Ramphal And Another v. Chief Canal Officer, Bhakra Water Services, Irrigation And Wr Department, Haryana And Others




    
     

  !" #$%$!&'()(*
 




    
 
 


 

     
 
  
! 




"#  '  +

( ,
 ,

,
,
 +

( ,
-
.,,

$%  
 "&#'"( )"&  *+  ,  

+#&#'"( )""#" -"./ 00000  ,

,
,
 /( 

  .

  &      &  (&1  +  "  &  "#  ## 2/ /2/2#4,&#+15#1+ "

///63")/2.7 8&4,&8+++")#4,&&4#+*+# 8&+(&+(+1&+*9#+( / #(")"&4*+&&"## 4,&#+15#18&++&4&#&#(+" /2:;<")&,# +1(.63=:&+))#" >.63=(?<&+# ))+("&&+) ))+( &'    '+",  "8  "'  &  "#  #  4,  &  4"#+ &"++#+)&+#"8+@(+#&*8+"4(", "&(+"/=:=<(("#+1"8&+(&8+&1#"&"+"")&

:/< #*"+&#"#8%("&"##4,& +'++"  ))+(+)+++("((++"")"'++"").63=( ;

#  ("  )"  &    4*+  &  4"&  & (+"+ &(+"/2#/=").63=("4#, #&)"4+1+1"(+"/2:;<+"(+"/=").63=(8+ "4&("(++"1+'4,&#+15#1# &)"&+#"#++4"4+# = #("+1"4&)")&"#% 4*+&"(&1+&(")#&"8")'++"" &&+) ))+(#&+#+1 ))+(#(+" /2:;<&*&"4#&'+1+(+""(+"/=8 -

&'&#&#(")"&+#&' 1"&"1&&()+8+&&+4+( *,4"+(#&(+"/2").63=(#8+&& 8'++" (+"/2:.<#8+&&8&+(&+ )"*&"##4,& +'++" ))+(8&+(&"4 &#4,&+#+1 ))+(8&#(+"/2:/< &+"4&#4,&&+) ))+(B&"##4, (+"/2:;<&"8")'++" &4(")#"&&+) ))+("&+#+1  ))+(8&"( 
 ()"&("#"),(#+1 4)""#+"#")4,,4"#+&"+,""+),8&& &1+,#&"+,"),"(#+1#,+)(" "8+&&@(+"&4)"+1,"#+&'++"& +("(#"4&# &'(+"/2").63=(+

:;< #$% C(      1+  &  #(++"  ")  & +'++"    ))+(  #  4%(+"  :/<  ") (+"  .D  &  +  "  &  +#+1  

))+(8+&+&+,#,")&4+(+"")& (&*#(+".6  &+1+&#(++"")& +#+1    ))+(  #  #  4% (+":.<+1#",")&*("'# #(:<:4<#:(<")4(+":.<") (+".3"&&+) ))+(8+&+&+, #,")&#")(&#(++" 

&&+) ))+("&+#+1  ))+(*,"*"()"&("#"), (  #+1  4)"  "  #+"#  ")  4,  , 4"#+&"+,)"&"")+),+1 &+*)    "  &  1+,  "  "+,  ")  , "(#+1""),"#*#&+#*, (&"#++"&"&*,&+E)+$ "'+##  &  "  (&  "#  &  4  *# 8+&"))"#+1&"))(#""+, ")4+1&# *,4"+(#&&(+"/=").63=(#8+& &"+"")#*"+&#"#G(8%("  H#&+# "'++"&"##4,&4% +'++" ))+((4 (&1#+4)"& +'++" ))+(#"## +&+#&4)+ *,4"+(#&&+#(+"/=") .63=  (  ",  #  8+&  &    8&+(&  +  "  4  #(+##  4,  & +'++"

&1*+#4,&#(")"&+

:=< &"(&1++++*&"'+##)"#'++" # (+" /2 # &) ("*(+" /=8&+ &4 *+"#&&"##+&4)++&"4# &"'++"(+ "8'&+#1*("4((#)" &"&*,+++*")(+"").63=(&(+*8+& 1#""+"")#*"++""+"")&8%("+"4 #(+###(+"/=8&+(&+)&"'++"")'++"1+'+ (+"  /2:;<  ")  .63=  (  +  #"  "  @(#  &  '++"  "8 (")##(+"/2:;< &)(&(+"/2(#(+"/= #""*&'++"9+#+(+"("4+'"E##(+" /=").63=(

&++"")&1++" 4 #"& ++*")&(+"(")+1&"8#.63=( (8&+ #+18+&&"8")#'++"+(")'++"&"8 &41+'"&&+) ))+("&+#+1

))+(8&+(&(4@(+#'
 &*&"4# &*"+",'B(+"/=").63=(" .2 *,4"+(#&&"8")'++"+&(+"/2:;< &41+'""+),&&"+,"8&&&"## 4,&4"#+&"+++1#&"+,"),(& "(#+1#E4,&4"#+"))+(&*&"4# "(#(+"/="#++#4,& +'++"

))+(8&+(&&"+,+"4"#+"&&+) ))+(# ))+(&(&+#'++"9+#+(+"( 4@(+#8&+(&(+"/2:;<").63=(

:-< ..

&(+"/2:;<#8+&'++""8BC, "(#+1F#C,"#F8&+(&(,+#+(&,"## 4,&4"#+&"+,'+)*+#(+"/=").63=( 8+4'+4#(+"/2:;<").63=( ./ &4+11#&&(+"/2").63=(&"# "4*#+(4"(+"/=").63=(("4((#" &1"#&&(+"+ (+"/28(+"/=") .63=(("*#&*&#&'"4#(("#+1,

(8&+#+18+&&8&+(+"/2:;<'++" 9+#+(+"&41+'"+#+1 ))+(8"

&+) ))+(8&+(&(4@(+#
8 &)"+ ("4+#&&@(+")"8#(+"/=")&.63=( #"+#&("")(+"/2:;< 
&&(+"/2:;<&"

4*#+(4+*++1#(+"/=8 .;

&&1*8&+(&&4+#4,&# ("B(+"/2:.<#/2:/<").63=(   &+#1* ("4((#)"&"&#(+"/2:.<").63=( +#+1 1++#,#(+#+1&1+&"# #4,& +'++" ))+(##(+"/2:/<").63=( &&+) ))+(+#(+#+1&1+&"##4, (&8"&"++8&+(&&' 41+'"8")'++"#(+"/2:;<").63=(#, #(+#+1&*(+"/2:;<").63=(&"4+#+ *8&+(&@(++19+#+(+"")'+"#(+"/2:;<") .63=  (   &  *  8+  4  '+4  B  ,  "#  #  4,  &

:7< 4"#+&"+,'+)&*&4##(+"/=") .63=( .=

+1+'+8&4"'&"###23 2/ /2/2# 4,&#+19#1("4#"4'"&"'++" ").63=( .- (#8+&&+++"&#(")"& 4*+&&+4,*,41+'&+(*++4& ('+&*#,#(+".D").63=(4)"&&"+, ("(# #(")"&"#%+""49(+")" &* .7

+1+'+8&4"'&+#+*+#8+& &+4,"1&4,&#(")"&  ,

,
,


  -
.,,



, 0 12 3/*  

 &&E+1G"# !  &&"4 "