Joginder Singh v. State Of Punjab
!"#"$%& '"$ ()"$'* + ,(#-# )
-$.
/ +#0$ $
1% $2/3(-# "!)4 3"
(#$ % ( *-3)* (1 5 6!
"$( ( $ 0) $ *-5)( 5-$.
/ ()*(-1 $5 6!
777
# "# /"$'
-0
("$'
*(-'* ," $ ($!"$' - 6" 90 $ 1"! ( :("$ "$-$ ()!
"$9 ( "# ('( ('-3 ( / "3 "$( "$ !
# 9
('"# ( -$ ( )!
"$# 5 ;5 <=5 &5 9 $ )!
"$ ; * (1# !
5 9<9
3"! )
"$ )8*> $5
5 "# #0-(5?
$!#-$ ()!
"$#& $ 9 * 63
( /$ 3 $ -$ ()!
"$# $ )!
"$< (1#!
59<9* 6/$ 3
($@ ($ !-$#3 !$ $ #
"$( >* "# 0( "!"$' 6!
5
"# #5 #0-(#"$! !3# #* #/$
3#3:"103"!
"$
(1$ "$ !
##33:$
!!-$ $ "$'!"6"33"
"$$/* *"#(3
"6#"
*1 !!-# 5 :5B- *3 $ "$(#0!
>*"!* * "$!" $ 8 03 ! 3 "$' -$
1-( ( 0(#$#$ 13:1("8)"$'*5 (/* .
$)"$'* $ 3."
)"$'*A !-$#3 *(!$ $ #
*!$
"$##0!"
"! 33'
"$# # * 6"$'/$1-( ( /: "( (1"$.-("#/:,"(# )"$'* / )"$'* >"
* '$( 3 33'
"$# !$#0"( !:
(# "
!!-# >"
* (0( C -( -'* ( ,"(# )"$'* $ $ */*# "$('"$ ()"$'*>*( "$($
"1 "$!" $ > # $ 0(#$
* #"
* "$!" $ /- > # "$
("$'"$ !
#/ ( *"#
#0-( ($ !-$#3 *( !$ $ #
"$6#
"$ "$ #"#!103 5!* $* 3#/$0(#$ 5/#" #5 "$("#
== :
(# 3 0(#$5 #-
("$' (1 $-1/( "31$ #5 (B-"("$'
1$ (16 ("-#*#0"
3# $ >*"3/"$'"$!-# :>
* 5 $ "'
(*
1$ ("
3 "# 3"83:
8 !$#" ( /3 0(" "15 *( (5$-# -30-(0#>-3 /#(6 /:80"$'
"$(/*"$ / (# < ()*(-1 $53 ($ !-$#3 ("$'$/*
* # ( (( * ( ( * 3 ($ "
"$ 3 )##"$#- '5 #0-(
!$
;=
9> #('"# ( "$(-$ ()!
"$#;5 ;
3"!)
"$)8*> $$ */ #"# !103 /:1("8)"$'*#$ )- ()"$'*5(#" $ 6"33 'C 3(C*-( 5 3"!)
"$)8*> $D !
# E5
"$(> ##
$ "$'$ >
-3: (1 >"
*> 0$A"8>"#5
> # ('"# ( $ * / #"# !103 1 /: 1("8 )"$'* #$ )- ()"$'*5(#" $ 6"33 'C 3(C*-( 53"!)
"$)8*> $5 *#"3
5 "# #0-( D !
# E *(#>6(5 A ($ )
-$#3 $ "$# (-!
"$# (1 !$ "(1#
$"$6#
"$5 "$(> -$ "$$!$ "$
('"# ( -$ ()!
"$#;5; $
3"! )
"$ )8*> $ * # " > # ('"# ( $3:
* *( !!-# $ 13: ,"(# )"$'* $ / )"$'*5 >*( # ;=
9 ('"# ( -$ ( )!
"$# ;5 ;
3"!)
"$)8*> $#
$ #('"# ( $ *(! !!-# $ */ #"# !103 /:1("8 )"$'*
"$(> #0(#$ $ *>
-3: (1 >"
*> 0$ >6(5 $"
*(3 ($ !-$#3 $( 3 ($ )
!-$#3 * 6 !$ (6( * #-/1"##"$# 3 ($ !-$#3
"$("#0( "!"$' $ 6!
5"#(3
"6 !!-# $ > $ "$' *!"6"33"
"$D >!
##E$/* *1 !!-# :"$(#0!
*# 1 $ B- >*"!* * -$
1-( (# 8 03 ! #" #5 A !-$#3 ( !103 5 # >33 # 3 ($ )
-$#3 * 6 $ "#0-
"$(> #$ 0(#$
*03 ! "$!" $ $
"1 "$!" $ 5
"$6#
"$ "$ * !
# "# !103 5 !* $ * # /$ 0(#$ $ 5 0 "$( "# "$ !-# :#"$!<5
*"# $3 0(#$ ' ==:
(#5 #$ 80 ' * * $ > 3#
*
1$ >*"3"$ !-# :
= * 6!$#" ( *#-/1"##"$# 3 ($ !-$#3 "# ; 1"
3:5 33'
"$# ( 0(#$#* 6"$'/$8"33 /:,"(# )"$'* $ / )"$'*D
*(
$ #$E"$!$#0"( !:>"
* (0( C -( -'* ( ,"(# )"$'*D>* "##
/ "$'3 >E 3#$ */*# "$('"$ ( )"$'* >*( 1"
3: 0 "$( '"$ ( )"$'* "# (3
"6 !!-# ,"(# )"$'* $ /"$0( )"$'* $ "# 0( "#"$' 6!
' == :
(#5 $ "# #
* 6 /$ 0(#$ "$ "#
#0-($
"1 "$!" $ /#" #"# $ "$'
> !"6"3 !
## $ /* * 1 !!-# : B- * # 1 3 $ >*"!* 3 * -$
1-( (# $6#
"$ * # /$ !103 $ * # /$ 0(#$ *-'* !* ('# ( :
/ 1 * "# #"3$ $ * 1 $$(
"$*B-# "$ >* *(,"(# )"$'* $ /"$0( )"$'* >("$#
/: !11"
*1-( (#"#
( / '$ "$ -("$' ("
3 * 0 "$( * # /$ "$ !-# : #"$! <5 *( (5"$ *!"(!-1#
$!#5$-# -30-(0#>-3 / #(6 /: 80"$' "$( /*"$ / (# #0!"
33: *( "# $
00(*$#"$ 3"$' (
10("$' >"
* 6" $! ( *(>"#"$ ("$'>"
* ("
3"$ $:1 $$( & !!( "$'3:5 *"$#
"$ (('-3 (/ "3"# *0 "$("#( ( /(3 # $/ "3 -("$' *0$ $!:
("
3#-/.!
*"# -($"#*"$'/ "3F#-( :/$ # *#
"#
"$ F("
3 F- : '"#
5!$!($ 50(6" *"#$
(B-"( "$ $: *( !
# * 0 "$( #* 33 3# /" /: !$ "
"$#!$
"$ "$)!
"$;DE ( >6(5$ *"$'#
*("$ /6#* 33/!$# (- $G0(##"$ 0"$"$$ *1("
* !
# 3## 1$ "$5 "$ !
# "$( "# "$636 "$
$: *( !
# >*"3 $ ('-3 ( / "3 "$ * "$#
!
#5 * 0(#!- "$ >-3 /
3"/( : 16 $ 003"!
"$ (!
$!33
"$ / "3'(
"$("$ *"$#
!
#
&
4* *(#0 8"$'F( #$ %#F 4* *((0(
/3% #F