← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/201/2003disposed of

Naresh And ORS. v. State Of Haryana

2019-05-29Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu9 pages



      



 !""

# # $$%%  & '  ()   $  !" #$%&' ()*+,' -+./0 !

 #$%&' ()*+,' +#1'/+#20/+10( *  $'"+# ,-"#.! .  #$$%%   /"#%0+." "%! 0%.() 

-+./0 ! 3

 1#  $ $$%  "  " " &   +"  2&+,   

        

.    4)  '"  5&+.

6"4."'"1"% 7  

$$%% # '&8!#+8" # " #!$&"#4%& '! " .

8" #'! " 9* 1#)8!"!   !  &  '! "   9*    &+    )  "+& ",$",  $)"

:!#"&% $),  ". & #&+, #"+&",$", 1#)8% !"!  !&'! "

8" #'! " 9*  &+%"",$",  $)"

:!#"&%  $), ". & #&+"+&",$",  8, #

 # # !8 &!!& %) 

1#! #$!& ""& #%%" # 

.

!"$ / 1 ,+,*%"!'  ".- 8%" # 2)'#, #!""2&""!!" 8," ";! "!%  .  6"4.  '9  5+  '"+#  !#  #  (  !  #   , .;< *:

&=#-&, !!"+ #",.#8 & 

>  "/")". +#% 2)'#,8#" !%%%8 (2)'#,#+,"%%+%"    #!,)  ##& #""5" %"5  "%%+##$%!    )"+ #4& 3 ,"& . #) 8!,"+4!= "%%+%" 2)'#,8""+ #!  8#"%#8$"%%"" ?# #)!# #& =" "%%+ *" #%. 4& 

@%!=. #)8, !)!% "+4) #"  #8" # 84)" "  #,8-&%"$"  *" #%.8#8 & 

# " #"!#%.8##"  =8 #, #$ -&%"$8#"+ -&%"$ "+% 8 #" !!"+%). #,4),8" # " #"#%!,  4 "+2)'#,8" #  &  #"2&".! + & ! % 1#)%%8 #  9,," %)!,$%" + &$ 8 # 2)'#,8 4%"+,#"#,& # (4!,&!!"& 1#!!& 8), #$ 2)'#,8 = ",($" %. *%8%.,8##8 ;! "!% .6"4 1#"2&"8!& 2)'#,& % ! " =$%! 4 82)'#,-&%$'"+#4&  8, #$"  # !!&!  9 "+ "8!,$%  !#%%8$& &$  !,$% "%% #!%,%" " 

 1#$!& "<,"&,48" "&$$  #! 1#  ,  #!!&8%!&'! "  *  1#)" #! #$!& " 1#!!&8 !"!  !. "!4 (!. #$ $$%  A  !&%  $$"+    4#%    #  $$%%  #, %)+& #  #$!& "#"% $" ! A !&%$$"+ #'  #, %)+& #  #$!& "# $" !4)4%&4 &$$  #2&+,   #%& 4%8  ?##%!&% #$ "+ #&+# #2&+, !)!&%%)  * ' *"#!&!  #$ , ,<," " (# "! #%%8"+"2&" #4)!2)'#, 4&"

!,<!,""C% " #.<  %  %+"#  4&"

!,<!,"+#  %+" #  A! 8&7!,< !,"+#   $" %+"#  $8& !,< !,% $" % +"# "! "!%$#, ,"%"+8#% !%$8$ & #"! "# ! &%  %.% $" %."+#  % "+# $" %48$  ",  & " #=&%% #&+#! &"  6 % $" %%4"4"8%!  A"D&" !% 4%8$ " #4 4&" !,< !,% !# 8%%" # " ! %$! 

3 4&" < !,% !# 8%%" #"  ! %$!  4"!,< !, "&!% = 4"

!,< !,,"%$! &$$

:$ "+# %+ E !!"+  #$"" #! . #!& #8#"2&). 8#"!#8 , ," &&"!"  !& #"") !& & ($$ , ,$ .;< * 92&"  # !!&%4!&4)4%8  '95"'"+##! #69  *?7&=#-&," #, "%8"  (  "" # 

.#%+8" #2)'#,#+ "%%+##$% !    ## #!,)5" @4 # 1#)!# # 

  1#) ) #4& 3 ,"&  1#)  !,"+4!=  #""%%+ '! 84"+"4)2) '#, (8$"%%""  4& 

*  .8# #)!#

"*" #%. #)8!!&-&%$ #4) "+ #, !)!% #" "+ #,.!!&-&%$"+% , #  #4)!,& , #" -&%$ 8,8" # 1# # #4)8%#"+ 1# !!&$ " #& 8 8&  # #4)8##!, , #" #"+%,4)-&%$ (" !%%!  # , #4).8#8$ "& 4& #!&%!+" #, 4)! 1#4)  +""+$ 4%8#",2) '#, !!& 4%8. #! 8 & ! % (  "! # 2)'#,84%"+,#"# 1# .

#D& $ " #%$#", 2)'#,8,  ",($" %.*%8%.,8##8 ;! "!%  .6"4 ("  , .;< *:

.8!4) #$%"! 1#)%%8 & /")". #+% 4&  8 , #$"  #!!&!.D&%# =$%!4 82) '#,-&%$'"+# (#!, =8 #,!!& $  %     8#"!#  #  #  "!%    #  $%"!  9  #"  ! <," ".#$ #   #"!" .## #!!&" *%"!'  ".*%8% *%"!#!%%#", " ") #!!&  #)8  (#!, =84&  #, #!!& , #!#% (" ,,4 8##"!% #, !!&    #",  1#)  #    -&%$     #  4)  8" #  # , !)!%," !  1#$ #! 8

="%, $#& (" !")"2&) %% #4)#!& "2&" 2)'#, (!&%  8#"!# #!!&# +"  "2&)    8#  $    2)  '#,  1#      8#"!#  # !!&! =$%!84&),$8%8="+ " #"%4) 4)!,, #"% #$4) 1# "2&"8!&4) #!!&8#"% #! 8", "   !&"+"2&". #!!&8)  '&##  "" # $,"%%+*" #% #  ",  #  2)  '#,  #  !"  "2&"  "    !!" 1# .#% ",($" % 1#! ",($" % % # !" "2)8"& 1# . #)!#;!  ($" %.8# #!  % # 2)#%)<$" ?#"% #) 8,"+2)  ##$" %. #8)&=# %#", # 2)

B # !""2&""!!" (& #"!% # 8#"%# 2)8+"+ ##$%. #)8%%84)-&%$  #4), !)!% 1#)8%$ " #$ )4&  #) % %" (& # % # 8#"% #)8 &"+.-&%$  #4) $$ #, !)!%=2)  $ #!  1# . #4)8"+% !, #$ %% #4) !&"2&" 2)'#, 1# . #!!&8), # $

'95+ '"+#$ # #!"/ 1 ,+ 

,*%"!'  "- 8%" # 2)'#,#!" "2&""!!" (8  ;! "!% ! #   , .;< *:

.&=#-&, 698+"  ( =#" !% # (! #  , &=#.'&##% # ($$&+#" $%.;< *( 9#"!<," ".# $ # ,!!&*8-&,#!,  #=8%+ '9+#4"'"+# #!)!!&! 1#/ 1 ,+8 !" 3

*  ($$ #"D& $ 

+#4"'"+#$ # " "+ "8 &  #", 1#,"!!&-&%$.'&.#.'&"% *88!",.8##!&"2&" !2)'#, (!" #", " # !!&-&%$&" #& '#"*  '#,.59.*%8% !!&-&%$8$&!" # & 5.6"4 (8 #  2&"!"%!& )4)5 ?# #)!#+#8=.*%8%.5+4"#,4""  *" #%$&!!!&#'&." #& 1#)8 2" "  #  " "+ "       #," #  %  $&!

7 , !)!%  9  8  = "   $"  9 #" !<," ". # $  #  #  #    ,  )  $$%"! "    !&! "+  # " ""! "$ #!!&  1#$!& "!$!"%)" # *?7&=#-&, 2)'#,8!,"+4!=!   #""%%+  "+ ## #!,)5" @4 #  4& 

*  .

8# #)!# "*" #%. #)8 !=4)!!& -&%$#"!,$" 2)'#,!""2&"#"# ( 8 = ",($" %.*%8%.,8##8  ;! "!% .6"4 (8!% 1#!&  #$*?

 * ' *"#8#"2&).8#"!#8 , , " &&"!"  !& #"")!& & ( $  $ , ,  $ .  ;< *  !!"+    #",.  "2&"    # !!&%4!&4)4%8 

*?7&=#-&,#  #,"8#"!# # "2&"  8  +"  4)  #  !!&    2)  '#,  9  #"  ! <," ".#$ #   #"!" .## #!!&" *%"!'  ".*%8% *%"!#!%%#", " ") #!!&  #)8  (#!, =84&  #, #!!& , #!#% (" ,,4 8##"!% #, !!& #", 1#8#"!# #!!&! =$%!84&)  *$%88="+" #"%4) 4)!,, # "% 1#"2&"8!&4) #!!&8#"% #! 8" , " (,"  # % 4%#C, #"2&"2) ("!% #8% "8" #4%4& #" +"#"!% #  #$%"! 1#!8,"" 4 "+4) #4) (8

% #$8##!!,$"!2)'#,  # #$" % 

1#, 8" "+ 4)*?

'95+ '"+#

+#4"'"+#  8,  A!&% #$$%% +& # " 8! !!" 4& &!#&++ "8$&  *?  * ' *"# (#  "!,)"+# "2&" #$! 

1#, " "4&   #!!&8 # % ! " =$%!4 8!!&-&%$2)'#,4&  8, # 4!=    #  !!&!  1# .  #  !!&  8  %="+     $$ &" )  % # !8" #2)'#,  #!!& -&%$8 "+ # ("+% # #4) 8 # " !!"+%). #4),8" #!,   4 "+2)'#, 1#"2&"!& 2)'#,8$ % 1#!!& #!8 &  #,!#% 9 # *." 8$  # " 8!$%  1#, "  "4& " #"D& $ "%$%"$&  

1#&+# #, " "4&   #!!&" #  #8 % ! "4 8!!&-&%$!2)'#,.#8. " # !,! 8# 8 # &"$&  9" 8 D&%"+# 8# #)69!,$%" 8%++" ) # $ )  A!&% #$$%% #+& #  #"!"  !&'! "

9*" 8&%4!&'! " 3* 999* (8.8 #!""8 #  #"! 8&%%%8" #" #,4" '! " 3* 9.!""+ #!  #

#$$%% # #"  " !& #4)#" "+$ %)  ##2)'#,  !!"+%). #$$%"$ %)%%8 1#!"! " 4 # #$$%% "! ,'! "

9* '! " 3.* 9 9*  1# !$$%% 8&$

1# "#4=" 

4)8 $  $  #$$%%  #   1#"4"%4& ) 4%) !!%% 9"8&""!&". #$$%% "!  4$ "& 

 4# #D& &, !   2"'#, 5&+  ("'"+#'"#&   5&+ ?# #$="+: F:  ?# #$ 4% F: