M/S United Mining Corporation v. State Of Haryana And Another
! "
# $
! "
!" #
$%
& '()(*
!" # ++,+$
- .#&/
!" # % $
& ' 0(*
!" #
+
/.."1
!" #
%
2 -11 (3*
!" # % + %+
$ 4)3" &1
!" #
% &'% ( (
() *
&'% ( ( ( ( % - 5 6 718 -(39"
:;"9 "8-(38
-"8-(3
" <
% $
=
718 -(39"
;7" 8-(38
-)718-(3
"< %
=
-2" 7"8 -(39"
:;"9 "8-(3
" 718-(3
"<+,+$
=
#;" " 8-(3
98-(3
"< + %+
$=
; 18-(3
'"7"9;8-(3
"< +
=
-2 18-1-4 9"
5" 8.-48
#- "8-(3
>+?4)3" <
=8
"4)3" <$%
=
> ?4)3"
" <+,+$
=
-; ;8-(3
>%<% $
=8
> < %
=
> < +
=
:;"9 "8-(3
> < + %+
$= @@@@ (
() *
+ :" "11"9< =A3 + %+
$83"11)3))"-A 8 5 " 31 3 4()8 8 .(1) 3" .)8""811". ))8 " :"-A 85))> 7-
$+% %%
$:" 811"9<= 15153" "3))(3
(834)3" &1 " + %+
$82"" A31
!
" # $%&$
# '
(
) + :" 8"9< =1B 5 319"""339<=811 B 199"3")1"9"3"5 3339<=< =
3331 8" ""-A < =83" 5)8" "". ))338"
11
"4)3" 3389""1; 3
8 " " ) 11 1 3) 515 ")133338"19 338"
5 51" 3 " 33) :")5 3<=8 "85 " 8 39"(3 * *+
)9"3)1132 ;
313)38" (" " ") A
:" "" 151 518 8")1 333385"3 189118 3 3)9(8")<= ) 11 159")133"198 )8) # 1+ " 138
328: 1( '111 # 18
<" "311"C # 18
D= 9(89") 11 1)" 1988")133338" 8" )13353)151
8"
"1 9 338 "38 B 1 " ) 8 1351 )))8 51 "#E#13 " 4()83 13B %
(8)
5# 1< = # 1 "
# 18
8 "1951 ) 1 1)8 9""
58")8
5 # 1 <= # 1 < =8 "
5 " )1 33338" 8"19")1 33853)599" "833"
, )
33" ".333851" 1)2 3".31138 )
513 "1 , >"18 " !
3 3" " .385 3 ")2" 38 ".311333853)19"" 518 "")1338"
" 835
5# 1<= # 1 < =8 "(3)9""113 $ '"5((8")13353) 13))3)"33 7") 83( " (8 )5# 1+# 1 " # 18
89"3"5 18) 515 ")1338 "19338 1)" "8") # 1 8"1911 3(;
3)8 )")133 338(F(")3 ")8 3 )5)" :" 8 5 5( 1 # 1 + # 1 < = 1 3(1 ") 11 88 515 " )133"193 1
) 11)8"
8 35)8" "" )
3 " .3 338 " .3 113 338"153))98) # 1 < =8
5# 1< =8< =8<=<%=8"
)" 51 5 ")1338"193389"8
- 33" 8# 1 1) 3) "19338B 1)53 5 " )133(F("18 )A3( 3(5)" -5 1B 1"8"5(# 11 3(1 515 ")1338"1 98 8 1 ) 3) < =8 < =:" 85 11 "# 1< =( 33(F( 51"195 ")1333) 515 ")1 33"19 + # 11 8 ) 38 9" " 5( 338 B )<= 151 8 3(1 3)883(1 515 " )1 338 " 1 98 " " ;
38 A3515 "113338" "8"3 "
1351 " (8 8 53) " 38 3(1 # 1+8 # 1 " # 18
B 1 8"B ) 5 )B 151 1"1) 11 B ) # 1 " # 18
8"
)" 151 3) 51 " 1 98 " 5 " )133> 11 8"5 5"353)58 "5 51 " "") A 89"5 (";
3A351 # 1< =8"51 3 "4)3" 33
. :" "8"1 "5(B 5 "# 1<= <
=51" 3 "33) 9(8 "3<=8)"4)3" 338" "
") A 8" "". ))338 "
8 " " ) 11 ) " 4) 3" ")13333851 " 3 " 33 ) 8 5 9" " 3<= 1 2 33 5" " 1 " 3) ) 8 "
3(1 51 5 " )1 338 " 1 9 #1 "5 " )5 3<=1515 1 :" )2 " 5( 331 )
)6 = .;
3)3) 51 " 1 9 5 " )1 338 5 11 A351 5 " 1138 " " " 1 3 " ( # 1 " # 18
8 5( 1 8 " 3 ) ";
33" 8" "") A 8" "4)3" 3389"" 5185 9" ""3) 1 3)8"") A " 5 51 :" 8"132 " "9513) 13)8 9"5"513)< =853))85 " ) -A 8 53) 5 " 4) 3" 33853)3)19"8"
83 )" 1" 3 "33) # 11 "5 "
/ )8 "
8 311 5 " "9(11 ( ;
3"11333885 1 ) 1 8)"338"5 A"8 35)8")85 ) "( # 1 < =83)85 1 " ""3 ") # 1 < = 5= 0("93" 19"3" ) " " 15) 11 1 )"338 " " 513)5 " "9 51 3)8 " " ) -A 8" 51 )3<= "4)3" 338 A3 5" 511518"
3 ) " 33 ) :" 8 "5 8 " ) A 1515 1 % 7") 8 "3 "85)
"98" "8) ) 5)" 85 "1 18" 9 ) "> " 3 +
8" )A) )3 "5 3 )8 "33 ) 8 "
8 2 " 3 1 " <=8 )2 )8"9""" "11)2"89"9 92 )35)5 " 85 19"11" 33 " 8 3 " 3))3) " ) A3(85 3" ")133'" "3 1 ""33"333" , :" 81 "92 " 3 18") A 1515 18 11"5(
0 8233 5"""951 3) 3)8 51"198" 5 " )1 338 9"8 (1 )<= 3 "189B 5)8"
1 5 "113 338" ""A3;
3 # 1 "
# 18
8811 "1139911518 )2"(1;
38"
" 38 53)3(5 ")8 )")
33" " .333 $ '"98"93 951 3) 151 518 8")1338 "B ) ") A 8)2 51 )5 3<=8" "".3113338 "3" 338 )";
31 3)3"9(" "8"
31 5"8 " ) 11 1) ) " )1 3388"4)3" 338"1 933
'>+ ,
+1D4)3" &" 7 !"8 8" 53) G9""8"
92)2;
3 9" 3 " )28 8 > "8 " " A3)) , -'
(
. !
/ 0
&$%$%
&$%$%
! ,(-'
(
. !
/ 0
&%$$%$$ , -'
( *
2
31
. !
# 43 43*'
42,3-
!
"
# $%&$,5 # $%&$6- ,-'
(
&2
(
)
9(8 " " > + 8 9" 53)A3" 8331 "83" 35133(;
3(" "8 3 " ) 11 ) ) " )1 33 " 1 9 338 "5 " " 3"(4)3" 338853"5 ") 11 )8"
3" )" " 3(1 3
(
(
(
*
(
2' , -
+
. !
*
(
( (
(
(
(
( ( *
* *
(
1 * *
(
,- # , - (
(
(
4"
( (
(
(
(
( ( ,- 1 # , - ( * (
* 7
, - (
( ( *
(
(
(
(
"
( +
(
+ )
(8" "3 33 " >% ,8 1 " ; 31 3)38 " -113338" "3 "(
3 - " ;511))*<# 1=-38 $8")133338
13)) " 3 " 33) )"8""") 5 "-11333:"1(>%,8 3"(3< =53)A3" 8 "
(
$9$%$% (
&%*' !
+ ( : ;
,# -'
&<4& '
".
=
*
. !
(
(
> (
(
. !
/ 0 9 '
" . = , -
&%?
(
*
(
'
1 #*&
(
&
3
(
(
# , - (
(
@ (
(
" +
+
(
( '
1 #*&
( (
( (
+ H
+ >"18" (3< =81) 3( 1 " (8 8 " 3 " )8""1(# 18"53)3 851 ;
3 " "8 "
3 ) 1 )<= B 8 53) 9 ) " 338 5 " 33 3)1 " # 1 < =8 9"5 )9)3 ")- "8 "
"331"18) 3" )<=8"33 2"# 1 < =8 " " ( 53" 5 ) " )<=8 "5 )9) 5 59 " "8 9 ( 3 " )1 33 :" " > $ 1 53) A3 " <'
( + # , -
@
# , -
# , -
(
(
(
, - ( # , -(
)
>"18"> 8 "(3< =8 " 83 "5(8"" )1 9" )133( 118 5 ) 5 "
8"5 "( )"53") 11 1 )<=8(""93 )5)1
3(1 8"
3")<= # 11 )213 ">
," 89" 53)A3" 8" " 33))<=85)"1( 18 "5 )2")133338 " )51 3 " ( 3 " " 33853))93"15 53"5) "1() 11 1)<=8 8 " )1 33 " 1 98 5 " ")2 ))<=8" )5 ) 35)5 ".3113338" "
"3 ") # 1 # 1 "D # 18
D &2 "
. !
*
. !
*. !
(
,
( < # $%&$
"
* . !
(
*
(
(
(
(
< # $%&$
(
& < (
(
* * .
9
(
( * *
(
>
(
( (
&4 , - *
9
<
, - <
, -(
(
1
(
# 4$4342
4 # $%&$
(
(
1
!
"
# $ # * ,&-A
.
( (
.
1
> @
(
+
,$- '
@ 1
( ( * , -
(
( (
- ,(-
,3-"
(
( (
(
(
"
(
(
( (
(
%% !
!& $
&#
$ !
% $ &
*
( (
&
$ $
& ' (
$
&%% !!) ! *"
# * ,&- A
(
(
>
'
( ( #B#! .
> ,$-A
(
43
( (* ,&- (
* *
=
(
,3-A
=
(* ,$- (
*
=
* * >
( (* ,&- (
C
(
,2- C
* *
=
( (* ,-
,-,"-!
.
=
D ,-
@
( , -(
(
+ E ,-
( (
,-
( @
,-
E ,- (
>
E ,""-A
(
** (
,4-
(
(* ,- (
( #B#! ,8- =
( ,9-'
=
.
&
$ &# * ,&-"
(
43
( 42
(
(
,$-"
(
43
( > &%?
@
(
.
,3-A
(
( (* ,$- (
* * =
(
+
!
( =
(
=
(* ,$- (
(
/ ,2-C
* *
=
(
(
,-,"-
+
D ,-
( , -(
(
+ E ,-
( (
,-
1
( ( ,-
(
( ,- 1
1
( (
(
(
E ,""- A
(
"
(
(
(+
'
,"""- "
,- (
>
( (+
(
,4-
(* ,- (
(
&%?
@
@
(
(* ,$-
(
0 ,8-
( =
(
(
( (
,9-'
.
) &8'
( 1
# 4$ # $%&$ (
(
(
(+
, -
(
( ( ,(-
(
(
( (
(
* * (
(
> (
( # 1
( (
(
(
,- &9 # 43 # $%&$
(
" #
, -(
(
( # (
(
>
(
> (
&<, -
(
(
,(-
(
3% (
( ( (
$% (
# 42 # $%&$
# 43 # $%&$ (
(
!
( # 43 # $%&$
* * =
(
"
(*# ,3-# 42 # $%&$ ( =
(
+
1 F
(
(
(*# ,&- # 42 # $%&$
( > (
7
(*# ,3- # , -
(
$&
( ,- * *
*
(
(
(
=
(
(
$$ (
> (
(
# (
*
= (
+
=
&%
( # , - ( =
(
+
( 2
( > (
(
=
(
(
(*# ,&-
( (
(
(
(
$3F
( (*# ,&-
( (*# ,3- (
(
+
(
(
( (
"
( (
(
( (
3%
1
$20 (
(
(
>
G&%?
, -
( (
(
"
( 1
(
(
(
@
(
( @
@
(
(+
(
"
( (
(
(+
(
$"
# 4 # $%&$ (
"
(*# ,3- (
>
(
(
( (* # ,$-
* * =
(
(
+
,-
(
=
(*# ,3- (
( 1
(
( &%
( >
(
$4"
(*# ,4- # , -
(
(
(*# ,$-
"
(
(
@
(
(
1
( =
(
2
$8 (
(
,- 1
(*# ,$-
,3- ( (
(
(
( 3%
1 $9"
( *
G &%?
, -
( (
(
"
( 1
(
)
:" " 11 " 1)5 " 9< =8"" (9) " 33 $< "
>
# 4$4342
4 # $%&$ (
D*
"
!
"
#
$
$$ % ! & !
% '
! "
( ) )* % '
& #
! ()
+ , - .
$
$
! #
"
"
/
0
1 "2
! !
/
!
/
3
3
3 !
&
! !
#
/
!
&
! !
#
/ $
!
! "
0
! !
( ) + / $
+
#
'
!#
$
!
/
!#
3
!
4!
% '
! ()
, - . 5
$
!
!
!
5
"
" /
$
1 "2
! !
/
!
:" " 5 " 5( 3))<= " (1 85 11 A3 )"
, 8 " " ( < =
11 38 "5 ""4)3" 338"19338 "9 1 3" ")133338 A1 " )1 91"8 33 " 1 3(1 95 "4)3" 33885 " (198" 53""1()<=8 " 13 ) " 1 9 33
%
(8 " 5( ))<=8 9 1 8"1"1( 38)"113 338 " " A3 ;
38 " " " 3 8") # 1 " # 18
53) A38 ) 5 )8 " 31 8"385) 3" 38 "5 31153)3 )58 8"3" 338 "(1933
, >31 8 "5 " A3 " " (9 153)")1 5 " 8 ""3B 1"))<=3" # 1< =
$ ! )5 338" 53)G9" 1" 89" *
1) 5 5 ")133338" ""1)2
3 8" *
18) 3"8 1 "32 )"9) "1( 8 )2"A3( )"118 " "3A3(8"))1 )""
- ""11")85"1 "))1 33 ) "G11 + :"5()31 3(5 ) 3 5 :" " 5( )38 )
11 311(3)82(1 )5 13 " "3 + '""138) 5B 1
33
9" " .3 !
3 33 :" 8 3 )8 8 " 3 3389"")" ) 8B 11".3
!
3 338 9" B )5 )
385 3)) 9"")11" )1 33 338 " "5 8 3 "A3(<=)"118" ) 5 ")
333 + :" !
3<=3381 3" "11 " 32 ) 5 " )1 33 ++ I ")8"32"1158 58 "
5 " !
3 338 "8 3)) " 8 13)" *
1 )5 ")13333 + - )"5(8 ""111 8 1111 A3())13385 " )1338"5 "3338 39"992 ) 851" 55 )5 1"9
3519"2 )
.
38 " " 55 8 " ) )1<=" 32338"
53)38 8" "
)5 "(" 1 11 9" " *
1 " )1 3333 +
(8(" 58"))1 " 32338B 5385 "
33388" "
)5 " (8B 51119"" *
1 + '"92 "5(8 ""5(8 8"3383(51"5 8"1(85)5
31"" 2 )
3 +% -)B "5(85)" 9" " 92" '12
"! ! 8 3)13 " 5()5 " +, ' " 92 " 5(8 3 5( " ) -A <1
$=8)89" ;
35(" 31 3 4()8 8.(1) 3" .)8""8 3"8") -A B " +$ >"18) "3335 "1 3 18 " " " 3
+
835""")A) )3 " 9 15 38" 811"9<=34$52 2671252121
1 ) " ." !088"119" 928)2 8" 35 "
/
3 "3" 3385"1119"9 92 ) 11 " 8 5 " 3 33
I ")8 151 9 3) ) 5 3 )5 " )1 33 338" 8"15159")"
) 5 ".3113338 31" 5( 3 )28 " .3 !
3 338 3 9"1( 38 " 911)8"
".311333 ! 3"35)5 "113338 " 8 " )1 33 338 "11 53) 519"92" "3) ) 8 3(1 9" " 3 " 4) 3" 339""1933
-11 " 9 <= < = 9"
3<= A3 + %+
$8 1 5 " 4) 3" 8&1 89"3"1331 +
3")3<=1 "(538"
811 "13<=8 81<= '12
26 92 9:9; <14+ < 26 5#5 9< 91 3(
() *
3( ( %8 ! "
2(" ""2 J> ""51 J>