← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4560/2023disposed of

M/S Ambala Automobile India Ltd. v. Kotak Mahindra Bank

2023-05-0812 pages



                  !"#$ %& &    

    

  

  

  '$ ()'

& *&*&*)    ()'

& *

* 

    !

#$ ! !

 %

 & $!

'

 !

 % 

 ("!

  ))))) &*&*+#!,+-+. +/& 

   '

 %  

"  **+**, -

% "   

 *../*.** 01 (2.3' 4"

56$ %% %/"  

 %2* 72 89 .,2( *,.8*.28$  &  "       

  :

 4"

%%  .;.,*.** 01  (223 '

 ' 

"  (

 '

 "  2*.,*.**   56$ 

%%   "

/+." 6

 % " %%

+;. "  ' " '    4"

 2/.8*.** 01  (2;3  !

 &    %% '  % ,./ "  ' " ' 4"

*,.**.*901 (273 * 6 "

    !

56 $



    &

 

CWP-4560-2023 2- !  %



 & "  

 (

 

"   2/.**.*9 01  (2+3 '

&  

    .+.9*.*9 '  

 

$"

&  0<% " 3  *..* 9 -

 % 

 (

'

 " .+.9*.*9 

&' "' 4"



% 

"   *,.8*.28  $"

 290*3 $"

=

("

%> "

  <% " $"

&  "

*..*0%  ?"

@3

 % /92"  ;    

"

290*3 '

  '  

 ' "  %   A  %    92.7*.28  

  

 (  

 &  

 ' "    6 

"  $"

 290;3  "

 '

% *.2**.2801 (93'





&'   %' "'



"' "

"

 

 

  %' "'

!

 (   

 &  %% '

"     

"  $"

 290;3  "

 % 6    $"

 2,  "

 

 '

&'



 





" 

 $"

 290;3  ! !

'

 6    $"

2,0*3B093' 6  ' 1"

4 



 "

 '     %

 $ ("

 0;3 $"

29 ' ""

"'

     $  & 

2,093  6  



  &  %

& "

"



CWP-4560-2023 3- $"

290;3  ""

"'

     '

  %



'

:









"



  '

 !  6  

'

2,093

"  "



&   & "

"

290;3  !  





 "

   "

   &

'

& ' "&

"&6 

 &  1  

 

  % '

%;/&%  ' " 

  / 

 & ' 

"'

290;3

 *.2**.28 01  (93    ' 

 "  

&'

 %  **2**.*.

  

%

%& 6%  

 ' %

' & 

   

"   .+2.*.*2 01  (73 ' "      

  =  %   .2.;*.**01 (83 

&'

 % 28.;*.**  ! "

 &

% % ,*/" 

/9 " <!

 & 

&'



 */.7*.** 01 (293% ;,,"   9.22*.**01 ( 2/3 ' ! "'% 1 ;.+" 6  

' " ' =!

 &''

&'



.+.9*.*9 



" 2/.**.*9 01 (2+3' ! "'% 1 98."   



"

&'  /9" 



"

*/C  

 +   



" 52*,*.*.  % &   "   "

!&

    6

'

 &

CWP-4560-2023 4-

"1(   %   .*.9*.**01 (*23  %   

 %  

     ' " '  ' *;.2*.*9 01  (**3 & 

 " ' 

    6   '      4"

& % "

9. ...(& D6(6  '  

%  '

:



&'& "

% 

"

&  %  , 6 ' !& ' 4"

  %56$' ""

'

 

'  

 

' "'"   '

 "



%%

 '

 



% 

'

" & "

 ""

6 !& "



' ' 6 %  & 

2, "

 4"



%

  ""

"

 4    &'&/ *0  * !!

1,-+0+ " "2 0+3 4 +#5)3!&6+#"3, 071&*0 58+.6"3, 01/   * % &  "   

&

   "

%    :

 &   $  

   #  -

 ' " '

  &  D

 "

  

& :

    ' 

 %

' 

 & 

' 

  

&

 '  &   $"

 2,   "

 ' "        "  '  

!  %% ""

 & !     #  -

 ' 

 4

%

  '  

  "

! 

 &  

 ' ' '   

CWP-4560-2023 57 $  &  93,"0 :

! ;;

0/*3+3 +#5";0+4+#"0  6+#"3, 071&'+3, -<&&/ % *= " %  1 -

 '

    '

  & %    $"

 290;3  "

 

9 /. ...( '

 *   6 

         & D

"

 &   1-

    & %

'

!

 E2,6'



! 

 %  '

  "

     

 '

 ! 



 

 "

   

 '

  %



"  :

!

   6

 D

 "  "

 %% !

!

 :

&%   &  %

"



"

"

 %% 4

%

!"

%" 27F"

 

 

! 

" # -

%   &

" D' $   ! #!& <   F 03 

 288,0+3 $--;/.  !

( E9*F

   '  ' 



%4   

"  -

 '

 

 4   

&   %    "

"



# -



"

 

    ' "  &"

&



  

 $ " 4    !

 "

  

  '   &  " "&    "





&

 

"

    '  "   ' " &   %%"

% 

 ' %   '  %

 



 "&

G 28 6

  %  "

&

 '   ' &  -

 

"  2;2  -

 

CWP-4560-2023 6-

  6&  %        

  'G 8 6

"  1-

9#>+8+3 "#+. +#56+#"3, 071&?2 0 +. ;3"91 6"3, 01/  *     '& '

 ' ' 

"

290*3' "4"

'   

2909303  2.  ,"

# @   0 4+3  ) ? 3 ! 71& 7 1,-+ ,+0+3  7 !A+ '+#! 0 6 "3, 01/    *    

"  $"

290*3   "

%"

' &

 %!



  6

   

  '%

&

  

6%

 

'  

290;3

" 1(  '  

:

 4"

  ' & 2" 6

% !"

 &'

"

 '1 

 & 

 1-

'  "

 '     E6'

!% 

"

   $"

 290;3  !   !  !  "



 29.7*.2/'

"

 $"

 290;3   "    !

'  

&  %% ""

&!  &'& %

 

2,

$><$"

# -



!

'

<!

 & # -

  "

   

 :

 '

  "



"



 & %2"  &  9" 3 

 & 4

%  6 

1 %

  & 22," 6 (  % "

 "*.2/ "

"

 !

 %  '

 "

  $><$ -6 >

'

&   '% # -

CWP-4560-2023 7-

 

 

    " % -

   

 #  -

 

 &    1(   (  " " &'

 & 6# -

!

"

&   "  

 "

"

"

! 

 

&  !  

 & 4  " 6 "

 "



   !  

 "

!  

   

& 

 %    ' 6  &   &  # -

'

!

! "

% "

 

 "

 "

  6%    #  -

 

!  1  & "%   "

"

 "

 1"

 "

 '  

  &   " 

   "

 "  % # -

!

  G 22  6  %  ! "

 

'

" 

     1 -

     '

  

  "



 

290;3   & '

 $"

 2,  "

 % 6  A 

&  & 1"

 "  F

-

'

1"



4 

6%"

"

"

 "  " 



& "1"

' "'

 !



1   &'

4 

 2* 6

"

!

  ""

"'

'

 

  56$  !

'

 '   ' ,  >#"0 08+#""2 0+3 4 +#5)3!&/ >#"0 6"3, 0171&'

#+.B+0-+.6"3, 01/  )  % !

4     E,    "   "

"

 "

 '  &   '    $

  !

& - 

 ' % "

 %   @ 

   *72**.*.  "

 .7.2*.*2<!    '%% 

 '

& $

 !

&- 



CWP-4560-2023 8-

 */.**.*2 6 #  -

 4   

 ! 

&' !

  '

 ' %"

 & "

"

6%   "

"



 !

"

%

 4

" 7 F 

 4       # -





 

  % 

 

 %"

!& 

 %%     

 "

!  

 &

   $><$ "

 

  "  

   ! 

 $><$"

!  % !&    

"

!

  %

%"

!&

&6 "

"





& &   "

 &"    $><$"

!  % !&   "

 

 % A %

"  %

 F  :



  "

   "

"

"

 &     '

   

 "

!

 

 & 

  

&    

% &   



"

! 



 %

%

  56$ $" 

 "

!   

 

  & %  

  "

"

 "

'

 

"

"

!

  A "  

 ""

   

  56$ $" 

 %"

    

 "

!  

 

 & 

 "



& 

& F      &   

 

    & 

  

 '

  '&   "

"

 

"

"

  '

  8<!

'

  !  !    '"  

% &%  %%

%56 $

 $"   ! " 

 & 

     '

 ' 

% 1 2.." % !

   &    & 

& & 

'

   

 

 & #'

'

%

CWP-4560-2023 9-

56$$"  &%  %%

 56$ $" ' "  '& 

 

  &    ""

 '

 !

   6   

  

&% "

!& 

 

 ' " "    &    "



%

    '"



& %  %

  56$ $"   " 

'

  

     ' ' 

%"

  

 &  %"

  

"

! 



!& "



  

 %    ' 



6 "   56$$"



& 

 "

 

  &  

""

$ ""



'

%% 56$$" "



 $" ' "&"

 "   & 2. %  &     %

 

"

   "

% "

  "





 (



 

&

  

!&%

  ' "' "   &

          

 &

 '



 





 %!

F '





  

& " & 

 

  

&  ""

H

 " 



 '

    &    & '

  ""

   ""

      & 

&! " "

 & !'

 "

  ""

  

   %"

 

     

     ""

% '

 

 & % %

 56$ $" 226   " %   "

'



   '

%   "   &  #  -

1"



' 

" **+ -

%    "

% "

 



! & %

% 56$

    ' 6  % %

  56$

CWP-4560-2023 10-  '& 4"



&"



 56$ $" 

   %



 % % "

 

 "

  &    % "

 

  

 "

!  

 

 ! &

  

&"



&  

 %

  

    '

  4

% %

 %

 56$$"I

  &  ""



 %

"

"

 '

 ' 

!

!

 '&

  

 % "

 

       "

' 

 %



 56$$" !



"  !

!  !

 

%"

' "   !G 29 -

 %



  

*+(D "

"

'

 &!

"

 "  %!

&   '  '

-   &6

 %$"

2,093

" ! !& '

      

 ""

" '

  "

        "      & 6  ' "

  '&



       "   

  

 

""

"'

!

 "

"

& 2;  ""

"

 " 

!

' 

"

'  " "

=

 ! 

 %  "



$"

290;3% 



 &  '  "



 *..*"

' "'! " 6  ' "



%  & '

'

6  5 & 1"

 " -

'

CWP-4560-2023 11- 1"



4 

A

 '

 "'



1"

 "

"

 " 2/  $0- 3 A /8,9(/8,;(*.27

  

     

!"#$#% &'"

 .*./*.*9   1 -

   & & 

290;3

% 

&  & '

% 6  

2, 

% # -

 !

4    E7 



 :



  

 '  ' "  %  #  -

 & 

   2   '

 

"  **+  -

%   '  (



"' "'

 

"

&  1"



'

290;3 $><$ "

    

 :



  

 (

 '  "

 92.7*.2+ ' 

  

'"  ""%   & */C  

!&&   92.7*.2+ # '!  %  

   2 %  '

%  #  -

 "   (

 

"  *7.,*.2+ 2;.8*.2+ % "







:





 & & 

290;3 $><$"

 !  &  &   $><$ "

 & '& % 

   $"

2, $><$"



" D6 6%    !

'  ! 

  

! 

& &!  &'& 

 

2,

 $><$ "

 #  -

 

 ! '



" **+ -

%   '  (

 

" '  "  6%   # -

"



!&

 '



" **+ -

CWP-4560-2023 12-

%   "   (

 

"  &   1"



'

290;3 $><$"

G 2+ 

 & '

 " 

%

%"& F

-

1   &'

4 



   

  

 

 '

 "1 

"

"

&

% 



"%

"

!

&%   

29073 6



!

 

'

4 

-

 1   &   

 

1"

  %"

"

"

 "  " 2, ""

  &  !

'  ! "

   '

   6

  

!   

! &% 6   ""

"'

 ' &*&*)     

*

%& &        & F    J F 

  J