Roshan Lal v. Neelam Gupta
!
"#$# %# &# # ## % #
'
( ) %*+,+ -.
/
# -
0$1 "
2 #"2$ %#1 !+ +*- 345267#,8 *+*6+9+**+
$,: +7#,8 *+*6++ 4+ 6$,"
*6+9+ +*9+**7*6+9+**+ ++;
<: 6=,+
,*+,.
> 78,+?6 66+? :+,*6+ , 9*, / 78,+?6 6*6+99 *+,,99=*6+9
= *6 9*:,+2+ *@*6+ +=*A+ *:+*
# *7' 6*70*6+# *0)?
+,
1++, +*6+9+**+ :A**+,*6**6+9+**+ 6,
:+, 6+<:+,*+, : /77B**6+ + 9,+*
:**6+:* +**+, 9++*5,:= *6+9+,+ 5*, 9:*+ 9+*6+ +**++*8+,* A+*?++*6+9*+ 7*6++ 9,+*? *?*6,?*6+99 *+, A56+:,+2+ */ !
76?+8+7 6+68=*?*6,?*6+
+7*6+95+* *99+, %8 +? =*+,A5*6
:*A5:*: +*8,+,+,*+, .
9
+, # / C #= **6*,+7*6++ 9,+*+, +8+?#99 *
. ==+8 ++=,=+ +9*/77B
%:=*6+9+,+ 5*6++7*6+9+**+9,*6+:*A5?5
,+,,* :/77B8:*6++ 9,+*7*6++ % ** :/77B8: #A6 6+;,*6++ % ** :/77B8:#;* *:* /77B68=A++9,7*6++8+?99 *? +,
6+9+ +* 9*? +,A5*6++ 9,+*?*6:*+*8+ .
> *6+:*+<:8+***6**6+ 6+<:+6,+,5A++ 9,7*6+ ,+*6+ 9*,+ * :88+
*6+ *6+ 6,7 ++, + *6+ +
:A**+,*6**6+9+**+6, 6+*+,*6++ 9,+*,6+5 +A+
$595=:,76+,+*6+* =*6+ 9 +7*6+ *+ ?6 6?++*,6++,*A56 +,+ *,+ +8+*A+ =*+,5A++* 6+**6+ 9* 6:, *:+ ?+8+7 *6+ *+=,=+ +9*/77B6 *A++, 9:*+,
+,++, +*6+9*+ ,9+:
+,*6+99+ A;
6+ 9*? +,*6+ +6,A5*6++ +==*6* 6+<:+ /77B,*+,
:+,A5*6+ 9+**+8:*6++ 9,+*? +*:+,: ++,?*6*6+ +;
D *995+*E *? +=+,*6* * *6+++8*,*+7 *6++? +58A+?*6*6+9+**+76+ *99+,95+**6+
6+<:+ 8+,+,7*6+95+*? *,+ * ?6++ 9+,+,*6+ 9* *?6*
:*7*6+
:+,A5 *6+9+**+**6++ #*+*6+9+**+? :+,8,+ ,+ ,*+, .
> 7 6+ +, 99 * ++;= ,99= *6+ 9 *;=*6+9+*6**6+:*+<:8+***6+
9,A568,+ % %BC@C 77B7 %
%BC@77B7 % %BC@77B7 % %BBC. 77B7 % %BC. 77B, % %BC.77B,*+,/ 2**+$;!*$ 62,*6+:*/77B ? 9, 8,+ %% @CC> ,*+, > 6+ 99 * ?
,
+,A5*6+++, :*A+?8,+,+,*+,/
@ *6+ +6,7*6+9*+ ?++*=*=
:* * , 9:*+ 6+ ,8 + 9+** +, A5 *6+ 9+**+ ?
,
+,A5*6+* :* %:=*6+9+,+ 599+A++*6
:*7*6+**+? 9 +, 9+ +**++*7,+ ++,8 + ? =*+,A5?5:*: +* *6+ **++*,+A5*6+9*+
A++*6 :* .
7*? **+,*6**6+?+6,+ +8+,79 *7 9+ +*,:*:+*+ +6+ +,A+6*? 6,+ A:**6+?+, ;
6+ 6+<:+/77B6,A++
:+,A5 *6+9+**+**6++ 9,+*9*6++*7 + 7":57 *?
9+,+, # .*6**6+9+**+6,
:+, 6+<:+ ,*+, /77B*6++*6++ 9,+*?*6 :,+ *,=*6**?A+9+ +*+,95+**+=*,+ ++ ,8 +,?A++ 6+, F6+*6+ 9+ +*+,95+*7 *6+ +? +*:+,?*6*6+A4+ *D *995+*E *6*=:,7 +8+?*6+,+=*=,8 +A5?5:*: +*? 95+, ":
* * *995+* 6+<:+ 8A+ %:=*6+ 9+,+ 5*6++ ,+8+?99 *7*6+9+**+9, : /77B * *6+ + 9,+* A5 ?5 % ** : 77B*6++*6+ ,*6+,:=6*+,,+,,* /77B8:*6++ * + ,+,*6+,+9
+, @ 7?6 6 +G* *+,A+?- +,+,,*A+= @CC>,*+,> : /77B8: ++ :9*7*6++ % 'A+=
C. * C.) : /77B8:#A6 6+;,*6++ % 'A+=
C@CC@) :/77B8:#;* 68+ A++ 6,+, 8+ A5 ++, + *6+ 99 ***6+++, +*6+99 * 6++8+?99 *? +, *6+:* +**+,
57
:*?6 6 6+<:+ /77B6,A++
:+,7 +,5 *,9, *? *6++*+*6**6+ 9*:,+2+ *@ *6+# *? +,
. ,+=*6++ , *:*G7?6++A5*6+:* 6+<:+6,+,5A++9,A5*6+9+**+**6++ 9,+*, *6+ % *6++ *6+ 6,+A:**6+?+, ;7 597 *:**6+9 *6+ 9*?:,A+ A:
+9 +
:* ?+8+7 *;++9=8+?*6+ **6**6+
:+,A5*6+9+**+":57,*6+:*?
:**+59,#:=:
*776+ +<:+,*95*++ **6
9+,7?6 6 + :** 77B 1+**6*:*A+9,A5*6+ 9+**+*6+*6++A;,* *6++ *6++ ,*? 6,+A:**6+?+, ;
6+:*A+9,?*6 9+,*?*6
*6++ +*+,A8+, :A4+ ***6+ ,*7 * +,+ ,7*6+ 9*+,A5*6++ 9,+*:,+2+ * @*6+# *, +<:+*9 +<: 6+,
6+9+** *, +, ' 4+ 6$,) ":,=+ .
/ ;
' ++* +9*+)