High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1156/1994allowed

Karnail Singh v. P.S.E.B.

2024-05-21Mr. Justice Suvir Sehgal5 pages

# $%&%!'( )

)

*( +, *

- ,

!"#!$%& '% "(()) *% "&

!+!$%& '% "(%! *% "&

,,, - ,

.,/ -

" %!"))! (%%'*% "*%$.% !(()

"/ $%)$&%##%01 %%')+!'&

3% "4%'&%$ &'& * 5 4'%#.

--67.-889

&%! (() *'% " %1

&"))5 5 "&%&1 ' ! 5&%!!*/*% "%1 *)%+

)!!&%' +" )"+ +%4 5"((! !( );# % 1 -8<8 " ))5 % " ! 1( ! #%% " &%!1& %' " ;# %! !)%5"!" &%))51+$!+ "%+&1% &!

!-9 =< -8<8 1 "# %' %((5%' +% &# + "'1 1''& + #(%!$ !%!!

!=7 =7 -88= + "%1 "%)! 5/!( )01 / /( %!() ''.

(()) +!*!'%#(( 5 "!( );# % +" &""&"))5!*'% " 5"%1 ! + !*/%! !

! => =8 -88= (! ?

.-2---.-8<8 ' )! & $ ) 1

&"))5 5 " #(% %%'(1 "# %' %((5%' &# */ ' ) 51 '%!&)

(%% &!'! ' )!+

# +"

+1*#

!%'(( 5 ";# %() ''

!(%$%& $)%5 "%+&1% &+ 1! %" #!

'%))%+ 5 " (%&!1 (& *! 1! " 1@*

)& & /%! #()%/ 1 "# !(()51) %-8>- A'%"% B "51) %CD# %(1 "# + #(%!1(% " # ''! !% ' )/() & %! 1+'#!% " ()! 5%' "( '

"/)!$ !&!+"! ) %1 */@1!5# !!&!

!27 =2 -88:! # ! "1

''# !11&&'1) "' (()+" &"+! # !

*/ " )! !!

%) & 1!5 3 !4% % 2:

=< -88: 1) 5

%%' "( (()

"$ "! &%1) '% " ( ! &% !! " (& $1*# %

%! %! # " 1%' "(1 "# #(%!

1(% ( %% &!(%!1&"1!

")$ $ &51) .

!"#$ %&$' ( ) * (

)

* (

)

* ( )

%,!"#$ %&$'

()

* ( )

* (

) * (

)

+ ( -)

+ $-

-----/ <

(1)%' "*%$(%!1& %"%+ "() /%'

+ ""%)! 5 &# + "&1#1) $''& "*!& *! #@%() / %&!1'% #(% 5#@%() "*) !

!%+ 51) %<!8+" &"(%$ ! '

$ 5"%+ &1% &1(% "!) 01 #()%/!&% ! 5" ()/ & % '%1! %* '& %/!( )01 /" %* &%!1& !

'! E(%! "$% % % " (%&!

"$ 5"

+/(%&!! % #(%#@%() / "(%&!1 !%( !*/ "!'! % &%'%# /+ "51) %

" &%)% " #(15!(1 "# %!&% *1 !

+" ) ( 5 " 1@* $ )$ &A 1 "# !

(()D1)-8>=1(#%1 "")! " %((5%'

1) &# + "&1#1) $''& #@%() /! "# &% * #(%! + "%1 "%)! 5 !( ) (%&! 5

"'%$ ! "@1!5# !!&(!*/*% " %1 *)%+ *! % %%1 ((& % %' " $ & 51) %!!$ %* !

1) %' "'%5% 5! &1 %@1!5# !!& (!*/*% "%1 *)%+ !! "1 ' )!*/ " () !&!

'! .(%! ! & % ! *1 "%'(/ & % + " ( %!

%''%1#% "'%# "!

%'&%##1 & %%'&%(/%' " %! )%5+ " F7G(

'%# "!

%'+ ""%)! 5 )) "!

(/#

" 5&%1)'% "(%! "1*#

"(%&!1(& *!1! "51) %"% *'%))%+! %((% 1 /"%1)!*5 $ % "!'! % 4 "!( ) (%&! 5 % " )%5 &)!

" 01 &% *&&!! %

% (! 5'% ") #% " "!&! ''.

(()) " $! " (%! ! ! '%# $ & %

5 "5%'1(1 " %1 %' "$ + % ) * /!$ %*5 % "(%!

-2

(() ))%+!

! 5(() & %AD '/! (%!%'

)

.- ,/

JUDGE ?" "(4 5E%!

E% ?" "(% *) E%