← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6456/2020disposed of

M/S United Mining Corporation v. State Of Haryana And Another

2023-12-2228 pages

     

         

  ! "



# $

   ! "

 

    

  !" #

$%

& '()(*  

  !" # ++,+$

- .#&/  

  !" # % $

& ' 0(*  

  !" #

 +

/.."1    

  !" #

      %

 2 -11 (3*  

  !" # % + %+

$ 4)3" &1   

  !" #

%   &'%  ( (

() *

  &'% ( ( ( ( % - 5 6  718 -(39"

:;"9 "8-(38

 -"8-(3

" < 

% $

=

 718 -(39"



;7" 8-(38

-)718-(3

"< %

=

-2" 7"8 -(39"

:;"9 "8-(3

 " 718-(3

"<+,+$

=

#;" " 8-(3 

 98-(3

"< + %+

$=

; 18-(3

'"7"9;8-(3

"< +

=

-2  18-1-4 9"

  5" 8.-48 

#- "8-(3

>+?4)3"  < 

=8

"4)3" <$%

=

> ?4)3" 

"    <+,+$

=

-; ;8-(3

>%<% $

=8

> < %

=

> < +

=

:;"9 "8-(3

> < + %+

$= @@@@ (

() *

+    :" "11"9< =A3 + %+

$83"11)3))"-A 8 5 " 31  3    4()8   8  .(1)   3" .)8""811".  ))8 "   :"-A 85))> 7- 

$+% %%  

$:" 811"9<= 15153" "3))(3

(834)3" &1 "   + %+

$82"" A31 

 

  

 

     

 

      

    

       



   

 

 



  





  

   

  

 

! 

  "      #    $%&$       

#    '



 (    

) + :" 8"9< =1B 5 319"""339<=811 B  199"3")1"9"3"5 3339<=< =

3331 8" ""-A < =83" 5)8" "".  ))338"

11

    "4)3" 3389""1; 3

     8  "  "  ) 11  1     3)  515 ")133338"19 338"

5 51" 3 " 33) :")5 3<=8 "85 " 8 39"(3   *  *+ 

)9"3)1132 ;

313)38" (" " ") A 

:" ""  151  518 8")1 333385"3  189118 3 3)9(8")<= ) 11 159")133"198 )8) # 1+ "   138

328:  1( '111  # 18

<"  "311"C # 18

D=  9(89") 11 1)" 1988")133338" 8" )13353)151

 8"

"1 9  338  "38    B 1    "  )       8   1351 )))8 51 "#E#13  " 4()83 13B  %

(8) 

5# 1< = # 1  "

# 18

8  "1951 ) 1 1)8 9""

58")8

 

5  # 1  <=    # 1    < =8  "

  5  "  )1 33338" 8"19")1 33853)599"  "833"

,    )

33" ".333851" 1)2 3".31138 )

 513 "1 , >"18    "    !

3    3"    " .385 3 ")2" 38 ".311333853)19""  518 "")1338"

"   835

5# 1<= # 1 < =8 "(3)9""113 $ '"5((8")13353) 13))3)"33 7") 83( "  (8 )5# 1+# 1  " # 18

89"3"5 18)  515 ")1338 "19338  1)" "8") # 1 8"1911 3(;

 3)8 )")133 338(F(")3 ")8  3 )5)"  :" 8 5  5( 1 # 1 + # 1 < = 1 3(1 ") 11   88 515 " )133"193  1 

) 11)8"

 8 35)8" "" )  

3    "  .3  338    "  .3  113 338"153))98) # 1 < =8

5# 1< =8< =8<=<%=8"

)" 51 5 ")1338"193389"8

-    33" 8# 1 1) 3) "19338B 1)53 5 " )133(F("18 )A3( 3(5)"  -5  1B 1"8"5(# 11 3(1  515 ")1338"1 98  8  1    )    3)  < =8    < =:" 85  11 "# 1< =( 33(F( 51"195 ")1333) 515 ")1 33"19 + # 11 8  )  38  9"  "  5(   338  B   )<=    151  8 3(1 3)883(1  515 " )1  338    "  1  98  "   "  ;

38 A3515 "113338" "8"3 " 

  1351  "  (8  8  53)  "  38 3(1 # 1+8 # 1  " # 18

   B 1 8"B ) 5 )B 151   1"1) 11 B  ) # 1  " # 18

8"

 )" 151    3)   51   " 1 98  "  5  " )133> 11 8"5 5"353)58 "5 51 " "") A 89"5  (";

3A351 # 1< =8"51 3  "4)3" 33

.    :" "8"1 "5(B 5 "# 1<= <

=51" 3 "33) 9(8 "3<=8)"4)3" 338" "

") A 8" "".  ))338   "

   8  "  "  ) 11      )  "  4) 3" ")13333851 "      3    "  33  ) 8  5  9"  "   3<=  1  2    33   5"  "   1      " 3)  ) 8  "

  3(1   51  5  "  )1 338    "  1  9  #1  "5  "   )5 3<=1515  1  :"     )2 " 5(  331  )

)6 = .;

3)3) 51 "  1  9  5  "  )1  338  5  11 A351  5  "  1138  " "  "  1  3   " (    # 1      "    # 18 

8  5( 1 8  " 3 ) ";

33" 8" "")  A 8" "4)3" 3389"" 5185  9"  ""3)  1 3)8"") A " 5 51 :" 8"132  "  "9513)  13)8  9"5"513)< =853))85 " )  -A 8    53)     5  "  4)  3"  33853)3)19"8"

83 )" 1" 3 "33) # 11 "5 "

/      )8 "

8 311 5  " "9(11 ( ;

3"11333885  1  ) 1 8)"338"5  A"8  35)8")85 ) "( # 1 < =83)85 1 " ""3  ") # 1 < = 5= 0("93" 19"3"  ) "   " 15) 11 1 )"338 " " 513)5  "  "9  51  3)8  "  "  )  -A 8" 51 )3<= "4)3"  338  A3  5" 511518"



3 )    "  33  )   :" 8  "5   8  " ) A 1515  1 % 7") 8 "3  "85)

"98" "8) ) 5)" 85 "1  18" 9 ) "> " 3 +

8" )A) )3 "5 3 )8 "33 ) 8  "

8  2  "  3 1    "  <=8    )2   )8"9""" "11)2"89"9 92 )35)5 " 85 19"11" 33     " 8  3  "  3))3)    "  ) A3(85 3" ")133'" "3 1 ""33"333" , :" 81 "92 " 3 18") A 1515  18 11"5(

0    8233 5"""951 3) 3)8 51"198" 5  "  )1  338  9"8  (1  )<=   3 "189B 5)8"

1 5 "113 338" ""A3;

3 # 1  "

# 18

8811 "1139911518 )2"(1;

38"

" 38 53)3(5 ")8 )")

33" " .333 $ '"98"93 951 3) 151 518 8")1338 "B ) ") A 8)2 51 )5 3<=8" "".3113338  "3" 338   )";

31 3)3"9("   "8"

31  5"8    "  ) 11    1)  )  "  )1 3388"4)3" 338"1 933

'>+ ,  

+1D4)3" &" 7   !"8 8" 53) G9""8"

92)2;

3 9"  3    "  )28  8    >   "8  " " A3))  , -'

 (     



 

 . !

 / 0          

    &$%$% 

   &$%$%   

!    ,(-'

 (     







 

. !

  /   0  

  

    

          

&%$$%$$ , -'

 (    * 

2

  

 

31    

     

      

      .   !







       #    43  43*' 

  42,3-    



 

   

     

    

  

  ! 

    " 

#  $%&$,5 #  $%&$6- ,-'

 (     

&2 





   

  

( 

  )

 9(8  "       "  >  +    8   9" 53)A3" 8331 "83" 35133(;

3("   "8  3  "  ) 11      )  )  "  )1 33    "  1  9  338  "5  "   " 3"(4)3" 338853"5 ") 11 )8"

 3" )" " 3(1  3

 ( 

(

 (

  

 * 

    

 

(       

     

 2'      ,  -         

                  +    

 

   

   . !

  





 * 

  



(

    (    ( 



(  

   

     

   

   

 (





    

   

             



 ( 

   

  

    (   (  * 

      * *   



     (

1        * *  

      

 ( 

 ,-  #  ,  -   (





( 

  

(            

 

 

       

 4"

 

       

          

   

   (     (        

  



     

           

   (

  (     

   

( 

 (     (          ,-  1         #    ,  -   (    *      (

  

       

 



   

  *  7     



  

 ,  -  (

   

   ( ( * 

 (   

   (   

(  



    

  



   ( 



"

 (              +

 (  

   

+   )



(8" "3 33 " >%    ,8    1    "  ; 31  3)38    " -113338" "3 "(

3 - " ;511))*<# 1=-38 $8")133338

      13)) "  3 " 33) )"8""") 5 "-11333:"1(>%,8 3"(3< =53)A3"  8  "

                  

     (  

 



 

     $9$%$% (

   

  &%*'      !

+ (  :    ;

 ,#    -'

&<4& '

 

". 

   =           

 

         

    * 

     



 . !

   



   

     

           

    (            



      

    

     (   









  

  

 

   >  (  

  (  



  . !

 / 0   9   '

 

 " .     =   ,  -  

 

         

  

 

  



    &%?  







      (  



 *      

         

 

  (  

      



 



    

   '

1  #*&           

   (  

 &

3   

  (

      

     

( 

    

  #  ,  -    (         

(







@    (

(  

"    +  

 



  





       

 



     

 



  

           +   

(

    (  '

1  #*&     

 

  



(   (      



  ( (      

+   H

+ >"18" (3< =81) 3(  1     "     (8  8  "  3 " )8""1(# 18"53)3 851 ;

3    "      "8  "

     3  ) 1 )<=  B   8    53)  9  )  "  338 5  "  33     3)1    "  # 1  < =8 9"5 )9)3  ")- "8 "

"331"18)   3" )<=8"33  2"# 1 < =8  "    "  (    53"  5  )    "   )<=8  "5    )9)  5  59    "  "8    9   (  3    "    )1 33  :"    "  >  $  1  53)  A3 "  <'       

 

   

 ( +             #  ,  -   



  

         





               @

    

       #  ,  -   



   

       #  ,  - 

      

  

     

   ( 

   



   

 

(

(   

,  -   (   #  ,  -(

 

          

    



   



 



         

 

  

      

 



)

>"18"> 8 "(3< =8 " 83  "5(8""  )1 9"  )133(  118  5  )  5  "    

 8"5 "( )"53") 11 1 )<=8(""93 )5)1

 3(1 8"

  3")<= # 11  )213 "> 

," 89" 53)A3" 8" " 33))<=85)"1(  18 "5 )2")133338 "  )51    3  "   (  3    "   " 33853))93"15  53"5) "1() 11 1)<=8 8  "  )1  33    "  1  98  5  " ")2 ))<=8" )5 ) 35)5 ".3113338" "

"3 ")  # 1 # 1  "D  # 18

D &2  "

    

 

    



     

     .   !

   



 

  *  

   

 . !







 

  

  

  

*.   !

    



  (

  

,   

(     < #  $%&$



  





 

   

   "  

  

* .   !

   



 

    (



    * 

     

     



(

 (

   ( 

(

     <      #      $%&$  





    



   

  



 



 (

   

 &      <   (

(     

  



 



 * *    . 

    

  





      9   

 (

(  * *



(

     

  



 



   >  

   



  (

 

(    (  



 &4            ,  -         * 

    9

  <   

 ,  -  <

     



 



  

  







 

,  -( 

   

(    



  1   

      

    

 

   (          

  #  4$4342

4 #  $%&$     

    

   

     



 

  

         

           

         ( 

    

 



 



  

 

     

   

          (



1

 

  

  !

 "

 # $   #   * ,&-A  

  

 

     



  

  

            . 

       



     (   (

           . 

 1

  

 

 > @





 

  (     





   





     





   + 

 

 ,$-  '  

   

         

   

  

    

   

@   1

 

   

   

 

 

  

    (  (  * , -



  

 

  (

 

 (  (   



-    ,(- 

  

   

 



     ,3-"

 



      



      

   

            (    

  

   

   



     





 

 (   (   

 

  

         (       

              ( 



    "

   





  ( 

 

  

    



  (    

         

 (   (   



 (

  

%% !

!& $ 

&#  

$  !

% $ &

*  









     (          ( 

 





 

  

   

&



$ $

 & '  (

$

 &%% !!) ! *"

 #   * ,&- A   



(   

  ( 

   



 

    





       

 





       

 > 

 '

  

(      (  #B#!  . 







>  ,$-A   



  

(    

   43

     

        (        (*   ,&-  (   



    

           

* *      



       

  

 =  

 

   

  (   

 

 ,3-A           

 =  

  (*  ,$- (  

*

     



              

 =  

 

         

     

       

      

* *                >    

  

    



 

   (      (*   ,&-  (    





     

  C        

  

   (

  

       

  ,2- C   

  

* *     



 =  

 

           

               (   (*  ,- 



       ,-,"-! 

   

   

.      

 =  

  

    

 



     D ,-

  @ 

 

   ( ,     -( 

(

+ E ,-    

 (     (   



  

 ,-





   



  (   @   

  ,-  

   

      



  



     

  E ,-     (  

  >  

       

E ,""-A       

 

   

     

 (

   ** (    

 

  

 ,4-  

          (         

  (*  ,- ( 



   

 

     

  

  (  #B#!  ,8-    =   

           

   

   

             

    



    

( ,9-'

       =  

    . 

 

&



$ &#   * ,&-"

  

  ( 

       43 



  (   42



  (

  

  

 

( 

 

 



  

  

     ,$-"

     

       ( 

      43

   

  ( > &%? 

  



 

@  

  ( 

  

   . 

   

   

 ,3-A   



 

  

     

( 

   



 (   (*  ,$- (     

  

  

* *   =  

 

  

 

(



      

           + 

 

!

  

 ( =



    

(      

   

             





      

        =







 (*  ,$- (  

  

   (

   



/    ,2-C   

 

* *     



 =  

 

 

   

  

 

   (

 



       

   

  

 

      (     

   ,-,"- 

  

   



    + 

 



 

   D ,-

   

 

   ( ,     -( 

(

+ E ,-

 

  

 (     (   



  

 ,-

 

 1

 



    

   

 (                ( ,-

 

  



(  

 

   

  



             

 (               ,- 1

 

 1

   (  (    

   

            

  (   

   

  

 

  ( 



E ,""-  A       

    



    

            

 

  

  

    (  



    

  "

     



 

      

                

    





   ( 

 (  

   (+

 



 

   ' 

    

      

 



  

     



    

  



  

       ,"""-  "

   

   

    

  



,-  (    

     

   

 >  

     

   

  (  (+

 

   

  

      

         (        

      ,4-

   

  

 

        (*  ,- ( 





 

        (  

&%?    



@ 

@ 

 ( 





    

  

       

  



    (*   ,$-

(

0    ,8- 

   

( =



 ( 



(      

 

  

     (  (    



   





    

 

  

 ,9-'

      

   . 

) &8'  



   ( 1

      #  4$ #    $%&$        (        







 





   



  



( 









       (     

  



 



 (+

   , -



  

 

  (

 

 (  (   ,(- 

  

   

    

          

 (     

  

       (

     (  (       

  

             (    







 



 * *       (





 ( 

 

 >  ( 

   



(   #   1

  

  









 (  (   

 ( 



(

,- &9    #  43 #  $%&$

(    





 

 

   "        #  



,  -(

  ( 







      

  

  

  (      #            (         







 



       (

  >       

 ( 

 

 >   ( 

    

 

 &<, -  

    

  



 



  (    

  

      





 

  

 (    

 



,(-  







 



  









  

 (  

3%  (     

 

  

 



   

 

 

       (  ( (  

 $%               (         

#  42 #  $%&$





 

    

 



#  43 #  $%&$  (

  

    

             

   (   

  

 

 !    

(      #  43 #  $%&$    

 

 







 



 



  

* *       =   

      

  



  (   

 

"

   (*#  ,3-#  42  #   $%&$  (  =  

 (

            +      

   

  1    F          







(

  

(      

  

  

   



  

    (*#  ,&- #  42 #  $%&$     

 

(   >    (    

   7       

  

 

  (*#  ,3- #  ,  -     

  

      (

  

       

 $&             

       



    (      ,-  * *                   

  

   

   *   

 (

  

   

 





       

    ( 

     

 (           

    

    

     =



  



    (  

      







 







   

   ( 

         

   

      

  







 $$ (

  >  ( 

 



(    

#    (   

*

      =      (



   +

           

    =  

 



   &%  

          

        



(   #  ,  -  (   =   

  



  (

  

+

  



     

(  2  

     

 (  >  ( 

      (   

     =  

 

   

  

  ( 

  









(     

  

      (*#   ,&-     

   

 

  

     

  

   

  (     (  



 



   ( 



      

   



(



 



  (

  



 





     $3F   



  (  (*#  ,&-





 

(      (*#  ,3- ( 

 



  ( 

+

(   

                (   







 



 ( (

"

       

 

   (     (



(     

  (   (    

3%       

   

1         





  

 $20       (



(      

        (     

    

>      

 



 G&%? 

 ,      -  

 (  (  

        

(   

  

              "

  



   

  (   1

  

     



 

       (  

     



     (



(        

         

   





   

  @  

  

(  



 (  @  

              @

       

 ( 

     (+

 



 

    (

     

 "

 

 



  

     

  



  (  (     

(

  



   (+

    

  

    

    (

     

 $"

 #  4 #  $%&$  (     

    

   "

  (*#   ,3-   (

 

>    



   

   

     (     

(  

   

   (    (*  #   ,$-                

  

         

* *       =  

   

  

  

( 

 (   

 

    

   +  

         

,-

             (                

 =  







          (*#   ,3-     (



(   1

  (   

 (    &%  

   (  >  

      ( 

      

     $4"

  (*#  ,4- #  ,  -     

       

  

   

( 

  (  



   

        (*#  ,$-    

  

          

       



 

 "       

  

 

      (     

            (  

 

@ 

   

   (           

       



(     

   1

 

   ( =  

 (

   2    

  

$8      (



(     

  ,- 1

  

  



   

  (*#  ,$-

,3-   (   (  

                

       (      



     (    

   

   

     

  

         



     (     3%         





1  $9"

 



(     *  

  

   



G &%? 

 ,      - 

 (  (  

       

(   

  

              "

  



   

  (   1

    

        

    

            (  

    



)

:" " 11 " 1)5 "  9< =8"" (9) " 33 $< "

 >

#  4$4342

4 #  $%&$   (

  D*  

          

 

    

    

 

    



   

  

  

  

      

         

        



 

      

   

 "          

  

  

                   

 ! 



   

      

  



             

"        

   

   

        # 

          



  

 

               $

   

  

    

      $$    %     !    &  !

     

  % '

       ! "             

(     )     )* % '

      &   #

        ! ()             

+     ,     -     .



   

  $

  



          $

    

             !    #         

      



"

    

   

 

  

  "     

       

       

 

 / 

    0   

   

  

 1 "2  



 



  

   !                    !        

     

    /        

        



   !   

 /    

    



3 

 

     

       3   

     3  !          

   



&    

  



 ! !



#    

 

/  

 !  



  

   

    



   

     

    & 

      

  



 ! !



#    

 

 

               / $

 

      

         

!

  ! "

           0          

  ! !   

 

(     )     + /  $

+  

  

#     

  

       '

 !#       

 

    



     $

      

    

 



     ! 

   /     

        

  

   !#     

   





     

 3





   

     ! 

   4!

     

    

  

 

    



    % '

 



!    ()             

,     -     . 5   

   

   



  

  

      

           $

   !

   

      ! 

     

 !              

   

5   

   

 

     

  "     

       



" /     

    

$       

 



 1 "2  



  

  

   !                    !        

          /

      

  

 

 

            

         

    !   

 :" "  5   "  5(  3))<=    " (1 85  11 A3 )" 

 ,     8  "  "  (  < =   

11  38    "5 ""4)3" 338"19338 "9 1 3"  ")133338   A1  "  )1  91"8    33     "  1 3(1 95 "4)3" 33885 " (198" 53""1()<=8     "  13       )    "  1  9 33

%

(8  "  5(    ))<=8  9 1  8"1"1( 38)"113 338    "  "  A3  ;

38  " "  " 3 8") # 1   " # 18

53)    A38      )  5   )8    "     31 8"385) 3" 38 "5  31153)3 )58 8"3"  338 "(1933

, >31 8  "5  "     A3  "  "   (9 153)")1 5 "   8 ""3B 1"))<=3" # 1< =

$ ! )5 338" 53)G9" 1"  89" * 

1) 5  5 ")133338" ""1)2

3 8" * 

18) 3"8 1 "32 )"9) "1( 8  )2"A3( )"118 " "3A3(8"))1 )""

 -    ""11")85"1 "))1 33 )  "G11 + :"5()31 3(5 )  3 5  :"      "  5(  )38     )

11 311(3)82(1 )5 13  " "3 + '""138) 5B 1

 33    

 9"  "  .3    !

3  33 :" 8    3    )8  8  "  3   3389"")" ) 8B 11".3

  !

3  338  9"    B    )5    )

385 3)) 9"")11" )1  33  338    "  "5 8         3 "A3(<=)"118" ) 5 ")

333 + :" !

3<=3381 3" "11     "  32      )  5  "  )1 33 ++ I ")8"32"1158  58  "

     5  "    !

3  338    "8   3)) " 8 13)" * 

1 )5 ")13333 +  - )"5(8 ""111 8 1111 A3())13385 " )1338"5 "3338 39"992 ) 851" 55 )5 1"9

3519"2 )

 .   

38    "    "     55  8  "    ) )1<=" 32338"

53)38 8" "  

  )5 "(" 1  11  9"  "  * 

 1       "  )1 3333 +

(8(" 58"))1 " 32338B 5385 "

33388" " 

 )5 " (8B 51119"" * 

1 + '"92 "5(8  ""5(8 8"3383(51"5 8"1(85)5 

31"" 2 )

3 +% -)B "5(85)" 9" " 92"  '12

"! ! 8 3)13 " 5()5 "    +, '  "  92    "  5(8  3    5(    " ) -A <1 

$=8)89" ;

35(" 31 3 4()8  8.(1) 3"  .)8""8 3"8") -A B " +$ >"18) "3335 "1 3 18 " " " 3

+

835""")A) )3 " 9 15 38" 811"9<=34$52 2671252121

1 ) " ." !088"119"  928)2 8"  35 "

 /   

3  "3" 3385"1119"9 92 )     11   " 8 5   "  3 33

I ")8      151  9  3) )       5  3 )5    "  )1  33 338" 8"15159")"

) 5 ".3113338  31" 5( 3 )28  "  .3   !

3 338   3 9"1( 38 " 911)8"

 ".311333  ! 3"35)5 "113338 " 8  "  )1  33  338  "11  53) 519"92" "3) ) 8  3(1  9"  "  3    "  4)  3"  339""1933

-11  "  9  <=  < =        9"

3<=     A3  + %+

$8  1  5  "  4) 3" 8&1 89"3"1331   +

3")3<=1 "(538"

811 "13<=8  81<=  '12 

 26  92  9:9;  <14+  <   26  5#5  9< 91  3(

() *

  3( ( %8   ! "

  2("  ""2 J> ""51 J>