M/S Durga Sales Corporation, New Delhi, v. Jagdish Prasad Aggarwal & Co. Delhi Road, Charkhi Dadri And Others
2023:PHHC:049107
!"!
#$%&'%'% ()"*+,-
+.
+ #/ 0 -1! 2..
+"*" ,4!"1+"4,,+0-#4#
+ 2'
+5$ #67- (+'*"
''8-! + $ (+' 3!9*5+ !+410-/43
' "' :::
'
1-- #,
,*-+
#4..
-!"
4!"
*4, /1!0#!/4
4&'%='/.+ -< -- 0!#, - !- " ) 4
" ,!#"
;*4,5
4,!#"
57< 4*7*4, /!+"
-""/ 1+>1! 4+!/ 4
"*!
).-!#
+< "'&)' ' ?
#4" !3!- *!
'& %'%@'=)'%@'=/ 0" !- + +
+< "')/ 01! 1/ "'&)0" # 5
+!-/ "'@) "" !#
#4 "'%%) # ,- A.
#"
+3!#,+ ,!"
4- ,-#
' '
.- 4!#, .+ "/ -- 0!#, !""* " 0 +5 4$ ' 81
! !+5 !" + ,!"
4 .+ +"1!. !+5B ' !""* '!".+ #01 + .+ +" 1!"
!+5#401
3!#4 5!"* +!C
!#"
"*!
'81
,
4"0 1#4
' 0!
#4!
#" "
!.*-
4 !# .+ ' #4 #4 +#".
+1" +3 #4!
#"B
' 81
! "* 4 45,
"') #4 !"
+
"B @' 81
+ 4
' 0" !# --*"!
# 0!
1 4
'#4""* 17
5+ -!7- +.<5 #4 1*" 5!"..+ .+!
4,
4"#4+ 1*"-!7- 45, "B ' 81
+ #< "
"'&%%%) 0" 4
# '0!
1#4*"
+!- "!"
+"B &' 7 !""* 4!"#
#01
.+
! !+5,
4;*"
1!"5 !#-!
* ,
4" *,1
"*..-!
' 1+ *,14
# ' ! B ='81
"*!
!"#
5!# !#7- +5B ' !
!" .+ "
< 5 "'&%%%) 0"
47<4
'' #01
+#< +"
1 0" .+ 54
# ' +,
!#,!
+#"
++ 4!# 3 ! /"-- , 4B %' 81 !"
#
4!" - "!#, #5 -- .+ +" ! !+5!# "*!
'81
"*!
!" -"
#4 +!3 *"#4
+
".
!- "B '
-!
'E ' .
+*"- !- -" 7"!" .+ "/
! !+514 .+ #"!,#5 0"7
> 47<!
14
'0!
1 4!+
-!3
' !#
+5" *5 A'/
++
!3!#, 7!- <7*
'4!4#
--
7!- < #4 1#4 #"!,#5
' 0!
!3!#, .<5 + 7!-
#"!,#5 14 7
-!3 4!#4 , A.+ "" #4!
#" 4!#A'#4
0"# ,
"1 0 + ! - 1#4 +7<4
'
'
.+ ! !+5 0!
,
7!- <' # 4 7 >,+ *#4/
1 "!#
'4!4#
!#7!- < + 54
'7* 14 !-
"1 045, "! #<"* ! 0"
#-< "- .+!
#"!,#5 !'
' "'&) +
"'1
*+ +1 "!#
' 14 !-
.+ 1
"'&/%%%) " "
< 0!
! !+5#4-"
!-
"!45 0"4;*"
4" <0!
! !+5/
/-- !""* "0 !4 3 ! !+5 #4 4
0" .""
4 !# 3 ..
).-!# ! #4,!#"
")4
++
+<
"'&)- #,0!
1!#
FG.
+##*50'
' ' 4
!-!#,
"*!
!-- *-+ -!C #0!
"'
@' ?
#4" ".!
0 --+ "
4;*4,5 #44
4..
--
4! !
7<1 -4!#, "
<4
"'&/%%%) 54 7< ")4
" "
4 4;*"
4 !# "- .+!
"'&)/
/ 7-# 4*
! !+5 0"
"'&)/
0" 5 4! !
4 7< 4
"*!
"'&)0!
1.+ #
"#4!#
",!#"
#44
"'&).""
' ' +,*5 !" ;*4,5 #4 4
.""
4 !"
*4, / 1!0#!/ 4! <!#,
/1"
#.""
++<
#+
+4' &' 13 #"!4 "*75!""!
#" -' =' .
+*"-
+4 + -" 4 ..
--
"!# +4
"
.- # !- .!
" + 5 !+
>"01! 10 5!# 5 !# ,*-+ *+"
7*"!# "" +
!#, # +< !# 7
>"
" +
!3!#, 1 + -4 !+5 #4*"
+!- " !"
+" #4 +"!#, !# 3 ! ""
<7 "!4 "/"
"!4 01 " ! .+ 7!#4 501 0"45!
!#,7*"!# ""#4-
>!#,
7*"!# ""#40"-"
45!
.+ +!##4*"
+!- "!"
+"/ 3!
*" !+54!4#
0!
"" 7 A/ !#"
4 4 .*
4 1!"
+# </ 01 "1 4 *
!,# +# 7 "
<7<4
-4 !+5#4 *#4 "!4 "
+ 7 ! 6"
@ !+5/#4 "!# 45!
4-< ! !+5 0" 5!# !#!#,
>" #4 14 #
7
# .+ 4* 4 7
4..
--
4+ 0.+ "*5.
#,!#"
!
>"147
#.+ 4* "5 0 *-413 , ,!#"
! '1 4..
--
"
#4!#,
+# 14 # ># 04, 7 "
5
0!
-4!#, 5
+!-0!
""/
/#
#-<14 ! 7
#+ 5!""!##
!-!#,+ .-! #7* !
14-"
-44 *5 +< !'
'
>"7 "!4 "!
".+ +/ 7!#4 501 0"0 -- #3 +"# 0!
"
4!4#
""7 A
45!
+4 #<
-- , #"/ "
"*5.
# 0 *-47 4+0#
4!4 "
"'&/%%%) #4 *+ "!4 "
< "
4;*"
"- "'&)/
7-# 4*
! +!,1 -<0 +>
"'&)' ' # -!,1 .
# #
4 7 ..
--
5 4! !
7< 1 -4!#, .-!#
"*5
"'&) #-<' ?
.-!# ! #4!4-<
# .-! # 0" !-
0+!
# "
"
#4
1 "'&/%%%)+
5#4*"
+!- "!"
+"13!#,7
+"
! !+5 #4 "!4 "
< 13!#, 7
# 4;*"
4 !# "- .+!
"'&)' %' #3!
0 .
##
47 !#4!#,"+
+4
4 ..
--
"
#4
"'&/%%%) +
4 + 5 #4*"
+!- " !"
+" 13!#,
+"
.-!# ! !+5 " "
< #4 "!4
5 13!#,7
#4;*"
"- "'&)#4
7-# 5 4*
.-!# ! !+5 +!,1 -< 13!#,
# 0 +> "'&) 4
" #
0++# #< !#
' -0 5* 1 - "" "*7"
# !- D* -0 +!"
#"!4 + #!# !#"
# ,*-+"
#4..
-' ' +4!#,-</ !#4!#,# 5 !#"
# -/ "5 !"4!"5!""
4' %&'%'%