← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/11166/2024allowed

Jagbir v. The State Of Haryana

2024-09-10Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari11 pages

             !"#!$  

#%&'( &) * '!+ , , 

  

  -     

 +  ./,-0/ 1

 

 

 

 

    !  "# $%  0/ 1 ,,

2#3   

& '

 

  

( )                     * +      +   ,-  (.

 

  /0/((/(1  2 4&5   !

  (/2+52525 6& .0 "

!



   *7 " "  *7" // --  ( )  

 /0/((/(1    ,-

         

 % &(0/7 



%  

8 % 1 )        ,- 

4 9) !$:

  !" $  )% /0/((/(1  -  ;   !   !-  1.< $!*      =$*  0(   *  +  (666 #     +   $/0#;&6>( =!- 

&/<> ?

  *7               

    

%       +

      +7        +       "  *7"      3  +   * '!)

 

    "  *7"-



  

  +     +      +

  

@("

!         !"   +

  A  

  =!- 

&/<> ?

-   %

+   '!)

 



   "  *7"  



    %B 

 

+    

%+%

   

   %2  5     %

+     

 8 %  

+C% :

7 :    "  *7"

  %       3  +    

0/"

! 

  B  +C% :

7 :

     "   *7  "             3  +   -  %  %

 

% +   +   % 

#A

 +%    +% 7 % +   

#A

  %   %  

  %  

        +  C  %       - 



 -  %  

  

 % 

  %+%%     

   

+   

#A

 +%     D  

  %    +%+C%  

 )

   %  +C%- 

*#A

: ! E+ ! !":'?!"   % +  >.&(@0@(0&    +  >@6</<@(.(  

 +

 

  

 

     

6 *#A

: !!

E+ ! !":'?!

"              )

*#A

: !!

E+ !  !":'?!" 

        3   +E  +          

      %

    !!

E+ ! !":'?!

" 

     

 +C%

+C% 

   

+%! E+ ! !":'?!")  



   

 %

 

+



 +

 

+ 



   +% 3   



!

+C% 

+%

    

%

     +C %      

      7   +% 

     3   +     -+  + *$!)  3   +   *  +%  7

%   3   +   *&(0/7

 %

  &(<(7)   +    A   

    1    ;! 3    2  5  

     

    *  +  (666 #    *#A

: !!

E+ ! !":'?!"3     "!        7   +% *#A

: !!

E+ ! !":'?!")   3   +   * A    %

    A  +    7

      %



+% ! E+ ! !":'?!"  

   

6@/ 

7  +C%+%

 &(0/7*



(/ 2--52*5 6& .0 :,"

! "

  

=!- 

&/<> ?  

   



 882  

@(5 

  !"   7     

+%   

  

     !" 

 

  

,- +%                         % 

-    :          - + %  !    +

    -8 

 =   -      !-7 $!* D   7  

 %      :)=

  

   $*! 

0</ "F --- -      /   -/        @ '

     7    +  +     

   +

 % 

  

,- 0 !  +  

%   !

  @( 0/ "

!

  +





  % 

 6 !  %      %   

    &%  <   %   +  

              



  %+    + < !   %   +      % 

  

   %+ 

8 % 

        . 

   !

   %

7  

  +     %



            +    

  8 %



!

 1<"

!



  %   

7   + > )%   

 



/</>(/(@ +%%   !"

E

 "!

2$G5 *7"    % 

8  

   +

7        %        &/   

  

    /&%  /<  /(%  %   

    %     && $  +  

&.

 

+% 

  % 

+

3    &(



+7               

  +%            %        

   

   

     

4 &1

    )+          E         +%   $ H+

*

%+7 &><.

    7E 

   

  " "#$% &'((  )**(% &'(+  ,&- ./.

)                



      (& * 

  - )  % +E  +  

   

%  + %              

  %   

        +  



    % &@ )  

%      $       + *  7      

    

    9  

     +     % 25   &0 - 01234

"

"33"

  3$% ,&'+8- )  .9.

 .+9:.++%

   + 

+% $ H+

*    %4

 

     

          

    



 ! "!

   #

$%&      ' (  (

  

)  "*  + !, $%& (

 &- .&%!  &/01    2        

  !  

     3         

                 

 # 

     

    +



 ! 

!



45 (   "   

    " +

    *)   #  "  + !  ,  $%6$ , 70&.8 1  "!   8 &%/    

8

&6% ( ! 

 8   '(    

 

 

      8 &%    

8 &6  " (   

              

      "   



8  &%/                      2   + "'9'  !,$%6$ , 67- 67/  "

 +#

+  

      '(  !" 

    

 (   

  ,    '  (  !  "

 +   + + +

            +#

+ 

      +  

 



 "      + "   (+  (  



      ,      + +

   #

   

   +             ,   + 



   



 + "   

 #



  ,  +   



   +  "  

 +   +   

  ::

::

::

% ; 8 "8 .<,+ 1.$%/1$ 8(($$/  " ;  +!!   #

(  ! = 

     +   +

   

    >      +    " 

2 

    = 60 ,+  .!? /!/0-!

6%1  @ =A    

         ! 

    !       

!      +   8 2 

 + +

              + 2  2+



    !    +   3        B    

  =    3  

 

     "

+ ! + "

 + 



2" ,

 +  

          "  "

   

 2



     &6 , ! 01!"4 "

2";

11   2 21 713"

72 12% "5

12   2 72! $% &'(+  ,1<2; 12- *)'% $ H+

*

 7    -%

 



  + 

%>    "         #     

   

         

     2  

    ! 

 !  3





 +    

           C      

          #   ++   

       ! 

+                 



 + ++   



  "   +    

!  

 "  $0>     , $+# "  

+

 "  +                 !  " C             

 ++

  8  

   ,  $% !   "     +      "       



   "  +     

 "     C 



 2   C     "   " "      

  $$A+  

   

    ! 2  

  

 +# 

+     +        

    

   

       +   

   ,        2         +  + 

  +  D 

5 !   " 

!  + !4 ++

 4

  

       !  

    ? E   4  5

   2 !  + 



     >          #           

            !   

 

       3  + 

       !"  + !    C2!    

 "  "    +#               "      2

   $,  

 "  , "  

"     "  

C+   2 

  +   E 2 +        "    + +  "" + + !"   ++

"!+ "!

      

" !

    +  " !

+

  ++



 2  4 

4!   "  ) #  2 

   #          ++

  >!

   +             ! 

    8   2

  +    

  " #    2     "  ( $6  ?    +     "!        

   

      +  A      "

!  3

 ! 

+ 3

       (   FG!

>  +  +  2+

  

  2     !  "     

       4  "   ( 

    "    

 , !            "      +

#      

   C

    

   +

  "!  2+

3

  +        !    #  

 !  !+   

 

 

 +    +        " "  " " # " 

  ,



 +   C  + "   +

              "

+  !  !+   

B        2    

        3        +   

"   +    



 +  

 +

  &< ) $ I+

*  3"

724

21

  !" $% < " 6  << ,2";"

-

*&9'

 )8)/%  

!

 1< "

!   7    %)      E 

   @   @C

&,

  

  8 6

)<8, !      

H8    >! $     +  8      @ +   

             "  



! ++

  +    

+   

       >        !   

+      +      +

  



 , $ (     !    

+  " 

+    8 6.$1. 1.1 )<8,  &. -   

E 

 +%    =3 1<2; 12

"

>6!

01;

3"

"4



   2 2    2% )8)* ,/-  ,2";"

-% *'* +

 % 

 

%       

+

 

  (&)   

 4 $/(+ 

      +>+ 

 "

   ! " 

+ 

+ >+  +



+

  3

!2"     !

" 

 " 

 A +  ++

!"

    +#

 ++ +>   +     +!+  !  "   



 

 I  +  !      "       



 I+  !    + !  +  +  +

 

 

    "  $% 8  

     

          "     

+

  "    , $ ( 8  

    

        + ++

 ,  $ (  "  + 0  A  +                

I

 " > "C     +  2 +  





  " 



   !  C"

  +   &> )  *    3           

   + 



    25           

+ +    (/ )     +

 



 + 4  25    %  

 25        

 %/&% /<  /( %  %J 25     

J 25  % + 

 

   % + 

8 %J25  7       %

      H

 %/& 

  

    +

3   

     &.  

 

 J  25    

        +      +% 7

    +   +J25 

 +

 +%       + E 

+%               

      





*    7  %+      

 /  (& *      +    *

   

     +    ) 

  

 

    

     

   





 #33'6&$)   +   +    ++   %  +                *      

*

"

% 

 (( $   

          

              

4!

+  + %  7  

  

7      + 

+% *     %  +   4 4+   

 

   

   

  % (1 $   %   +   4 4+   

 

     %

   

  (@     25   $ *7'*&$  %  0/ 1 -&7%&89&2 :     +" ?  7      ?   +