← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14292/2002allowed

The Haryana State Coop.Supply And Market v. Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax Pkl.

2024-11-06Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Mr. Justice Sanjay Vashisth6 pages

&1-

!""  

       

!""# $% % 9 & !/*,-3,/-/2

 !-4,**,/-/2   

     

:

(""$;    C 

<



 



    !

C9

     

       ,97 =0   &

,> 

0,  , =0&

0 , (#?"

0  

,   (0@( 

 

AAA 

# "    ,   

$   

$0          "

"  "    #  $   



 $$ %  %& "

   '(  ) )

       *+,-.,/--/0 %#  $  %&

/12:B  /12:



*34* 

05

6 

  *334:3.0*33.:38 *338:

:

33% 7

, /,  



(    



0*382, ("

  

     

   "

( 0    )  0 "

 ) )  (

(   ($" (

% $$ #:" (

$   #  %

   



  

        $

 $  (""$ 

&#



(

"

 

9

0

0 ( 7#   $

   

 

!""&2-

#(  ($ "(

  $

# :#

( %

 

(

#($   

 #(  

 

  #  &$  "

 ( 

8- /



"

1,

 

 "

 %  #  $$ %    &  B  7(

       

 

! " #$ %&  '(& *8/ 9 +1,  7(

      #$ %&  '(&  ((  ) *( +/1* 98*2, 2, D   " &

 ( !: 





 

  

     

 

  



      

 

 



     !    "

  

     

 

       

 

 #  $



  



! 

% 



    

  

    

'  

8- /

 /    *3380% % # (

% 

 -*,-2,*348 ( !: E





 

  

     

 

  



      

 

 



   "

 

!""&3-   # 

 

         

 



 $



  



! 

% 



  (  

  

 

  !

#'

 $   F *338:330

  G   $$ % (

$ #         

   (  

$$ % 0  

/12B /12 

*334:3.0*33.:38 *338:33    # ""$ #$

&$, +,    

$  (#

 %  % ($$  

 $ # (  $% %   %  

& 

  $  % "$  ($

(# $B  

  /1,-+,*334( 

**3

% " &  

% %

#$



    "

  

#

 7(

$ 

(# '( $0  

'(   

&  $%   6#$

#

$#$

"&  & " $

#

$#$

"

() /12:B /12:

  % ($#  %& 

4,    

$ ( (#

$ " H > ,*-+2. *33.:, !    

! " #$ %&  '(& - )&.

,&$ ,  ,) ((  ) *( + - , / 0.

   1 &$ *

,&$ ,&, %&

!""&4-



*33*:3/0*33/:31 *331:32 ( 

/12:B

,



% " -3,-3,*33.% 

"

 

 



&

 1*,-1,*338 $$ % %&

 0 # &, 0  %

 7

 %& "

   "& 

(#

 *+,-.,/--/ &

#'(   

(

#"

$# (  

$%% 

&

(#





"

% $ #    "  &    

( *+,-1,*3340*+,-1,*33. *+,-1,*338, .,

0    (#

 # $ 

$ 

 "

 ( 

 % $$ %

7(  6#$

   (    + #$ *! '(&  ((  ) *( + -&& . /-* 9 118 %  "$$

&($  7(  "

 #

 %    %  $ "

8- /

&$#$

"

#( $

"

0%

#  (

      #$%& '(&4 ("0 7( "

 (  + #$*! '(&6   (" % &($,

 $  "

 % $

 &$#$   "   

 "

      #   

&$ %  

   -*,-2,*348 

8- /

"

$ 0% ($

#

"

*334:

!""&53. *33.:38,#  &  $$ 7(   , # 

#  *334:3. % 8,  "

    !  *   1# '(&&, (( )*(+  *&, /-/*.

3-

  $%$ %   5  *!'(&/-*.3

142 ($$ $$ %  " "$ !:  )## $  *    

 +$ ,     

  !

!  









    

  !   

 

  



  

  

 

 

   

  



- )# # $  

 

  

    





             

   

     



     *  

  !

- )#.# $    /

  0

 *  /# 1&#

3# 

* !





  !

 



 





 !



 4!  

   

 

 

   - )#)# $   

   !

 

 

!  

 

   

   

    *    5  & 

  

 

4

!



*   - )#6#$ * )



 

  *  #

!""&6- $     

 4

   

& !





 !



     78+&  #9 

  

 

      !   



!





 *  )#' 3, H    "(     #  "

 7

 

%&

 (   ($& "&  

@(    (    + #$ *! '(&6 (", 

  &($0  *+,-.,/--/"

#

 #$, *-,

0

$ % ($#"

 " 0   0 %

"

 & , 0 %&

/12:B /12:

*334:3.0*33.:

38   *338:33 %  % $ 7

, 

 $0   *+,-.,/--/   '(      ,  "

   

$ %&

 " , **, % "

 $$$ %, */, $$"  ""$

 

, *1, >

, #

 %   "'

"

  #%   H " )

F )> H "

#$ F )>