,+!(!5#!1)4% +! ( #1!"#1!%1#")55!1) '* +#$)( #%012134

 512622 7 3 1

 512*+88.  3938. "% !%1 +  +!

$! 5!9!% ,8+#"+#$(!"2%#$!1 '!)( 1!"(!!,1!$% (!F)#(!%* (!2#$ ( #%,4( #")5(5*8+!% +!(!5 #%$+#4!% # 5#%2 +!4( * $$!( (#2+ $)""!$$#%%1%$#9#5(5#%!$, " 1  3 162205 1

 512*+88+,  393-.'*$  #%2 +  +!"%$!% 1!"(!!4$$!1'* +!)( 1!"5(#%24( *8%!(5%11!$% (!F)#(! (!2#$ ( #%  +!  (!9!% #%!1  #%1#%2$  8!(!  ((#7!1    $  4!(  +! 4(7#$#%$ (1!(-D!+$5$(!5#!1)4%0

 512622 :5;:3  

3 53



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



<

   

%  





        

      

       &   &

&     &



 

&

   

 

 

   

           

        '   

     

&  

 ( 



     )   

 

* !7#1!%"!+$"9!(8(1((!!((!1 !%'5!9! (9 %4#%#% + #%2(!1#!% $()1,9#$(!4(!$!%  #%%1"!("#%+7! '!!%4(7!1%" , +!"945#%"!#$5"@#%2+! (#5)( 8$(!F)#(!1   2  #%   !"+  %1  !7!(*  1")9!%   +)2+  8+#5!  1!5#%2  8# +  +! 1")9!% (*!7#1!%"!,+1(!!((!1 !81")9!% $,') 8+#5!(!%1!(#%2 #%1#%2$1#1% !7!%17!(   +!(!9!% #%!11")9!% $,8+!(!$% +!"% ((*, +!38!(44!55 !)( ,'!#%2 +!5$ )( " %1 58,!%<#%!1)4%%'5#2 #%$4!(!" #% ,17!( !1  +!

$9!%1,#%9*7#!8,(#2+ 5*1#$9#$$!1 +!$)#  %" , +!1!"(!!$)!(!1'*0( (,#!, +!45#% #$#%"! 1!"!$!1 8$% ()1)5!% ,$"%"!1!18(# !%$  !9!% %1 +! $  !9!% % +'(!+#$ +)9'#94(!$$#%$ 55, +!(!8$$9! 4(!$$)(!)4%0( (,+!8)51+7!1!#%# !5* 51 +!)1#"#5 #"!( (!2(1#%2 +!55!2!1()1 +!(!  #$  % +!(  $ ( 5#%2  " (  0( (  +#9$!5  44!(!1 '!(! +!(!7!%)!) +(# #!$ !(4$$#%2 +!<)129!% %11!"(!! 1 !1-/=B K %12  +!9)  #%$%" #%!1#%7)( +! (!$4%1!% ;1!!%1% $ ")51'!)%1!($ 1 + $9!()1 +1'!!% 45*!1  +  #9!,')  +!9)  #%8$!" !1 !( +(!!9% +$ +! 4$$#%2 +!1!"(!! $4!"##"7!(9!% +1'!!%91!#% +!8(# !%$  !9!%

8

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

( +!(!$%$$  !1'7!,%2()%1(#% !(!(!%"!#$ 91!) "%")(8# + +!<)129!% %11!"(!! +!38!(44!55 ! )( $)'$ % #5F)!$ #%58(#$!$(1! !(9#% #%'* +#$)( 

!$)5 % 5*, +!44!5#$1#$9#$$!1 =>;51*+8/  (')# 421 %&:?$ )1512@3 A2

 B2A

)151 5> B2A