High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/434/1991disposed of

Ghanshyam And Others v. Dalu

2018-07-13Mr. Justice Arun Monga7 pages

!!"#$#%&'()*+,- .%$.)/ .!0$ 11!((% $ 2!0$'$ ('

!$1%3!%

!"#$%& '( $(')#

0!$!% &

0!/% 0#%*34" !* 0 .!11!((% $

0!5 #*34" !* 0 .!0!$1%3!% 66666 (')#*% 11!((% 71(#% ##$#% !8'(0!"%311!(8#%$ .!

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

0# .(*!.$#( (5(*#$ 0#" 0#3=3%3!% 0#!$#%('/% =!

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

(#% #$#%$ # ' !3%11(#" #%0"00!" #% .!@.$0 8#0350# #% .! '0 $$#$ % ((!" 0 +%3 03!* 5.#". 5$ 3#$/#$$!34#3!03!03 !3-> .! 3!!%3% "% !$ !3 .! $'# =) 0#$#%8 %'/!0'$ 10!(#/#%0) =9!" #%$ A' ("'$7$ %3#*

* /#% #%=#(# )* (#/# #%! " %/!0# $*# 5$((!8!3 . .!3!!%3% 5$5%!0#% 1$$!$$#% .!$'# (%3*5.#".5$8#4!% .#/=))$' .!0 5%$.0!$$.0!#05 #.3(0!3)=!!%' #(#C!3=).!0=)5) 40#'$ 0%$" #%$.!11(#" #%0"00!" #%@.$08#0350# $'=/# !3%=!.(#05 #5$3#$/#$$!3%->.!1(#% #$* 5.5!0!/#%0$*"'(3% =!#%"'( #4 #%81$$!$$#%$#%"! .! #/! #//!/0#(*5.!0!$ .!1$$!$$#% .!3!!%3% 5$"% #%''$*

'%#% !00'1 !30 .!($ .#0 ))!0$ #%"! .!10 #!$5!0! 40#%"!* .! 0#('0 0/!3 .! ((5#%8#$$'!$&7

#$% & ' ' "

& '% !

( % '

) * + & * $ (

' ( * , -

.!1(#% #$!B/#%!3 D7'/0%#%8.%3 D7+"..!

:(%3=0'8. %0!"039/=%3#B 0 .!)!0;-7;*B + @.$08#0350#0/?.0#;> =#;%3 0@ 0@* 1. "1#!$9/=%3#!$0 .!)!0-+7- % .! .!0.%3* .! 3!!%3% !B/#%!3D7('%3D7+!!1.%3%31("!3% 0!"03B+$(!3!!3*B9/=%3#0 .!)!0<+7<*B @.$08#0350#0/?.0#<; =#<<*B;9/=%3#0 .!

)!0-+7-*B>9/=%3#0 .!)!0<<7<-*B<9/=%3#0 .!)!0<+7<%3B-@.$08#0350#0/?.0#- =# --

.! 0#( '0 * % 110!"# #% .! 0!/!% #%!3 !4#3!%"!*'%3 . 1(#% #$/'$ .4!=!!%.!(3 =!5%!0$ .!$'# 101!0 )% .!=$#$ .!9/=%3#0 .!)!0-+7-*3!"0!!3 .! $'# .!11!((#3=!0! .!:5!011!(( !'0 =) .!3!!%3% .$ =!!%((5!3=)$! #%87$#3! .!9'38/!% %33!"0!! .! 0#('0 .!$'# 5$3#$/#$$!30 .!0!$% . .!3!!%3% .3=!!%$.5% =!#%1$$!$$#% .!$'# 101!0 )%3 .!!% 0)#%.#$%/!"% #%'!3 0/;- ->%3* .!0!0!*1(#% #$5!0!% 104!3 =! .! 5%!0$ .!5.(!(%3*=' $$.0!.(3!0$

0!/% 0#%*(!0%!3"'%$!(11!0#%8%=!.( .! 11!((% 71(#% #$*#%$'110 .!/!/0%3'/11!(*0#$!3 .! ((5#%8$'=/#$$#%$&7

.!$(!3!!3B+4#3!5.#".)$* .! .!0"7 5%!0%3$#$ !0#05 #$(3 .!(%3 .!3!!%3% *5$ .4#%83#!0!% @.!5 %3@.$0%'/=!0$%3* .!0!0!* .! :5!011!(( !'0 "'(3% .4!8#4!% .!#%3#%8 9#% 5%!0$.#1 .!$'# 101!0 )E +

.! 0#('0 '8. % .4!0/!3 .!#$$'! 5%!0$.#1*0* .!0!(#!$'8. *$% #"!3=4!*5$%()0 "00!" #%8 .!@.$08#0350#E

/=%3#B 0 .!)!0;-7;$.5!3 .!%/!

.!3!!%3% $8#07/0'$#5!4!0* .!3!!%3% .$% =!!%=(! 104!1)/!% .!0!% 0 .!0!$% . .!.3 =!"/! 5%!0 #% .! =$!%"! "70!( #% .! @.$0 %'/=!0$=)4#0 '! .!$(!3!!3E

.!:5!011!(( !'0 3!$1# !=$!04 #% . .!

3!!%3% .$% =!!%=(! 104!=)%)!4#3!%"! . .! 1'0".$!3 .!$'# (%3*0!4!0$!3 .!#%3#%8$=).(3#%8 . .! !% 0) . !B !% 5$ % ""'% !B".%8! !B".%8! .$ =!!% 104!3 % 0!"03* .!0!0!* .! (%8 1$$!$$#%+- 5!% )!#8.

)!0$10#0 .!#(#%8 .!

$'# *5'(3% 0!$'( #% 5%!0$.#1E ;

(#% #$ %!4!0 !B".%8!3 .! $'# (%3 5# . .! 3!!%3% 4!% .!$(!3!!3B+3!$% 104! . )$ .3 $(3 .!0 $.0! #% .! $'# (%3* 5.!0!$ .! "0$$7 !B/#% #% D7.3% =!!%0!3#%"00!" 1!0$1!" #4!

4#$774#$.04!$ #%8 .!"01=) .!3!!%3% %3* .'$* '08!3 .#$'0 0$! #%87$#3! .!#%3#%8$

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

3 10 .! #%3#%8 %3* .!0!0!* .!0! #$ 80$$ /#$3#0!" #%.!:5!011!(( !'0 .3%""$#% 8#4!#%3#%8 0!803#%8 .!5%!0$.#1 .!(%310 ()#%4'0 .!11!((% %3 10 ()#%4'0 .!3!!%3% .!"'$ .!'0 $.'(3.4!=!!% %()"%#%!3 .!3!"#$#%->1$$!3=) .!$$#$ % ((!" 0+%3 03!3!"(#%#%8 .!10)!0*0*"00!" #%@.$08#0350#!$3!$% "%!0%) # (!#%"! .!0!5$3#$1' !=! 5!!% .!10 #!$* .!)$.'(3 .4!=!!%0!(!8 !3 "(#/ .!3!"(0 #%4#$774#$ .!5%!0$.#1.!0! #$%(#/# #%0 .!1'01$!"(#/#%80#8. 5%!0$.

0 .!0!$%$0!/!% #%!3*5.#(!'1.(3#%8 .!9'38/!% %3 3!"0!! '%3!0 ".((!%8!* 8#4! (#=!0 ) .! 11!((% $ $!!@ "00!" #%#% .!0!4!%'!0!"03=)5)3!"(0 #%5%!0$.#1$ .! 3!!%3% .3"(#/!3 .!5%!0$.#1=)5)$! #%8'11(!34!0$! 1$$!$$#%%3#%"$!%)$'".0!/!3)#$4#(!3* .!'0 $.'(33!"#3!

.!$'# '%#%('!%"!3A'0!!0!%"! .! # (! .!101!0 )5.#".5$% 10 .!10#/0)0!(#! .!11!($ %3$3#$1$!3#% .!0!/!% #%!3 !0/$ %/*+01 (')# 234 %&56$ )474389 :3

;3:

)474 7< ;3: