High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/16418/2014disposed of

Moti Ram v. Monika And ORS

2018-03-19Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi12 pages

!"#$% & '()"#) "*+' ,-.$%!

! #

$%"#$% &

! #

$$/ "#$% & ! #

+ 01

#&#"'()"* +#

( #,,)"* +#

-------- 2

. &.#"

# $$ "$ +/* $

# . +

" "

$ " /.

" )"" 0 1 "2

#! 3# !

# + / 2!

"# $ ' "/ !

# .

# + + " 4#

45#

#$ + "# $

$ + 2"

" "

$ "/.1 #!

6+ " ! '

" "

$ "/.)""0 1 "2

#! 6 + " # 7

"# #"

6#/

$# "

"+ 8 98

#:#

!# +

! + "4

6 4# #

"# "

! 2

;

/ +# + #2 ' < "/ '

6 = " 2> " +#'

" !+ #"

'/ ? + "++

6 +# # "'

# $

# '# # 2* /## #") '$ + "/.

6 0 + 2 +

# +'

# #" 2'#

$$ +

;

"@ 8 #

6 "@ 8 #

6 #" + # " + # $$ A 2 #

.+# 0 $ ' * "/ '

$ =?9 '# ## $ "

" "* 2 /.

;'+ # 2

"##

'$. +?98 +$

.+.$ + "+

6 #

.# 2+#

"##

' " + .$ +#

+ ;'+ # 2

"# " 2#

6' " "

6 "# ' " .

/ #++# " #"

"' "/ / +# $/ 2 2;

* '+# $

* "$ 0 &+> " 2 ) '+ "# "'"* "/.

# 2#"

" "$" +?98 2

"/ '

$ >'

6 + "'#"'# 0

A 2#

.+$

" 2

6 * $$

'#"'

# / #+&## $

"&.# ( "2

" "

# 1 #! '

"# 0

"2 "

@8 #

6 "@ 8 #

#")22 2 # ""

+ " * / + )01

#! '#

+ " * +

"'# " 2# + #

6 #"

" 9 &. "

" "

)"" 0 1 "2 #! $.'

"/## *

+/## $ ;

* '+# + #

" 9 "#/. "

" "

# +

6 '"

"/ " "'#"'

# +

6 ' ( " >'

#"'

"+ 8 #98

#+# " ++ 2+# )22 "2 #

$ 2

$.' 2/## * '

# "

$ "/.1 #! #

#$ + "' / 2

#* $ + "$ / 2

2 # "

" "

$ " *

! 2

6 #" + 98 98 #+# " ++ 2+# '

6 #

" # 2

#&#"'(

" $$ 2 / #++ $

" #

" .

+# + ## + "" ## #"

" " 2 #

.+# $

" 2 0 9 0# + "" ## 2 #/

"* "/.

'.+

'# ##"/

"## ' "2 +?98 + "+

+"$ '

" .B

" 2 "##* 2

"#* 2'+ #"+# "2 # +

"$./

#"#2#.

* $ . * '+# + ## +# "* $ * "/ '

$ #"/

6 ' " #" "' " .+ #

+# $/ 2 2 9

( #,,

" $$ 2

/ #+ +

6 "

6 #" / # #

"# #" '

# #"2' 2 7$

2# ".

".* 2+" # 2 " 2 +#2# 7+ +* 2 ;2 "#

6 '# # ' " @ 8 $ #

"/.# + "

" "

$ "/.1

#! 8 #/

"98 $# " +#

;#* # "

" +# $ $+$ + ? 5# +' 2C +# #

+ "

# " #

" '# # "

$ " /.)"" 0 1 "2

. 2#

( + "D :#

#"/ +#

" !+#

98 # "D 5# +C '# # C "

" #

"'# # "

+)"" 0 1 "2

. 2#

( + "D5# "$ / # + # 2 ' < "/ '

6 ; "$ "# + "++

# 2

/ '

$ '"* " /."

0 &+> " 2 ) ) $ #"

* "/ '

$ =?9 '# ##"/

"# +?98 ' "/ # "*

6 + " +

+ "$

.)+ # "

+"* /

" /##

9E*

# ' /. "

" "

/ +

/.# # + 0 ' "

" / " " '#"'

C # ;

* ' + #

6 # +'#" '# C # +# ' +# 1

#! '"

@8 ## 5#

/ 2 +. + " 2+)"" 0 1 "2 #! +

6 +

+ 8 #98 ## " #

" '#. ( + / 5# + +C '

6 = 5# "C '# ## # '

#"/ +# '

" !+#

# "5# 1 #! '# ! 2# + +#

# ## .# .

;

$ E7 "57 A $

F5# "2# ?98 # "'"

@ 8 #

6 #" '# # /

" /. )01

#! * 98 #+# " +#

== #

## #" "'# ' " 2# "2 "$

' "'#

# 2# "

" $$ 2 / #++#

" ## +98 #'"

#" * "

" * $.##

# "/ "

$./ +# " +# "

"++# "

++ 2+# ;2 "#

$ .

C # + "# " 2# # / $. .# 2 # 2"

" $$ 2 / #++

#"2 ##

" #* #2 "$

#+# #

+ #* 2 "+#

2* * ""' 2/ $

+ 8 #5# 2

/ " $ +

* # 5;) 9; + # 2 "## 2.+#

' 9=?8 # ''## ?# . # ' "

5# C '# # " / $ "

" + 2

0 +# # #" ".

# +"* $+ "

/ +

# 3' *4,5 65*7)2'6'*7"(,) .$%%!

3*'-8%. '# ##/

# "#

+ $ #"

++ " $ # > " 2 ) " $ #/

$ "/.# # / #+# #"#

0 " / '* " ++

# #"

$. # #

$ # # > " 2 ) .

/.# # " # .2#

0 "=+# ( "2

" G H " # $ % #

&'() * #

* % $

# " + % # , %%# % $ $

# , -

%# % + '( % $#$ $

/ + %%# * # , # + $$ %

1 # " % +

# , + # * 0$

1 # , % + + # " %

# $ %

1 2% + + * % + (

% " %

+ 3 4$

$ + $%

% 5 - 6$

% * $ $ 0$ 2 # % 2%! 577 - #

%# +%

% #

'(! +% + % +

%%# * 3 4$

- 6$

1 * * + 3 4$ 1

% %% $! $ % % $ * % $ # 1

% #

$ .

%$ #

1$ $$

5# + .2

"/.

" +5#

# # $ #

" $. #

2 "

6' # C + C +

$./

6 #" # / " !

$ 2 * ' #

+ "/ +#

5# #" "+ # # / $$ " '"

&. 2 # / $$ ";

$ 2'9'*)5,":7,695 (')5,":7,69))'*79.$%8 $ 5%//# > 4/ 0 $ ## "#9I+#

# / "4

.' "/ ( "$$ / '"

'+ ;

" # >2# #"

" +8 #

'+ +#

.+=99?8 >'

# / "#"

" #"+# " "# +

" ' " 8 $ # ; ' # " # H% +* # %$ $

% % + $ 3$ $1 %

% #

$ %

JF " / ".

6# " 2# +#

/ ? "# / /

"/.

# # # (.2 +

0# ' /

"# '#

'+ " == )# '#

"/.# 1 #!

# '/

" " " # / 9 .

" >

" C

" ". 7$

2 2 * $2 + >'

2#+# + ##

"+.+#'

$ 2+2 "$

'+ "' " 2# E*

+# 2

"/. +

6 $ "## 2 "$

+ .

$/ +! 2+ # *

+# +#

# +2* * #

# #'+ "' " 2#

"' 2.+98

'## .# .+ ?8 #$ # "

"'##

# )"" 0 1 "2 #! $ " # "

#" .# .+98 # 5# 0 '+ " .

. + # $

9 ?8 $ # F #

# "

$ "/.)"" 0 1 "2 #! " "

# 7

+2 2

@98 #

#"+# " ++ 2+#

' +== ( +/

$ 2 * ' # . # . + #

"## 2/

#" # "

@ 8 #+# " + + 2+# ' +== ;+ # # "#

6 #"

@98 #+ " +"

$ " * /.# )"" 0 1 "2 ; + # # "#

@ 8 #+# " +#"

$ "

9 ;

* '+# + 2 2" C 6$.

" +* +/#5#

;

* '+# /* # #

"$.'

# /* 7

. 2

' ,-.$%!

3* :# $ ! 28

K :# $/

K 86