← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1556/1994dismissed

Amarjit Singh v. Rattan Singh

2025-10-27Mr. Justice Virinder Aggarwal17 pages

        

 !"!#$!%&'( ) ) #&*&+!%&'), ) ) -.#/010&23.&%13!#"455!66.&1"  7!#"*" .11.&0&23.&%13!#"4!"5&%!&1" '8 9 7 :9   

          

  

    

   

 

   !

          

 "

  

7 :9; # 

   "  $% #$ #&&'

  !(         )  *   +    !(    "  $, #- #&.,  !* /   "     !( 0

 

"

<  $ 1!  (      "

          

 "   $#,  2   #  "

         

 1 2  1  " )+ 

1    #    "   

   * 3  "(

( (     



    "   ( 1(  4 !(      

 2 ! ! 1  1 / 

(   564 )'  )%7!   (  "    564 )$7   1 8

 /    "   (

   .3  #&9:  

 (     

  !( "    

 '

+  

   (; 

     "/        #0        

( 

     !(

  "(      

   (!  1 1 / 



  (    64!0)' 64!0)%    (    ! !!(8

 /  +  

  "3<! "/   

    !

"#!   $     (

 4 "(!  2  3    

   8

 / "

(

.3  5  =1>7   0 

!( 1 / 

%     

"

  "  !" 

" 

 /  """3  #&9:

  . 1       /   "(

    2   00""  



/; ( (  "   . ! "

 0 ;  

    

!   ;  (!(! 

(  2    "

!(

  +    8

 /  (

        

    

           

 7       !     

 :

1   " 

 %&   '  ('"   )! )        * +**'**  (*!  +),*-   ' * .)  ** * $/ 01 ,  

 ! 5#!=

 5"1= 

     3  

  #&9: 

(  "

(!("*#$0$#"305  

    "*++!""0& " 

  ( .

4 (!(4 "    

  !   

  " ""  "  ( 

2,$/ 3 * 45,* )

  .

?    2 

      

( (  

 ;    "( (!(!   

(

  (        

    ( !  !(" ! 

( ?

 



(

 "

 (!( 

1

(

  !( 3  "( """



  "

    ( 





(     

 (

 8 

  0""

""!   

(   "

 "( ((   (! "(  

 1

 <   #!5#!"!&1.10$!.&% 0%*+0.#>0&&.1*#!



!  

(  

   (  @  0  !; 

 !(

  2 ,$/ 3   '*!   ** * $/

&      13  #&9:!  "  

      2 

   (" **  1

 ( "3 

      !!(   2  ) ( ! 

!

! "("  ( ;

(      ("   "  !  ! "

 "

 

#- "

  ( !    

 ? !+10&   5    (   7          !   "

3     2



( ( """

 %!$6$!?>"*#$0$#"305  

 1                 2  

(      #&9:

3  5#$0"1!+10&        (4   4 (    " ("

  / 0        "



   "  "



(

 &1%!$6$!?>"*#$0$#"305! !("*++!""0& 

## 8 (:3  #&9:5    ""!('&$--97     %

6  )    **' '

,



 

          

                      !  !           !  

 !             !     "

 # 

  

     

   



  

 $ % 

 

   

  $ "

  



                  

      !  !  

   !

  !       !

   !   &'

#$ 1  0#&9:

     : 3  #&9:  :3!#!  &  !-.6!  6.""=  3!0#  !@0"1"' )      !(    ""



     2   

 :3!#!. !-.6!6.""=3!0##.-.6!+6.0-0&213#*233!#!@0"1"' 1 :    

     <!("*++!""0&!(!+10&A

13!+1

 #'

    8.3  #&9: 

!     "

3 (       %.

 7    )  **       *  )  ! , ( !  



!

  

  

     $ #) * +

 !     

  %



, *+

!

    %      

  %% 

, *+

!

    ! "         , 

* +  !

      

  &'

#% 3!+10&A 13!+1 (     "

(    (    " /      "  2    ;

             00""      

 1  3  #&9:  ""           "                         ( @  " ?2 0#&9:  2    



 ; !(! 0#&9: ;  &6>*5&13!%!.13 13!5#!%!+!""#   (  . 1 (    (



         

"

   " 

#9   1     "

      .        0&3!#01.&+!  

1   

(6"!"01".&+!"1#.6#+5.#+!&.#>+3.#.+1!# 

 2 0&%0$0%*.6;"!6 =.+B*0#!%"3.#!  (  ! 

!   ( (  

   !   0 ; 

8   ?  0#&9:                

    !  (   (  .

"

(  !

  

( 04 

(!   ( . 0&%0$0%*.6"!6 =.+B*0#!%5#5!#1> 3&136%0&25#5!#1>.".<.#1.0& 13!01.C"3.#."!&"!0A0    

3     !(

("  2

0#&9:



#:

1   ! "

2    ("  ) $/    ;



( (    ( "

(   !(   :

"!   1    (   (  ! "

/ 0 1  

"

3  """ ! ("

 / 

( ( !(  . !( 

B  ("

   "  2    .



0&%0$0%*.6.&%.?"6*1!+.5.+01> 1 (  !

  

(  C   "!6 =.+B*0#!%5#5!#1> 1   !(

"!(3<! "/  !!  )& 89

 $.

/ :  ;   

#!$.:   !  (    . """

 (   "( (0 0

#,   

  !   (  .   5#!= 

 "*#$0$#"305  5#0&+056!"  +.&&1  ?!  0&1!#-0&26!%   0#&9:

     (  #&9:          (    !( 

(       0#&9:

    (       (!(   .  

 !( :

   ""

"! 1 (   (!   ;  5#0#1

  

( (

!(  C! .

1!#

    2  .3      ( "  0 ;  

1   "

 

 0#&9:

 

 * )    2  #.

   / < 

    !"   "!(

 /  " #&:-  """



3  #&9:

8  " !

 5   #0  7    / 1  ;

( 6.""3!0#"    1

(   

            5#$0"  1  !+10&   "    (

/; ( (%0%&1%!$6$!?>"*#$0$#"305!  !("*++!""0& .  !  (

"

3 (    /    1/ <   ;

(       2   ) ) 

   

#& 1  (   (!(              ! "   0&%0$0%*.6  .&%  "!5.#.1!

5#5!#1>  

(   1   !(    "3<!  "/  !!  )& 89

  *5#.   ;   

#! *5#.;  



( .

 (    "( ( 0A0 

$- (    / #&:-   

!(5#$0"1!+10&  

  !+10&A  (  .11.&0&23 5    #7      "!6 =.+B*0#!%  5#5!#1>  3  

! ;  (!

(    &6+*"   "

!("

 6  * )!   " <(')        

 $

 $# 1   "

 (  !"  &  - 5 7   ( #&9#         +              """     

     (!( #!1.0&!%01"+5.#+!&.#>+3.#.+1!#  

!(  0#&9:    

  "

  ;  !(!  

$$    3.&.&0&23   D #.11.&0&23 #&:-  " #&9: /; (  (!(    ! !("1.1*1#>"+3!-! "*++!""0&"! :5 7  . / !

    !!  !-.6!6.""3!0#";  

:  !    ( ( !("*++!""0&*&%!#!+10&A  /  1!&.&1"=0&= +--&  2   

    

(    / 6"101"+5.#+!&.#> +3.#.+1!#   ! ""!6 =.+B*0#!%#"!5.#.1!5#5!#1>       " (! 1  

       ./&/&%        0  &(   !  

! %  "   !   &1

    %        

             !!   2   !   !%  3"



  !!4  

      " &' /&5&(6

  < !

(   



!7   

      &%8  

 " 

     !!   

" 

   /9       

  "   &  (    /9 

      & ($ "  "

   

3  

   !  

 

 5 

  &%

 

 $ 

  ! 

    "

 5  

    ! 6 

!!       "     &% "  

  

"     ) )     

& /&&%  ! 0  " 

  ! %     !!

 & (   !!"    

" %  ! 



      :2&&2&( 



                  

  !  !           4    



 &    4     ! 

   ;         

  !

!4 

& &&&&&&&*    

 + $'

  (  ( !(   

    !  !  """3   #&9:

   3<! "/ !

    #&9: (!( "

 3 "

    "



(  0A0 "

 5 , 'E, :7 3      #&9: ( .  ! 

(!   !

 (5 , %E,

/  #&9:   ;

(   ( 1 

    

  %/&9&  8      "  "  

  

  !!   !         

 

    

 "

"

 4

   

 !&

 /&2&%;   

#!$.:   $ 

 # <&( 4   

 ! $ 

!!  )& 89 =

   = >$.

? @8": " * !    6 =+

  

0 "        3!    

  !&

   



           "

!    &>

!  "  !  "      

   !      ! 

       "

   6 

!           "  6 

!"



& 8  (

           (  ))*  ('

* .)  ** * $/   ))  * 5      '    * ! ('* .    #  ) 5

)! '(  #    

** '

1 &&&&&&&*    

 +

 :

/ )   ** * $/ *!  )*               *

 2 ,$/   )     ),*-   ')!   *        '  (*!     )  *- 

 '  ! **' '

/&&%    

" &&  

  

     "

 !     "&(!

  ! 



   

  

  !!     ) )  



    "

&(  

!"



   !!  

  

  &'

     





   !!!   "    !!

#

            

 $# %   ! %  %

& &

# 



      '

!  (

 )&   

 

 *   #      ! 



 )    # 

  !(     %   *   !    +,

 - .  %      

    !

"#! $3 $% 1

      !       2 ; 

(!(!  

  (  !    1  (  ! A  '    /  . 0&13!

" ! ") -!&%-!&1: 

 ! 1   ":

0$--97 (   

!(! " "

     ( " !         ( 2          3                  !  (

     (   .! ""

$9&* 'F  (  

( !(   .   

(  

(

   !  

(

   "

 

    (   (!" 

 (5!(  (  7 !  

( 1 

(   !    (         (         "    (     .#&:-! ""!6 =.+B*0#!%5#5!#1> 

( "

(!( (    ! 1   ! 

 !  

 (    (     ! "" " "4

 A  $:

        /       """3  #&9:  (

  #0  !("*++!""0& . "

2            "!6 =.+B*0#!%      

/; (! " !   1 !

; 

( "        1 8

 /        

   /; ( 564 )$64 )'E64 )%74 !( "     !   $0% 1  8 

 / ( 1 /   $, ( 

%0"-0""!% 1 "    )* +   $% #$ #&&' "

$.

"



  ( 

 57 (

  

 ), ) ) 7 :9  2     * +  ?  # @?> *

+   # @?>