High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1921/1994dismissed

Prem Sagar v. Chaman Lal And Others

2025-03-25Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain15 pages

! "# $ %&%&'

"#"(#) ! "# $ '%&*%&'

+ ,-, %%%%%% ..

//,#0

1,+,# 2,/ ,#! "01

%%%%%%

."#!

$ 32 % 4

! " # $ %%%% 4 5 %

$ & '( ' )$ ' ( *+, # - .

' '

' . / )! 0 )11

" 2 11 ! 0 ! 0 ! 3(1-! 1 - 4 &2

11 (6## * (! 0 ! 0 ! 7 ! - ! . (3(1 1 ! (686 4 &2 )! 0 (66 ! 0

" 5 9-: ( ( " $# ;( . '( 1 1 9!:

. '( (

'( 11. ( , 11 ( -& <& ! =

( 0 91:

.'( (

( ( ; ( = ' ' '( 11

(' . ( ( , . '( ( ' ; '( ' . '

)$ '(.(

> 1 " $

1 " $>8?6#>586$$5$8# #

; . - ! ! ! 0

& '

(

8 ?

6? = .

0 11! 0 / " . '(11 '

" 6 2 .

" (

" ' 2 . ( . = (6#?! 0 / 1 ' . ! - ' " # 5

9!: @ . . -! / " 6. ( * . ! ! 0 ( " $# 9!:

; ( 6#?1 ' 9!: @ ! 0

$> 0 1 1 ( . ( '&&

; ' ( . 1 ( . - ! ! /

< .A 8 ?

6?' . ! 0 ( @

( ! 0 '( B '

. . /

% &

'()(*

% #

!, "

(

1 2

# ) *

)

# '

/ ')

414, 44

9 +

< " !

' 2 &2 .. ( ( . ' / ( < . " $ #5?$ # ' ! 0 / " 1 6?>- CA 1 8 ?

6?. ! 0 ( ( ( 1

1 ! ! 0 -! ) ; ( ( 2 ! ! 0 -! ! 0 (68>CA D = 1 . -!

! 0 (6?>- ! CA ? CA 1 $ CA $$ CA $ A CA $#! 0 . 2 >)/ .& ) ! -! ; ! 0 & ( '( !

CA 1 1 8 ' . 2 4 ! *

. CA 1 5 CA 1 > 1 ' @ 1 ; .

! ! 0 2 ($>- ;

' . . ' *+, ' 0 . 4 &2 . CA 1 # ?

! 8 ?

6?CA 1/ . '( '(- 11< B &1< 5 CA 1 ' . -!

! .

! 0 ! 0

. ( ( 65> 2 ; !

'( ; . '( 0.

! $ 5 6??

1 ! 2 " >6 6??

; . # ?

66#. / E! " 5

$ $ 6?$'(

! 0 ( '(.( . '(

* '4= !

1 $ > 6?> ;

686 6?>. .'( * 1 4

F 0 .G ; . $ 6??

' = ;

CA $$/#$/##/#>/55 /5>/58/5?/>/5/> /8# ' '( ' . . (

4 '

' '( ! ' .( ' '

(A ' .

; '( .!

'$ . '

= .

! ' ' '&/ = . ' = /

$/5/6??'( 1 4 '& & ' * ' 1 '#66#

' ,

! 6 66# ; .

@ '

! (' (

< '

1 4 . B ' '( 0.

! '( ; !

9!:

( ; . ( @ 0.

! 9C: . '( ( '

( . I @ 9!:

9!:.'(

' ( . ' ( .

( 0.

'( $ 0.

! CA 1 (! 0

(

. 2 ( ' 0.

! ' (

9C:'(

(

'( 0&.0.

! ' ( . = ' .CA 1 . . 11 ;0.

; ! " $# 5?$ # 0.

'( # 0

. '( ! ' .' . 9-: .

(. '(

' ' I ; ' '( .( ( ( 11 *. ! ' . . ; '

' *' '( ! 0.

! .@ ! ' ( 0.

! . '( ! .. '( !

' ' '( ! ' .

CA 1 8 ?

( C

. . 1< 1< 5 . .'

& ; .

' '

& = CA 1

( ! ' .

( '( > =

(

= ' .

' & )$ ' ' - C

9-: ( (

" $# . (1 1 8 (

11 9!:. I ( ; 9!: ?

' 0 91:. (. ; ( 91:' ( '

' 9C:. '( ' (

*( '

6 ; 11

; 9-: 1 1 ; @ 9!: 91:

= ' CA $$ #> # 5> $ ! ! 0 11

* .

( .

(' ( B . ( ' ( (@

(. @ 2 ' ' '( ! . ! ' / E?

; (' ( ( ( A * ; . ( =. . . . ( ( ' @ . ' ('

. . ' /@ ( (. . . '

6 .

= " ( ' /@ (

" '

( ( ' '

. . '

( /@ ' * ( (' . ( (

( . '( . &.

' '

' . ' '

' (.

( . (. I ( . . '

' ' ( & .

(' '

F 2;; 1 <; & ! 2;; 2; J=26# ! F65G$ !28$K $< # ! $< & JF688G !!$55KG $

. . A '( !

! ""' / $$ 4 * (/FG%%% F$G; ( * * ( (

( '

. ;A @

( (. . ( ( ( '

$$ (

' . '( '

( 11 . . @ '( $# CA $$ ! 0 7! 0 $ # 68 ; . ! 0 & ( (! 0 ; ! 0 '& *+, ! 0 = .A *+, (11 0&.CA #$ ! 0 . 1< 8 ! ( $

! 1 2

2 '

(! 0 . / E;. ' . " # $6 / / ( $5 *. A . '(! 0 11 -! @ ( ! 0 ! @ (

1 ; (! 0 0&. $8 6 6>>CA 55

'( ! -! 11 ! 0

B $8 6 6>>. ! 0 .

( = ( '

& '( '( ! - ! 02! 0 ! 0 .

CA >

" $ 68? > 6 6?$'( '/ 4 !

! 1 2

; (

. 2

; . . CA > '( ! 0 ! 1 ; ' ( '

'&' ..

. ( 0&.CA 5 = - & = "

(

'( 11 . '(

( . ( ' '(*+, '( CA #> #. . ' . 656 ! 0 68>. CA D ;

! 0

. ' 2

; . CA 1 8 ?

6? ;

1 $> " ! 0 ( (CA C CA .

. & '

& B

$ ;'

. & '

& !

( '( ! ' .

= ! CA 1 '

(A '

/ '( ! ' .

$8 @ ' !

( ' $?

(

4 '%&*%&'

1 < & )

L < 2 '