← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1657/2019dismissed

Chief Engineer Punjab Roads And Bridges Development Board v. M/S Som Datt Builders Pvt Ltd And Another

2019-03-19Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal3 pages



       

  $%&'(&)*+*,- .

 /*&',0*,&&1 2,3$4 $(+ $,(*(0&+&5&678&,%$(  &%*%*,&    9   ":+8$%%2*6(&+ 5%;%( $,($,%/&  &+7,(&,%+ "-  <;"

  =;

&+&,%- "+>+/*%$/$2/$,11 2,3$4  ???????

 =;1 ;# /&  7&+&,%  7&%*%*,  *+  (*&)%&(  $0$*,+%  %/&  (&  ($%&(

@ 

17$++&(4A%/&((*%*,$6*+%*)%2(0&188&)*$62%1 ;2(/*$,$ '+/%1%/&*$62%#1(*+8*++*,0%/&$776*)$%*,'*6&(4A%/& 7&%*%*,&+&&>*,07&8*++*,%/&&*,%6&$(&5*(&,)&*,+277%'%/& 43&)%*,7&%*%*,'*6&(4A%/&%$%&2,(&&)%*,.@'%/&4*%$%*,$,( ,)*6*$%*,)%1 '+/%1%/&)%# /&  '$)%+1  *,  4*&'1  B/*)/  $&  &C2*&(  %  4&  ,%*)&(  ' $(32(*)$%*,027,%/&7&+&,%7&%*%*,$&%/$%%/20/$,$4*%$%*,$B$( ($%&(@



 %/&&+7,(&,%+B&&/&6(&,%*%6&(%&)&*5&'8%/& 7&%*%*,&$,$82,%'1.1@1 :$6,0B*%/*,%&&+%DE7&$,,28 B&' 

@%*66%/&($%&'7$++*,0'%/&$B$(/&&+7,(&,%+B&& '2%/&/&6(&,%*%6&(% 6$>/+$+)+%+/&7&%*%*,&B$+0$,%&(%/&& 8,%/+<%*8&%+$%*+'A+2)/$B$('$*6*,0B/*)/%/&$B$(&($82,%B$+ (&&(%)$A'2%/&*,%&&+%DE7&$,,28'8%/&($%&'%/&$B$( /20/  $  7&%*%*,  2,(&  &)%*,  .@  # $#  '  %/&  )%  %/& 7&%*%*,&'*6&(*%+43&)%*,+%%/&$'&+$*($B$(($%&(@



 F/*6&

G H +2)/43&)%*,+B&&7&,(*,0$(32(*)$%*,1$,$776*)$%*,B$+'*6&(4A%/& 7&%*%*,&+&&>*,0%/&&*,7&8*++*,'%/&*$62%%6&$(&5*(&,)& 2)/$776*)$%*,B$+(*+8*++&(%/20/%/&(&2,(&)/$66&,0&*,%/& 7&+&,%7)&&(*,0+ ;&$,&(%$%&)2,+&6$77&$*,0,4&/$6''%/&7&%*%*,&/$+ 4&&,/&$( ,I 

      J

#@1%/&,<46&7&K2%/$+/&6($+2,(&-

%B*66%/2+4&+&&,%/$%+7&&(A&+62%*,'$4*%$6(*+72%&+/$+ 4&&,%/&&$+,'&,$)%*,0%/&)%1$,(),%*,2&+%4&%/& &$+,'$((*,0$8&,(8&,%+%%/&+$*()%%+%&,0%/&,%/& $'&+$*(43&)%L2*%&45*2+6A1*'*++2&+$&%4&'$8&($,($6 &5*(&,)&%$>&,*,$+288$A7)&&(*,02,(&&)%*,.@1%/*+43&)% B*664&(&'&$%&(%*+$6+,%/&)$(+%/$%*'*66

'

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

@$776*)$%*,1B/*)/*+$+288$A7)&(2&B&5&1%/*+ 32(08&,%82+%,B4&&$(*,%/&6*0/%'%/&$8&,(8&,%8$(&*, &)%*,.@ #$,(.@ # &$(1B&)6$*'A%/&6&0$67+*%*,4A +%$%*,0%/$%$,$776*)$%*,'+&%%*,0$+*(&$,$4*%$6$B$(B*66,% (*,$*6A&C2*&$,A%/*,04&A,(%/&&)(%/$%B$+4&'&%/& 4*%$% B&5&1*' %/&& $& 8$%%&+,%),%$*,&(*,+2)/ &)(1$,($&&6&5$,%%%/&(&%&8*,$%*,'*++2&+$*+*,02,(& &)%*,.

G.H %/&7)&&(*,0+2,(&&)%*,.@'%/&)%$&+288$A7)&&(*,0+$,( *,+2)/7)&&(*,0+,*++2&+6&$(*,0'$6&5*(&,)&+/26(4&$66B&( $+%/*+B26((&6$A%/&'*,$6*M$%*,'%/&$4*%$67)&&(*,0+B/*)/B26( 4&$0$*,+%%/&8$*,43&)%4&/*,(&,$)%*,0%/&)%%/$+'2%/&4&&,/&6( %/$%*,$,$776*)$%*,'+&%%*,0$+*(&$,$4*%$6$B$((*,$*6A,%/*,0 +/26(4&7&8*%%&(B/*)/*+,%4&'&%/&4*%$%42%*'%/&&$&8$%%&+ ,%),%$*,&(*,+2)/&)(1$,($&'2,(&6&5$,%%%/&(&%&8*,$%*,' %/&*++2&+$*+*,02,(&&)%*,.

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

 G =;H +/$8+/&    F/&%/&+7&$>*,0:&$+,&( - &+: F/&%/&&7%$46& -&+: