High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6781/1997allowed

Gurlal Singh Etc. v. F.C. Etc.

2017-11-22Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath7 pages

! !"#$#%&

! !"#$#%&'!()!*++ '!()!*++ '!()!*++ '!()!*++,+- ,+- ,+- ,+-

.*//#%01%2 1!*$ ! # #%!*$ 3$ 1! ! .%4)%2 1!*$ !$5%2!% $

6& 6& 6& 6& 786996 786996 786996 786996

*!$!% & 6*$:/,2'" !,

* 1!5! # #%!*$ 6$.%#% 9.*,,.%4) 6*9%:/4# #%01,*2'" !,:# 1 6*)1#$1!;44,2'" !,

**!$5%2!% <

996, 996, 996, 996, 1!5! # #%!*$1'!5*=!2 *:*# #% 1!% .*! "!* #**#

* >.$1#%0 1! *2!*$ 2 !2 +?-

+ 5$$!2 )= 1! ! /!(!% ((#$$#%!*, !1)#/# #% !5* (!% , .%4) @%%!A.*! B, 2 !2

? 5$$!2 )= 1! !5. = ((#$$#%!*".(1#!

! /!(!% ((#$$#%!*,.5%0*@%%!A.*! +B%22 !2

5$$!2)= 1! #%%"#/((#$$#%!*,!'!%.!,.%4)@%%!A.*! ?B 1!5*!2!"!$$*#%#% !*!$ *!$5%2!% <,%(!/=,#1*# 8/ *@$#%"!2!"!$!2B:$// !2/%2 //#%0#%91$*$

+C1!*!#% !**!

!**!2 $D 1!/%2#%2#$5. !7E$# . !2:# 1#% 1! 6.%#"#5/ 8#(# 91** C.*)% *!E #% /#!. 1#$ *.*/ "/#( % +- +

<<1!$#2// (!% :$"1//!%0!2)= 1!5!*$%$#%5$$!$$#% %2 1! // (!% :$ "%"!//!2 :1!% 1! ( !* *!"1!2 .5 1! 5!A .* @4.20(!% #$*!5* !2$

< F?B#%:1#"1# :$1!/2 1 1!// (!% (2! #1*#8/ *@$#%"!2!"!$!2B 1!.*)%*!#%

+ /#!. 1#$"/#( *.*/*!:$#//!0/1! #$ *#" !% %26%0#%0

#"!*,//%21*:1#/!2!/#%0:# 1%55/#" #% #/!2)=%!#%

* *%$ !* 1!/%2#%2#$5. !)!#%0%/2/!$$!! 1!$#2!'".!!/%2 1!/2 1 G$*!0*2$ 1!"/#( 1*##1*#8/ *,.%2!* 1!$!91$* %.()!*#$.*)%0*#"./ .*//%2$ #%//=1!/2)= 1!#01.* #% 1!#* *2!* 2 !2 1! F- 1 '!()!*,

< %2 # 1$ )!!% *%$ !**!2 1! .%4)'!*%(!% #%5";0!2!/%2 1!.%4)' #$, 1!*! *!,% "(5! !% 2#$5$! 1#$/%2%2# $2#$5$/:#//)!**%0!2)= 1! !% */'!*%(!% ""*2#%0 1!*./!$H :$/$)$!*'!2#% 1!$#2 *2!* 1 G)!

*! 1! "$! "./2 )! "%"/.2!2 1 #1*# 8/ * /$ "(!#% 5#" .*!%2$$!* !2 1 1!5*5!* =#%2#$5. !12/*!2=)!!% 5.*"1$!2)=1#( *( 1!.%4)'!*%(!% !"/#(!21#$*#01 * 1! 5.*"1$! $.5!*$ *." .*! // 1! ).#/2#%0 !A#$ #%0 % 1!$! ;1$* %.()!*$:!//$%!:!//""*2#%0 1!*!0#$ !*!2$/!2!!22 !2 1!

- 16=,

< !A!". !2)=1.* (,:1:$ 1!*#0#%//!$$!! /%2 1! #(! !'".!!%2125. .5 1!$.5!*$ *." .*! 1#$:%"$ ""*2#%0 1*# * %!# 1!* 1 #% %* 1 //( 12 %= *#01 5.*"1$! 1#$/%2$1*#//(#$ 1! !%% 1#% %21*#//(12 ;!%%!$15%2%!91*;1% *(1*#1% 8/%/!$!%/=H1.$,# :$ .%2)= 1! #$ *#" !% %26%0#%0

#"!*, //%21* '#2! 1#$ *2!* 2 !2

1 1! 5*!2!"!$$*$#%#% !*!$ 1!5! # #%!*$:!*!#%5$$!$$#% 1!/%2#% 2#$5. ! #$ //!0!2 1 #1*# 8/ * @$#%"!2!"!$!2B ('!2 % 55/#" #%% -F

? * *%$ !* 1!/%2#%2#$5. !% 1!)$#$ #%$ *." #%$I!*/#!*2!"#$#%2 !2+

-//!0#%0 1 1!)!//:!2 5.*"1$! 1!/%2// !2 1#(#%!A"!$$@.*)%B 1#$*#01 1!$#2

F *%$ !*:$(2!)= 1!6%0#%0

#"!*1!5*!2!"!$$*$#%#% !*!$ 1!5! # #%!*$('!2 1!1#!

! /!(!% ((#$$#%!*,.%4),:1 '#2!1#$*2!*2 !2+? +

-1!/2 1 1!5*5!* =)!#%0.*)%"./2% 1'! )!!% 2#$5$!2 )= 1! !1$#/2*@$/!$B".(6%0#%0

#"!*, 5*0#%$ 1!$#2*2!*,#1*#8/ *@#%"!2!"!$!2B('!2 1!.* #%%"#/((#$$#%!*,:1'#2!1#$*2!*2 !2+<

, 1!/2 1 1! *2!* 1! 1#!

! /!(!% ((#$$#%!*$ #$ )$!2 % !"1%#"/# = %2 1! $(! :$ $! $#2! )= 1#( %2 *!(%2!2 1! ( !* )"; 1! !5. =!"*! *=".(1#!

! /!(!% ((#$$#%!*:# 1 1! 2#*!" #% 1 1! *%$ !* /*!2= (2! #% '.* #1*# 8/ * )! *!0./*#J!20#%$ 1!$#2*2!*2 !2+<

, ::*# 5! # #%$:!*!

#/!2)!

*! 1#$".* )!*#%0

F)= 1!5! # #%!*$%2 -F

F)=#1*#8/ *

F:$//:!2 %2 1! *2!* 2 !2 +<

:$ $! $#2! :1!*!$ -F

F :$ 2#$(#$$!2 %2 1! ( !* :$ *!(%2!2 )"; 1! !1$#/2* /!$@!2>.* !*$B".(6%0#%0

#"!*,//%21* 2!"#2! *!$1 !* 1!*2!* *!(%22 !2 -<

+5$$!2)= 1!#01 .* , 1!!1$#/2*/!$@!2>.* !*$B".(6%0#%0

#"!*,//%21* (2!%#%$5!" #% 1!$# !#% 1!5*!$!%"! 1!5* #!$%2 .%2 1 1!5*!2!"!$$*$#%#% !*!$ 1! 5! # #%!*$ *! #% 5$$!$$#% %2 #1*# 8/ * #/!2 $1: 1#$ 5$$!$$#% '!* 1! 5*5!* = #% >.!$ #% ""*2#%0/= 1! !1$#/2* /!$ @!2>.* !*$B".(6%0#%0

#"!*, !1)#/# #% !5* (!% , //%21* 5$$!2 1! *2!* % +F

*!4!" #%0 1!5/! #1*#8/ * *5.*"1$#%0 1!5*5!* =#%>.!$ #% 1!*2!*2 !2+F

:$"1//!%0!2)=#1*#8/ *)=:= 55!/ #/!2.%2!*!" #%++ 1! #$5/"!2!*$%$@(5!%$ #%%2 !1)#/# #%B " ,

<? C * $1* D 1! " 7E 1! $#2 55!/ :$

? ""!5 !2'#2!#(5.0%!2*2!*2 !2+?

+ @%%!A.*! B :1!*!#%# :$2#*!" !2 1 !*"(5/! #%0// 1! *(/# #!$, 1!5*5!* =#%2#$5. ! )! *%$ !**!2 #1*#8/ *$5!*$# . #% -F

?""*2#%0 1! 2!5* (!% / #%$ *." #%$ 1! $#2 *2!* 2 !2 +?

+ :$ "1//!%0!2 )!

*! 1! !5. = ((#$$#%!*".(1#!

! /!(!% ((#$$#%!*,5%0*). 1!55!/:$*!4!" !2%

?1! 5! # #%!*$ 1!% #/!2 *!'#$#% .%2!* !" #% FF 1! " )!

*! 1! #%%"#/((#$$#%!*). 1!*!'#$#%:$2#$(#$$!2'#2!#(5.0%!2*2!* 2 !2

8!*%!2".%$!/ * 1!5! # #%!*$1$$.)(# !2 1 / 1.01 1!// (!% 1!5*5!* =#%2#$5. !#% '.* #1*#8/ *@$#%"! 2!"!$!2B:$"%"!//!2)= 1!.5*!(!.* ). 1!//!0!2/=5.*"1$!2 1!/%2#%>.!$ #%% 1!)$#$ 1!#%$ *." #%$2 !2+

-:1!*!$ #% !*($ /.$!F@###B 1!$#2#%$ *." #%$, 1!5*!2!"!$$*#%#% !*!$ *!$5%2!% <:$% !/#0#)/! *// (!% % 1! 1!* 1%2, /!*%!2 ".%$!/ 55!*#%0 % )!1/ *!$5%2!% <1$ '!1!(!% /= *0.!2 1 1!*!#$ "%".**!% #%2#%0 *!"*2!2 )= 1! . 1*# #!$ .%2!* 1! " * 1! 5.*5$! 55*'/ // (!% 1!5*5!* =#%>.!$ #%5.*"1$!2)=*!$5%2!% <:1#"1 1$ )!!% 2%! %/= !* ;#%0 #% "%$#2!* #% 1! #%$ *." #%$ 2 !2 +

-, 1!*!

*!, 1!*!#$%(!*# #% 1!5*!$!% 5! # #%:1#"12!$!*'!$ 2#$(#$$/ 1'! 1!*2 /!*%!2 ".%$!/ * 1! 5* #!$ %2 5!*.$!2 1! *!"*2 1!%/=#$$.!#%'/'!2#% 1#$"$!#$$ :1! 1!* 1!"$! #1*#8/ *#$"'!*!2)= 1!#%$ *." #%$2 !2+

-*:1! 1!*

< 1!"./21'!)!!%// !2.*)%/%20#%$ 1!*.*/*!"/#(:# 1. )!#%0#%5$$!$$#% 1!$#2/%2K %*2!* $!*"1%$:!* 1#$>.!$ #%,# :./2)!*!/!'% *!

!* /.$! @"B L @2B@###B 1! #%$ *." #%$ 2 !2+

- :1#"1 *!2$.%2!*& G@"B :1!*! *.*/ /%2 "/#(% 12 // !2/%2#%.*)%*!H G@2B@###B #% "$! //#%0 .%2!* " !0*= @"B 1! "/#( * 1! *.*/ /%2 (= )! $$!$$!2M?<-I5!*:1#/! 1!5*#"! 1! .*)% /%2 (= )! $$!$$!2 1! * !$ 25 !2 )= 1! !0#%/ ! /!(!% ((#$$#%!* * $."1 .*)% /%2$ 1! // !!(=)!//:!2 *! #% 1!.*)% /%2$ #% 1!#* 5$$!$$#% 5*'#2!2 1!= *! :#//#%0 5= 1! 2#

!*!%"! )! :!!% 1! 5*#"! 1!.*)%/%2 1.$$$!$$!2%2 1! "((. !2'/.! 1!*.*//%2"/#( !* 55/=#%0%!"!$$*=". H $ ( !* " , 1! 5*!2!"!$$*#%#% !*!$ *!$5%2!% <#$% .%2#%5$$!$$#%'!* 1!/%2#%>.!$ #%%2 1!%/= 1#%0 :1#"1 #$ *!>.#*!2 #$ 1! #% !*5*! #% /.$! 2@###B 1! #%$ *." #%$ 2 !2+

-:1#"11$)!!%(2! 1!)$#$ * 1!5.*5$! // (!% /%2 )= 5.*"1$! #1*# 8/ * #$ " !0*#"//= (!% #%!2#% /.$!2@###B 1!#%$ *." #%$ 1 #%"$! 1!/%2 //$.%2!*" !0*=@"B :1!*! 1!"/#(% 12)!!%// !2/%2#%.*)%*! 1!% 1!"/#( * 1! *.*/ /%2 (= )! $$!$$!2 M ?<-I 5!* :1#/! 1! 5*#"! 1!

.*)%/%2(=)!$$!$$!2 1!* !$25 !2)= 1!!0#%/! /!(!% ((#$$#%!* *$."1.*)%/%2$1#$5* 1!#%$ *." #% /;$). 1!* !$ #A!2 * 1!*.*//%2%2 1!.*)%/%2:1#"1:./2)!25 !2 )= 1!!0#%/! /!(!% ((#$$#%!*1!#%$ *." #%$ .* 1!*5*'#2!$ 1 1!// !!$(=)!//:!2 *! #% 1!.*)%/%2#% 1!#*5$$!$$#% 5*'#2!2 1!=*!:#//#%0 5= 1!2#

!*!%"!)! :!!%5*#"! 1!.*)% /%2 1.$ $$!$$!2 %2 1! "((. !2 '/.! 1! *.*/ /%2 "/#( !* 55/=#%0%!"!$$*=". $1!$!5* $ 1!#%$ *." #%$"/!*/=$ #5./ ! 1 1!// !!:./2)!//:!2 *! #% 1!.*)%/%2#% 1!#*5$$!$$#% 6!%#%0 1!*!)=,# 1!// !!#$% #%5$$!$$#% 1!.*)%/%2 1!%1! :./2% )!//:!2). # 1!#$#%5$$!$$#% 1!%1!:./2)!//:!2 5*'#2!21!5=$ 1!2#

!*!%"!)! :!!% 1!5*#"! 1!.*)%/%2:1#"1 $1// )! $$!$$!2 %2 1! "((. !2 '/.! 1! *.*/ /%2 "/#( !* 55/=#%0%!"!$$*=". 1.$ #% *2!* 55/= 1! #%$ *." #%$, 1! 5$$!$$#% #$ 1! $#%!>.%%1!#%%"#/((#$$#%!*,:11$./ #( !/=5$$!2 1! #(5.0%!2 *2!* 2 !2 -

1$ 1.01 *!

!**!2 1! #%$ *." #%$ 2 !2+

-). #/!2 ;!#% "%$#2!* #% 1! " 1 #1*#8/ * @$#%"! 2!"!$!2B :$ % #% 5$$!$$#% 1! /%2 #% >.!$ #% %2 :./2 % // :# 1#% 1! 2!

#%# #% // !! * 1! 5.*5$! ;#%0 2'% 0! 1!#%$ *." #%$$!*/#!*1! #/!2.5 1!.5*!(!.* 5.*"1$! 1!/%2#%>.!$ #%%/=% 1!0*.%2 1 1!12*.*/"/#(#% /#!. :1#"11!"%% ;! 1!.*)%/%21.$/;#%0 *(//%0/!$ 1! #(5.0%!2*2!*$*!5 !% /=#//!0/%2!**%!.$$#%%%! 1!*2!*$ #$$.!*!0*2#%0 1!// (!% 1$)!!%2#$".$$!2(."1/!$$/.$!2@###B 1! #%$ *." #%$, :1#"1 " !0*#"//= 5*'#2!$ 1 1! 5$$!$$#% % 1! .*)%/%2:# 1 1!// !!#$(.$ :1#"1#$"%$5#"..$)=# $)$!%"!#%

1!"$! #1*#8/ *@$#%"!2!"!$!2B, 1!*!

*!, 1!5*!$!% 5! # #% #$ .%2 )!(!*# *#.$%2 1!$(!#$1!*!)=//:!2%2 1!#(5.0%!2 *2!*$*!1!*!)=$! $#2! @996B @996B @996B @996B '!()!* '!()!* '!()!* '!()!*++ ++ ++ ++,+- ,+- ,+- ,+- 1! 1!*$5!;#%0I*!$%!2

!$I 1! 1!**!5* )/!

!$I