← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2301/1991dismissed

(O&M) Sampuran Singh And Others v. Bachni

2023-03-29Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra17 pages



   

   ! " #     "  " (") *

'

 

*+,

      

  

             - .!/- $ $ - $ ! 

 

 !""

#   $ %  

""

#   &&& - $ ! 

0   ' (          #      ) *+*,'--*

 .  /00# '-11   

     2 

) 30*,'-11

 .   /4+'# '-1,  

    



    3 5 %# "  

 #         + (  # 6#  #   

# 

  ##  

7  

2 2   #   ## /'32 8

 6#'9+

      

%%

#  

 #   :  ;<$'-0*" )   #   ## / '"3

2  

 ##   

"

  #

#  ## /'32      2 

2   62    #

#

#

:  ;

 



(   ##/+

 

2 2 #  ##/'  

 

 #     2     

  ##

 

"

6=  

#3**,'-142     # (  =  

  

   #    

  30'3'-14#

 "  2# = 3**,'-14"

  ##/+ 2 

#    2   

#  #

   2  <2    ## /'3 

  82  #             2  #  #  "

2" 2 #  # 

"    

8'    #      

  

82 # #

  4 <2 #  %  #/ >

 #   >  2 2

# # 2   #    2   

 #  

 

 # <2    #2 2 ##

2     

%%

#   #%  2"   

#

 2 #

   ## "

     #  2 ## 

#

 "

     2                     #  #

  #

#

"

   2

    (   ## " #" #

#  ##     ##  /'  3 2  )  2   

 #   

##    2 

    $'-0*#    ##/+ 2 2 

#   

# =  6



 

# , ( #     #  2       )         <2    

82 6 #'9+

    2   <2

 #  #  

 % "

 #%2   

 *?'''-?-  

   2  

2 #   

    2   2    %  2   6

@    ##        2 ## 

<2    # 

   2   ## /'3    

  #   = 2 6



##  ##/+<2   = " # "2  #

%%

#"    # #   2       #       #     =           "

#    # ? (   ## #      %  2  8

   #  A  

#   " #2 

 2 

 . :' =   7   

  



  BACC 3 =  

##    

#$"'-0*"  2  

#   ## /'3      BACC + =        

 6       2    ',8''814" ##  ##/+BACC 4 =     ## /'32  D

 ) 

#    BACC , =    

:%  ;

2  #  #     

2     



2 #"  BAC> ? =        

 6        ?8''8'-?-   :%  ;  " # "  ##BAC> 0 =           #      )  /'+BAC> 1 =         ##      

           /3#    ) B ACC -  #;

0 (      #    

  (   ## 6 C=83 

"C=8+)  

"

C=84C  

C=8,

 

(   ##/'  

 C=8'<  " %

%%

9@6C'2  

2 6 $'-0*"@6C83= 

2

6



3**,'-14"@6C8+

#   "@6C84@6C8?  #)  # '-0-81* '-1*81'"@6C80  # #

@6C81 #  /'-, 1 A   " #6 >=83C%

"

>=8+  2   

    #      >=8'  <  

 " 

    @6>8'  %    *?'''-?-"  @6>8'  #  #*+*0'-1,





.< E"!

    6

 >8'"

#"



   @6>8'9F"@6>8'9

# /'?*'D   #

"@6>83 # +''*'-1,



."  /0*#'-1,    

    @6>8+ #  #  C   - #                       

  "  . 

  # 

  ## .

 ) #  ."   ##  



 

# 

#    5      .  2    2  

    ) *+*,'--*

 

"  # 

 8  ##  



 

2    ##/3 

 #

<2   

)    # "    8  ## 

%1%

6 "       2 

 '*  #      #  



. 22    

2      #22 (  . 2   )    /8 %      

<2 2  

  



/'  ##/3  

 

   .

8'    "2   

       

  82 #   6#D

  . 2 

 %     2 <2 #    # /' 

     2 

##  @6C8'2 6 2   



      #$'-0*  2 2  .    

 

D  



  '' <2 #  

 #    = @6C836

 ##   ## /+8

 



D

    

   2 

  # =     6      

"   .5  . 2  % #      " 2   #  



  .

 2     

%%

'3   " 2    .  

   8# #%2    

  

2 2     

 

  #    

 = 

  " 2     )  # . 22    (     #     '+ C" #     2 2    

# %2  

#  # #  

 % "

 '-?-  2 

 

 #  2   

2 # 

2      #

(     # 6 # @6C8'@6C83

   #( #  

## 

. 2     

#   ##  " 2       #  2    

 '4 A      

 # 

    " 

     "    

   D    #  2        #          2          

 2       #%2   8#2 2 ### #  2   2  62  

@6C8'= @6C832 2 ###  B(    #             2           



%2%

#%2  *?'''-?-  

  2  

2 #(

"  8#

 @6>8'2   ##  6  >=83C%

# 2 



>=83 

#%#  8  2   

    

 2      #  # ( % #   #    

"  >                     @6>8' 6 

 

 

  2  >

 

    # 2  

  #

## 6     

  2 

 "2  

   

   %      #      2      

2    

2 # 2 

86       6#



#    2 %  #   >=8+ 2 

".%# (.

" 

 

 #2   >

 

#   @6>8'2   2   #  >

2  2  

2%    >

2 2            @F>8'   

#2   >

 *?'''-?-/'03*    

(      ### 

%  2   

@6>8'(  #

%'%

 

   

%" #"         

           #       2 



    "  #  #  #     #%2   

 *?'''-?- ',   #  

"         

 #   #     D   #      #

 #  2 #92 2#  

@6>8'9F  #  #*+*0'-1,





.< E"!

D /'?*' #



2  #  # 

" #

   2   #  2 

2   2 2#   ) 2  

  ##/+8

 

#   

  .       ##            

   



 2"  #  # 

."

8  

    ##     2 #   2 2 2#    

 2               #     '*8'3   (

#   

##     #   # 

  ##  <  # #@6>83    #     #    #  ##   

D  



  2 2 ## 

  2 

/ )  6

 #

%&%

             

               #          (      #      #

2 8 



#  #  #            #            2 2#      

(



2           2  2 ## 

 

 #  '? <           

  

    #     

    2 #"   #"          2#   #  6   2 2< C) "%# ##8  #2 2< D            #       

 #        <   ##  <-$

34 ,

4+

56"<'-0+CG '34"

. 

 2     

2 ##3,  "    ##    # 

< - 477  64 + -455,  74 5  64   ,  4*"  <  '-3-  C.  '+,"    2 

        2       #  #             "2 2     #  #  <!, *,+ "8 "

)  (

*  ,

 ,

4*"<'-01.',,0" 2 

 2       # 

2 #" 2     ##2%5 "  9 4 ,+ +

65 "<'-,3

%&&%

.3+'" 2 

     #2

2 #    # #  

    #  <    " #   

        

  

#  

 <

  # 

2      # 

( 

#  #      

#/

" #    #C=8' 

 "   

 #    ##    2 2#  

 2  

 2 D  2   

2    2 

  

 #  ',8'?  @ 

6  8 8 #" 2  

  2  2 2#    

  #

  <          @6>8'92 6#

# "  /39  ##/+

 

  )      #  /'?*' ## " ##  



 2  ) 

2 2 2#  



 

2 2 ##  "

       8    #%  2   

  

2 # 

 # ( #" #  

 

 .

 ## 

5  

%&%

.2  #    '0 C  #    D   2    

62   @6C8' 

 

  )      ## 8  ## /' 

 . 2   @6C8'  

 ## 8  ##/'   ##/38 

  #  2  

2 #  '**98  





(  .5  .

2    D  #

  # @6C8 '  ( 6 #



  

"  6 C=8' 

"C=83  

C=84C  

C=84C  

  @6C8'

2 2 

   

  '48',  %"

 # 2 /'  ## /3

 ## 6     

 

   #    "   

" 

) 2 

 6 #@6C8 '    # ,**982 

  #6 #

 

"   

#2 

2  # 2    ##  /'    3  >   

86  "            #  % 6  2 ##   # ,**98   %  # 

)#@6C8'    2  

%&%

 



  

 @6C8'C=83 

2 

2

 #@6C8'   @6C8'2

  

        

  

    A     #  

6  #

2 

"   2 #   # 2   6 =        = 2   

 ( #   # C=83  (  #C=8'  

C=84C  

2     #@6C8'

    %   

 #

 "    "      2# #   # #

"     6       2    /'  ##/3/       6# 

  

     # 2

2 )#@6C8'9%      

 "    

 # % 2

 

/'  ##/3(   # ,**982   #  "

   # #  #

 /' 

    #

  #" 2  ,**98    '**98" #"

    



       

 

9        #       2 #  '**982  ## /' 

  '0#

%&%



 "  D   

 # 2#

 "  %   "          .      5      .    





 @6C8'  

 ## /' 

  #  ( #  



. 2        '1 #  # /38  ##/+  

6= @6C83  #    

# 

2#  "  # "<#       . 

 )

  

 /  " @6C832    =   

  /3 6  C=83 

   2 



= C=8+)  

"

 # C=8+)  

    =  @6C83 %  #

"    

 

  

 #        2 

   

  

  

   2 

> 



86  " 2"   # = 2 

#    = @6C83    #

  %2 

 

  #    #C=83 

2   # 2       

6  8 8 #"  

 = 2  

2 )  

  

%&%

2    

    

2 

6  8 8 # ## 

 

 2 =     2      #

5   

2 

 

      2  @6C83  2  2    

      @6C8''(  



86  "

2  

  

 2 ## 6  

   # 

2## 6=  2      

#

2 

  

")C  

  2 

A #

" 

2 

#   # 2      6

 ( #"   

 # 

"     #   =  @6C832    %

 

  2  #

( 2   #2  #  6 #=  2

    =             #     #  <  

< @ (  D  6             2 

 #       #      6 # =    D 

2 =  



 2 

#2 "     #  #   ###   =        6 "  D 6  

 # # .<   "

   2 

%&1%

  # =  6 

/3" 2  

 "    #C=83 

"   2 

##        # 

  % = 6

   

2 

 "    6 #@6C832   #

    #

" 

   2 2    = 2 6

 ##

 2###   

 " #"   2      "

 

= "    2      2   2     2 #  / # 6 

2 ##    

    

= 

 

2 #

 6 #

= 2 

      (  .  %# #    

    

  

@6C832     #   

 

(  .#%     

 

 6 #= @6C83   ( #  



 .

 22  2 ## 

5  .< 2 #  

  "

.    #2 

#  

## 

 .  #   

 D  #2   

 2

D    

 ( #" #  



. 2

   ## 

%&%

'- <                      

   ## 2      ##



#     "  #      2 

#      2#  " 

  

. 2 2  # "2 ##   "     #      

(     

(     3*

   

" # "    # :- $ !  ;

'

  

" ) =   %  9  H 9/ =    H 9/